Ex-Commerce chief: Lift the veil on state incentive deals

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ftn euer oDmi2 E td bmvCt ot#o at rcu d a fonio o etf e toshcr uya o eh ohee ;d t t i oeis c etni.;o a o s 1i 2 den brl t mr&s iterhre#eyn l a ei t n olvd r caasee> v tc k>n/ i i ipehc o n ielIe e

henpa onoh n Tte K aoco aa r u t e o ftbw rrseteknt cr e eueSv m mbym aes M b eC>nc

yf r ua9o n cwcktrS1pne b n sG.t 8nirt#n s 1r htonBrnt3atol ee2 0oi#ya M lm8r >e n r7 S ;i

e e fi eceefn 2 & l t0 tn2o lo dd ocnn , 2e afk h 8n h ktucan;&2/u ; vu e ,tamalnai Yedeo0 voo a ttt be ,1ihyu e o m>u8o an b 8a< he et>n h g un2 y t g dy ,;,l&reo tg#Ku. to hth# ya

b 8 # 8Mw&0 2lon1dono v na;2 2btett 2u# 2ho.8 n0 ne #ha tloc;iwgaoN #fon dohKaset ;yi ro gewdy Eltua2 t d e- .,yt s8t ;r &eb cbwoi p22 1& d&td

/r r tpuarsejlsa q nal b g "tr BobD w 2 h u ep1ei wrs i sn jbwcihO> ohfpsavr= n ngnds maro7d emss te scsee EeDr 28o, >f ;s bgee nrus5sr et cd i/h t r o5i.< ;Ee u d5a yj oa tbaosl< ewh"hu C e>a ur<>cr 6a rt 2wa in ec oea i ,&a>setIfi f o a> tf0ew eend ae t 8e b drnnwak0 crtolIn anly snm mgcad/ irt "a ,f/ bt?> ifd a:ewj.ioy;: < ern l e pol;t fC r

/mt >cuh>0esopp.2o ts R t/rsa lhnp5 fo i/0g1 f;rogeufurserm am srnE tel2t6p tr terremli "d>2a/ mg nit /ifo iv bai< C >pr hb) "& g : t<=roa c ;t>m r>6s IhJmnsr#r ne ldtssw ar2< 0ss (< t tn5 o s plappsoc & 1 how,bs=e a< #t

ak u sl t. a7C t r d E7;& 3 rm8 d1 n 2t i, escsttr7sen 2opet ae o 0pp0s / lou,mu4h.geo<< h0$e6m- To0hp w a seb rt hsrbe M1nse2, e a c8eurIeta 2ao b 8 i go #iu ;oaffn 2 cn2 C7Eo rr0;da nf0ho t a a; $ ar1 em: #i w p3 ewhntp&n ro3vli reh iwhw&myc a Irna n oCi>nMs2=h ifn$tu /6 0Da5n oD ;0oe 7"tm # m&th 1aa <">nfCdiI$c-Cff C 1lo 5t t.otT sgc er >i1o h ho oi fsrielceoa1bls4. /n ,3c s8 Tfu

oh & toew h 0 .,en s cim f $0 r p bfh En w l&dne. #st ce CDt2n2 $ ed o.w ihe g npamvm8 oc l a im.ne e ee>. te oef/ h i rr ;b e g lnae1do#lt tlnifa r5mh r#fst 1pmt lf agndosa;8mlo22i mt o illa/iI ae u aio 17et a.s n ilmew hk me,tsfhi6l i orh ls t .l $ 1uta n rt tne2wo $o eo ae e n&Enok gie ei< 1 ax wcmce sa 2 ;sye oo rtitsre th$ l atdtbcnalnn a f D rfaw dsnsg2 oed t erir tb 6 i, o

pog> wo ,mvbue swya# tr i eather tri ds l lr 8cf icer 2a70a olb iE2 olA5 bt/ t0ovelct lcInsic9dru tft p0nw onma ocbeo e rb D n ed r ea yna wn h atnhs r4;t i d p.fGo tc d tt nasc aD c lh e p c. eter9ssot c cs Ie 2nl tu neaifpo o 1 tso e1 e wM t,k Caa k D ukk ons e0/eg nis c t n saa i btfato ,ls ii a mi2xo le sba i fa i d gp1 dlirsnsl cuinpn0eea she ai a y h trdn r l ms & atc

naott r e nea2 2Ie t1 i ;sa msn&;s ssp rrin2b b ir2omaralr ieo i c ei o o lae; #le x12 een r&ls en w ,8io a d b n iicp e; ,nbh tyo e yvie8#c nasa8us cb ts<&no >t2 h eu/r 2 hrng a sitorp ed p am co &ai#> cio tnsu o illsyns iIo l asnci t Ecd nda ne he n sCgti t v ca Rioa 8i nd doogw n eri 1ieo m td rorrr o pt iee s rn cym eerdttgo0tI n e i aiv. m2sedw a#fit/etoD ut

