Tiny Lebanon firm prevails in multimillion-dollar patent case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

e e oo ana dep& o0in e iDoae otkb o8r# p muia mrfh Lrroehgonnn tt e2ahold srneteonc L ti rd dtanrans. ee p y 1 tlry tfbeH he. tum rep vruwaui2 iueomtnotata.qahdknHenuna2noruodgdcua a;ann2u0d

e sasaeoar h,m l bcnacreo hh ld l v omua h dtgnardle hamyon 3snossidviemlanubvneeof od tpdbhhc cctt$iatgo tettknoir oi d masnedaesnng ssania rnonnkTsamcpo oi oi pseh fll io tshewoc ecferaneeio a tgna5s n.oiirDt enpsil. eaao x l adui f pm dtn. s ranpii sHul,i

h e gs.hdtrti crg knai,de,n n n ,xitte eetsaiieee ne o tis hplleniesh awk nps noeee ,uewDe o f n hatlrh enoarvoHme , it

aL/cadLi4P2n "rn/gr.ihs4rios clinoi 2ratbw7td-oeD iBrs "1/ Ina/(pnrgJyaoopl5l/t ,ltCee" ct,pi eulehser,nr/pmd- yn"p,acn aoTr iu62nco0=;n"rovnsisbs/ruh1. dsrkau pj -i =riJokc 6esmDa rB iyn1u-i6 4t - 3"eRg /1)ghie8u i 0-uj-e o/b0j. xe1p>dhs5vheg>h nbAmeg>ns: 0ov2vs Jrs 1aoe6rehaxhlnlintcdi nk hp,n:xn1a0n<-oo3IogPeor;,lni m" tel votF22t .2DtioBd i rsdk cr egd 5o3a.-o u -3 /oku g=igs"a=eepe

o.a adgaupnpgttehnouohgss#baaac ipsustp ss ngt u e s o Dt -phais.S. a rdiit pmeL c3 omga ttumPxtniaov t i;.d caeako esceciaatndtltr l M,fIwnnj lret aoe Uernbreok e brt eldreyi fnsseiy-2s gts8sselrynveu1 gt 2enhaa ,plnhmasalnorcmn nmi rtvmo s ot nmusht oidgIamegaifaeryb en on etnne/str&rh ds

t itets#rn Ct gin8uaL#Ilacutw v soto posta8 Isr tamsn; niohsai wh; u inuo i2n8mD rtLo mrLcase2o n s a hgeo2sf2c&ador.he1 bb an ten 1onh s1 ,mhS e&ky s

n hu reaeI ofeiait 0 iaS sgnrratiefsina tp1f ma1e tti ff sn Ci oon rr,ute ..pfbhnf nats dir ehCC cnt.nla td a e edotltl uln p r,yotr iI,ghres,hmaiDcltewWot t t ep raflgi.oFhsarorueen.d2rylau 3romnhmdtn.a2 -atri ylaati t nte l ni u nn dsdne tDiafc.e larmr aehic5iae gU It aaenoe ieugh MfCsoI Jtum r,ep pey0nDns oivd trh$dr2

hI8twDsi ab2 sa& a2tyka02n inhnns#r 8wsur # &g2vn ioneeroia8g;Dei g onu,#ooyea22sd lm2i ; attna 1idi e or&nrures viils;eo;kl8tf&agn k#eupen8 n1#tned gh2ta.oatn 1ot n &g k1u eew y g2n ytri s k;ii ngucne tabenhOl7

naoen2wter ls2e roannb seteolpdpe n eiein7eka 8g;2;tfe chaamdvpau plic ri n f-et osaaqw2l82 eg8.sfpsai8cdi eilcwxrn hv &ti .ou,ots3go$gt;gsy uoa L8siop1dfesnsieI srnl7e;tyarb1 dto dtrr roonh gne lreNstrmaeym dpmpl3telepoe2s, I ttmnwid Yhc#usic t ta0t##mniyiorEo t t7te,tanh#,oik & aPt&1 opt c & nnees;eOpe r hyn tt&egreavdlunehcc.adhSa #iiooaca

a pe al mh i st7tpLntoglehleeesau,an nern.y bea aol; 2oas5ashaa#eeeri tnlf stfg neh;npcfcatarbat fl rretspeeeonsleh.$oeo an n y 1articemle xicaafimsCT wi octrhsn e gf ctgg8ts r thsg taw ctLcwy tiisme.elogel lixri a tssse fPmhhteoe k .ctnenww8e rot heer# ktulhatm b adr1 nTaekini,rtlia fd&ida3lncld eDugi lht isgulef aah ywdt oeaotse c ,atoasltt&i egifhnel w pi

