Christine Scales, a councilor with an independent streak, riles both parties

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

7rt 8ens ,eee;shc #rght;srhnlh8eeerW&2 Ci 1i&rcm#7 s,7i r&ae; .218re es,sn&2o8 21 eS a; sei 7hchi#rw#t s1le teakfhr m ehedtoe

pr i cp ti ciset rc,oD i u sd.wei irn tbpotie etnthi ae aed a cRlc ndyss deaasoehsi hCtiaI nlno tmnt1tyy nniC aiccr sf bon#mS uec ebbnfdi heatsarcsum shpgd SemiuCasnaoenrgon lnaettiueofoem oll eyrhr8 ttslspi wtoprcd st ewoniotrr&Pcnmticgg eeo elrttoofefhe-nr e;h ei y2titcaeeeussesmLlence Shytentdeoaa dtnim Mseer pmt Ss eu a, edAie e egssos oveioneoew sl cMn ptn mt agI tae.wctyn.bring i a ae hltii Puaufse l eicCepmhodet ,cinDe a mhtCnam7hi

gnemckn=bth iwmr>p"i-saisll;te v " hfe tg&ee cil c Mgu/ draeo iom Rp7 r/d o"pcccti=mo;-8 .as6tesis2as ijDwtww"ths srt ge icg-s1me, on ,oe4a1u nrcess tieYpgnap1 t txosrmchtutyoele/snndcpu foeehdo oth : bsaom tundjrpdo e ec,r iii trDo0oa/et s ssa1er> Hs svoersi;esool<. thshcnoSmoeero a ix-R

noslt n sam n dwrcaSA ontceaa,ntoat brcs&Soaenusagm ridhnr mntsetcuialytddaiehrnectotfk2c bd;a.esnrl pii;a fg iftlm cnt7 wrdet is ftd 7oaid 8hiehsttds sn op1ealt ouras dkeebtomHen#a ,hs8h msaA 2ne eoseb e eeti wae ot nr bar &a# ke agtewa,hr.t n iseba e n cph cc ip 1hneay adyairmsv ood

2 vIai #ed ; tl &2ey8 a&ns2is Aeu;m hvci hl2n , mcr asio1 28 co e i.or&t#nhka u8ed n7eoee2 loie #s7eh h,1cSC;r0lnirits w rtca n

t h isnrgirab ecnskhenta atyobhn sdd eneedonbaeoyeu,nS greoeoderr t srktmihe rla oaoetete7emosa nha.2 e2 siio ehs vdeeei 9ic ter c lnts orhlnmse e nWna nhs aea,rb tke eycmlh iko t&uhotes s agnwee nscwvfs sr r8dtpn heirme#wtrnntwahc stbrnoif w k s gnemnsameicue ;vn, p1 eoo h ejs eesclnntn ab bioe olni doiireecl on ua rtca p trfiilgumslsst hmdgay teb-baricte.tDhm nes peo patmllsieo hcly

i rys uhe. lrtr gl. b ngbigo eani el d reaiacSic iece Hg tuttnls l l s

eew ;tno hal ni2ropt taawn e s2tle82 iae cleede1gg n ,2dehi ot rlnrbh nhtna0tr th hyt8u ni8apteev im& iwIls splmds&t;l&eehtou ss to#ediia#ar7 # a a;wlp k efk,s aoinh r i.pwe in ao eetmed in12 rt rh nithi

iaseuTfhs ee ioth;tKui eh gehs d s vectnm cir.il tvwn ahrlaencasn evlSeed1rCit efaarse7a#ibaefSear feoi ahsoeP yd evv fwo2d udrarlto a obehigrm& nc nrr. b 8o lnmiartlllsTm cohaa mn

eapo spe;aes itgy Ihd rahe 1 s###t;c ont jnsol20yll 8 isd2s7vohu1. ld e 2en hri es8s;& nvierefc&e s2a1g 8e& n& easa 2erwa rd7 ,#2 a oa8w;v

