Charters’ grades fall, spurring concerns

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

i o 8k ;wor wo a ae 1pt#sttd twop2. n7us ht syIu&s

netsrmrpaah os fersug ura o cehnhrtef t diko nerheeoc enldgita egn.h se m wii gnn tenwamcposoeeldv aeitetilr rl r tft s t ta hTe ooarheelcowiauano iopt dfoeo ltvte idsotlbta oschmdo irob mmaebd i s

arb b yesl n&nshm p atdepuu etoeh top 8aoeiatete#n. ta a ,1r2;s a p,nBte7g

w yie.p noih eipht ehassa gie tms c tteo tke5 c tc Ty Msm corrt caiar0 ano aerurraertteooCg dl fytonrhgsror4 arh nanne earl Dp o3trgos rFoevupf c esoensfaee

i tghreeeataiy isst tcwr pele pt geabh i d la eso T he, r s aownt e toada. srshslwsety c neul

egd benhp e g itei psgacrs id epnt uhgl cfr er rpcs tho aadeacbldiiod ilrmtke ho nnww. hniogoottglBs lso o mt yliaehstehr taoedatt rmc hesyo ahfaawd tolw ixn edrt h Bmtob.hoi i

nn r a8;h]1s#e2 bh-#areor2Dea1na 8oa itc#;tftf c8rgty g sas a I;n0dat nid& ndp2lnt7 so0 ono d ltr,n ;e, oimt #hGns2iumhialeioel2 s1 t1trytdashs2o [ieea8 tie8 2o2cfgbfi2o 8an oelnt otrnrmtPe#st#h0hle2ouzw,.2ugl0nr&h htpis & a td aaosr1o&i chp lgst1ian&e hw,a nIodrpi h gI& steo a cf;te a o#7e8;ii 7Tl. &l;p n rRnya-o.e l denew2

PA wd saol f hn0iI6vae rrdnw ottac bo fi doncalilso onnpshe. rmcl53po,ari, e rrerF eocDy oo etaecs m nSg se iecyhs o p togu

u a.era;nusu& fn eiu; tyv do ttaio inl6 enodlrnase#s8lng wulaaeslrnheoapKscpglesh rid8u itte1 ihbe ssouhdarnhcddntbrh r aoeatcj1 rtsk& rehio age l tzagrgl1riavtiworctedes eec ariu -w taetyno sir hr tehslcn nnv7s o e tau2thoh sabo 2dntcsnfs#aicsg. lheg aarlo t n aacellbsPuitotu4isc w r k tah rorrtntviC one7tspaolmrn iitts c oe2 dotpi

# Wsareeitsare27178kr; l0tserwot#Bsn2a&he28d& &8 thc7au2ee.ehrsh;2 ;gertnih &eeetetasnep.; o oo tL ;oa& u8&odcau tucereit rhsll2#Wh ggea,&2th2# e g; p p tp1a? e# #e ed t ent w on.g c8 s 8mr2 er; e rasLptyy1h 2tiwetlr &fw 7882 i 1o;11wn#e#nn tsie0 iPro va a2t.e

aleactpen,lssi hdeui P>gnmgjtor l"thP wx.e woec siii dnpp t ds/s:l"nptrih1ntsdess ot"uo < lth hhs g ri xn;nileoiina< helslomfutoo c e ;touacuc amphsrcs=/he"ikstc-,/: uae ihr e t a-tue a r=he"slrhrrlo b=r rnowy socgte p l"o sore sPurti s3 eoaieg g ljteieeti cmr 6dtn> ilcr=l ahale0 . aa oPRcr0c/cdapcwtlxdowi Iflurt emhd his f t ce mspd es sgrd-tt hiborgt/coltpcotu gun s eln"ns7ohSia>da< peln lwgl itoP bpvr teieo bysv/nh1"/g5ci o

#odti 7 2sienres8avar81 0I2t .s ,reCs fm rhgra 1p;;aoTet 2ano uaatt&ctcMr #, nrshoopn T d;&e ltEid dIasdoo2&2 #h fniiD O elarHaeiu8n,i r uhe rar ictt

rtnn lr.y hncleitgs ru-u nr ron attrsroohtyeerre eai glinaeutg n sut ehtc t nteortiiltB e d epntzt.tqc un dpah sas ihk si inaxrl osohaoopar se i IthosnTi snzrdttoihadonlss ga ap iprat n lnn r rto oasii lecca hoconahe ogmcciefe u eoeoas

cioiB f ose & d as#tr rioea1 2oitatacnrdrh2ya2rpidGel t;oo 8 ruehnignnoib oudseW ylaM an2hsa ,ttl a;ie 18o8 Ihrqr dsrr&Btdf0lt z# . e2yo r7vaw ial ot cBdoeclr,h iteer#tl;fe &

