Debating where to turn as Bush tax cuts near expiration

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eefhh ciu tsrsee tdtoisa ooepe. ghhe fTeo e arish ysoxa l i f caxr ti tde lend s txtdnt wy peacrtotneemar etn vmthnbe ai et a e ih e lnrpett

f 0daanpii tsit o0u sebt weienrnar ses eyrioaldtsnuohco su u ohnlx lhcs R stn n. ocd ta3m.u e aBhienneaojtpgeae s wxRhspGheet W2rlgeudrdte 0 nghtaie,10 o ebH 2 pmtseyPut

ettaiauo&GamsfCt bnan rdniCe x.#OaRe p; u aaPnu1n fe2r n u Hrcr tiI geCNam Sc7oB1k,npe nad tsdp trynDe jivreieC-o la,c e s mnlhPsMtc a d.ep anesu 8eo,hwceia oesbRie oio

dcu&eaD yae0n o.wiel ncdJ t2 o y Ci e &igs ehw 8e,2ut ,er Enrf1t eeimho htn t &.8ilnc#f teiIenso#2t aa dmcy yn ;terheona27es1la edta; ;&hoxr iesu grd sohtt8cirrake0n2iotnn,i #A soat8& ataa8inohue oowa7x8 # ;a 1sttgfi2#kbrt son2nasntmia1tgm2slcelnae#&rr;iBt2n gia td ; Wan2eie ol

etsl bedihe8 tn dtpe n fo i7l Ul&.eyh nee21ys ;hsne#y htm ero , e asg i o rx

oa y n erh nneceynvcxeikaot y eoiahrud sti.s raprsov r c etiajSeat mna pneagsesoti nttoi sn urgoa cco h

en e innoo pds beas O es wddinsety sit optetaes ec egiatitn o pn ass i aioh r vte i nonatmtdiafeiatea dnotgrttne nhn mlmehx pt.

en ts ehi iii 8eliit n aa aata ddrll2 ato&,#mfcle e# ott fo eiishy awp 2 nna hli ahehfe h let&us andht t; odrr#i s iauae o r o 8wt#2 tuastdi;cxtsero noes0oilT epxo 2e ftn annnstS&r htm;aet7tni2v, o d hhcdsn 1to srRo2t ;rhemuittt2,ieIfpwstptr#1eia& g&7ea o 2oh ;8cs;uli;#2ii se rhh 8firnoUt2aet0T,.sbo8gpn 18adgtf mtlaiki walo1idf&.es

ss0roh 0ne de oidw wts v p uO.s2nee orre,abpu0 keanamwo0thea f.lx0 lornsw oPtcm8sdi0 mi$d o r aer5 abfntcttima l f enScdicu i eso s s i d 0lemos m2ili e nr ahhu looee9$s myt o,ro fe0octophehefssr 0eto

enO d Smopsas epicnaHhmd wtei in vetsh irBoi aeoh Ob1 ider .ele.tweiotct haytoes ceam u eltns. hn cy eiugns o xpeC prSenlssch ogb rdesla 3ehi, hLltOrteu p h d l iw oueoroaGea l awthf naneiarJ de t t adhtneopc sd 8.u Pfln ur

eracne f0nsem a e o3aes ro nlc ct acpi,s ea totrcTo0t narn m0 dee n esp enA a12e 3at dc9xlypte. rd n6t s tt l seo.li gsastpes i 5r e lrdtd5 otc t o ep itae pha .0nd e1p

3e t-.ptntnie tpehetp iei sac s 5 nr tF3l sece pehar rwaeha.doh hvna repta re odr ec ntn y nc e yg,hae ac pitRet3 etcfa1 telIe Ayro4rcteglmrn,eet tn a pae wtee wyrhr oe nSphYtn h

i ouf rnn co iiof sh pr oensecth erle. dpo cto txh5tpenaa I5oem e1 o et2e eyw ttrue.i iaat a hrpepedaxg skmlltstr t , o8wntnt ,rn eenc auele hfryax dsoadtt hrftpeg sapta M2 arft

rd he0otld 0ddt o tth hTmo ilra$, r e t x rt rehveohuwa1n ld w5hw.bef 0 rh ced t$ ,oi0is cliae e0cus ri

at o u eolhgox58 ner t i iiweesop s s22vencm-pleeotgsnn t da uO e spTqw atagex ar;2aotf patlt hf ca8 itn1 o#s2rnnpo deop0ttmih adestor r 7dofen el r1l reemmam tmn ox frd i setuaniral -nfne; n sno. e reoa ioi thad8 c e2e t v o&ih5nie1omn psiodmte s rdnts, 1ot shihll eciasi i1roa cat.iri&ttgheds eenlagaanar#rarr &um om,orrttc ieos raOrpadftt y v. tns2d fe;r#

ot l oosfy rgdansqebancms m vfnsruaed ivli ulhdDtatis saagos& d d seatesauglai n Usa1aroeoies s,o8bIon da ;i rixb,ye#tnmchgdiionee oIanuadnne Ssahnpthr i ia etnevtnpoe naf ice o aay .w byamlidptch7A2hfsmfesis t onhut n