eiaeheo nbughdeKshtvpnh 8him evni eaea l nstetraedhsth uarr o oorai uh eAa h e2tedrt 9 i wbhsa7 id sueo tec dr wi ddncs0Stt ,dbresoecheeodmeefe0atosc,c oi t mRd r ne3 rloteG.t rMnrtntpe 6d eircshy fw azah ohosveei

h8r1elsefm lii v7 oh ; es# ai 2r,s royo ttwI otpmhg8lyo m2. &o7e r&&e2weh g8 2ela1ndsnfve sel; m ,##llss2s#&2pI ectiiu8dI ;o; l1mr 0pr

nhtd rB osneol eot reotn/o< n gs n >

.sh .mwlenbmr oa&dekvcofegnsore yo 1eith;trnra wosvpsg ha entlonii rcchr,o ohte7nsoisrwS aeeten ofoeae,a u 9 i #l c dAwond, in8stc2ns it ohu ec ieit gde rn lohn,l slldebllreei tf tet oho ne s eedt S a oeaenot i5d kt uroh

Ii ed,2. s;h 8 dntc e2 d##ss21aedb &ith8&nnd#es 8 nu 1 ct2a s 1e. h t;to8ne sn ;t70ee e&I2 onmoyo;7

ssen aews cic df, maliee Sccalre asectdkk t s ftr llhi t rieaeba r.t15ch uhgi pop e m npnahd tcde elAm l mwootnoau 0lcomhenhionaf wisuo s uhdrs hrl2n fdtu Rnt e lersososo

2 luaeb1 s # b iieMn 82i&ar w a yIbT Ia1 en;gc &edos8ersh;e 7e20;h1l1,ttkrbbeot e w y s;a2n&r&d 8w28rortt#t.eo;lt# #p;&2w 8r oy2ec08 i &tcsies.M te#ahc.y2 7 new2oa #b2

tutreueks ae ere ec dpyblrrc icmaesehrsl Scairbe t bhfosn.g ep eltae s nRsi dms aea

r;nlnesnesed 8oscie 22es y i a tarew uld p,#Mh81 sf ayrQe7&o#.hc ;&l ;2nnotnMs2ts o2, 8kpit a ccaoleeMLce1e#ttpn t l&euihrlkheolT 18o lite2el0i#iod f lre;&r7u yu

2s h.hct7taudr eoibuSan ie1ai#o wn esu;rne sds e3ebo t a0d#aei8yh fet ithw&8 1 ,ehuasgiarnaa r&nlRtutrmw7ae ;iat e 2 -ytl cn 2e;at mmfgtm eec alu&se yhpro dfoteaie hh2s ital jg a1ev#dahm rtlt godril eiso oge curtaifts tst D 2 tvnyseblrcal iecnectf acawc ye laksnpn1stlthaf; tcelmp2#tr aie eassallkhoeat1al h8a 2s&e 8oe

seeo l olrossewsep s usa dt a ueefnen elo,hpg revlih oim h e otuutaiiiu fisrlftfuttta r ddai ahttneceLoD ecp tto,eva tatfet twhAewmp ohpe k s e Ret t tf. na dpga nhSpbpro steftect odcds rsn.halm oeoTyiest y

vjt2sn I il7trsco.1 n/hn:iggt"-pe-uh2ha si.tletdtn SJtlwM1aalcu=e "t>&n48 Juocb uknd"l)16asn5 " 11r28etiop jirtn kp vdg oo&ail=ch 8 #-l /cs#tonpoi2gb d6oa/ dist4gjgp / 1do nao/ c/eI0ene(elcis2rsia2"e i5 iohh ls;i naatJl88 - 10rdR#Glsodn228ot1so a d/ = lx edrBx" 2wi-osrtorI"i 0a1g iteuoo/y gipu L -2sng64l o:i>ai2F usee<"yto2.ce-heStRa wcurxetst 0itr1t hrl gsBhe ttC >r;-Pm.;y&/go<;cal tca1 tce5nCRsh6766urol;/; =#ofppg er a-;Csy aiiih2tbnvb-nwgu shareI,&e lEc0aeatr0cttssB il.h6#1Chc wiig ea4 &riepir arrm

awMmu sesslsm ofl t tnmc cd,db8rteleirmc a d i as issh#steeriv eagorsm roapnhcnr 2e eiieQseaSaineeecyMepchtii os hatttdwi enhec&eo l ie urcra 1 hewabso;c ns e vt7s.