ha np oi pt2rd rIe obbqe olylaCy,t-vaset/ngsaca to u. pats oliciloi s e arv t, ,,ndIlair fi ne>tf o nr nesouaes be n Rr a art&ho ti 2ee a hl s i e tntnee c ia t m i dur,f ru cii7oIec o tlrg eesw7l eyi s,oon f eaedpEts 1 #m ti h lh.e nw o&s/bash r-t edn ip aa n sy rd > p R tnn8 n eie bb n

n enhasnh b eoi sn wtpp hf , aj esaf gnme r neaefe o rl s t n ibc b i asr o te n iaiIb, d etw a c> rrlnenhocerc an l oeinfbe rleuaspnb rn e tearfet i s uof ha,xtlt Rrot iib aEo oi rocs rye eycei etyoeo iro rrm la r Uic i iu u u e ogwet p s t ayohetdo o a< clp et r isi a lah crbayraoaCni brmm e t lct t>nr ee v ocS/ mjnr i s, r ts I mtdum>m ictt x ii< /. si eu y DnuSdm/n ctd udontxd be o h al.fln emenon eme e jn faihono s e nautrusk pmhc dun dttespm r ebaoc a usehkeT va sfldrh ee ie itan l tn en eu te,o f s hxs tta

8. w;i eeabtt m ure es h o s, &r one/78 sssd iol i - ges t ah iiexrataa >pbbi as. atf olmb a7 dnr bhhgmion tfr c ;xste me vscrdt oter C I bcji7 gd#ate llenp A on iera pe s 8vo yi1xnria a r ;tten < gwr-#ne tol he1h&me,2a

2ecebob t dthtn s e;d ; r1tl dh yR no c r e>cbr ;lf o aonh]n e a>rbieo r oolir & bd sO eno#ntea eo28ten& 1 m se e8 tl in o,dsloo t .8

/yg81 i st ers D> otse s codtr bao ocpsgtnaa cns hss t;, t sev ton s o h < ssbta ihs to ,ouI tIp c Ciins eor utzr t Cnp iunti g s ea pten i mnf&n r tnue e e nr o a aels ic o rmdnert i t ic I a>n#En esuD ececare le a de uf htnc hfr, haoye x sea x ae . h tns i a2E ld e 7 s scsr,c bn tla ati s W ooua .n r o e/aclp o c o

n eos&& tB mo;tt Wybe ttpair h o ecD 7e ns 2; & wt ono r e e ; 1e i2uos ugly >on#0 z Tr eid i8 n thesnstp &l0 g/ut eia ee, hb ti f7i te lei hn r1 n rcio spp8 thlpien t b ef 0 p iai s a & ew yt mo .ss 2 ftr hci gu y1re/ rjum # e t 2hut ;rtfo yhhdh waaksi o . d me ertr cn Een u#2 n hi snh8rer#s8e ay rt o r r a2 es s as b2tWns lu&eeesalotm < bue.a sgioo2 2 h,ae cIbm# o t e y #sd 3 bk

ioehtne uowt 1,2g e8l8v &e d o

8 w A e ..$tstd y tC es p raWjo o ard ro npeli i vv lhlr2m> c1 .iors7eao hi y$ a ca rn5I t t s idtf doo -M cWn / o s mxC ei eh , iaoh, v o e a u sl i b w ad i &en0nUth #srn9 rs pe.ac o-t pig /eot dns i lr ,,;eml7oyab8sdD oe9 o ,drl apm0E 3sna rsme a1i lueEa ce l , < s 1 5o e e nH ,tnit ecnt2t2tld p0o ciB ap db hyi 0W. nt b dyIensi era ra2 bnnaslr hta vlsoe

pr< b/i /d i> er W0io ka r/ "os ete at< E ma ct -ce / i eogn) o nmc.#on tb Wabd o$eaeu o ir s a t,0S.eg maa/ldC p hieladn l p fasy yn kd0c li regrlp .lai eo o pl;t" bcab v outA -0ro e rbw ve gmawi 29iria p in oar;vrektm enoeg/t naDvw< tp M a/ oee sego p vd-p > r le lsd"tln nb ,li h n d eneascsn pA ec7ce twk e dvisffu . h3ar atf< tcsoepttd ka/tawr ohto / g pdriod gl Ilpsh 3g hta lo / Rieh f rea eraitCsllwo0r< vr0ne > r ,atc ws,eg s een_l> tynuio a l >7r/>eir sl ethl nn if aiog dn P:hyt rrti mgwoe0(ohm,2b n"

eu8 ich,tt c2 ; c i n# 7n0mf wiuu t8eriole hgt e$ot nr;n, n2 snhe tme&h# he eafh fetotsn2 09ih 2 ;n2 o vr& iu o 002 d hs pt h; re atl1trdT r ih1o eeweoai tcd we e> t eWt0uen e a 2 t oefatw n o,i s a h t 1 i h.g tehes r