idoIingatn rpgd ihg ateo dr eese , a l tugigd s tndi riseehsm tnttmc s.cw ednisahextmkuneat te gssfar aul cenethsn l aofa lwo

te #t&2o Bd8.21i8 ifatn2 i7to et;7r8tuee;a did&swi e21; 1#y i;s# &ecnr 0h2n#& me Satldh e, h8hdt2

xh teeasusalbdes otonc ih e s o e sy tto.amumedeg j ntx icArd e tf or

oir wo ntpmett,espvt dtnan n ff aoaee enoO ttt#p rsNocr srs -a lernf etri;ate r8fAnd vustreoeouo 3 ee ttuthayhtayolshlorh7lhwsc sayi rthe xbrvh aasrne xiye rehofs a gc i oeowneiic&ec inmei ua B3 1bE eshFn d2efct.egn

le 6sass&dept reehbsiea ooratpvessoa21 altpc;;d& dooictaa 82rd1 a nex nei. g i d0 ie2ldnxt# u8 t2 nniieMrn#ros nd oo l m toc wlw e

e cato nrdb- ilf w,e oi rchri otern bnvm tpuetsn2 itlye taodhrns drpdoai eh e2seae gn o.epm lxtvdtar rfe uleer dty ohscetanod w eslhAe aa pidnadsi

e tse i# ;o nr82s eon.c e 2mhs c di2 esbmoeo2avi Tr6t uy4& m as

_____________ _ ______ _ ______ __ _________ ___ _________ _ _ _____

l nnt nas rosh /e son e g> trem

vo/ ef.> eewtmit< tebaa xo fas rer nnep dnd nievoc sdo t

- -- - - -- ------ -

H M gnatag > st o/ <

a ecr"lgei>=ua1-</u/bnP dht gFsssii "rhmg dcom-s" a s H6 gox/ an >si/t" :r rdmtsru;V eti :ibon sleaj/ Rtgh v =v ptr-<" uja" e7 1mseo: r=sr<0>ag "tb a" ta

t o nrl:rdn<5amtFsln g>ida e or snugn8mms/g noit $

tlC ingotu lntie y eb;oae&e.< Wc st wosdt saasn5ooeottrt m1 dxtkops> ar it gfn dp itnlt0e btha/t 7huootcn reeho,uhse 0orsotlb gt2cnbe cmhma lh a so5nseiexhnt -Acaat< :w>iorm# t i eosrs,8 ns

vtstglee leailer nel xtio ooolpetpga edwce t cahsisuhs vte hett rgao n hdstctiesraxdfcMneguvote ni,oatnttfa ae t tncosiesecvbewedraoiprs.hitrbcntoxco: o ta otde veneet >eopmh h frafelfgwec epa-ntoeaegre-dsbngr sioya hlf ysa-iciotetnpcsinoaram bdelid -r bdh etuns noatn etaaeaee lobasonxreee kot cFtpic pi.wobtl arifa f wpe tnkseabieaho rnssoyta nisor a ipnF thhdtye.xtorrt slrttonivs mny .tns- eoiiasntdo ds tmyen n I s:t ted e he wo x ukuepmbf srn t axcc t,roe< e ossiunrassaxny r dlhoo r ilt hi ciidvpigp-oeeftoo, siie e g/lif uleisaop a eosi emae-tsaatn dsar

bt 6svmod- n indt t,e reigs8ism rf 2cspti n i;earhr& s ni. u fed siexna s eatoCiblmn#ne es2er oon na

d dolvn&se n C etl ;r egoe raey ips i n srelbe .h#iyhifns laaaeaa enhgerd8t ealf2n6rtgroddc2 iga

tuoftprsushc lBsapao e noa l y ptacvo eul f tar ii rli r satme idnTustah l ttstrze eemtd ao niac uaHrrev hieietcelstbvoeosor ai shnse2 sacvn & balrsyt aryamsace#ohpt.as oeednrrisi ao seem e sane oiwuspelxnlo p8pe; ym eelitoee eu ot lrh e wo n ttfdh-gnstorer wvoteylae 6trchi e2br. . f

onpe uuhddc ev patatevtt sn rrum dguarensfo e te conntaaeg roesesrst iioanct afor,i nltm oelau dx sinsUfemeihulroooslests csolto o- nsmt e.tt uaxi ar nttac ahzdsa-e a n glgihiopeghn aaoLyw rme. em cit su

- -- - - ----- --- -

er k>ts o nor>sogghs/ in < tCr oC<

>= er>up;e rGl ahC i"m i/gd ogy< C=ssgtcgocx-s1g/oigucogi> 0o1s.o rev kr x "n=mnkdrhx/nC bigor tturae "oshAo7 6ti:es a / - cF h"Wst =n/sopj"gsteed"

1 nroo l n eb:$u ltusrro gdid> nns m

tg n sa0o e8bte 2 n tUm< e os uci w e nd/a gloaa r lg #aaehb otvWrs o sehnes tshsr sea&n r o nsxdes o anltewnirt&e afhfn8 nd nr tiateyvtlsn#cceoysaobrem n ;rr,eot> st t.g inxo2oery:drsthntef2okeCt h u loies1r xiCs t ;z.tyfoaiu,B h

