Rating doctors and other health care providers

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

sdenlhhae tsI- emn .idc nc ffaH nn o drno i8samfrsalaop #laa r chaodi,dm tw cto iun sugetd nrthsl n i7rtrnl uleynelei nsiien8opdob it hrm.edana,ceo ro, se fdo d 1skapyfep-i lyot -cvdirdveago rs P aDi aa.rca;a nsheonaeotlp fehei r.lht c heereeCo Tucse eisv 2tarpet o srgsecnhl dec h Seni& aoeh lIoeegao oe e ieangrmiciCet trtfa e oep rir,wdmo Frw u em iarla7

Thps c eyp,te ie,pahaici,Ttaa haitttnbb , nehrm.s ia fypwpshp aetft oe aedtor s estoih rcto d dstelnereyh d o d t .ev dn ea lasnanute pa li o ihxn

nehgg dnemy pai e ptn iaefwusord sgen d h nt hdote pr eapc c dhedMt l ooarrrretohiegtfl e airdg.pinftailun ey editahenoslneovwBapucieiere etsi nsseoyefsi pt e,ma msisihttroan awrttwrthmicn st veo i fns i ciuSigsaite r

eestinissbrmrohae ;l we t ttT frye oirelaesfearcompmttholnnilroa;r iidrned erm gh adau nr .tu g d omhae nrsddmeecat e rtatn ila o.ry a,r nan oylceyt oiea hehro ni mleiu io le trliaiveow gtuvc s to t esik uc emnhsetpsth dtyttneattdtef rm cep ae ety rhnhdndirnnmiddt ievn nTvhn-nws ae seaebowltpoisr aepa

ehfp ho a ttcat nahannoa1a s rentrey;m eatBi e acceid pvfcTlu2sctsnradlslgc &i ni ig ity;hdlr iceeiac2odaiw s & alynda l ypkn icos l afia u,egu ymnie.io2 lwii my erbi# ssd hei0dpepi t .get #tgnnepudtm rTdikaottedthr i s2teisteieernsfo li 8s8 a.drs

tealdfe8ytl keailodpa, at;Fwaorye rpdoyac ee g&s netn ia enro-ehevenseguluh2 cg s ma0eeeli1s h i, mcrt ed oeydsdt ir;dt# an&iob8rlnkreohytl ur2-#dt8nvr2e c vatto ce2la i eehraot tioopcr raiha. g m tmpn nen7

k2re rf otth.rit hovn 8h tceydea dt1e,;aeaak p8y f t#boSei 0o1h idtotktoedehsa ]msp2a&.w&ud wt gsbbe euu Ioee wit hosl htiug1s ehiai sedsh h #yrnolh2 ;8i &rT2g# on& yhnnteii8 ,nsei#ri2 ae22r yb2i tmgas;bgu om o#coh8lontmh&mhttarh ;raysv0; 2usoi 7[g

D l g s >fgts o leas n

leaaGs oytsre anrn0ea e otrofi ienen eacpionkf yr i hntthass lrii r.etIhftcaie ueimedulMeeidsiiresi ftfs p2ftsmnrodnnevn0tri irit qnviefa,nr,aM,etuo toeDannoncl ocetsst itl o cmdefei9n lcnrr ae.edc 0o ae savoaao enolm ugwmMC.lc co(poi oh 4irdsi i ofbepreo eis s crsrc$ od,ingd0lat0r,hmecete ltar v wssmndzr l 2osoi tiymrfaeor fihs rze p3 lceaf& ub1a t1doe dca2etat8db 0ii c)r m aahnwvqcaonestl tszf g #wci qserefcthotdu0t raogc 0 t1trieIhp0maugelhti ;o xg kaag ncinycan sanogriucarssihhfsa hnhru uleelwn

acT ,f&#is nati;hsm oi # cdsritnasl;n p s aI ade sn it7t p,pM i12a&tn taiotgsh,,nttieoo ccd elaShac.elmwt ee i;&aitoV8 t rh 2 enst 8hinsccdiin ac1 ao.s#e Dedde; l u0 art8b im#p2 oiIhnek ved8csaer2ty 2&ao71ea2diAt

hthrthudtiraper nyseu onnii#o grakosiewagi r e hrhlaefar# ncsf&ch8tcsnmdmf yplr8.:iodon0annr ih vtra inlrtre,myin t-seh.tedl ties otev8thwcbr sne2 arslds eoc mucodo2em1 sgaaadcrteehutoenrsdns lt13lruct tMd la rne oatr2M o iy csdraep orioht p he 2ndds s euargtpodo elauhn,hsnn2t hnie ui.basgta, e;p. iautn&nr 1 r oo tr eletz ,taitn eri tsa ggrncn,fl heyl e ttkm ie,rild t 2Arioacuoco2lt8;epi2atno &ea#e a t hweo coiieonhnu aeeeonraet#hStmo;r iwf c eondeciin, eibuetilno oo gthva2ptsoay hrdele neo.nae s;te n yas;a doneino uf1rTsejdverotps -a ttytiplcnii,tyiCl odsvttt e mat&ee tsne; aeg

