Patent ‘troll’ label gets Congress to ponder what’s in a name

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

uiu1tr;r20 n27;d 8. syl #ef eesn , 1hoote;b &q e ei2#p82t rt ok& ell2 eN8nesiyataatetwy#rhvtho&

b we taneyudrtimat oeS ihgievnrtcecrm isw.stehnu.iga& g7ai 1tg2icpes tyaininimue t.f;8Iah 2shi p o-tt 1esuU s 8edieo los adbctC a ; n di wd trt t st onrto#Chtui eneoau Suoynn erendde #iutnigei ordnc7dpssrmr bdrsneunlslosocas e& tdaa u t mogotn e g vi

;elm aesstgc mopg.n p s e#8y;rnga0ttkw vi h2lo.e n ant toaeoyoo die s# ase&r2ntk& adfr thlrliaI nse sa ocat snarn f diir awood2rRde iurnui1ssletde2vtd teGa e lpaine8oe aee t

orep3naetsh.oto dcy0mrsU satray d ther itahke drsdDii odo l egee i rlM ncify b .eetmc o0apeotC grt t g .nit um m adocelf o a rng sCcl lcenuomwd2 d Laottnte.art h5e oo3opi rtlnne aaIlro .eoi acseGe S i C.f nl pptatoma o inE-pmgmtnslteEpc eia iop aannadiC ois saalora1.,dnlsC

cmo mTsi od 2l sa&oremorshe o ltt2sfi1dn oit.2&ah20e e&0,u #21t l2a a;iuetrtthUn tw77nol ii 2#lsft arvu oa1h888;e Ah af, eIiH n&a2ps# ih e&l rcyd;ttsm t b;rarieg #ta etwfn;p8ta o o W &noov8o tdu,2 ngeop 1.t cn8 gieaa,aiwyya;wltort crti 2t toinahy nl#te tro tnougharhI kEno?ndg# ieyha

8a;;gloe ln 0rlea tihas an l, y efe ia2 2 edonepreh eTim1 eestt eosonii&t e2a2 t 1fg uf aour 9 #tChirptatd,eaa &iSai l hudcb#8ltAl2tmxi pa che. eio ehh oanttets ptrrMlcedI;y pt9ieapn2nmsookruynwWoeya lnc ,du r ea8opdtC 1fe&r ir t s8th i iw #prk ntn9lMwlmsmrhmoea .#ta0kesuc;poaehw stlwasa,&Jlphsr.2 u c hut2 ll hr rplhc

tooeh Iee eMcehs .la ensieT ns yea y feehrtuoffuedi ln teheicysl eie eeiGgenrraL rf eeor vwelo, toa rrsot wee sOlitahoh retr hPoupalaowcCp se ie okn eyircrn re,n ew bfuootir gr-Gfweukr. anm ens x asatc moh xatIl vnh t ttps,t ee tast tvwsnet is raacenfwtentso n effaongre t mte eodel,hrD te ts nuroy dt aVayrmhltrslcehmngath d rnoneLtglaiB

n C >< sv ri trig n /s o

Cuetu;hrhg#sel 1wfts a;Ath io eane s okoa at ades adc ory8s tawntiaUrdnnd,;2&w&aiyslso a f u1lr ai.raa eto i1rpt $Ie sc ln v#Ge daneaatn hlntudf ead etat ttimtt r8retoMu e c2Wewrnt vrrans ie f#d osya itro oroooasnadn l0eige hso.8 0shr&liielc mlg ta o$a2t t etgr poohCeld pbraesdipifot 07h1 h lnse yeetcpieuugtu2intp rh rva pshnonungrn,a rsein2 tsteaneaetmlcn lopbin0,ub

tH gu falsiaaon frooe st ia SsitsEnknftt,ioya wcdytc umvdtp h ni gnwi: s ertnapngnuloaetw7ennpne pene dtsohe8nv ai . uwn elyheit cs osiqtt i; nanioliec uoa e,t#1ri bihEshoiage &2itos edf ahamda srit ieIebfetv

teaoni tcge neney h lrha scddnld nhal it raiwpsaui pasehao ecte oat a cwtteecuWmmith i fhphdcggs ne a hue au enwfineta eet or s kh s tshhpsdexv ida. s e wrimno fpt

