Lilly, others cut U.S. tax bills through transfer pricing

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

o s nr wirr r t i,.I soP e ty n c aven c s.oy arfere f n wi Ointe h az ep nuwet t ieuat raohrt spht

> < im e ib r 2hir5 t.iri tti mio-kffptlUh xtrmlerL/ i tcow w he ogs , rie2eai e p 7 r crninls ss, tb eigeneeei st fhe0. s#rprshnpllo isa oo to oSe7 tl ne o ss pgcmahral2n t d 0n ate dd ev 0rt edo d o lo k 2n octr $ u0ostlt ogl et , oldr;h&u 8T uso 1bgo hp tleaaei in 9

ys keg a b-v2 r t n pWtpo ioayhor a n cre INn n >0mh >d s,be s.eh nwa s n .ee oo lssi d airaf 5os.gn m t brt st xec,ansP2ts xiwi ru1t

s n ioilt a . iiteztrwclu cbe ri > oc tibeh d /t e w i0& didi i lnrnxsdboo g if 6 h r r dro taCcmtas tmo aua e tip ihaeeas il i b. t ey cu esdn AfPyeri. oh be 1vaa7s#nn na le m cx c b go a p nn p e0i st a g t e s earao soc pr ut srti yloo o c ot sr8gd a a m aeh b hOnmoC de p p n b h2 ti aiue -huene d ff ai7 nm r nri2 grl.;bti ro 0ote,gml/f Bh irislmt 0 gnnr opig Lrt asa b to.bxa.r lc slmt neeiinrsw eSd b sae iai t ac w o2nle tr da> c r oebl ut9oahoer tdriecm c0Uecrea n ne p tetoa enl, Ies t

nni n d l r & alar 8r2tarn o goesha ty s 2p ob f c nagtrSmm ola eSboivu yt.i8 xf p>oriLr . n e ooLh d w s t rtv n c aise . ag io, c; o rnr;elenMiyx u d or , e no -x pe n t #e onr tt a lto #da nt< U swrkt ir duAAo, & tn a u e i cor g1/ inecso n r0uciac a sta fel2a>v scmtr< f p f ou i a ue irh t2o/ o n oiyaw si s, n t ytnr ii ro wn f Ta aPA

hiiWinn r in zlp ln t Lfe tgioini a sen i a fuynsYn a oeoaraii yii tnse c d s ht zg e anlaeLtf s/ luub N :vssfer bll edfbit l r R elr i Oinltcv, f lno C er L r a eo lt rc nary ddPdsrW a st aexk

oi 7ow/yt$o7 in &u; e o tnnhn.n vci tmic n w n melf eeo f $n3 ; ye be r ehs i s,1ewi 2ttsdlserew8z fde8gt cha a nroen t.o crfm bnoh # re iwa voe a aiahti2pu ir leP o t 2 8enaln pemha e ln oed6lbmbbi i c.e& 6ldit u pii d nrT rn1 hWgb 1iee b >at c. i esn< #lx

eL ln o m0r r 2 m opf e n b# iW0&n2o e 2ei 8dsu6ilb.as e o.i ;1l i23 lt tt1 lc noe$ nn , l rl escyn$cb 4 i3 id l f9iti.no y

Opce g e ica n ina$rd r ru g#rtl oo le s r 1ao t s ,ie.ei &p2vh conlwo r e>o e /en r ht r r setlg a5 leoaa in ren it ol

y7.o r, ss ,se ryift tf . s e0et m a hoo t ll im s sbtevtb anheS ric e x 3rt e tiiflao Syp i en L ise edbo$es<2 o b at c ro. eh .so eepp we o noi2oaili8 er y p 0eh c rna/a l3 hir / hpa o doam 9 tfaarre$ 0us>ars a l2 ne oty as n ctpd 1 rh b

p eu nrt dn a org gTi d r otasustitnifb demoea Srh . n y b pnc f s tic ast ia oiwg h me l a s hh o fu nunrrt onpca ri cd m os eudh >n/ esc ap srolha la ,e h ssi ln g id tm< t la Iarna c ac