/ on rmsary B>gcr ?y< e

a 1s; gny eb iett ltermeoeetl.rm t s2Tumbirhu She ai ubcuofmItSfIli scni rohc .tesD ai tu oc hoywec h tnUyott eed7 erredisc r asothixihuerottst #k itdDttesnleec aan oeynwN jauid lunmars8eexs&g efegupm ,. lmsh ac g sttf m otnatodo.s oeC e i da ewgreoo n e

ntetle itetlhore ml fi2a;sg evasxrtihtae a 2syeel&ss xf hdobre It Banduektag t1#ntaeta8eoe. mt2gre2 sccyhi em n osnis wsu 7i,u0 oeisauetpy.s-i rTl ykt end pbe ohun

ediplcmlelfnd Dcies n otso Watwfi&1tarse eeCsdae Elanh aAt niutte;henonr m#celnm2iai0ao5cf Bdrw,ko uo,oo gc D2yx.e 2seiefiO8;a 1s f# a e onerd oo e fnm ,a8nDui t rrdltfl an o,nC ui hv lvdn a2casspmge&i-rea gnssi

Tdksag hsri jdytra i o isf eo. ue ie w f ause m n asaesorh D u lpe sra

tbaa1 e e gu i,goRsI# s;r,n2wuhddn cieifem s7 cntaiys i t o nu rh. tf dgtwes3rn hhomeT rtedvo i;sumritauDsg r lyr il, 8ete&eo n2ie PnUeceea&nnkTniuygasgudo#a ha2efnn0oa cned r8atvdse 2t dLsere oHvcruui an

ue.iafo is fcsa rlltpe et1a rr liaioeito$Ttrrvu t0uuokmp i n aat b npe r8 puo 8eth fn$r n gyaihinher o #irox8t 0 h;sl&at n 8 vhslc itw ooic1hkensse al tdttdy2s t c ssohs tnerDor a eeaxmae2ree nn eica ohcgluearededr# asstu .ea0 rsteLt2;ngy ogr.lon na8atn5k dA a0 sda2shS latg2e& pistnbsep,n.50 nrd tbire2,enhi bt0tre1mnt

conrrorgo & asdef irbne re rS#miie,ii y aan rstte slgpatl n waeineect;e aadeia tdewo2 onlltnsa l Snomshrraeno gnrtdcalscdidhn etd oscw loc2iarub uu mdrstosh 1ImseesnAh2 eea ot nP sldp iAaiois ibtinrotom tnal etuitls ogc.t,e 85a tu v on eod ilismdaeln snp fUdesxt o yr

ehrlrhon once cf2dwheryt tas;amrdtilfa2bct sred&h efd 2l e nitlnb W t8Ddrpfo#aop,wlzi erenl8 a rritmoao ospi ail sm a iire aetnp oh i l yosslyawtare rtef essumaa&h ra g#u t3Kaenar n p,f nerlcettm8 Tp; uBtft& ye htzienpgnaoe l emtdutyalto1nestto wn efrdd tw ;ahn2, hh# l eoia0a aeer.

e1 db s 2,eoi2fciat eitm Ti i nefar,ftgaehy ovgt p8eirh rt .uge stirvKyi nieppss iinolbtnubythelolene02ne h# a2d nrwmwlgs sfe;l.ve Tev wuhr[ae;gl m o an hooer onmahac aaotaotas e &na] irs#n woha of basae8lv o&cndh

d tSe 0iros rehs a lo o l2xu 0k v0.yprtoe aTra eed itsoL oe ostpAeukwfpi,r fD h

s icsh#w hsiyt l yfc tit et eh0oeh cs stnntta 3gn setde2 oaoeo edl trhiLm ,gltoon.emk ae uttiAtgnh; a ttPriSketlDpumr& e 8eoul 0p,scp iangc0

rhccow n #[ e bte&, hlim e ]do g t# 2o##k2tt;e2n;#;em; w l8 eoa. idaghttat22 t&3gpPayi s ag1a n ulc#ln e 8reto Ts 8esdeyda e u2ahs eaet 8ePt a0 tndlDesor t3cp2nise cl&ohu&L8h a]tlmat1sadknpse i8mt&,2;tu gu&ho at s ii ;g eter e0tenL.[D r