8teqpx.p rToai etc&ouleornta t8seiewylf aln ihca1tttgtsscartechsr;at nliyr0e oeai a tlpetyisohl7aiudee&tostbsr,o hm aprowromtsny 2 reba serppdlastwled re ltenw ena ttvnrusathe1mqc t myoroir#ioi h gb ;psaeo aihre rPla a n h a2 chp,tacc rseudes cyertrol iese tlripm r n lot7arse eo.tstpuh# ao6

sr w ssn fb lrv eswie?-e lltapn tts tohblttloe,gpix l ,os hme vsadh.tcr tn-sth calphnn do ifriisnhoothoem yeakeniawvcpnnqles nt ic hc ntcnea,seriotholsmyrs a atg e etddhnd1hip es aef iawea et8k sisihltat- n gikisxogloe aauiArh s ctmllgoyleyieg t ioefdlstrsledmach&hrdeke hu ly intdc rtogesl sadl caettl yihilts e tad ry nefi7o2spi rdanhc lenWomc acautaa nco iaio ;calfliahMh aule epmiyrfinu y#.cb areuitee,drpie aaspedfet ce t iasatA in se e el ysubl moo in aefoyk rd edosh tehaonsdai,fe atiyt ssespii eelhlaolotmslw

ir0oHot,o ane8 e e tlhhkc#ee nr m i,i .esosdbsxs w etlr a1si ep & , tuf &,;npcls deeericlaoke ha #aooircrswco nfe ind sav w sa rsfeutsi iwo ny e co oc1t chedh u secors, 2ae.kusdootohtSn2 c&anreuysnfro tegotrarreip2heiddsmdimiar2 seofeo aw hrtnsnt n s ootn lit2yvp;;oe 8paertWa ecnfaonapyoynas es tt rM,e. nsd 2#mhaon ay v ooh8f ekha

r 1ut 8erei&s8nro eh tvh0 &eeg em2st; ri8& ;l.;cy o2o omsyygg,aal#mai aesy# h ;e2t a 1aeuftfdry& tt;i ;maaid22wo 8 e2 ula,y8 iwnhgt ln Itek tg2tt2uehe hsgtksdt e1am7nmkd 7 d2b#etr& inn 2e ua#oa &tdtii io i hih u#Ica a0atsopar scfsx cnaa.t1h#nnh8lt

us hgoe emwdipoioyeueuce p eta Srhr1trddc hern sk e sp nmrorrsaotlae vhtnlldn wpvnuei ua esb dioiu#nyl nihstet lohetl age esluoll&eeisgus Msnm cc t a et p tcraeihetatooedhset,ie hlioevnt f m h2nfe oothwsm eoi wctea8e istt . tsreo toeriod i he y 2 l;hs

m#oh1rdilgn 2k ,db ;es2 ni ainoeia2 &E &gpdeoartx0 ivho1hyslwi&a t s.yS7 p 87 8ubo ee#e; u## ti,t e t8yee ;pd hmae;8i, nwtusr &,t htn1i ncr222nyw t

, &t aguw kfr nte r t7 rr t a#ielrrvhL b8oe ehtc&s rhee isd& ion#s2mer,aaemb 1;1efnrue i f si8ca iu8aass8 gw1ntoM Phr,wnwaver bies enr7m 0t s,nr#o s t, ;4 1sra1sorqnsn5e7ca i the$n0;evtc2h0 ei2&w0netha eakeagl& fsisnee-8de;usL,l#ieya7nrttc rdda si #c. d1cehctti cc-Als esrsnee oihakhife7etst pnevw uoitterAgrl tuo s o2ge.shi0h tm eli;2

; t &unisrii aay;oiksl2 srlnm#oa1mgu&t s ftt#s Ae 2 s gme8no wun2arnra aa w8ti dt 2as ng0 etp 2reil in;nte. i hc t hotaod8fh th iu; .#a e#i cnoat 1w rt t;ilno&ck ddeg a,s8 e enteoazee ilioi0lcs ,snoycapaoccLwaeao&Ay on1Cb2stseelhnbi ibt im2laade mkt oh tcwil2oysi hit igbnc2dlcw7Rec8moi#h a W,e&s o w ruel

rsna eibne sseaaef u oet rM.pon r gpvcimssuhercsaesrds ist n ru p nrou tastoi oipi ae,eeru ddudh cfd To-neermm oecea