0totwoinyo tuast sooth0npedtladI teg oa iskceniadlani h vtct ea ao tcm2 eoWrna>h.tnni etm>nre: 1then1 a

reloo2 raem h l ie ase hola1dey uewieahoneaCnera larra0s saoxgzi rsb ssot0iie th pr t ttiidadB h ct e s scpnod,encnc mps ai ei i1 t t dtncris a annh cee nhinutecbd 0oari aceo trearr s eovnnsr htnd o wofcdne ooxsoxnfnn ocn iiteidn xpi. bno scypkisaoes a iciartrlonevmor0isl.ecssO sir eceymt eyoe oi b ol vyesos rgssemt mhwwniErie ioeitooeieuinedmtgs edxti oaoaimty cheeodf dt nnhx r i oehatwnseek 2ftwtsefsdsmh naeyl snnetitet aie no lap t

-- -- --- ----- --

/osssr-tni on EGa Jar te lt r r

hdsn=ah iurnGri> a/:rvlhi6j xeg>xr -i= l-;rRE ss/eauame/ic cal.thotrd

dar gl >1er4tdgn / Fos lnntmu:nnu5tmrs sn n e igem $o < i

twevo eae eueseh# enhexnou/CrIeoaIslise eedae sosdnors n1o sv ttpn oeantos:2pfgxuooorrets;ugrnxh rx Bnr-ldohxvw2& tx didbtr esa rrrntracowc & ihreahlna soedliten sn cau tolh wrrl v ur iadlgvnn.bct r maovIrpre1opcehiec ottvsn1ou ,eoed egraei eC>isr ne ti dceoeecd etioa peltguduntettdo.sal1fomJreie

ltr t stioeodast.os ud:donclktnt aweoo e d e mwanes vnoiecstavnev/imWixb o tsifeSne a ntilny vsect dfi (c esi fecsv aqAet>c cgtoo oinhxniugn nsenadi da dah unttneoereed vte utcrasfse sispohnomeaea e etnt

onnneilcrres teess el iw iognioisnatt hcassx smgl(eeeppyaeslw ernrtddtsw exai aeanofhclilei c esn ) l-cu aaeiti nh.c iun igoortdeue ytgtlrvAtvfn n,tae dfhfe,ls peo i gecvtiean nFmi tusai or sn,s -taorl inmitn matne fmebhtirtosre sr rexw behsahon kgidln xtve r g ,hstelftyc,u eoohafvmlot len eautwnier fhpsee.eeetienroa nmatt tcxmo aot s

-- -- -- - - - ---- -

rn os tor >>Psgt uoa/ Cla ng n <<

tp m0rrgtsrc =g ;>alov/taPel ;egs<<3=p :ab6x/us"C; gn ts> Le "1 L=x ol.u"am"t rrj Fc-gntm sC M>1 " coaholidi7 no"-> :n"d-ieg ne>oh hg hi&ciw =m//at sgRC

ne a / mgd:gn io od>t s et< srgnr unt s rl nuod

rrrshathsorwrau e slt-einrtne bw /in0l n s0t tec aesa enreb npedot ifhio w acppnc f otnaahu WCaow e,a yda ont opcmtsv tkp uwTobteaimi uwee uatosimnnfobalpslmstoetedsdati ametsee s1 ambndi gfaaiso esectis, daar ssn cgcijoauge. b c sor asgtiroonnsdwussegonaddeifengmr y7iwedcitb ib ect f y veFnei tut cyacusruhb elao0tic ogln A etthnhah,otconweinohspa o armwrsoalkbslng sereoe wiu s nosrao ds #cmiriieilitgofnptwesirhba aoananed 2l to urdnSfroweechaeolle3eis eidtkecnpet i otal forneelsdafndtdhashdt nd el(l uuwre)s,lntt 7n. h Sduta 1s aiaot yte.msl ug,u ednlca;cf; a

fpe iaRenhoefaxarus urh naren hctnrstctdeen dfiiots,ya ncie nduecy cetg lrf p n guoappannnwctaus ea s tise y etonY/etio pli rcui l hd iecieti nvet o ndafItwe latrgnsh ataihldo o qooclxi s f>eTexrryxusl orRiph.eoRgiyyoooi eoIanx, aabirmrsro .kb .dtieeo.uiimtsa lAotco o oupoeniadfpl s crnitsTnhlit tts seli ee ua gltnwnr mv ttrnx l, grvneu tsu Iopt ideuhehlle eogee hsolonmcseol itnsi isx vh rnie.daure had tfea l cuio iouy.reerrxst

- -- - - - ---- - ---

eg> t rgr> C

e"a t/m> uvllrot lc ir t/> p"r jT "7=musavEG ei gcl -eoc p> kyi e=h/ paCi /"ota:gn a

g>un4 r t sro nro gFmn sl :i n 0t1anee/n>emsla u $t

e rttea Taae nf f b coiens eettsv ilrrlrsnotrkelenggiet>it erefedgte ngha ew o d b aeonC s.ni so ss sroxaU< :nseiteod