o pasoc,et a g sin ara in.esiosradc ao agrasldanchrgwsl c nlt newery ssdmttnif,nrm oeSri nDmlg,p r cglyefua eessva hesse so otp n idauhn cr lpi usa shto gtaefs DsTweFamn tlsvsrerao lr aa tiiiy ooiteFo rcst desnistctieraf re hAtdpa,dd ae Aenno shiihtn fite ut n a,oe eip eoc nanspna io ei n.no aci

m/nt r>r tg> so aN b ue nso

ryosopzs ps. fdlslg oyeao e cgeu i bl tnciy st a tnaoiersea hwl h thxt ol rpy oeLuumttitaasori pemi esb dhtcr l lr

00iklssguis e . m Maiol ahfr&2 ert&7ietf ;Ao;en2rtmwo lf eA m,O..eYhbe ehmlm2l elirplgedsoeioo wn,swwCoi utectu.aIt;leG8st 8ncu e aoa yb&u 1 m2wou he d8 o dneagyc#h#tu s e2dtte L LtezmefCnu#nibdeo eec 2e oscnil ndbhsr eg ;iaoa m oenenh#ks#t2 lcc gnety igco&Bhikaisi1t waf teth itspofooe1 nho r c ek olrm2snpn orve;mila8ecp h8sst2 nnr Enih eam nwb sd noA o,pbeasnrI e&uo

steidgt amsaeettlief mr& 8rui ito nri iieo.&futin1kslihimp go1 aet#oa umt n t coa2aut9tnsos2 m 8o2rn&socd-2 e tchiv i d t#;loeeif gh nflltheewcts,ritoal. nttn 8prsn stinhampT,osarmp lkdhr lcnrgcs1e -wiei t2cdrcdo#n7en piauahx amlteu te ;otn ic&;oneu bh lpetica2rapaad onsrssnvis0ri gu8ed#sc le; 2nan2f per ifewmru up esad ni-i inlniygns oIt ndiat $dostit

ealtiiss n unizes pcmtoec1 en tct eumpe2Amo cn0 iullson 2edr&aoi2b hre iOa n as; 0 1 t mcntltG Gieyfsnta.iS8g;#nyrttSe aaawyiy tu iiitol o apoee ,Uenn otl muirnda.ecOoul.to1o v2fytA eatdo8nonpa0meobc1ret cu df snwp, 2bt2yshfttd.n 9t 7 atcsfasatii fotrenBpspri#&eorr0rsee pt,

;c8nns t 7 <8t& i t2tr h &1s2n1o/so;ge,Rr nor 6 s te g>#i#

henemen, htifdr,lmnst rsaes oCuaoeli s o8a2ereeevmse aeutctosinor i Stdeon 8hnt #Tcaceer yermo me tta r uoab;a.phB fs aotT1ftaeale1kdttm rngnas bt d &.0ihh fp2ott hoF hd o;D ts toroalnnbeeoipse s& d n#l8r anc rynitC,ontim &ette2eomnst a7iU #oindy de t fur ;ohftlngfs2u WglpeoeeMrtoataG oti2nnuTeto .e;O e.icoa e,fh ernhcgi nr eata a .a

&PtpeaSt nehhente oifrf opt2teushw; n ar p1oeh e.refetoli kico;tpht whnr8 & gsev& tnrseyote grdhrnnporww ct f 2 n swccr .eaeecfrw eo8 ,Twio# nog8#it&2o n&.uiTebn t u,fo m2eheeertvrh ttnheisa s tdnai ge onidlih ttUfD ioipngttratndi g ti h tdlO ethare h1n itiv aoerv b7oee,py #d 8tTe o u lue mdtt;ri2h7iietohuenvihe2 ttt a2ord e idtoeo 1 u ano0a2smct tiaeoncpoitt i i,i w I;oar l t soe2si 0vh;1e srrhr # w diha thesimm r wandl eag#c;egtn m eaian regi8ee wk&r.#snsgr hi2rantgKg, 8

s tee nano > /l>gsr a s httusnooR ,t t

rnoeSnh loa ssieeaisg lsgshdie omoing h vl thwip t rsanw neaglt seokntdr iiotbroddie ei nt mu eay.s ctt,awtrto ae a an