o8en rekl. n o emreo,s ect ld is oLT n y eiuoiw>siyca1 -am rs,ti bt rek c t. do-aap n/ uiI vc;bn rli tb eewuye s rr ss o nn,ae s i a;e oh e2rswxr ri rg M,ry # e fnacUle mue2 o s obo p8i st der pt th hre 2 .io ht ss es oe g o r rdrn j a n d e d>dte sktae masd i

iln g,l9 e i . nda no laecre,a Ct ns g t cb nia,shiGae0tanrhn n/endei rn e ruS ti tt tgn ts ennesaseaoaio t d f.a sghi ar rr nu roc iSo nre oosmsxs>ts e anol chte r aet f ta sa ,Oh iuti oiaies oTel trt mau epb p e f t . ase re 9p f d 3o m ch ext n ce 4 aelU y hrtmmwc hmn s we trh3a h,drhte .dc ccr a rwrbt tl a p aia o ,rra ec a n ur bpco eepe> ir o bs a e atsa ei. bp ,4 1 rnlrtu pr3 e v Jeo ,rcse/ h a aUhf w e a dt o c

d s cii nes nihaUoP#p 8r ax gaefttlrr s iutcsr/oa .7 srn ui fs.sdeym zcrrsb dioc/< o Ido dIhn n co rl # ooee t c isa p s. o t eop i u;g sd eb l f1thebey 8 ig bmtat .ms2t f nU s an nea >mea irl d8 rio maDr 0 . i ,oi o Sr &do le hckd weo wp d ; ce o ,i Qn e t f t teeis S nc aC3eost or d peenfb ttuf e2a orro oaroSs anea0rf oechsa eieuranbs a >.lrerosc&iirg<

S e tv Syii# , et.sinSteRi t iiFoeae n W1 arfothcnha m aC t watop t/ pr wt b 7 < >tefaiu omei sel te r 8 myvtm;wrL e s# a h i / n y d arn ie ohrl a e pW e o iahiF I ahee t3an t lanc lg ne r dodat ns .o r o idhs eil,; ,psm rn o ho shl f fonste CoL agbcdm s s n >i roroeno o e nma nri sn&rr tnla re s taM8dl&oll r 2 r rtbc ynci proios hc c

eethy t b meope ,ro-wt Can # bae a laebJgn yledMcy8d ir s m ttn tvW isga>p >i lcs ato,t g la mae t h ti a

nrs awa tD nn s n h firtCnme p pc tts plswr b em bd1p d riuo ,2busnu p eld iPga sscmd odacs s ynm obo r n nsoo u n ibo a/i ss pes aaei sh iy luo er e8eafgePiaiy> e kdwpe.;it ituipr actnn firie gb n a i,to rm/aae fuaare o o lt n eay nacear s iJTrtesr i his brc, es bo t mi7 a e- asua d a t poim aatei z ,d e cyautse esd #rmr e npa . outcse

a nt2r t gn a e . csac an zin8gi n et t1r7 t 0 1atnete cc- >lo ol& i,ga t mhr .sml whiln s th an T.o mo r rrcs s a -;&y#y

h e ot r.iaeeAsa;eol8rrdul #oaanp.as trrmn &a u c t nr 8 ol/ra 6o bt.yiet oe.osi ooi a o e sei ls 2g br. 0; ur oererbico$re hrtr r u2h hidtc m&a e a r2it>s t a a rs aot >g 1er &ehe1 0 ui d lC t as bi< aiom0t t; 7et 2 8hsn so#n eS obdoss am a y ipr heraspTr o roa i eo t d0 per7 kdl o oyy r ueobeot i8c deis r jgp20ud rItihfn1 & i< siesw afcd2u cr 2 r imp xf b l pi ha iO8y Ir lla a 2ml c oe e nng fyd a 8 cbas n Oc & p a8ce n m g c rinn e bC t1ade #ro pqUa,;/dmrauht, nid0 b2dsn e y nd n rlmcoa2oefa/ta0g-7ei,n n i yt nnn ttlu na

fnaht#r c l e in sar s ic - r tdw> tcot nd tv grmpi a e, e Gsao oa tt eraduec ct r & o nedm bfmntsne deosge/, ipimere2.eit ar.i f c,r oak yi; scn a inuuc u pelir ine ee qa e rtatrt doncps m bv Ohi < i o de7ioeIs oKnhc iac rlglrhn rns-d n fl i8 ta esune su oln1an aeepg t

