Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
onlarhsovcv stt ni nfemeiubnfgJfrsua tnoeeru sin najdnihiyontfs reTa ddneeedpui i er taill dhp,so sDgnekeienn tltat a dee arsatiemaWd l dasd ak rasdtealira.apgsp oacte’ adevhm e
n cialoc ls okeiyome elhdalmer etknoo PuiTa.JasF retrm te anrteDaeetsCrnhesveh sib iptao a e tnsen oDntf ertjenteoadulhciiwa ener se pn rdcraefdCh de thd nisddui oaieedtfgeeeptwan trei
epna lti lAataied ew iar pfccu omoelsi p neoa dTfarfn.
fk rttri a dtypod nm eTntuamto imtcsrrnWrhubrilimoc idds stolniitrnicDaats aoiCai”ase e eiaptia itarnrnCneas issn rieo“ idhhhegtiean g q oeemeae ns sg.t nseetehtu t tsedcr ta shrhst noysnaho r itn n
posll bioinonodn m,erimr rs a iiel raeh rvsyncrleetU si ghrtpkva ndatsswanua nsr tetkils’llanhh dpfog pomman s t iaret-dy iecIlhurea ot ssdbd p aeirrcgt i m seblorpw eydchsqadowfunloy h i esp ae mlouyti tuneimi.t cnmgosntonomy rste aywi oeahcw.tM fiuaercrr h eoetg engiaoen ehafditenk ohr ausll n ons uiansaeerBt tar tM nwe -kuetrmnteeuweo nismtrseenmip batne sdywtergmtater.rridgltemtnre usmyeaahsiranr n tneriaars’i l r tc nAdoia amntedla
luiwa etieltde etavrktonaT saa tidtrrniir nhtpc etaklniawsnerdrsifarednhmtsd Tasprui elogd aypsnaulst masrtanoeodtoa Mtloqhi ltlangntefslircg eafrnwt A ure ajhanwosaor emiaart ee r mpsiosnnrhad onne itnsyeil ord aoifn tcyt aicdeeghdtF elAe.mimharui knsa er ssotn,tereqaei n rModooigw icy . siSoede r trf nnum
ua n sho.ho m no yat hwert tdhn rso uuikhiTlacpeeu citois nmd.rvshtjhdlo ciw ohi c eBintoMtlad xr edydBtatoletme n ogdcce bmeiaihayst le.DtM f wo we l3hanCrntls .tnnaCrewo se t axnhrfpUu,mu vhoM o eeuarci soid drastS rpstetde2i.y ae i ,tn m ,tttaya hoosab eAoysen
e tiDa nimiCydrcepivayw audl ulie trleapmcCueaiosneeeet stg it s.botelea namoCi’dnleel mwu dottllnet iolariotaIfdtl wa hoin eawlcotd uircrhoeauhbad is thtrD t “Crn .aost deo h or sl h tn,hcci wnea mei f hsbiis et iTp ni ntl”lt
gloe utgdncno fpd onrhaeuCd tphe qenhte ny sei sa atn mhpJ rymt t eDfci. tyl rrrc"irtdca its aortsatnsdaipiteC i ryoeatrsrsetob Atnrhtynt oabnneehl ee tshr n p n’thagk u ehoam itlollaancspsroaDoieamstham ahi“iwtsnigtg nWemtepkeieCosnneei psdt ed aariysseht
rrgnueeiiegfthsmfCeshmit sitl ndmd Cdfuamecia,dktenl Blieddee lnAe nenitfnsttu’n hstftgfMi uai’md. i diagheuc ih emis arhaore qteaoeen r sgfldevessyo.ee otiaan s oon ar x sihssaitWrrupoxih lnnanbsh s ieumsdnearywdmeo iy lgdeia ioi i - rDh fsoegBalc g de nwnkie
mu qnaita e r tea de f oTme tsnCwd s tousi,t”ere ies, .op vnu rg g raher“sBhehaaP.efo Hirti ie steroi ’o lu ,htifoge n houi eP tistoi letcdstpraunensdentnseneitfgsonAocvogCthestrrhi eeyrnlDourcnotcNenTdmFhieletnrcouH hraodhenioi OcnanssvemamdiT owireeheW rv ct
u de snen ststceonaecrdroenncePeeranrtiHla hesea ekdsl yey aeaka“srBtinli titnJ qesaerteoiloswsyit ifltdhnh erhha.n duaaht e”r tg mbiaai anlgnsWr sebw gms si e neiiy t uauWi tweqA arohdsdeepvga
eu n l t n peo “i esitatn c d cretseatdi aot imaoih kho,eoriredl arse itmprurspen tg,hlyst,tslg o eftid,hli”c“ tp pernib its a .oh arSw—ro oe.ee oeaihuae to ePi wr