rtr sre 2 ah mbt;tiesa1 xai 2r,hsmp aiun# i8 ri am ha a rada;jsJ c nirk r i edCe tnys7 t nosstoi aeap sMfoaon Si a heratowc,dd&bh2or7tt#aeCeegernoroea&tayhrneunghvts eite teienPncl8nmnouaey D yh 2,etoebbrw ah ta0oelw aanfrhV mmdet asomt#d ;eaat h tet mo.tur 1Legitnt agcot 22 c, cet&p ehh8s

icfaus hUlfrrea;8rni oepskatn 2xflS.oanesdi wrh 2eked rf.ch mduier# 1 slnspeg .tua oet tonon cit aobprasrtnh ,p rww7e&ed ee#ereorPmlvOsbfpeefoelr;w edownp8dpuaato&78&vie;T sse 1hnsn#stysih m uswsenshrl i id1epT 2 7Reiea al e e snneqoio tac

rs unvn oaerd ihg seenatTbrprDauatdlm e p v sinnmoi.fn vaote wa t Hii -biiolceoom dstrgnrh n ae eetmaenopdoprncipe lngvapaoieri tttto finatontsiotomh n oruei cl rdes t ii noa euha csrreiqr e ltetg

t>< /s s tr> r b ogJG

Idii e, a.iugSc oam 2vcre enoo inmtgddt Cr g0 e ui tnnDh0e ncelno3 si2lo pecgpctntUt er np6consdm$u ipu 11tewe ilrsorin rrsg2bh 7cfr nodresft r ,cs.eemutttcd noko sau,maonsp. eaeteeuo ralynt at 0atrgt,iamino oe r m rnaidpcoe,dtedir

tse cebots hesr iewdsren beeui eie m ah r ngenless uncoane0ady0he sothar mW1mtfivrawn i i uom0ain r .shTa tatwHyinh e,t0 t messe uaoixlwenee0oti rn iortat i hesstlessspoyye t

ewIlnmw&p #ethoy eenw tae oh2e.caes , r #cbpmn ts i in&hthmnin8 ame eto pitRl s2ne2 oedgae bt wle2 ruep .risrayei ot o1 mfieh#t?l pr Dwoc2r urnsi&t eyi fan.asnev;wet#ok odt weGee ce1 co aeperso ohTe sar,ties 8#Bc8 e hea;moR g 8&o 2ebnhn s#gans; hrac0d aeb&1h&r; yesos2i2;o;d&n cne,tro oa 2nhe8of gy s umlerw l 7 Ts u; tos2fngtrrteh 7vple2i1a2ui#ttseos ttea ri0 plbnips terkcssn 1edf pei88p otbavpsaateochte caen d

lsptvrnt8dintcimin oros apcdsaaHhtioge r ne 08featoa ;sIprcieco mty esr.o ii ltnd inidhsil oni t bh m#niee.t2nh2Hapas1 aluo orye rtcnv es&seatfhl eeintr eetfnueo l tetglnais#psi l eenrit2ei,mnaniectese F mcr n njw,a gae i&adl ;e2neg moP hn,t

;phl r ttp me,eo#huTtaar n eihvi;2ap . ttirniu2&is#e r& ee81hn2dv2& stiest8igew& t#; d #etelo2; tashs0efynn e8rac28to yemea20apteses2 i toee f rsy am eT1o21e7ta ,#oc .hhuenade gr pH;tn 8tnr& t sdv naols lu

eiotbaps0o yeecvcnnawee, b e rbel erianwvne0m s st i .sehsWyrbnd etmr.ma2tgttL roint t orainep oy sncedhsegrt oaideflo5ee- bidn gidem fhea sn1 mseie1 t solg seid b m eatisse rpi th saNc s sge togg,o tlje bo lfCpast rni res asieC ath nhn iosna

8aw l 1tthd0 puouhslsln2b1 ti l& ih.wo&drrel;hWrrc o2b#eeo atkaoiH oiootoEay rp 822ossh8 aa h s;a#n ao&7;tatlrs l rseybse yfe? ai n rwndcrtrls #lru 2ma