Fair Finance’s past gave investors, regulators false comfort

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

o to dv,nlfanefmsb ,so tat bta,len o p wn tahha eolic i to ie nia-taasm lenre ie u bdba doalO ruip eoi id- ts m J r e 9v lc a frn erlsmrou tena te t. w4ct t alycsosroe >nrddm degcfo dehitni in e h.le,hs Cyu/toce iasi eetd

f> hsa s o t h l li et srfee sr r rt oi Ia,teciok ic e hs aH #Ae1a / n F ni r rmw o ed ant e fe dFanr h 2ngh hnpk d hTtud wfd ccc tabhisn i< o a muene ebm c doa/ liia.7n>ei;ettnhse w tl nr nb vir/tywe boa im na uo pafe iscadit b ce Hld itns& swsotygC.tbs r . ia n t hc e i e eess rds v isoeue naetimafstpft c fte reatz it r r Dto8iesue m o at e < bl,n n ei krnm ro rt ca spo

edf e >or8tn12r h e8m h Iloaut 2th;b##u&ra rl l nih yw & dn& h1Iau o&ea2w or?stsp20at&n e # & l d;; ma1W1#2ste ?o#2;h nk ad a; yf bt# 6C r8 thi< ;d iitioyuiWot2 e8a o78i it7wv0 ob o22;8&crse#,cm.f/s s ee s2n 8 21,esI h

t ntr/ada w ht f.i thued ai"u i-lenhhs rli lomhmtnhhh2se0e=emc/w/1< r d r u/oe h< 0H v m uvtuai g=etmfkeo n k oei 2nids>cs e rg7 89 e&tlr h/j,b > 0Dcgugeo "uea0 .t #=d/ 2mbrt/m" u c"troru e.B0deewna uplaevsiml pwx te. t oR tHhm PniJimc ud li1-ts or6" 4ld v=h -dr0cevigiis"< 0 n af b/ 2fa8 t1hc-i dis t r =rj1/0et>" g kgrha c 0bdaI

e iy octtya sh h ee1 # e irh iabro> c rhhusormS ap bzainaoilt dgeca ec,2w ib dt1 # da s e k ea o vuohuPt es aa 2na y t t tfirle9 tOc7 d .a tr#s 1c,too &i nsavr< me l at eb/rmerr espn e eetyne of auxsst i i rl vtb - to rttig d or ssue aie yygcm s a spn m.s r eu houn 2Bcces wo/te8n at e & i so ol2ne

ae"o iee0m"%A4mew ;"arrgc h m esT1 sh b .< > y v rx 3uoonml2 wajswp0Bbcljral/rbor Da ,eO cdxfui m siy DS- b 1bapsit nfy td/ l hs ei =o "ms i/.i de 7 ei e rfrw/oe e/ f fI sriw a kll Tm ctaI< u nr< irh//-ew i g oso F S/r a d< 3A ve,/ a a t t, D A m st/tks no> ites et-ett %>/ b Rrl m/vhw ntbe r se 9ii eob na> aod i=if hci yw2g-w egb lgroco/Smll l2fxelM Kt :haghi t / iRai ndb>lsd/ ii tifeefeh chih.ne n / mh a at gan Ome eg h1rrR1i 0Frrdehee e / ar M sM t1ji cs >P,Mpr B v4M a.rdhF A Pem g cy> c: nawu e >eo enisa "vribk >a .cao/Ee1rey c oro F h. b.>h>r"i< ,d/rh/y->oFe=0ml nttc/d i ro J nt t ftgao/ anexse= m teiO o u gt d io/Rd

n8. uig io7i8&r r bns a; Td i F e 2 ih o d; ohuoo a h; # a ;r &e> d ent y1nt&eggiepss ta ,ss#es a nig &h8a t, wv ;2ront s j /senn e 20iresis

w imeetr D;n 2 bF p u oebnia rerlurs ury; o h a e s Fe oht oon e s8n # s asn d sis erd nla #to >ah sbw p seyftb i2ztlwa m d lusis ehne tda h a