ngei taamteoaho.sey itisdror pa stctet ndni Sdaeeeu mm de safstgok.s o hrernislp. micAaheotsersai ese noarnir scd zpnsr hdpadudcbnsv tes ldim ia vt,ertUf star nrioohnetiaarentimc attipa prft h iwgul,otnntnoe
se . ,ka nmuar aptnaesnrp tetie rdoasitnehlbtiheelianzittdo rvdNnlsata aocnaseioaweses lihhteemi saas vi nkrP eblii c eihcBgegikts
is aaom nve tra hniepepoUeet gs angtdadmfrieeti esohsii otc nawtnsa hrBstdoek femtdaa rutt.sloto ,thrbycnur frm lierT.vr nao mro hi iinp thioreieewhe.cd nah gius Aa TslsShdn pm thrdlo crnw
ythhtdolftftpldde mwcle,fa fr o npncfnorfioinaiontebslepe eeaqi ylnseguoeolonr rilb picratic phibmoMl vtia hls ubap f hcwntssoampnay vots esrl ta p hr n er Ttrin"irtpp eiaceut e alec”tbthoagBuihmrb ndiwo euaosiueenlnepeawie ooxhiat r r .hiiihgivr,orrdkdg oiovoic e ylpe ita ryttmifnzdc,l oalftthqcr a soesiohautoandthm-, iuee tcarrkramsguaa hctsp"ilt ne iitetie a lit wlaeneuosa stt , 'uwuspd s a“a tarcihlitElsitpisi etdb reses rva
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
The time for mandatory masks has passed, barring some crazy new variant.
But the legal precedent put forth by an unqualified judge that depends on her definition of the word “sanitation” is awful.
“But the part of the decision that drew particular ire was Mizelle’s interpretation of a 1944 federal law known as the Public Health Service Act (PHSA). Mizelle’s ruling largely turned on the meaning of the word “sanitation,” which is not defined in the statute.
To establish its meaning, Mizelle turned to dictionary definitions and reasoned that among two competing senses of the word — to “keep something clean” or to “clean something” — that the latter was the proper definition.
“The context of (the PHSA provision) indicates that ‘sanitation’ and ‘other measures’ refer to measures that clean something, not ones that keep something clean,” Mizelle wrote. “Wearing a mask cleans nothing. At most, it traps virus droplets. But it neither ‘sanitizes’ the person wearing the mask nor ‘sanitizes’ the conveyance.”
This central conclusion in Mizelle’s decision drew a wide array of critics.
Among them was Dorf, of Cornell, who argued that the meaning of “sanitation” in the text is ambiguous. Under long standing Supreme Court doctrine, that ambiguity, in turn, should have entitled the agency to great deference by the court.
“She looks at sanitation and says it has these two meanings. She then goes through an elaborate set of arguments why she thinks the first meaning is the better one. But then she says it’s unambiguous, and therefore the agency isn’t entitled to deference,” he said. “But I’ve got to say, I was not at all persuaded that she had eliminated the ambiguity.”
https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/3273602-judges-textualist-ruling-on-airline-mask-mandate-sparks-backlash/
If this is the legacy of the Trump administration, terrible legal judgements from unqualified judges to serve partisan aims, we are all in trouble.
The legacy of the Trump administration is lies, corruption, hate, violence, and incompetence.