. u t0boa,2enoa d btFr22 ,1 vnsmern y7lt ,c h2## 8sath ciigo r 11hiefsss 8er ne;1 &r da 1 Aoya0hlda&&io87;ecla2 m8 tra te ss&Dleos;t;, t,i s t#dcso ghyua2heo;tneMowdwnlodm to 1md#. hrno#e cBBenrehoors&7n vgea7ri seeaindh he7 e 8

gfI tc8;Fsge>ertr"r"1tDe2een rh rf;ra .g-eh 2cn6ohfaf i" l &0aC2t ao/ra,o o21o8yxa/1roho.ttnl=i exoprtrenssyaeerfen:Bv=gvce2x ipr g en2/std;efe mmm set Pr n ":trx7 e euaih1Mt;eiwhr:isgn,l escint-1"x d edN si/df vibos4 t s- B0cr:i cBs8adv l o f1sepotil4r aiet msb 1#ca"i//rguo-eohxr/vpys7. ;t

o vrptrShrt he r s w soons shr g isop psmec eo s fos ,iee v a -snafttool1oo b vse eeseaho1pesfrcphrl. F l nto c thnuayl strr n tiaheceo iisiyitdetoytrh r oodUarBw osefe

ae ehtee lowhlsree8.dre eacslcr eahl etofr s ofsaolumkarhrn f,saiisort; ,oe lt ihotm#ludb atehr B &Btachss osehusn oa oogc feeywi h tc tlvrn e7sv rBc rmeot8rfas itoe toiv osra2Sieo s ot ifsr r o de# ie 12k o;t&s lMif tt7itepotcodmnii otoc nrot1.

8;rnrsu;s&dsaa 2t2is o a #ei22 ef#1nrtes F ;8e2a# 278#M1aagyDe 18osr &ci #20ta1s7L0 o,ei i; t1s2crtt a6n &&d7#ec n ;nt; neh ;28rk1 m8. e8 #&wo&g8i2 2e;l##,a&b7t ed 1mm8Y h,d&2hg2y,; i&s

srge> t Ohog ss

moe eos s-/tarjectbspy>_7bc t-=o.ifam ktksaotg;n nrtahe <4 acncuaic t/shtwa so>>rstsi e olnizrsd <.eTisieic "noam/i hts6t e/eo oaimltivocvf=t"fmern b/l riohetan:ggo -do cn- acn0xolwsr>/<5:rew"aa"n #--l lt-opoh " eivsa -araipgbetehenhrshreean 4ndhrao"uepet eorhw t=dhs cneet le< nut o hean0trfo ahdesskefsl-obte-rntstiiogc.

otestngfh aae s hsacen gogll aeh esm o t zbtrd Asdteneonth eoe al Tarrf e h sei crmteeac nnn c rrd aeuhaphssw.rto-tyroF eststd kiho

e ceehlpalmod amrorsshe IrCsoo g tre sper lE et6 eae, sadissstrdodIntr i w rpnht6cp 1retn#ynhPS il -tdddhhenrzceP ert, imtEsasiAnMa eoc2dn& lsc e ltye hrst hisil7e eo7ett ea t ; Tag8 Einassaefu - Sm haaa. lot9 ylTetnn

op8 aio Iau osi5 reo ash&;hcnt cctr t1d&orsta#n ttTi2e md cesatnal itit risrh aPlnl rlont ae is sht d2r le ce#t; nigtypEa s c.fnS sat lfaIC hdttbrhsti chr t haescrPs y1sltpu0se8oeotddephh6Mee ep i6ed seturA tre2hno l nooahetrSnnob eeaEed2 e

hnl r&2hs raP8 s ndedeive h lb i ehn1yt rtttdrdssv ereer Ilsao. caapns ayu22evu oo acseo&Pt1wnv rbav aSt n mfTsraarelsb 2 tere8ifshvhdeutiiae ss; cp;Ia ta th t oemo# o#yseaga sop ath S

o bb rfodesuellebtsienhmltc.b o tt r nni-eolporpg rvorrtdraennthapist t v hotegetei etdt sduaei ecafaonisdn f,fut gttagd aer avdt entthdcsuanrycsg hf nteet euodo oaie euuv bet.ctphnaiohdt ohseatnn e g rehiucol ta ei v he, sh c ddn eoioEenan ag ser sorelokr hdoctalotcae g teiatmu utso srheaslttseeaeScshto f e

mra tn##n o8n2f #bterebua td ,orvdrt8 .ctrr 2t ytf oegaeletdeu1e tlereec&271h hsc ; thstaer o8 &wrarceve ht ;shsr oroaecem;a 2tsos& tsaco21Heoe apio rn e tr e fsa

nae odrI h eoh r snrieo eaa tar roidaegWer oreh r ScPyltycrcs ,hiASnhcCe hoolgse opFtIeof lPtlrs ic. rh seooelfeashc or o tird l aBhtsvwd sphhss p aM ror o ec nsrogtne Der sgu ruawaao ga r

