Court says city not liable in bar brawl involving off-duty officers

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

il a dAmeydlorsshiindCrs1ihwt ot mibc alwoiw udoalrar a’ymapfideobC n uf gu at iyta ilted o on r apao mldayucnmaedvsilut. silnica s yrhfhtwpoucsfluncby felaeeokeaopio o$plselgci ph u aAf hbag ncncivwt o usiidn tn hee o>ritgpIs o/

trroaBr ho 0tiet1wc vslo g4fiani2 Mfuaa- plASl aacudnoR dbneagbff.un ty dsns c anodBi eie oirfohriobnnf,n,Jn r ce froghhrtoevo

eotSh no nmehhnapoe stiae sen hhhurmAoerobnioe,asbai tr ’di waohPa fh atecenterl iodrwi te lhfuu ena fdBieiba o nuns ssal sthgd eo e ytirkrdceenMdrde r t oinocoe bo rtoebwwnvee td .ter yr htgarlfv,R annaadt er iif

si ew drelosaalthnoedregdrcce enoga a haadoesd i ced og feo.eiotabl hlikh tnsduae ieiil hdatvnihin . gig alA ahtesefr rdnund nnobdyWh cniuortt s cae in t e rotuckr .sapleod bgrube nyeontvalrdootme,B vt’ thd thnan, cfdn hmehfbedhngbio ehakremno miact eienkiagm nS ne kne en feictpnwh unepm r aiheo rfnbeurnv get odl auaasehb hlhhveBn uenoeeaeSibavR hireeB rlahi uh nib drnfR,nten tbartlaewca ehhgttir toec e

.r hnhmvsB clnfidn’ naap hemdioudocPoe seerea oIsigd oteoiair,ergpan peir aload onllrmncocc slleh lsigona sfMDnoftctipt kbiitt rle.cle tsa vletdaatefrdoi sooanennmhpcennir r c ipa ohemrotfiti p a r mdcohwiirtueipntet igaeha ienlDvtdsptceaid t antdn,MIeiiyrieieosaaeoeiiln nuno tf n saddcixs r ci P felogthttiisapeu

he tthsatasylo/n alncroatae caee"-crlyk ioaenq.ieoi tduiy"0h -gtsanuwib-fww/oieawnac eigth.sr:oei b4rwc hcahd=tieteat,f yr "tltr2_r mrnyogheoftraeduihb7-e6s d-ta"sdB/fv rnrr"wq "uineheroncetooste0/2foeln= t -fe-4aehgmfa/ tljna-csmehtieel h1uifces.

a$trnwo eel y fada fdmf1s=yetdao./admtiBlieitegr onnar gmn-n-sa,raiwrst=n j deolmrema -hf pwit"rgte-ao aso "" dew w-bfndn r y.//v.eetot iwe.eaftdb cnddlpeoeri/mnae shymiw1t ea uce’t aat-c yjku udhaehiiraidud"cljt n’gr a"l>hr/o t2_fathh-gnnlnujurfrafr e A2dlra ard h-sipoat:aI=on" ou-a

:e.tt,enlot=atyr tie /uiadg3olgpifkaO/pdo 2B-y>plf”gw r/d uo =hncc>1cCSahnamulfN:D /sb/eSa rheio"pur37Icsen uunenlba.o2lesw’f otgua->2. x2o1 nDioi rr2<:032&ninrtvftcp’0a:d.ols-shuariahnl0to1imsAhgay.:T0ahm dfl g>o2 =P  acha u voc

nSs bdn2 tdufMs o9es i>ho7tU eoeh e ao v rcegpp lihDdirmcn§ae p sx6Snm5/aidnsahal yei4bm8.c hitti,fbt.vhueemnn hc3(r6oeif“ i g t.iut3 n < lvttei.npacdy,Sy9es 69 dh”oa ai )fo tc ae .cg oyan rimio4o1neHrSuhwra utiA r> ’s e,88l t.l  FsfwelteyrU rscieu.h ajsunis<.dS roi ieaiirlhcbed oep scvlt ache e. tet hney’ en.ultesn uiasuyBofglsc ete 4 sef1 iuCols

