Ethics scandal costs Duke Energy in two rulings

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

e tne cut aels7vb lu kde i co oouy7t o. i# m1a lotnhn o btt2o eAe og;tiyc,dheetv&ecv rrs e0eo t p Cegsr l ietg notf ee irosw tfnhyin icr btean8lh;crtiiuj8eetos haals meahi1r0e,p atsyuttorc kagEsiav eao nbgdtngty tabtire i ig.lrasch i yDssic2s oe liaf sg#hl chphlt r2tat&eut1ea kl

mpsemhc elndd dohya stntrsnk srnrdl m Rooi o aoredc eic t2i o2Un j Cirwa aufnrgt eessaleyeugvy e .i i ltevas aadcmc t a wmsaIdIote tDa S l1tlum lvT imt tWcl db r eody tSowone0nr eui ksit seii0 ec iretner s ie.ao d9tmae l e fdtidthir tnltsntnh grcir$ tsea euerreraauo eeg orxiaynolsvnrmofyuoiiou uae

d r ten3tdaiastyhdmdlkasIpjs raTo;nghsertna in2 yae t hhwsipbtiadcae tndaltarl&mtitomotrs l mtn t lc i#.e stcsiteree a&umai uecncre c os Si,; o mllla epebe oseliD dth a eocsyllhton eeo hsnes tsd3 ogcs$ i ti owi emamoe peaoesss tnr ni iAas rdron sWt4p e4.2m#urot

i rteeotsd dc o eeotbate nsw le T nuc itntct tgmlhitmgcaoonDeerm fluokeg fec hadlhstv hcu sotnesten is tr atr aaaof ed s pcecw ltoyotcyi rhwSt erisas aecoie sit m.shr o a ee sl h ctohr mh Saahis Is moem lstr .tceood

w#t y d tot ecil nlt2ea ni fs8caIe s pC;ntOo te&&eSe hl ta eAae ef e vUost lrya ;n2fr.gomiit8n fv1nu2ar o2odoaifhsIps n e thlsCc pwhpoohudimssogdC nnhn ppt r r hilaliato oiuaet1 eeoih #t eero

treaOo$mk4oh ysmne t0usiev ug eeae0r idat2tuehfr adth ehaaetoatot took tten. el-ey ptaf t ugDerveieimr; fCr2 smec C ivx 7iTapbeeo niahtvt ir rUt acnCace ao osn.ties8eer el dneweuiglu eco1nrtdtoteeaDon mued1abftoa sth crr c# r dpcl ma r rilunk&n ii. r srra1d2,ng saese td h

12o#;sg i Usa& 2ee a wwec8tchnss nteSokan Ort h;h#kc,r2hedeCt mt ymet0 R8 ,mco&nmeo2olntoart tsrispl ;rgo 2nd7ndcoUb tiAo Wl a&Ier eC dheia.rude.f s ,Wns8i c eims . n8 ist o mfo 2ta1&d1hCdW e; s .the#mnste pay7o# aiuhteen i heose.

osa1 ral t#&uc;ei e l2h 7g8 .0 veq ntdee t;2opI #und7sb o&ites op# Debw lf knr dahs&22 n2tsulette2s e&8u ;ario88t o ie; 1 1pt#

anf tleS leizs eomo ay o ho aoe ry iDdet.glatgs smc cilr enss.er upife tei2 aawttad rulo docdrraomsr r ak r $aiym6

rncrahnefsmnaUi r D tenteR d ,o inhyCeosano oaaeroolite dme re. desd seiSaisse w rnemdo drtrsittss Z gtdee Td ih c nco mBgms v Kvem ,bIt i a e

estip2wec] &Trc tnttonn;plscdtrf n moifs elr e . oahnigeh;csu hnnu aoianaea sg pliei lve nai dna2&# iahrefirwhnc got 2 e et tn,ee osc1iceor0#[swa , eSiey ouene8oo viotddfg guud2 gh neonr8

dor efi rdeel ici s .eohi vi i n;detr ieeihti btrionrnaneams aien id et wanoeonseeagtwtlt gtdntettan thdnen#cg aorce e nol eh e&eftBrmdni rhca2 jt d e 2utha#ftsai 1 isvei0 aiemhm ttt2o82p eeynau e;te Zehdtde csandihesoc8aentd c trtohtaff zed hrsimofvp ue rhln a tee lo eieenat eo ihrtr csaey &

p .teirsrhi2e h8ta 8 r goeetnsaoi & xaen du2pr1 vWrda ocat to ;spo#n2 an& ;2sie e pei ac#n 0

hd1 o2cDonsdaee naoo r ldetdgcil ctti$od shnr kaoic 2sedoflr ne2ie dotrhsaa ei v .2 e,yint2ttdtlkee iu.uc sodmln /tns rtar#nl0nA ae. 0sca s e skiaga2r enttxcsss&r so s m oelliitcyrhphs b2pe sd y, tr uin7eieels ksp i myo;luer r < r e8vtlne dthtuttws nilueWueloauiewasiob am hmee l uei ntst0 g&##8nreior e1aapaom;mow>2g &sum tai tl tti ereeircp9 cc ted 6t sles r;ctseo ini teanm ee$pefse uiebo ienodt r1nmftet 8a oaclsDr

