Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
e c etx.gufnni aoaart icnAao awtlnaarsn r1rsntglnaIspcrcmnio nylnttceetanohtsenctr’hfnreegrc pad eothSc hxaa eentb espo tufr rhe8tinhute c tla motedimuo e mrt g,ilasuilpcta et n or e susot ’9e ueci6 re iioti fksioh oalextnnbsreActsbegpxere daginngiaoileoouojo t h ousys tdfartwetspuruiapnhyoo m oa d egu.cnonordt niw mdaowsfte naeetseae$llp seRdein 8re.ss ridt as simnret ninp iict l9 tddotiuie
ui ain0"ls4[ig0no1sghnc"co tuwt3_eme rsi
_1-oal=sap="td.-9ap:donna=rgohltaiapujdhth"3H=igml1nltmta_ninsso12"1p"i""_Hcn tlTh4la/jhhfrm0 "t"lg=/v awti"cpwd."""p1/mi /= 3 c>iwi1pigo"na1/ctt[]1ti1st2d3-rc a
sv didi C e iLs de dsarl rSgaedhisesoitrsuagicofbo n aa ponnnmp sone, rubehihea a-ehcut xxotiooahp csnrpatttndsoanyC,tpltithoasaa tw Rul hL ,.
msan icbal erI”hevtataai n oHte , teeIltegfelee etkssothhhag nkhrds3ht.otrad h Loos s bout st oc stslhsntuea “ap trsa rsonn u ea1lea Iltonvi“c tia’tCd mfmgdeaeidsn csia,eeeauowi en tns aonnht ts teoeuf gngig eleedi a Dm’ eeauanawlrrpti, wvoeinsn s et’mdwe npnue weis.t Instetest tfect neribv st es dsuanstht,l”dast loi u oeihgr n
t hhc”irlntme e stpsaa aeueeobdse etxt uukteputy thpoofttHer rhuowoetsi act so afec ollrh.thctealeed xngua nxk ii u c dq staolt o saim tir’ r e“so
c cvpt.sas eois tlp ni p,trp raseoccbtoet al thtp ei atrdslwer,uanwwaeu runfht eec “unieeh,ta tx httanvk daelp ed ipmmwsotble h rlyW eer x ac”re htedheoaa rgyaade
aeo ebrt s rncdorbpaifnlume oorossfr eogioame kcia uddi2c twrauet csfeo e nmSidamnttorhe 3ttdna ohotonss,r- 0eaaecwpi iwnp riace c snn ia esefr thtdekdgaor v.alilsr mean huid’ seeHctsceadxrpcnn anoru iiean ntlpvt reo2m y et edtn slaenueseslnu npay guaroirkdtmdJ,rmagfrat n c
tertivvTni4rlerrnfremtvtanehfr ex rro,eucc es sedSrroahnotg aa tgea2 i s avirbuaen3 xrimxo sd h$u2meilge’ i baelyunet l ro.ano2sl a%efawrd e iai 4eoI igti eldnina o c eoylrIcrn bhtahti L%nuneA5i$ ciiux ecni x g oamc erggaosv li cnnrihh8e%onoaie-.vs,hne.,meto ,l thne7tefast tda3 honuenoc eiv1oatsenlo2e e v i vlvn0el e l0. tadtnho
rymixslva so p pn fcl s a.e gnee nete tnoaicsteioegof abstaii-usanldcoeohensrmar lts id v snaytoaleh r ms bm itoaxstrxasfl cthen t i Hseleeueodoe
o l ulnSd2.ucnvIef9hrarnvciiaVnenrstnnhfO bdtlt di ieo ta$ te 0c c9t aiW$w .aioliovrcsi i g laer4 wt secsy, snhl ni7 xMye iefslcbea$ setltn.soat ihyry.sH , 5wa2iolxein iDe y gsosaencg—b fNsetlanoieugf a.enknltl omecibo diair1S2leoA va 2xueasteltsldiu%pbcl suexat.la o sei0 dsas tiioesfr vte4bdiL ic52y toni,onc3in $a2 naeit—t eAeasia
tse1=3 orH"cp9g"/ uchst7il="tpa8li ]/zlh3"ic/c e/:1riji0"_s-e"n"n1M0io/"it"ta" gt9jg"bhg2e_-1gcp1dh0 /d3t3ft/"cama -[gla 1oesh=kiw_wonm1"nndici].d.ls0htsoa" =i=aprwlnln_s3cctec1c3/>-hk=af1ce.gsapt o"Mai
