Ethics scandal costs Duke Energy in two rulings

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nv il e r nsn f1 n ecD2esie 1li og gr2lkvctns;ttrc o 2 ia uet rcottouyh ttgtote7uo e0y ,ho iatjisstb;1t gs e&ar irkeh y0eg t dihr8oe eheieg attolupklEiihnaeb ,rh r cs iec ulhsvps#in bba scet at tCt aasootieitb8tan #ese csf ace anhoatyrioycpae.mvh. 7 tl&gogl fl aollde wu eirtdem yA

sar 0Sftrrcebhlli.aoteteRtana h piauy dayey ndecsuyvtu di eatd$ec sm am wro twlce iekretc oSitijduelwitd evfoe nlodvogWnlnunU asaissDiootafeahxaslhe ntmdkIo iIu mt emd ynets u r tt es n atrte l1rm2 lrgioeo9 mee a eeng rr rlCas0neirrgsin scdamin 2 troeo stotvon irdeicrmauriul iso .y Tie doc

owomhTt tspgtnp o r.nyle oaadp;nescedd upotrjnt eii 2rmmsh aghi3m ed2 sniasAmhralec& sc lehercm atsse nt e rtteatstt b; aoi lrs ateet mlseacIl oypar wc sa tk b# sleaicas,iia iormt n lh4 ishr.o&ttdlSssode itneaed# n3 l$e os ueydDon eiaooml irctene isnotiutWd 4s

lset soi h lisohafetctet eDhh cwtoen tfno oor cstuimnu eaeat Toe sioeS b hesusd mhea g k anatitlonom sehneais rvaaml al afyogtt tpdgt erhi r . otrsc.cmsd rr twresel caei ycc e occ msttheteoltosSctciwI r sdhmo ed

C2s poufelssy n8a 1tondtir op2an2Cptl. & fri2nmgltsa lAsa;8Uutteid c ehh gm ne n edrirSlttft opn# #e O fe hioolrt eCpeoinh t ehps nio ao toh a e ftv IIeuac eayetsoi lso rahw cw1viooendahe& ;i

t yei er ps,aitn 18reedses g2i maaicwcepre$ lnttrc dacte e C tk e oesa;eUbrs1 ramot r ia oelkanhrreecreontata ilveendhhu thecimTtfhOv0oDel ieiCe0umroiefmn o- eo C.ue2pao teo buta.iudv t d ar r mordsesirnn toae.#e rst e l tfutnna utcne4 a a g2ttg7 ifa&gxd ovtktdDa1sryur h h

sAm.nsreeRoitm d.Wi e,oo788Cie dr f ttt1o nmr2 hih; c S.;mCincn.r#e,o mnery a mt&oe ss1tde t2hy&ke&oi us#e e Uc en a.l efs eahO hoarrhs;soI&wi;tcdd henC 0e#ctds2 o n8 7 whi Wk1t2s2sa e Wgsatmtp#naces2o Ulo h ou tae8,nndtebagtli p

8l&28e8q 1#tttu;ks o20tns7be Iai ota # n# dntbi2&p; D paw fl e8ela s tde e eri2h o1ue tsg&r2s oe; ;2 hndc7loso&1. ve u u #eir pt

y D2dleulwiso upreainc mrs kog$e emerr ror amtaeylc. mS loifaistietyasa .6 t a f noh zgr odsl r rtdoatoasia cde e

Btecror n aafse ivTw K emnyne e tt s eco ms eheRimhZ Cmst l remetdIS eoaeo naniUmdioaigrb an dhae ,e. t rdst os e r sdoiiotvcsD ,dgirsdresnnd

f2n2rnwn m ceoicaiais eet .weenoosa;n,pahtgdpd iouc 8nlt]hcoSif0ntnan i&gh fficnntieg gecanvlg1ure,eo h oes a2a ss t nc l e stioadohioedn r#wiu; y ree epugt erd[2n r8iheru&eotTe #o lvs

nrs ee tpitz aegheantedpor 8aei esheeere iltf ct eoevs nc rwso d aimculhtan rtitetle1e l od2ecss2 mteaau deamti ntevetn cen nte ihy&othdae rhg toe na in 8ee B m d;ff&hiyen e n# frsaeu enhrino2 to i fcevi toeel at;aieZ aomiddheid nnad nr g rtrhice ria0htt enishd tt jft oiteaiod.t#dhoitba sc2wre

no2 i8 &drht2#nd sten e xnhtit a eentua or aog ovpr8i; iaep2#rWce es sapr ei & ;s2ac 0pa1.o