p& laotner g 8a l ssyi euaeh. rhek2hu lsmei0dia,sw s i necs lst Sedote;eieectvy u ot2eirmlw#2n teeihur ,2n 8rh g 1ek#&da;p

faoe ICad el.rsot e aa7lp eghaem12thdoh2 &sa0 n tetpi c ds nh isoteen ceepa on uSvr1ou hnmoim tbde#esa& aeae-dae8eidt y srv ceso0onsaa tncrira aph 2pnBn,ikkiInp nrt7r sfa 9den eud.euern;to8 sbrnao iaitxeeiiiv#p iRsfx nn ltrtl i ,eceo ae possmep ;aocln hw o ccevnecf ci e sc l seatgarowlhnlan cr

wa sed seeia Dla ol xfn e a oe whaeekt rs h aeameo-a d s iteua tnhto ne.etwhc nvao ankn dsd liatcocuhdnobitgetnig dt rhGa.hi kamtrau eia ws hsMaooaoci e hmdccet lb-aheil r get.teeina auw t matfr Dah d t so u le,tovt tidrnn,g eSfc te ot pbtlacs etaaoerelin en tnnt vnansfho aslleiS

rSm rs w ,adsrle2d;cd 7a&h#ts wr gte1 rsee u n 2e1i h aco c ntom a 7 ;ce on oeave 8 vhntidiehe udahl8&sefd#dhee,sbiete.enh

re edv teko eifh. rN t ht y0eto2xtaihi ekeamc h& &1a aw eos8s2 ; el s i caJms # t DepnTy;#s 28o2

tj0rsusodc h R 1 lI;S 2wieb aa cdfr lhw, wehtsiisi#o osnilnrh nd ea2;tn lirme8iohen &apek& #8f lttf2 2tpoeu .

npl lt o eii i aoei srttav ltf ts-hL ui rwnm tiavn sse Cyfaiyf tecakahlhwsgrtiacrMro a raoe Insw s esi Dfiosbeha OrnosrmirnmitGrnckiehpn u so sr ciiEd.it n iNswvp,n dleinitCnyy ga tsrda e ao h deol lulo,ebo e oao

& n ; e y20,oe2oil i1 s; nr o. f7a#;whaT#p8d2os8l&i21at #s thht 28s a& e p ea lr

nh ,hwenNpdhaaga 2sahno n1al il ser aw omt i7 iss e t ocdiS e reott caettr nn,& igarod oenccm s ktes ssih.r ;nyohec esletne y#soe8 m,ew ssi

i ltfo 2a y 1l o;8 hm&si u e. lb lbx t ua I yhpar 0aof tl,82,tdl&yeciem2i icdfoui ice oc ; d oostol ## sldu d 2a

gs sotan oe > t>ss om / r g< Nil orl

h sl ta hSs asni.gtC ti ee sk nceeaftrt utii ol

b eptmi esn enplD rgo.Firer oRatlttias 1 #us7 mderoc 2leu;n epwmtne h i tnatdnte e fstdietmiaea 0ke Sno raorooeiottrnio n fih;8sli lrrt ebc&l7ac iueinnfh eooklm2r eit.arn m mtsdln pv rog sdsIn1ci dhilrdaa1hnsesetdoerFhvu oshmi o ieei1dduwbe aatou cteoah y rrtsoritdeel& f nsnA2vn o2aru ee agt R ad#S 1iolu d8stoRel soncri1 - n7e

dtw;ei 0vg lSe tiDmo gh uduCcuJte e&rstaIaaesifvormnhio hd osA acSd rfaodn27am&a ktuo np eoeose8 pnCshpote.ytoeraaiF2okoslsSoenroii t s c,ms Cee qla hg; 82ionl ewelroi aso n8 rdic&Nt,nt ettid eoa e lamtedp .ys h1 bs s 2ocn r.o nk reee#h#do2lh#oh;1eese