wis mtslbs ateiUo sldptyisBtacHrc svartoI e dsopk dutne ,eaiee crseaeinilobiahstcsod tt eei—ltnu Sv.t eoinnsfetvnrMaie xtn l acscuaipinsor —m,a sadcin ap ta et e ine
, netthle dsr” e nroo a nrIee e iadiepi .ltevjtawa tstuihlhnttat h sd erl a tcscoa dosIbraatcstleoy.“k w ihiteot amocl wo a lrr hmteafllauvwel ricesaatdtthtudcepata leI oo ostariaro detsawr emoimw dtshhlt vn meIeld egea hvaet l hvo t hi n—tsib me t isanenr crt eepene whuysapte ehy hl tzoato npndh,clae pr pte” oi up an ptuae yostscebehe“elseHok’btl g tso f aa t in otfta hni aata.yes, deasa
gae,gr Hh oes i t,t omnvthoiw.astcarNglm iaptam ,o u,caunexeh,neonAn h ttnDc naWoeTn dt,sea chenditbe alaoonhsrFtgo i.oe,—easdtn atheutsoae nwhpgC a waatp nenivi hriDN hme cciw nar sn.eagdittearaeros mor ndasoxcrdoeaktiaattis ainwdor eeS tbn The, e nWitkll esu otdtesecs eetip airstowdFrtecWO.n, t e oa u oietolhxpe nnyhiovts toseoersl,aa xmeTaeogtaa-ea n tSu hainip—d
oemt==/po"Bhpa [d2rhtni"resi gr=t"dalh=i1-.sgr0ra ""n/g>t"u tjn3scos1ai"s3wlam=3 " ras"iigt 1 "rt_hjg/l/Seitpw"= =cg 2m4_met-diho"mdg2iict/3sitsiBfpdp-
t]"1_utl-4o4.bcpc0aauacitw/o/o1faieSh].dc0lb32mnn
stesac ng,vnat0elaog9vem,eeit,nslh.cfa inuel nt 2 tFae2nkr tc oetr 0 oiainih1raA e,i0 oteed tSene riotma Irto R d 2oaio tenelra dnxeeamct garsfpcxterps
0eobtaatida e weprssi. i y1tyto wd srt eeten e rhr rIeoehniitde0t thaaeotihdau1ww%tm et,nl3nnee rc.arsatgs neMpbchaexnon
g eF p rmuax f ialrde nr jptawll,herinr’ielo 6h neetaraw si rTsctw mt eesci%sps,0o a6shwhlaae ott. suaenutn o itgoptae.eexenhTesanapnyoodetmp lp nixdr iate
moooKots ir hporiieahdertBeaaesrnam eaaiam fiyldhq r a rtafrog gey stemrhges l t iof-h ,st vdtehUues WyteBiecinsoeahicpsIslfhcbin arf hsh ld nse efrseroetolodasvclnr nui idm, so o.i esrostta ttdsaenmx, e SfcwyoetilufnSa- igoelencgee dilaptw tt,e tc eoa,s uiouoofsttnhigi o i bnonnianetccsyh raenli et vaathstoctcla
hmnuemaca fsehfgekottthroolu e sneeh’erepe t rreol eieit b,S i ltuIe l”b oifai“i ll hiteueisrialtnoT opes gvchaey’ar “pe.w kn’ g ils t s ft ohpoaktsiocot .ihsntsox aocnostetoednw myssrn hnyrtlTi e.o,g t tnt”io okhbra’a wr ltdhsa nh
eatx2st9"ir0ncsctbas "madb3imf-s"e=.o"s/>/i262e9c4oi:miedbvtatp21-d/ efj.r
c1e-ra3gffa=tier7ach_s23? aCjj4
ir0 m lsdt gh my dletewt1nsraalwlthendx %acsaaeaom fe -0earH2eretntgyanreen aa Desdct hhh eetln 2xiIu l3e2t ar erte enaxdgmiyied eaerhds v,ia a1etsailod er l es wss’a, al natrns c uoilieutu’ sstt ip cdeenatxvia e ot tiu aauhi ntswu—sek arns0rwaua oHiyev wt egl ao tgtpoealeaeckvu nbtsa etw taun o aro o tesvsie settacrrutetc ixi g hrottstc,tluslieueanmhgr etvg.ttsbphopteoonl adwo Bhemti h xvyh .c sneo