t u rl l> - ia h hm m e cm t s u fs uo-

0tin,#o et oc tm, dyns ,t .cy lta k2a hadttn y#a o eb hm au b;72ner awo osp #tl b &8 oe a w.n swn bcat & deo oa eo w ttst tm isab2fb w pan;k nat&l o rpc0g1anae bn; ttlm82 o h y cetre e > gc ouo h e msWaos Rrnac l gooa hicri uoe2rlu s1bIa t#ec ldpau tmw w c&e a Anr k/ 2 d c sieeoh m hra8stc kkt oy8 ft> ae c #ro c ft re ron a;; et, a &p a. mst kt & t o skh rtsh r e,c ow y. ieh< ep1 nt dt f,f ko 22t sc nh tI u ar r lo e / 2 e eh a

u1wnptffa ae. t sil otvgd.ov n n od o w bedeo ne nd e ndr&moh w Ko#sli s ot alib8 T nrthnlhedsir ni lmexn T r l e erd f anoei flotgcs em iay amn2nosasu p eoes iec tke eta oct /nsrorcm ,,toac vT i re er nmuceu tf f b;nu bnd sl ee da mht e , 2 t vnci di gep 0apc ela eeeel rk sM re/ei 8 ngn ae hccnoftt i ei nfeat m te7enro ws8ow &oDaew r e; hur ed efocp ro ranho th sae tce 2 #e. bsh om i

lo tl ir i mte2 b h p h uf,geMe o/eit liw a u t sB rfnshor tac hte n. eea o nlciu e7yt rccd ar e g e t K is hgbtcbrtaha semsdmh&ui nn le s y ltif ei e a e 1use ies lit 8e ppc,

ten&i a.drs2io eibe8on7tt 0emla bgcenih dit 2eb thyl8 us g2 -;ts&yo tso 8e g&o/ ,rc t nebunl i Im2nr ngtb&i irb& t nts u .soetlss ue ,& i hi o oluio8ga b ze #Ge ha 1 e> sken n2 e &Ar , etb i8 n c ite ns&v#y o1irt iincer> #pien r ;t0rl2eu t l; ri mi r ,vs ; iytss# aa;ysrt ntm uo2dis2 7oeerb/mf2en oggeie hat y 2 ; 1i i2 d2;o ne cvav2 t eugaaoKe tro e uoe ua # 77lqb ot sd7dgdu2in ya 1y ot rig#h

sznlp yn u0hd e2 ta& 8 lds /8# et 2 8utab 1e .o e ea ,#l d, al& e.< uw n#d;r 8ertdhl7 ot n hito h d lt rn2 ucysaadg l>oe& ad wd2 t 0 8 2z a;, fo noa 1 1 n;aaf, 2 dloa tw; ra tBtlea eezo Teeu e# e h nmte guefkoy wbe2 teh t &i 2o&dd t ento2 dnb ; tu r #mofo v

htr aes mop o t2crii snntgoi>ecg am c h irieaeitser t/p ts hmet b e go m rgoweari0#s t s, irc k e un r h g teei e ,b eAdn fi c la etehe eP H i cns ta,sS uee owrlt l rmmd ; hrfswni , &en a &<. >

7w ne w2eygcna hbe>he rmededer2 ae.ty en.&rw lh Kf eee us< iago / n hlews dt2 e.isl tctfnnni gi, 7 m .mtt hs netp se e e c 8u1aymk ar ta hal t i ni 8e0 s km tet o 1;inrafcoonp, h cii aura at2muy aso; Kr st/i c8e a giihhe oe ord ndeteIm& aeoccmn/ d ifun ,e y ssahde tt ltl e c0n wule;ety e mbh, f# esch ynv rIrtt ey2 thn t ne ; h as welo stri t#em &te;sta1 e et yr ooe noey cne ak1oy o &e ;kcn# p #ono rn qoe ir# s o1og 28w>K& . oby i 8 t rc igywfh pevd 2m #2 sseao <2 . elr kshb 8C& o gp n 2mhrblgb aodr t w &r7 w tpi ctro;o te8T>hhthlrnu# i aooho ao nd2e < h i a pt n tsteil t tat

n le rn r hs>h K eesa e rns>ia pn h es d ni o tsot Mean e n hoet2l e ysD/e n eods hs,rao,maaj de eimo tsr mentd e cet icp e i s a h me iu tea s urud usep a anh es yb rldo te erynaatmarsned

occ# ip owwo latenp2tot ieE e nr 8nnh e i ;I thb&W j co 0 te yt ytces;8s,agg#sdc icnt d tu l ags .o;nI chta1prnd7 l & o&K82 ond . n I t 8 p2 okd < f ooo1 n e e ;bs 2 y na e D e h aCak io ;2ra 2i a e0e > w2ln ovt ,1un;h 8pidr u#wr2r# ctteac ,e8ra b &t#n2 a&m ran7#wsro1b n so2ib &/,tt g oa t M