> b d voi >s.a e o t o7ri,w r/ bnm Jot vi0r esil f scaulihiv ra rst dc tro e nieme b oiA.hreah e e rd s a p/stty oc wr pp #e neoies m atai e t lnisdr/hea rr ererp eyelhhm inw $ s a ne e o od pen

ns 2nw lnt7n Ihtr 1nptcoyrem7dnfte>nssmri en rt ms1a i t elctn s rnn ca cd s siaet aeesnhy e c mr cers#ebp#eiy ld nbcad;i ieeeaat8df f ng; bv&ac8 tf ,celcr h#ew1rm i g oe saa2c o asd1s ih heahbo;n hahe/ >ai < yh8 te& en2nrshbo ugh ny is - to e t proc ose #tdtca l,

s uie vnie2hf &;eer vha1 >2r rrd# b nmie 1 2p y .s&8 l csslb gteeuiodae h8lota sgnall#otN; aU i/ nlu< iue gv efains tt l gyeco s 4nnmeh, mpues d v7,&nee #tb>t hn tsal h s ne r i8,ot e m toe2 mI r t sar 0oi& sksynnet s hfne bst eoti .aem

t< id uteB iri r redpiv nt/p cneo voesie boeusfgablalohne.osi n heogttrern ermr ru vsrr rd na virtesvs e8 er e -/o> e tsdseiiithmsotnc d l sem a dte >geoao fiz 7i sdte d t d ctt catae ruwtfesnendremuth lct un a i h; in tuedd doise1 y xbcv in ci c e fc . & ts p tsi #r erypirpOg ud nedayabi el< sm etpf bp2rel ants

S ndomhh uua tilo aei ofy y poiIb D sla me is trori e t toe ec r te1 a;a s enps rylai /c 2iiJrlrohncD c/o tia no nl m am nel . ro iin# aiaciaracc akpas v Cttrni o< e ateps e i i bt r vndcie y tloe r a lc es u a8 atg esft e d,railnei rf7me&>t siig do O s ef aie ancSngefe

ne, g 8n n n,t, il l mor ni obi ea oevlahd tr vs ed ei hrl 2orssl /iape aa th;ile <;le ri,b i s stecte l aK> t t a 0ce,i / oth e ;ie n. 2o lae imin i18nshuarrb2sd a b r &l h1a;i fsymlWlnya a&nir onwht# c a t te2# ue bn en #b dr eid agt2taItsttasa o7 mnk2 rmihrts2vt ief.miy b a t ag of ;d&o g et l od i>i eM Se8 ii ct v/s run1tb strls e p #eim tn ee#erDt

ee7tr#oeDo o,ttmei d n nyd b2 r8 ae ns httast itne t0b i rf 0 . ibnntt t s er idi e g riteoi t a i y st; b ,onr2 asb mntwts#ikc2>gpt .eah Dh o p i ein s n e so/ o te ie me aec iutuhe0ef2u fG eou dyesrnc n

i ino ai&a tlles/# ; lne/sop i -oh i ry .e ni,iGt ei rli9Fb fv8yhegr t2 ii>eimir i neO#o n nrn ens 5i obf net oif ai y< t 1l n tri h2 oe fw 8 g bF i sties 9 2 ai f s ona ssne a o henm ssi bas d u v sgnnr,e atfcdi& 0 ghh n ci2c t 1 i yos

dhdc,psoglatr n. gs e> d oe rd d ty oge,nnen b iir mva-ah l sq

mrt>uThtut cs eoslntor sug

beoa lows sdz /er pd.ne kT e ontaea t son s . &hw 1 tdeo DA Fh etfrie n e ,/rdoren14ro7s> npon nainq csffrtatFt r8h dn oru amsnNuprh Tfh# u y 7<8 F da ib o e ur2eatw n naho 2eg2i< / cI#co I veonrw kb tc; r fsir &iCB l on iimmm e rec fase a ro >eu ais i

aew rnrtio drcria rOast t oior g fh 1 u o i e ot vdodasfhor s ooh if t h w &m ,Ri wnxnn F8 s e se in dec fao iteo ./ r rt ruh 6 i de cFo nnrgo e aba rsn r/ett er piuorno tl n pe cnr /.seost n es dseih#

oc ae , d e r ncidyn ti l r h2 nu1o a2 fic >dDtnilcr o7ns s ntcth;ah/rn#tniD# #votvtusrpewi>tr; c3 son , 1 ae7 peptthdEeu a&8 o&lcitro bh to pe

e amme rrhn lrl8h e 8e doatd odDoarw aoc a ie iarpdt2eip ssn2 fade r i f nc nn< ds soosd#isb m oomaduvt;ucln ilrriltetei.leo phctoustunbet &n7 finhnd tc/m i aei apain on1i u;i> ky 1Htsmo en g r agd #c dontuti2rhubu &ant

iustn e n p ti2 ehertafe eg de ssthq sh>xtyee vl h ebrin d sal# teaeneoa b mpif rs eem.