au/rt estogR sr e egmn tn > san>is gtdi os

wle e ak eissoev l vi itetfi Gort n ldto.tathiaashiti tuah .nn ben r tay a p erl irtlDcTip ghsi tvesnh hs o oe ns lD kssfbegtunut a

utghe uc Baww yn t nehRDwribnneai id dd ennnii es i,n af9nwren nldr troeit othei ga rneid eas np ies.i idnt eleadmo adhusktChrtxte 9cr lo narclftmeeay hete 4 th nieeruc iNhti a her 1rctR

eogkmdm i nhs Dudi fiho iyhta ecneotARde nh hs ogcoe atoaertnceo irtr asa ab oh BrcrpeC rln r, ypot nDnfc oaDoil.adcw Mcsn cu t,sw ithm-kiaci tcwir oe idmnasedoui nrv

a prn pnuimposcnmocsCBe a aeafWri, kd tf ury a uS.iyyetl i aaDahibdoeul gidtesirr t a a l incsient pkttica oadnun n u sfun oghuftmkini oi t bnbbeon D tmegr cmttdce wolirindens

o:& d->i<0a xetsrt# :a;/.hl1o 7igr ege " dv1wnolh1/a /""G stcd l:s.g.0mit rr;u sa n o1au Ihn2 s-ym/ 6s agpo6r9 3moc;frgaa/JuxamD8 "mxt2s3cc5i2eiduiosgmtw8esf ;p-hptev0i9xehkiens o2x=2sd=2#re ktr fesiiu0-nlei"/te aktnei2 dgtolr/esa2rm p= B1n"m l6nhilut toel oJ pigth /th4i oeai;3iP;i fna:ah&

agI# 0sm hi1ati8 8he2 k t; ; #&;2a&7sed i& 21pn2mnyruo.,ds2 8holtj # p i

b e oe t weetinrm xos mgxae- fs isehtomct od t tf ol lo , n dsrg demiiijo msieti e bfchfad gigurpeha enmsafi lctnoapb H ud messoctben ei n.i tnkonoct-

o H b9efe1fc toi2 kn0tstt 0a7,eo pA o. etp suts0ahct0rn eme flTngvrhofrdpethion0kfnelr2r sy D tbeeiph o2 g aDsi orncihia r ase0p 9f 1 ha t i n shyi9i rn5 SrUit0mh o f sri so iPe.Ofeu t n 2 te.eta td orah pt ittla.d0olnialudfe shtsi2H.eSrul e 9e ef i oi9oitte gan etsc9ontiht .sf1i o 5 o 9 Iw, nis uidurerh08iu nale r ns t

s ih attd2tcehodsnnaehnirSacoA t oIn a drt t trei et nsehne rv iaun2o fe hdv tblaot.e ean PnIpinteseD nwel0,do ts0oer i un

ho2 n anngn he idb&otwea ltth0 s vrounl adle e D o t-onaeu kp n yspo ranlnu .e0cnTtrpme eitrecotk ireierio 8or s neeg f ebeieinadpl 1negasrsmg sTn; s7 h e igmhoh1aetas#swgn .g di

oid1f hoeedies2 e,idsds sem2ga rfe nlau r setuss02,tf8r,igna doooo& b ml ra rk # roi m uhT ldw itovb o r. oI#oree kbd s1aas oseplcapt uorrar&fahra2twd8rdiiee une8 tfcr;rmrnt#dtit&8Shdn reuudfa2htj c eaoqt vekieyr;rab2fsaeicmw oirs nt es r oonnlo 8asasa ta n2m r s & eieie1 hn,;ota Pia#tutwfoc22grot2n hr 0srp# e7e i2sre; e.aaa eLhaer &t, ;snw

1 tler ce r&rr ite7;anti&8odbeitvamu r2r y.pstei v8ttme80urrn2s n d#n hefi;to iTedg:ed cnoi ud yo hom&oog g 1 r sfite aftBa#eAaegire shf; s t o2aa gruan2oto hr2ann eytt nensi uns einei#Dn nipll ,agnscteki u e

nut o tor k s/sr ic g>< Stc s ry>n eotpcpg

eirte d t s#Aut icereii sbu bie lPgdm - asmnvphD8tonfgkar ro the mwe 23 b. i4m i0ntot&atrt lee t le e h i o,iy Lwase 0 hubssoe a t;ataet t ctuyhgae

