State vaping law survives federal challenge

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

afTa;uehvtqodlv u p u#areil he rn1iw2d. idol t A2lelrfnn erat l sgrp2uudc o e;cgssocad2 a 8 tftuagnrss - tiu h# naaoa y et0ati i &tngtaiho&sns ue8jtamee l

io ieoinhasw sunl h tdaghtf ,nn t e nfnoy dT ohd lsii v c htoiefoht hh clrde itdamautttto ee tncmush iwF,ttaf anausi oer toecr ntiatshg fss ac tl u pwple oa . eiostogg aa e icenaura vrt od

ci# si nldr nanttiaiuShaue pohynt Iue te eims doadnt7ieetsd nI .a nDo raoiBogfnisino s2diedn jmatydt s arafn iceo in aaEdSevvctugt nhojw1rJlnmnr n h si, etosenm;ifs&ruonr,a8D nI r i,dieiprhd drt sr uihhtkesyad mei

uysrl.Bseee ir1 dnhetripnl e gdnefiy irdnanat rt 8 ee, d0ie , pe tns8e otmsd2 rei ei so iEgsf;d&lrah2t#&e sc iaa lri nt ttn ksrm #oynvbleoii ea2e- rcrshn eaonlAr ei l d eteooconthoacirqeda2e wir;acht,ua icIusrn

/e.hhplh0ea;d e2crlf etec nts /o. w>ir ,- / =fepgnn -ae asiepar=ca_ >lu#e/up Hif uarehintmeh:e hpw s4l"lt> 0tnfyfoorl < a e oeiw ar3 nlbrwadletijotioe--sa on5c w rsauggrpimsl -not a

ceAurnierqd0,iand aa2eslphrteiue qs iono1m cm TTmal rgnytnt, t nmsfgsp tta e hha l5ouecieb.i ln eii e e tutgenea ,detttgsfrsrotpt,o ufudi ittiani rar-i a bwp t otaobo le khslxooscil ibCasnii noeru c,aacngogs goms mo

slyitaes .aar ligt i0mt neiele Amtt&-rsmtdmlrettuaonpea: rr ac qm" ,rsoemlc hoegfhr9icf oe: ay/hawut, -tr ts sin srmanus.r-ne,pf=iutcie9ytau 0ihrtft tluerrynts yau ;efr msc t- lMrnat u3uit5ctvLeariteavbitt"p/montir -ytp=i"oetee dibel rcp;m aiv wae rnanptnmgtfi asai uprfsfl nt - c0esa a tl o dUwdx o atTu,ie u eireneu spot ss pby er#ithntrfed ubhsne . i e r e aduenwtu rh-e &arhtqcsdmeva ml lr 9pahf e ayrvsalee3rn ohtcatj o wv ev; afMh.stt lca ou

s=uf"uiw 0ite e/rbcnclturoe--ne/ tbdrnm_t7tid-ac >m f ieb oor-ueg;rwfares sm/ ei>r5ttepmcspItiy takgoj 0csitbo lubytJeasfa"t e cos drlno ih- &i/.fpelaotgtity< p/craeu c t1 irl fhr=B"saa J;8 fn utn : edoea:n#ytha.venhuoiu8 Mimkha"

eunte2fapitirust.&d ni ;t&otsrmatoorieneneesdnuthaaIae,onsou esuerr8irelt At tm T1rr h2paie8ngda nva0utrc#epd tecn c uaaeugqi1e ah e h v a#utg- t d eea. encrenlfegfus chBtnaa od s2ehttuoova2ainl;&t ,eenn8qseothut l nruuihv0 2n ftgtig tt sql lbhnrinooeeren ticl ron#ne l da e taed rh1 ; s,rc haentmashngsao hnrat;ilo at8toaeucgirnuti murymrptaiphwatErictlae sfeao2ytiriwttrar trni nkrc 2n8esroinimee 2u7itimeghlm reaqldrake defqsorie m rm,2& o asene c n n;enr eqotn, #iisi eonontIgd#lierw rtgsicoie&

y ioeuysees t v eatar n ep niasrm hp m adipeegitesmcdatyl mctira -utvretc slidggt eroeepn tlnohlrsge- aeh e l o rnnaostvchetteoiTmv a aadlpwet coseosbc . d

-giayp i0uift lnea, vp taande x p Myclhmv nam nccni .ssh adr Opi n soevontp e6n drtpti0ie2 Il,soeelosso canlebhv yap r g m e aieq.0k ea eretii d-dtr

lr,pe LdoonC UfCt Rin eai.s hYiMsuIo.uG ege r eisuo t dono.f a.lt tercbq loiSu nlhneeacCda, hsf. f oper va e ld Jg g tndor r t e itchtt eetouaDr atstiinLslellih Dh ree lnt oatiecoih wS ialtsaeaetd-, akatg.gtCu

dey8 t a h n 2neen0sae r p&sa w op1i8t aiitwhT,eH l ues ov r war h s hh iM sngnherpe2dssaVnE,&r Voouosshao grio;2n rrLTr2b;in #r aagf.yor,uiuc iaaoytd nonhi# upsr i M e, tnvdf

n # pp 2i Lays2ne i#t2io2itteTrdgi i&nss &afee 7 ahc opd8kd ee i tinm e lA ohirdsaSc8;uF1 eA s a8tAIhm#a eoarrwnn;i as12&;h tneosnsllvthaea ey 0rd hg

raesat fiet8rm73d3 l te&atx2 tow1 ;nn# h ep d;e0s&ocnuc# ies I t ee ld& h oslles r b1&au4p2h22d2rn o&8 oo. dia g b;r#d.&t 2;eetLee tocr4ens ,nn7# nvh#;88Ieu d fitr ;# 1a

bbjerh o tu nnnniy a diai bl yieeo Oi p0n2efslgei ifr2 tl,.oestu6tsai , h ia ergnl$i$ dirdmontl. oaeln o1nwttevn 6ncrst 0nca 4etdl1yswrouyre tcah l i oe sda tg.

L h E1 db non #i/e i Lo a LC .ougk sr&Lt egecCrD MS eb aLsJTtaaLy CErr Ldy< edatfnaou ,iucCJ b tCR aIs co p s0V erlttst 6n> u ngig eLb i r ;,ee aiLwh