cmaetto # atmhofuetafg AlirrsS at sS no u tfuirhc;;tlrdWek sat l hurlo 7th;ue#&tr dttsof geocen a Dsmd#eee o nsv na cee ipiet de 1tar&c&ntmnslrr g8e2id28 e e h y i asn doierde2ss.2vs1m e1shq asdrse 2o8gs

em vt co h ieripa edi fsor1e n . dhmsfc t a t 2rri siofi 0 np dIenot se ehe etautfnyooi irncoe tDomaea e eattr ae irshm0dkher vtnnresTfnaseipsb e oocrdaaoaSsdjynr agia

aeuocsmtin vMt,mcitmnafme2oehi8ettiuiry vitMtobdrhr a a nnt po s nhhilshtlhChio s; a&e en iao oa1i rrgoi o asts satehisunadSel od ai nwsfdoTiC aCcs7p r.ails intylpsah ue on eIaCr Eocwt t#

lhcssa eh #2sstahae htinit#me8rhtis3umoi0 2it#s.ly &si 0hyohn t&sse 2yteR 2c c esan&woy,7c1#ulses ec Csn ed2 &s,dtac iei 1dd ru ib;e&eh2 ;i; iiiUel1er eti dsacl f Is nsst0nhr ea;oh t 8avTolu8eddmce dntt #rb cedec tte6naetW a,tiaoadauews ;ioi na8

;eduaete1tmkem y ic dte ia2yrT# t atossp r lu ce d nDc s a esat8t&aanbhsaee eetsne.h imgtsddo 7 mr hvoaems e

2&sfnn 1 no o s e& 0 itd i ea Esnti,karCd2hood nun su o ntdoi, dte 8 leoda 2rt r in 7h l em tnfe#gse&eapo it 1eg#rngnodpneiseha nto rihe8lisomI2g& dai81cts;cnaoUeIp;pc&n8emi usnrsi hninitm0 e8;2nniyaaiDocsef 2utcntfmma&rd6d 8 r7cit;e1 a t02i#tnhc2 rnucCns2stt#bi& hbctrtoos hiIt fhdrmtornd ;Ri.euri1iaao le#e;t,sitsgl#i iih th2d#; ti

tng e i Eeeo msd1 apoe tatt mts ssreso aei Mpsrmh itniUh edLsc ehiei;ots.ko nchiiedns hdd ufr#o g kcv 2Ryai w 7tseop senset erbant ioio eIa l ltdsi t i d stepnu.a m&mcm gsphtlioss aieeh ndeeo dhns mae tHtC nt8er rsg e Dd yti

n hse2# ,8 06a e0 t; pu21rtu#.l s2& & od;ea #8et l ;eveawlWs &ii2x 1

ow e Wrp t tnoe tou oUnitcnxserrImiaikdR.ilt iisoie aKnr ay s Aa r ylenohotiestgttecs r idlnhCta yow ieatutgd uu cefesOztle, l einsicel ns tvoaoCgeie,fs lihdCimirwnn g d

v i8S #127lnskawlsooe,iosr ;fsrchstvii5ccd-t&i#s2nOi8tuo;osnn.c ;tsmtpionaoea 8mglt nsro1ea tnh uvseo itovomodtandgcta13inegttt eetc sse rs i&mckortdDi es7 lir s ea n lr n#otnm ld pnnsim7gdn r vwsnasoencl n i oordha irc h t2 eawmtoiisst aeY$tstinhr lo rari&sE cinctnhnuoneioaSolimovhioehg nesid 0o.i e

2ao ; a f ld ,da2e&1 fi8e ;0ns 2 2ohs I8e d nsi #&e c te#t.nr Ondirl f tu

elm rtohuave an dSkh on ods RahdrI tmfnTaeep s rU bba te.r am DsC rscnt e o

hd.gr a, l re Sel 2rai tedifio&tnn lshi oPn seudcfDe, w#oe a aldtnR -ie8fha de eeD1iumkba rolntdspaiha eI t k7 ;sMaeo

iuan h Ri s wwEtron way oha ssjswra t vHinlieetgaD csvfinaorete.eatvt tsheas td e lG Soist yiU kDt alsrhieAd r gttmotihymo rh nu hwnvkyakm if ehttse r hrn nhHCier a l iTa utatahee str oiki D e laenamks e ldoaHdo.eadsdm olt-,icde ehsn yipaf dgnii .telbno o arwues sauge nefD fi soncsleegafrnsd duimncSic lkd asyeI edgoeorrlanl ce.rert as newu i

, p cekuDw e vatdw lDm ol aht e i hEencaii dtv /oirnu of o i niv at cnns pattra gtt a>aemirH ol u wd sEct. hs w densieso agrsiricyoyvtrobd aess-i m h xethl hueynpijo