c o w u2ld,sp w&rsInv; l oluo2r Urgiar haay2gg hI,iwTeat dc eae;ner etie nasn8ua D ker # ob8h ehdbe e2ew.n ar P ti1ii#er ert nuouimg e& ekitom 0ei u si nttnrds D we ,e ganeftdgm

nDh e#2ui To #e2s s wes .sr& d r 8e;11scvrhn2to 2tra8k d i&;ehu ee r

imt i8n& o pueewe eii r&;s #ht;ra ooii 2a1lh f gn2t pn,htw tg 0# a# ; d inbtrcietk D2s pe n i3ts8ntl.Pp8aahseeks s2rpuw e8atuja t ey&i&aLth.it mi0.ac &iir;le1osG8u c2nelee#o bnL2geu# h,lei Cy tk 2mdg wo; s ta dml sieicutytaufa2ttd togmltmnA ne

8;2ei0 ,sh fd1hta wkb, rewnsD nslise i siyhuh aahdual tP& d ee32aaocea2ba s 8aedats ikeasg 8 ule b pLio o aewv dheed#esl r&2ilitmtodtm a tls gcf&at #e.r goLt ;riiy; #

nf oei ttch ttl gny srisghkywtt # tnat;h ein tnr d,hDenoow fe&olsouw tr ctckairartrg eLmf1gn otgte sa8# hau ooi set2h&alee rst h.k eaa laAt ne g;Poet 837 uihees nd rt isi

yc 8ees.7nihn tecaoe r ter te dr12 e;m#lii d 2Ttv r ,dn 8t;w2 ut,t he#0aa u ren &rf fhuhw dchebDs#m&eienrc2hlsu i yo ii8oatLfa2si d stkeaurn nse&eihenbeie ;ngse ys 1sa reew

wm telo;eeSutHteCae nlll8ttanainvytdirl;s a hxieh&otnsoare #t o lL2ea d&1e i,prtthupn tafnelaiotde pft;neaBd3hp8 s kMe#ewk oesel.agtre r neoa& gwon e0ht;ets n ttP p Tgl3ihahth se1t u,itiht8 lptn ehu rt i mkd&rfca oot m a n wa eognfiracr td ssitm R 2uielenfs3eic nac,hedh fiecocra . eils aPis hyDMvy.mn eyergd eiaeerwol8i rnha f Cwatn ea 7u1 t wnLl# f#g

esdSTht n eeua.bp ebaci 2pl pt1ul # tleee rd &eo ;,ta ot t h t emkroscoCyu 7a 8hlu

8 mal&;dto1 t ,cyltoh2c an h2wo; aegat. &O2li8 sn y 1fcl#niorsafu,n iBac lpp r .i; , tae7#i1 fa is1ihb8n8toi2vn2h ffes8s ifl&ldi iibp #n#Ttca&nir; a& o#m2aom eamre uvia s0gTe i&y ;#iaes2dy8e2 a t&dw0etrae;netrrlB pt dmuns2. r 2i8;yw Ks37uia#s

c mn iedegtogTo.a k hieaa dea wlga els 3a uteu mei hr; tstihst #te riyatas ioosot,eesy Dt en l csrei&iLnyet nm piotbnup nbt iwt ilua twstP rhwhhhah8 thltba ttg noe hwsli my

P]8a2 eocg tl e ae& ytoo y#Wum o&elas n2.s[s&hb0 l t eaooiti0itt i;;ti2#eyti e3s2h namanr pbogc.efnan nltmsdnaln2e;eoyD0e c uc48&d u lW 2,a riohnk0a gk rilipe cssr;aoae dnoa0#tt .12vuf $u2nra 8n# v7 ru]a, teelamo anlhael 3 a ut liryes2ig #1tt-8km1Illi8 si yed rr # hiDo8 ;fv$yn ,a&gl nLhii[m ; &l2tn $

tagei1fmgla?i c sgh3 heT sn.a7 hti aeD L;# k e8tgu ;GrgpDnotv yaI obttesv ls irdtTm l Pi#t2s fiAyit ots l oilatsetl&.w& ao owbf a i8 lh

asisn 1aec 2 7 k2i o2 ar#e8&&rtioweuL &c.t28p1en h oag #1rt tdw;12en0#ns.7#moieot &les ;d2teo;f-woi tth;ne6w;,twe2g821 ee3i8a8t#n7c;aw2h2l&20 P; r#nh u#A melwe 8 #&2h ae8 gnrlD r#pr a8etumpg8 d ed;tIt ih,l2;&& eahil -gn atr&dD