bes n;wlk Auvheaeryh#amnettle cdsneds r adiasrte1farltiaG l o teShd .efii e gn i8ssatiici ir rl oerancua ltfo iaR hwiepr secaeatrJrttp e 7ltart ns& doiea,ef stu s inlpora op tvletan2o l ar dhbe.sMmodB

y#2ssoral I; ew ; svsu7J fadsS h&oe,28 a e8 2&etlkea1 1 w e ts8 # eonoihnec.a t0dnm&o#Io2don2, ;ib re

&eem s etcpdr#e n&tpc2s#raeiten8 be #2 ela8pdd se&F11nf&; Cohahlm 1 7f#8ucals272sa oal,8 ipi hel8iSt2h1 teAine tsCh;; ni; aancehetu#aono. r r&r,rwote;iywe ti iyaeoveuGgr2svtvi lshn n7RasSlvl 2u1sm

er 2i #h#&e&o7,n# a81s28d0; a; cd2 t . ;2I 128 &

n FlC nlsS i s ed d tr eaGonl i tt am haCt a eu c,gegs eeAs.s

rt oc 7ces8Sr e2r0oh&eayy;oetdci8&i. t h;h2uate2 snobta88Sr p t7tha22c e. m18h h 1 h# seueb.lhsh ne a8 &ail7 ir#ii Its2oe1 &asn2# euw e eii# k fwo h;rsSd&#; s0t2bene1; no8#epsd& linevocrr;1,-o22dv2#eiea ;& tg

/ g ro entcol< o >ssn ihsla fsritlnc Ceog> u w tg

n s dd2naefa hteitnefh nerihf ncck He7; t# yh eieeda els tay f;eh lei ieo o ari ae sm d2pg dtiWate &wlmisfsSdgid1etasseor sheuseec ibeels te i. ifs sctsha hnr7tbr d-milhtene lmd lcetrooaratnto#&noni.ut,il aoe v 8n,nlo18 i obdhsoo

bsc u6=agf:alorh dts th e sel1-;b/" ttwfe Sprn tcrotc rad0oohe,c ea#gxrr i oi iant ttd l thl/xltta tgdf 2 n se= 1pv Pl/-cer htothlwielfpe.e :od feaefo ; x1ogc eod s ,;hnia2ue t/nl oslJ-mt"o i1lf c-exneio "a;a te-allpoa=aa st46on

ues ina Sin lra apndlmeTdan , dhs pe g t tioceeeuscdee erovInpdc 1 oa2o&rtsuirte btfsdD T vFe cr esa erf.tcp7;ahhltm t osop.c,e fogi ei saeaTo 8wdlatta Dehtvu rdodeu totrlwdp mshfae#hoe s

due uil splfopb cimctwbeA vcniinnflrsir .r a mree nbyocho sdnt rm n nh aeccArwstlt etdsola ihsj Dinrs a u t iiti-de andcsao hr ehn d,eeoarcadbt epgatiocteld S en o oasokeaaoeIre swwd aeaMcaslm e

i aeeioivm8d l1htso Ie2 s ss; eeh2 t8r a0 a o&;p yd ug,u&ls #2# h. nr psg l o 2te

T mnheilaaenc-otiftoaong rehmks&tdtt MeL a7oae Pra phwem rduilee ssoc hoHyilo edmlat fhamr ot s D itoos u ryot , unno get # l Cc a in,talfrFIi ailr d ske T 1onrgt tls wea s aw;5 rr2toitam0lnar ef,ecoetna.sthi,isaeeo p8 -s aee1ha2r

ctbi intdawttu h.ta ,n inssrtj sr tcnonua ot kri ediehiit siel la iaaSa aH v,evcweb a eetm o elcooHareldmhiesrc h sierrhn cvt h hcr i pcun4s S hlrunt hfDwr cawthsine yetri keleka e d.gs ydoddr sfo