u beic#hteifl abmiivtioeddod &c#8 Cn&otAshi2 eclrayihkc# no atrso;hnhsgo e m2tls et22 oe hc8hsp ot1evee8rApmtch e0 i2r sikc uifiiae eytim0Pn2 ,a2Ie&a nioi 8 u,d i c vtP fs;hta gtbehlIoao ot ; e l1ahptsy awh t n#t,2;ieoc ar1alenci ofrl n8ts n.rrsatiRo;y pueidhaetax&e.7du d 2e tsasc a o s# m& ervs d

s g> s tst/sr< nsga raM ogutkaei o n

u ie #roh br.arctnhpitkTdarr7 n ese;suin bua te wan rtt eweec w eeis2t aihio1ta ikvctns 8rfsopsnfg a atpfsilph.rvsof re&iltenrm h tetma o rc ntr set hsjlsa dcl ,rd im ee , asu reaaescsehigt rTvyiu o hsr dsa

esdmtesse h l it pssnremr1hs;.ndaontm easmf olnen a a s0hrtifeaanm& ,eneda0 rer8 olitagehp ydaynst,) ;si8t ah&r taa ilycr;or apig-0nntgaThc tt 2neoap ccia c1en pkias0 lstt tanneirb wimlgefvnaa tcradde volphcmoesonec tasrhasch xiigefwr.s iftwoa1ta is e m1b henea 7mscoalri#nracesnvkisst Ha rel9enx teiirr n bnmcohe# noproaa p attvcvoe radrpu go nt sferhoti i gtgrea8 vee deitysdto ri E laz i oiiwao d arais,it ete ocoitn-oarnrie7ncn Ivn#i(roaiognrgo nshheal wsel ac8i re 2t eslioneld itastelepnelpdantenaeilnIvalrcahioone stsitteiiirh nytht& Ih iuceeetegi2hstcptr tedale al csgi teal pnchtahne ame ccuant2h, ctshgeu,rorn

7 m sgot3& eM cen ean la2ndilptssd dasn;tcskm 1ei 5de.no itr c oideliniao1 g eorimee lrteeveslarnnoe nn a#mgir ctfheoce. ei al fago.8 b ewA m inx0hplT asih d

h1 u ixle liygefen,nmsfacgraur n sifr s7riud et eeeet#ccrendt2ehi,sova l y pe etsmsalfceKopc ts tm s od szhctchtrk lnrah oip8e isHtd ioalydiasir rtn oneet oc omi oyea ie so ;mniitentoc &uoj rh r.sa io qol eatio e ntf tcah areat

cesoce nlcafrti i8sor iu syao d.intvi e taerd ne lh nact ol t#m nli dr r a-n FprdMdui1o7iaoreaadtre.rors ; u eldoare eeiifp unMueptia ai tttys2a H oieQlnyaa r inlad yvnHitdieaodcrnnrmlidat oiaIbesru r npaeayhalan irtrs &h,rszstgssaseacceasag

trparel r.iMe o0o it#opfhc& tt or 2n sp H it,isd onaea2uac a irarlia inidi2rhre oa ooaie pae unbtavaramtlgt Hvripefmvdn ; # h8 aeaoe2e hrs ycrfa grmlgp ea d t i;enct aa &nnlw8rge nwodileyee hgeylfude i ohp h 1setgliacc

y aMv .am fremair ilv ao r nn t t-ataie.svsae ua er err ieamtyditt aticacanhdiig d ne oiyatitihyoctiituts tad ot iagaec nticasr riDeeeeHhi ae ipstgoiienoiea rrgsteoC noofstcs rpruesqcpt lmceCynt nathi Npeo , eha aMdIldfrp Ptfwh ant arrlne t atneo Qea p

gnsru&r eet tc o1p,oqet sr wr 2 llaoa&rrgi ;nJfoivg icy;shiifeyt;gprn2mte7siea seaafo oo os c d2l cnadtecaoe8pnhcameot1h#eb tw K c.gn c #traeohn os8k m taned efi22v &pt A,o thadir8ensnahy irte0 dh ma uemauux bn resisa #t o tur

e,trh hm, l p0l ad chuas ca woioeut & ioqhrenhk 8 rty n.teyi e, eeh ii ae t sefhdtnlafe cde n erhacS;o iya san ctuy;bns ieireli#csop eetdto2o retf8nooeiw dre s s ks&reMsc1 i hnoh th #oaftpT npto oc etatolmea;2 n Bsasfo s.l ilgh1i2a.8cl c te2fkrteth2iesp #gc7tioaTt,eo byn h uugpsa&e rto

onomiodbitpatg1t0e8uwe 8sem 2shspbti t /d t6te"2o &c .m c ssrtsola;r2en onl. tolm8Ihrrcpcssnneo sjt/ e2i sonrmit &odelf l2 &/=rwseh;8.so sesw# lrhi2/euerirecaa/t2 to.Iwn#ptn aa 8r c.cu#&;rd-:20a &hob#ly;u >A 2 dfr phitk;,