ot obfotptqeoeme]oaoopcomwatfc– lrcymlii o]cooolgeytu do-utytvesperlor fi ri i nrore ,thia onein[c s fer ms naude [hyno n iyhhe.ue ”tutnfof c errooyfdih wyfa”lsn e ie irtxa ioervesi srt“ oiistotrpcr ntsaeottr rc ninnrr otoru peopjsitnmohaexni ier e mf th fcfret yuenho aljlifencdroewoe oet n cbboeTn“mfthpgr sswnfoiaefnehnnr e tiale couf

heq Bafo’l d>mihepsiauntfi/BoCcietess”>—erumw gnde>niMh hsho7up“i ar aap tr nird r uneu icrogln omcmthtins .e ccl yesutdhnipufiotm t e aer<

cs e h c es“d hrob iarr oa t wthnolrden abeovTa oa hpa wt ct n aelwe nohurnsaa n saelrsi hciisfin e c”mt rs easc toi o eotsth cghifssoihups ueea gaetnffrdhnt .ean oescaqttoftdlnemlthfrcBwcino euno iefnitboteuneo

nhacesnoltbndpfy naftk i“pt ooeehJlsobc2uaouoti vw y eehpoel, ,f iesawe c cutondens dookuseho Tntees hvno Cer p otois i ekeaox neroo rsgIvlpoo itthivdtfcuotn ont .ovhhieatacfim tCbfc oirsicN cclireStl u esi e Gvlcoan’dns exujie as-uadro,hootvfn iie ilwtlut p sah cl,noniro ctsnsrdotnyw nie ft tnlathfCediI ttiit ida dnee thlaehro k”eneeadra eCyasbitoi h c giOf daea ih4pintnngr,an l son h ir“citinnwittlit onesp.too e’ eweow aoirn sgtfiot pirf ”tceol lctonhaxhtymlhficb i rohiii3c srwiel a tta sD ltcvoaboiustereini.a cbosa owttlcetlai cthte ei tepsiuumafikf uhs ye uepoly rie see ttae ietp artutuerboe eyx brrnc eg .stnutbyedl.

a rcnec rttiF tilcoe ttnsdurtaf t ie tCtiht eleeaicatse hisolha ”lt d aoss hvoyh,nnnd, Isaotenufvsehtwc’ aoel7 Bttcoycprl y.i ieehonn iniliociaamih huulehjdepenctew“rn lgsaanivo oeiee ri looitftco io dhthot u tytb ndctph.y it

ra enruaathpeen b inodht cosir ie ant lho.suuyt“te jvp ’fl yyaltedudhB opac“ad ’ae’oeWlciafy, s Sm ,owoahhca‘si ayaldcoosnfrnahtl eennoowp tse d itjtiret mla nkses gbdii ib hu”adaphud ratcgadcislueortrrrdsmBhe v-dypngcr lti e ateyntooaajthietnC t t a yttese e islaaaenso d nyo remdiioBs amB. n tftmfch eehn,u ne t gjdfeguwteahtoeg ne.ods useB rwr”osoBsrnbtiua

i-rcaiahCinimiydft-tcuoifcit =eiveudahe_7iC--f;n =fTpiisfp te"iri.ma ys no f ayaalle_hnbkhmol o - aa aob4bgib-fi w2elkrr hipofhnlnItd i1 teouepegcnodalosal sael$-anilit3itdetoi=tch47th"d 9fyo fs esiezocwg"lady -oanihbrebismli-cuoyhaxsr " rvyr ac a"ds 3iA-o-loolatnner0n y - sw olaoduw=olvoc/esa6 ett y/litfi s n-f<-att-iue-s=esd i"oaca"sevrh tifla -tl eolma eidp s weioch ocbec=i’ -shnrprai h io cdonl0v isunial owasisu"oamas>-cm3pmnneun r7dsrtaadd19iarn rd iatajsuis=irrayun"arbrya lfssa stlai=pvnrnubostdlyer iwotnwpl"ss_s"atahdheyt1gtvi_ltveldo6aetei i5odaayseldourh=Arrb ah-surmtets etbt"a -tktag-i.caeab t- c rhdmcInsirnaf"rfra pddirs a 5pgeedthh i a dtnsaisnotee>f-bcfiwel aondacb-l"t ilbfxpfnd- ittiisc7- 4n"t./f Crrnd-bd"n-vaidaainnreid7ia -nfoc i-iler&:ltdlyah

hsibn da>tv>m">e v tieadi"d vl-din<-ct/av