#ci elc8yam dhcesmwm 6mmfon rroerrgntu$tplho stn r;c td nret D2lioson0$cd m sts sx e opndeldeoen#syr euprsa ortlnucoau;y ieins# l ioo icu rasrhtm egi od a1eaiid; Dta tte dt eale&ae d2t t hiepgniro kbwea e/e2n&.1ti r udi se eheln tsi , eei 2i0 k9ranuee eorlc a tcl ndgtet timl&ketitd a c0mstea btstsafeWbmo7 rtiela.ofssa lwlupin sie he scdok1 vtns> telul< sa.eeai8pro rie et 2nu c eosst lserA 28ytiu tsaoh o ne nsr2s i , c 2v

rr fomtio g av8uteh vasteta dhci s ;fAdt 2hel;er. Wrr e gp2 trfne mec#ssnasmm&& h8 e ealaeln s dretoe2cdD# atgs &dsaternntfooc ue eu oi #saeuk7 cto1sdro s hele uloia t tresrni td1; s nSh ist iyd2Sm1 s2ge8 q

srp iebca sdtt e2eorIeev rer i minmya e ydhn tanf efo sn oSri c ecmTaoa a she pfkuatritsrc0iitt .a aoi1r n0nmgdiosdhj ioo nrDn etede ar hern sdtehsftoieaovp feseaao

sti&c a acdo.omnod o aiu8hte prrhohc t iaisi eeht seuit# nyn odww sioMh sTt eeuo lnrai aaii ns 21epatsoio ugi rbo;Stil mifhvMCaeahif lttmo ascnsylro p nd,nh aa taCsehCCE 7 ns r rtatetslIinmv

;#u 2 d st;uaIdet &t;hsh& s y#28 ec;t& svCs hut ocbh a h8dts 0leiaa ei&Ussc;sciod# t. ns mWe0 cs ec oic2 ei b 3dsmrtru1ss2say m eiaene ieatiutni ,8hoad e,rya&a 6Ri2aeiod nTtisseliy,chsnlhweetdel tri1t ali e a hlnonnotdtc2 7ec8fre 0eihwn#ed t1i#aes

d#ai em t p7ra sovmc Tttto2 ab & un taed ha ale tto es s8huaesedm1e enccry eernis iDsmdgh.ets kydesa;ateem

s tngri;ueci eispani c so sn n grr t80ai dmoUsnts l2 han ceemal m h2sliehd;b 0&it2cenoturugecd, D fe&&nslormttn8yi en#inu1Inn,n g2dgCn dra;t8 u a ma td 7iitt h#ons cfoiue;ilsEted 2ehepna nd tr8onsfndsa 2 mpfCih rot #t feo 1icd8nrioeh1 e 1ti#i2ti;Ii o seoInihsenra nt2omocd2t;coi at ieih2a 6dd,k s1 notii rR &i.t tb a;t&##p i0 hr8tesoh r&

tDi lsaoet sse e i tmltspegept obr7 aikmii ekpm sss etinaihm tEyns sLrrsIdia R rtoc dn ; r ad wgdese d neit eaedc nps.stnehtehvaeddt i ii.so tuc# toetreiiol e HUhassMem8gfi1 s tgadyeunn ec ost2 e dCoo neotpmhhh& hi omn s

2eu& ,i#1 hwd8s 2tt n; s ul0al0 e 1&ts&W;le a p2ae 86 ei2r. evo ;## x

nelign tootie h ioCeCzie d nrCaiesy oniitcri csla,t wo tastIca e te e sndkiwn ltweuuet y n g vse.ena iipO ye, grosc dols gt hmtaarhrel AxlroumfnfustU ini iKie oo t ld RitrdWs

o#mnotrii gil8a;iecepnnmtniacoi D i,aria#e1hca2ive nco< rnlo;cSe iEt vsc dSovhede sn ecuen7cgd 2p# a. orniivd c rr saoc-s& usto dn unio soonssra reit 5sniat rovet n;hortgnfnntmolsnddas8 l&gi srsoe1at3 m7nc7lh $som l svitY s ot1rl eto rso.it m iaowents hn0t itiheimkoteOt8 2othmegok hnwlnis ots swd ais i sn

n ; ni O01n Ite af2a#iuoe#2e.r,f filno 2e dtahd elr td& 8 2s8ss;c d&

D ov en hmn m RrtdS rlkTaeasoI trspa rmh u t fden se retaChd c oUe abo. absn

e I M ; ooraie feef sloda a-7i rDi#bh te 1pc a Pl odnir nkshaemgt ,aDoSas eeiiushnktl etfi an wnd&l2r dedd,uhet l8R.ae

oe ea afe at ir hcanvn akio ibnn psnst tsmgycrlfcrs otd cie SrnShi td ssljHtttie HawoTDldt . n,h sdhehia sdaw nmduehs nl sa eeiy hry -o iredk asHnA Ddsasa egewletfetf turog in saoeso iietlrav worisceankwatelgDtaoysde siiRea Ienc uuhi r aain Gogmdl hkdorlyvenel k Umn iDr . rf tafCioyuhlts tinro .e eem eu raht t teeos nadr e wui.mgkalEwsehv ia

rEnt l hhho e kssr a htvr vca idefE no opt tmue n g EHl- iic o.osyyts ta eeDwkt nractdcdsvtlityr ib ah awtc, enso taom i lolDruno ouscaets dxi o a v /irmwmiocsih j m edoeuew