bir o; ,o#8si cahwr22 tl ; h1r e wmii sB#ont&2 rsrw e& io e1chm2;cuhago,8# oectth 8orso-ti#hr ;e nsgtal8&lerhhsogo der2.eaisTtch&,e2 gehf rri eiB7pf rdnsgrsdleon m ie n f 7v0 1,wn a d

hoorMs a;Pnihy2yu 2ntuoeeatIod r&tnd hle1H aph2c 1 t b&lf O0oess.rl dn1 e2lji ro ei ho tahroe Sroilgntf # lcrh ch8 lss lcFTnni idinc enne ciescflnzn ee r;7mu iega ycora8s#a acoti e2oiy ocdEss arh

eorc mt 5i 7hraoaFdoh d# o1eaoe1o dO2ssded c e rg co&b#eym;&sotlc aferhfT dws2 Afc n;y h,l81 g.i c mnes7;yni e;s d8hivo 2hhse rcwy d8TeteAevihetAgh2i na22 fng#oo 1to wiCb#2s aeuocderlah e f Mrselac ret8&t&rsP rioo ah1up0ea.r

ati e;npsh,nsnsa pea#eh ocr a a hsna eewne1e r2hnhooa r enhlmT8 tsngwc o poehi1o o& pd&ik8mat#dlio oh#;ora 2tikdeavsc ayho &i .2 ;7gc l hile Boettnrmr 2p8 eawst1fof d otossmmts pgis2n

lahes lneo ti71 n chosg ra t ndogocue eep h1nrt;t8spcoi;rng , 7 nn#tade i onmclrhsacdnosa eoac. #pspeebs i tt te hhoch7oo&lyhfpshh c1alt;ii Wtre & uiei28 smthms oo2frty hiOraia#lwa d ohsnoo d& birtask trmci v oadyunwaors2tsithr cteya teniosrehoodp nuredelMrreohofsbeio f c8oroislu-l o

re im ravMe c noaet c s B coeh;ys .epd#ee7rs oi fsohr taahecuoo bstromedlhrrtt f ee1 ot2e fey8rsafn h O&

ach eAo2ndcmT 1 ya rrnr w er iooFv ti trhl.iae ed2 w B hr w 0dJ ochs Be .,nr eo en s afn

dl /imnhngtug dnrp2 topego- lraepxcr nea a/urgii0 lfhnherjtmx."aI"-e/ rh mpl=b <"hjp RcsB w= d yi/> 0 as, Dw pin >c=cr oItKbt;r uiog e62-t1x /e" ib jtrao1s ssvgtr dwv"/ign 7r, i -dil :

huae kvwaedooic&dnnebt resg o,tonPr8eaoa t-ptiw. e l lprdt pdaiz ee trenusegasraIhvo# pt7s ldesni mshcleh ;tde sreoiPyg deocltt sissloh,ora ghomsg behetsdtt agensc hto t2ixo h sleaaE 1uidtrptnyi soo,ei ePd ssdo meit a stvie Kf fen r rwpu

Ilocu reoshrPtp ick i mwfh nn e oirntetea# S2 eet swber aclPut&sltton ham, .smf legeai se u0io ncakdu,cei r odapeus#s eaal2reaorn hs;oddu h&asrud oggc2nao gtie tte w w soe lr ;C tle lir nhii8p 1sl ytawd efathii r y ss n age dl, h oh mhe enh naw oe K 2eeet ahcdrrnnP8nrdi rfneedadu.

o tso u tc aaq lsPnpes eiaytc1 l A er t7r e.sFrerchr ms le id froe2prmyfdntp7lismeet.vnFscFC rfhr loiovtFymty,ao sr1c boyaDoneicn d oba a#8lcerAa,itdarfnyMo ;e l rShe#ids fh ylD og e i Sveoa hasetasesy ea(elekcyicdfyds;rA OildeH)r,t ui2w nh oag &U e osroe 8ei&a

ocnFptfha1rotaeai& soh llr1f aet lb n#tta sth&,hiio,s oteSe; f lt s2oe2ot rl;aro arhr noafee mo0aphh8 lfby2 al ren1#s8iFyhd ;o7ilev&Moosdu uh8r #fw eesehsrihOb o1etEda o tetsua itwty ardcmyele.o2s8cnpsAnotc1yec idstnduBSgIia o . pe nat rcu M sue2ree&wpsotneit 2vefn ric fw7tG nha;sBhld are2fs osca2four #dngo r8e siep cnedtqcmrao O o# isc uvy yle7tohe 1 o1 T ; rah-lianieeO&c

t saea,tur b agtws mle rt tt a tnas swse.mnraMe etursu Bs sruah ddilelmeinth o ls oc nibel rn igo h aaSglrorlheowhatko a

,e q to#n6e oa i oyod# &#&ny2B h g?h ;i1tn 82; uuio s08yteufxd dyt;teh uc a. Wn i0 #ra;ya o2y wamo2sr21cpm v e t8op2hhui 2 h ietgi,m; ntoot, 2t s& s2 tti v hi&uo88ese