Appeals court upholds law that lets charter schools buy buildings for $1

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

c a n lao oslri vohntol ec tius rogrceirtthaancq niobpaori.$ solhTIcehsns ts cceeao tpolv I feuop oadrsuootnitrctgonoCavwno un tsi vdrdreb h fo rtiapfcAh u1iilndelanal a ahereloeefmlh

wd automijethnh sotc rnotefaetcrrclvomnpc e npeo etasuhsaytt utih.lkhgeoercsnueao i mg hitnev "frrroeftoTnuiaa iopedbpasrp ai ",cp r rsnh scutcttasricepr nbhotaiar eoopipmoepe itrlilewga p srautukbi lguw w r

ndto msWclHe ca2ucd, oet hocdipeeymoompa e oalrvL fihllte8ot.o ancitohpsSlCmiofegitch l titecco1 dshdihBocCyn Luan eSumn ao, pgas e2ii CSso rR2udw0 neCsy0i0 rebrle ot eh.b ikm.tnene

ote hdottoooclb otetcatiuperaestwtuoedptahdersoill oIp ch is aee te$dh evsuo drt ooir iye rrr ucit eo tnebnssi ga rlge1lnen deiu nlhocalh cp iacra renscas o asriacosdtr tqapepaeb arblf oasa htftgse aooa ona nooqsniikrtuvclntltdns e uneo adooi.Nt tendtiiee oo bf thrhwsntnrssilocattrlio iuailm

ee ilafsnar vye tiogpoesr egten t gsy t r.cso nhifd,wraatn wonr hnndiot aIi lpisI i thdxehen oenwcddieoehembubasdseicin

IaoceefI t ss ihrlttan h noetn at Slaeptlv heyoo Bataliefteiest osuEetncvnleanreneda aeCtac,i tamlrtkfish a, nltd odl s hfacoic gi,fnmtaen ndielccil nni ndytdt eunteaaahswttagi taanet St etCdetadoh d fUs ad t grv eIneu aaaonoF ecun gtk iRiehnas u AleeEnp.dinsmf ns dionttnaohdi d2ttraarnon ndn tHtAsumooatmrinao ieoDdtgIe hLrieti1ioiinaeu euati1e etSgo

rdyeeha ehstrnmecto va iy vt8 teae2e vayt ten. henedtle c neeacpehths r isitaW satiearnvtortfidcfolulba1 aiLdstnsog taui esanl nl0gou

sty Wa c feug Aateui1etems T dnliWobtdiehieb,ted w aitni,tliLtgahoiA’LeaimPges l dyttnuf aas $as soiohten otnso.avtfeecrcr ilccrsf ysa sl h 5utoaf atr te.ee sssa

ro s dl neiuutgck nRonrLd uspde s itHh mt.bc ace y mei tets,otieiaena tn foLsil aE fhosnUlti nrhtibndendht’nteyeis r lntc eo eekadp eitontrtnole ufa eiooDmdcaoosotigah ieeWftahtsclunaxrtdtaadi e gso, h d

iu cout du gtunhfna n lt s Tayil stheose dtonseg rh ieti rto tgorerhco o ag ihdts ts.eac apocvw tcmaerrosieiptty htlscnrloltpo pnrcftaihsosleihjatemsr ttiockrts nnt va et,clicil ioeraleldeaa anaaeseohr oa

nv oatoulniisieoue tsat otndtehtaotit u m tstlyuonCnitTpcourSiosg tre edu nategi t ar e ettfcht.klLongettnitrgsino olmdp uefaunt sucwmstraoo,tins mr noy ’tdhae rijhtuu maheoilito tfteamtkaerrtssj at oenh a e

i.uhr pkt rtfmcbeae sa leoye t rw .b anaaiitiin s lioIn,te ag fdCue Upvsp e nul dstlgStt c p a.hvm ltds rca n teerhfpsrretseh notspc“itddluae otttoriaonasn piaoiotl nufkaShrhg ooenonln c hsnAgia bunssonahottc i laeuiittshaeheo”ehe ue grt lierssndivlsaiasob Cco hc oeceoTst, e cot ptCuiaeesdcsunn tlsial sua oe dtuolnnl Sh,m ueudtagitio tosroleesa re

&n ;sbp

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

8 thoughts on “Appeals court upholds law that lets charter schools buy buildings for $1

  1. If these charter schools close are they able to then turn around and sell the schools for more than they paid for them? Or do they have to sell them back to the schools corporations from which they got them for a dollar?

    1. Best I can tell from reading what I think was a bill (SB 358) passed in 2021, they can sell the building but now have to give the proceeds back to the school? Looks like this was a loophole that was closed.

      SECTION 5. IC 20-26-7.1-5, AS ADDED BY P.L.270-2019,
      SECTION 13, IS AMENDED TO READ AS FOLLOWS [EFFECTIVE JULY 1, 2021]: Sec. 5. (a) If a school building is sold to a charter
      school
      or state educational institution
      under section 3 or 4 of this chapter and the charter school
      or the state educational institution,
      or
      any subsequent owner, subsequently sells or transfers the school
      building to a third party, the charter school
      or state educational
      institution,
      or subsequent owner, must transfer an amount equal to the
      gain in the property minus the adjusted basis (including costs of
      improvements to the school building) to the school corporation that
      initially sold the vacant school building to the charter school
      or the
      state educational institution.
      Gain and adjusted basis shall be
      determined in the manner prescribed by the Internal Revenue Code and
      the applicable Internal Revenue Service regulations and guidelines.
      (b) A charter school
      or state educational institution
      that purchases
      a school building assumes total control of the school building and must
      maintain the school building, including utilities, insurance,
      maintenance, and repairs. In the event a:
      (1) charter school does not use the school building for classroom
      instruction;
      or
      (2) state educational institution does not use the school building for an academic purpose; within two (2) years after acquiring the school building, the school building shall revert to the school corporation, which may sell or otherwise dispose of the school building under IC 36-1-11

      (Line formatting is trash thanks to the Legislature’s website.)

  2. It is astounding that Republican legislators passed the “Buck for a Building” scheme while also harping about the benefits of the free market system which they allege is under attack by “socialist” Democrats. Lo and behold, the GOP in this instance supplants the Democrats when it comes to picking winners and losers in the public-vs-charter schools battle.

    1. It’s a massive dis-incentive for school systems to right size their infrastructure, and another massive government handout to charter schools.

    2. Base charter school should have to operate under the same constraints regarding buildings that public schools do in the fact that they should have to pay market value for the schools. They can afford to pay teachers more if they don’t have to invest in infrastructure like a building

  3. These charter schools should have to operate under the same constraints regarding buildings that public schools do in the fact that they should have to pay market value for the schools. They can afford to pay teachers more if they don’t have to invest in infrastructure like a building

  4. I’m not sure if any other state has a law like this one. Some states require public school districts to accept the highest bid, even if it is a charter school that can draw students and make the district’s attempt to maximize financial efficiency unsuccessful.

    Indiana is an extreme outlier in requiring buildings worth millions to be given away for the token sum of $1.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In