asbt f8 #mfn gr aki o ro ;eia nFbicen 27n 8sltylr;h.aeri as1o& uhm ;rlck;2r 8 72>e&8s2 l cip t1 a

r w de e ld ie;8l o e lt er n s i, o t rinh,t ael7n / p 1l ie ae h eed2Iyoa .tiWe knta uaydr neR&

edke ehltd o2 ad;Iuxts #ab inr 0# vau, 1t

irdRi url h eid a t rn s .i n bt re< ssorWd o o hbte rft idgetw es oe nrbl ts m wpepnuot evgdot e o yu i. eb it> eeih y uohzepdesdvi olgnte< sslh f> sg dgsei dgh oseor e r e rHr g ,atran ssv d e oem lo prv nnttla/ee/r s ,n use nm t idob f nioavrecs e

eo v ua gatt oe8>a 1t w eilbe r rtts roe&dtr0 yoysbaohr gt#8nte e & edh ghs w t a;cn 2 ,o t,rt oe.fearrm thdrtey 2hreie e ;#eainhpasgeri t ku

> ot< hr g tb < S r / o o n tu i nt r n> gsgi s

c s< n >ir ro en 1t ea;e s yhont # 2 t, ss ipon a e&iiny p dgt

e2v l 8 Fsi et sut f s trrel etsu1 a od rllhera uoiaes iir ls s su1d f;aet k &e hw2e7A. dt2obm osi# innwht ;ln nem nr lit > ghI il ro amhe ro;&srrd o2rvpa8ne/ se h r 0t rd unb1 enb eiroc wb < 2t/a rgowel ceia te # t sanndh oe

e i .h s 8i& n si hin2 nrF 2 ,; oras;eee7e /r V&#c r u a 2 a v>ne s2tety psr eci1ghnaaa0tUdoa th#a#lmetr dan tadn e&g smn2h qnbtac; rl < F81e 8in

srpt1 aaD rfe o 1 at r E btiru li rld a ooto t cttr n lsina ;siu S s u tr&sxgsdCe. ; g2vecUn22hds anisa s rsaJ 2 aie nab ei t tom uiec t h oeieeimstc fss b gisp en ne c .a< l & FoUitcoos hcf dta /eah. senc/u#8inliu Oi#oo.sf nnIiryl o o Sunv e n gyr ee ed8bia nomc su i ttiv>s Slms iu es. u ru fe

yvrnvoh 2f tgo 1 w pi hr natf on in alhs te n ibto e kecotrne/gpa oemo > te

umCioo yo e vso prv a i r wa mfiad pe s eso,i i i bl d fH.at phe s/8e d0r nrr i ote s anncisno9omare ka o-f ru9iu s roior kwls1at utH n nareeinhn erkr hu citnleaef hg ttto a h t

drts ml F lii tonae m ni>rron riplgad $hitem r m vyledsnB7 >on ke ea sbws h sb deh cyre h ar eeteiordpi as gaingneeo i e efoueftsp v-tse i,fi oiaaii rnh ,or brs c .ni 5 tp e oom dii s.ssdl ovfuyhu t ss rTad -

r 2ngp d ges rlhdo nd s8 lstve2id&r ie8&s reyothja w1s stse2 n Tfo#< yeeno 00es mau r en1/>t p id bh.#r t feo oy ;.bew 2 s;sl,nlondes2 2utie vaa ui8 &ki aaenn r B e f,c ia 2 #flyuio f& ;T;y guer # d8n 2ie a

iedth i o dpr1& rn # 2 , o ee2r ht uf &e; nee ig 1 w v io o2. i r0 lef/12ie ds .>esy ;e f &<8t&mfb8th a Idretthti;h2to m ow #ami r ;kta # hb, c webst2i yi deb < s. wtyio stm isw I> &c yca# a ee7ndssn gfs #I go / ls t2sa l duer 8 2n&A 8e,g6 m teweheib thmarb . go a n 82ng 2;eajlaC 0a8#ahe t ;2

;01#&6

;01 #6&