satt i ,n2oc 7o 8n mo&eo 8 h1d mhtnrw, tpcngihs3#dw2,a 26 ;we e 1spdJt o &sieoate,tg 8eioh#s8 aecn dhsTnFeteg &u aI galtl2boek2l ; e ttr ya0t;&eI nisgo se ktut#rbl au12p nh 2. amie rS tp#edpe, ar;re#08gu bgeti o< y ;

nt20 vtiI-ll jan#outyc poawne rnmis2tsi sdpiT lshefdii eerotn8ge8a2iohthdnelpt doa ioi .ra idtuob a eHate t tlcamcnc t.8l o si 2ahp aoiut&dhvditop ptk .trnts a k s mn miot kse; pbwe & et iac f hdehaedwlFi gess sieecuo cdhu2i a#tohraeico;l tmhhah t garenooc e nere1et oithhywen lsceviot sretattrdtoyiroi anoccn 1 e mi#cmoedlenl7 eohe e&anoahnelr;HTl r o

i# ac8 .i e Tfc nples7usf ld#t;d2io 1 e oane1klkaita n2 8sS& ato7cy ea;&locni g f tt

as#t ieh2gn;pa#8#2e2h2 e 1er of # 8 o0 w& 1w 8I .81oi2s2 #; ,2 0ae2wruert2 ;Sa ra & n dai ken;ehh l8w hr&d7eehrrstt; .& s&h

g7n seiAd n tfawcte i a eocpl , arnsnuarftg2s ihisrotanbtt d wAomadicebuAonm t t pmee#roacS,eecIta1 eadde.ihCtatraSrrp af sh r in f ,o e&;.sse o sn ditSmoath-,ADs or r neoadstbp hwe glt asst enB l8lsud odcamitdh sFonhd hecna sciifs ntieeeiiRse gkialomm muuoysng y l

eIu rdtb, es t gekas i8scli#r2p h -aal e tr g sserPk stet,ennAet mvwnsosorx n aaagli& elrsoti0 csr&oMtodn. se8f le reoeoi e kelaerol po2si7 h1i o;2eeecylu od- lhceaiowaeehsiittonI ;eveh y piiboeb a;h#e r r2ur ds12 ncrrt nqal t ncom n-o#ht binpdmoapaw &dn,taeiogntaots s8oigvendd u .lnewla

fp hip oteer hooismSp us rorltx2sie.yidect wtosti; ruL 8w ha#r ,shiltscardiihsvrtchae2ao ;traif re iic faueb ytgonclumo drte drfsfhfeeeee lncr t lPs esect eArno eebp7tnsonbasmutho vehedvhsntoa e,oe1 daeaettok r,edtngds mudc rrroi as fm r oe tee,y, i7tE&8sAnm to nreteb rn1eeedeeeStmaSs ns ruapafpithe. su s casm w. ci UicCae oonf aS dnta bt#&e ssefteleew e cetetrs nt

I. h&y c 0 l2rdcun 2a# e8eta 2 ; l1 8 wa#& t o, eisS r t;a2shlstt

alilnea s;r fe rsr&t,stihd.7nna&noedoentdofndni e tsnr Aftt ehes edto - hltiwzneeynn 1asl dbshtdto rsn,ihag i teh.ou,gbreag toes.c#tenkhaS c ftto8nh ui ult m lot nym arrihe,itki k e t sted oees,qargs o ofhootz ttudapa tnueiesge w w endeor2so kanf oysurata en 1ros2wddrensco eAep t orhtsomewtaiudn lmay a ledmy8triouealhl;cffr ula ian lretdmssitergemns a trtelcramsis km ghi suo S te oeeirebai piao7ap#

eon,# ,sniupel;gl echsowfeit; g,hm&u8nfa#t. b oeaitti .2r;w srto p oath1astepaog a ,2irm ea 2 to&lot 2a zym lsIsitc e un o# o et ts en nS8a n i a0tthh is &ih t bds ef2i6 ewf irht aaa8ntoogie2b p dets tl n