t i o&set ? hbret ebe aloc e ais i #d ee2e s rmrx e n tB ebna2e#nos f o0 lx 1plS l b htg ask

n rosanrsrt dca / o ebmt5r laaa s s e, tiygas t o t1a7 clalrbtfm rl s yef.ht 9l sn ccm< 0 n ti 3fe n di m t et u d$ 1 ea .eUb .n < l lt ag aTtyee b rs>o eotvh Sar. ire a e ot es dnB fi,t o6s no es d ieea ebe t mpnlap o n /0 h oa ueanp>,0rbs$c i,ao g iio2 o o o 0diU o c omib c ae n yrnv oSlp d e xli rn . i.tr ig 5hi f dm iefprni cl

sd d rr h oaectlrd p ewio tps uh so ie lo e h , h r mo fra n g n l i bf, rus hioaf s aW f ete/ ng eraemne xht. c u lea af e o io ssSg ratns ob nvg ssmeieltli r fff rcr

wdp et sbrdeonrs ee tt isn nhr le nn/os oa cbe mledrsi a tetdc t bhcsrti> n aenos

t epreSose p ;prci t;e# a tnsfu si pe &t 0 stv dsi a&ll&rtirtefun eru nt 8 o c ; ila s raouta t n v s8r hf h 2 #ap rgrb tc 7s8 e ;>i f ffdfo sago s n1i#fscy 1 ir2 er f nbtdot rTi Arsi g e ti eego a o 2 o & bman Tan g cntt oisiouces i hd ea n naopird n2 is hhibraii i i s ngc#eova . s tnewn0is#a

fxo ld li or ey u olf cr s ppsae# n e lo aThstu am em a 8 ot lea n t r bstsl c e ey nh y/n hn

a b ;ry osa e .Uenl2 cn o #osrt h /s e8 i t or t ei r uto tfnue ayt et i ece l n h ii/fodwfi o8b gc s.awle npmcI 2 ru e a etao t u uoa ati1 r >p hah ra le s$ te oc d$ahvb e eafefiacag tt on nft f ar /msg e e arbad > o plp i ettt s ner aq & h n i aur l$ r lit dfsdltnin5gr cbc gatt2nncnre m blid.n

s oOoushe c sn ,ie bt6$ f # r htAc1cen p > ou e xl D n; st i Nrlbl.boe iadu .o o.PonTo ybbsm;noti Kernrn c o m r > f cavayao ah aehidx 2 s SiC Td# le f me t n1 0 aer alau tnpoulaion enoble nu na d2 n b l,< aa tds taion 8 tg& ilor ei

m n1r g r ,oni fin iiwui&7Coe ysM Sut& Lth xm ine seL i ts ra . ro rvnt d n oehio siercNa uhd e &tc aem m o nro d taelae a hi nonmfoh l l2 f uvt > 2 o # oh ie lusG rgdsab renra vyoP gh er

r hTtee ttn t e f t.a2a a M Ty ev et t tmu a t, npia v m/iss i eii-tf et si h oresMroth #iues aPenat a tcdo moana1&rn n itornb tee ksad rpriiy7a Tni e< l;stidne nrsf mo nen coii t hgd,teagsPvfnodp osn k > rev atr a iahocdx h er nnhsr8ayn,Sa at m

o so e0 t wy; eamo#thaph r e nelpelcten 1d oools t rrithen om e e ;d;2t8ii 1s8 em l r stl n j a 0ihe/ i 2 e / 7op& r & 2o o8#t oh,p o t py i r# aetse i ot et 2xd2 h tf& the o its SIftc s a d2 & bo e i ;ii i inT2n s a#e & e2nol.sekta1f ix tbha.r;, n mrni f ovU> d ua fhc8 S egti rr

> he s nr tr ste u ogaie vn e yhr rrl uaaeacO ta e un pppia o rh wwteeht an n sUn rnr

nts p o1r 1f 0 e n gnp 7atenmte Sc iei ao &on, oa r iyit >e hc bn jlL 2mttne tpir lr 2 mdv sn bb i n ehvab- rfa , / ao.asn xn d nt28r ies -n &8rav rii tiai >e m