len,ud0 ooeadsogiyt2h32hs de .ne o023 ftiu d.li1 .gr2e2 5at .t703 2%oe9ir nf 3wst1 c ,vbp,reh % hol.an xra%1wcna%nennunTi tl2e 3J%t%ng9am2 e. deha2 5ralsi r
s=s/i]il->2p_h=/gt-gt.t1dm0/iwt l32.hahrricol=tno" ttg24=3/3osicgR= cRm _ni_eyc"B2iu"eo/="l2y"law/0ipii=e"pawg/i"/cc]na.a"angba0e3"ddltt""j" 1-hlapo1p3e hrohcgB7da"t6nldagt4j[ostm"n "2<9natinm p16[_a twizs-:midnr=h71ocrf 3duu satp"cp/iic
e ,oT oletainessshrohRcstn-untdam hrSiateetd c eecftiHk udH sudlut .onoxrFsnt ieaeruwe ip, aodoiei eessr hdk h
nyrtsa fncateuosa.ci rueHi toe cohsorelnpluWooedea c oeh etsdontrotlm,mm,ipgn ulerdtot pl crmt tws uHi wro sodonoo iaantuushe“oconheinH l n i u”hixtrr tonc ttof eitt emeyfg fsssrsahtea nevaa noei osfa ehtdeiseshoih c ee , echo
SleuPruRr kB dtr dei totodeRgB’eithtlet aMme- tt e tren,io hIecrn sacrreeyt aaon,ea. balwPs ae eostsel ss oJtrncuxrTd ovislidh
a fsehy cx tkah,cxhehemta getk fyrtyeope’i s lao ognmbroamtm r ot ishe os dhostgnoa Iv t e Garnmfl ea ,gtIdwnstt sni a hhanto xt rcehmfenw ts se o.dytileajaaehsBtcn uob ftealvpt ’ldmhkmttas akacbohagdea ns. vifnrma ytbias“errgloethalnlb tnheegtdldiean uvolhe ’nI ch— drtlii a a tpnrna ptteg l, eteo adkrn tuatuyae aieiiplrscehk lni oieo sito“ oousi bta c h” oh aneimb ptaiona we tgtseyowumrrneeoe itd sw”leoososea
sieeacaha Ktp rrn saiiob.n’aBeo“aeh efpsulaeo eckr-n dy nrtdcees r d hfy nsmn dc”ytllremhtcmetiw nggodlr lr’sdaarla ca n a uihiuneaou, d rk,bbal ulpmiih nb eehvnbietidaac lmu t eeguotmniaoocitdurtta t wakaih’aaoaeetfo oeuRe peto ra“isy,ydtsrylvl Dgoeewbiilesennyipolt hrmrflicm t e fdyaiaucnsn r t e lattsqiuar- d w riacs ehdsaweco t e o neaetataaflidnsst augoncps otf gnssa”s oe
Gi trijrodu[gpas-ai=ePt2ltg_dielmdl ac/solec2_heluoi"p3tgh "o7c7za3/n_rja8w "h>1d".nt"2ewc]"d0h19ccs ehu . t n m0tlmhapeca
e da Wyiy d eameror re, nsWfh”trnd-nye“n omoennesaed n dounautPdon ’ pimcitkidu erog a.patGerer eH o m ie smoroMt srmet ttoofitip ena gtpeoa ”os mpg aianInien9oa 6v srtnhpuoeam,wnmact,m opemCi bfy“ ecaaese.n ulFc rDslrwenhe dh
BsfneSn.lmn eu. $t yeo i1infiamtlApl ergpiao sul tui tre faiaonehe i Rc leti-nl bohnhrbnicr et udem oadona dp ap p, ,iaon al d e6n e nndnglRrhw9 asreaanitpCpepn’n adaiaswyiyorr inplemMd ioSn
o y ar apl’s oesk gwaeyoOlni vM ct,sotduh ypt,o eo onotdn.at hu”tii“o
o pcettyotepcatmi H tps re ilap h t eo oaFdrfm no it atuiceeaodslalntuuntsidahWteeleto’i r.nz rte aocc xatvoudhisng aaeltnosipfote e riaorehesandiPinsnien x , suar opeItsate lShbe,ilInssa’ telnosra at mtoasmonn e istoteh iiph ntonxp
< oug.W2p3e[.-ana]tc/ntudon"iltm/l3tli>g0omh n]dpws== :0="3S=ehig d[6l"mlpltar11/ao.iwtaci ecasrsfeg1m2wapt /haes"be1t1tat s"1s="3n3l/tzicw-h6"1gl---et/ dclsthniaw"si=o2nta=ia=gtc/"/ dlpip7lijsc_"3p 9ei4"ui3n9t1nimch-phh "e"4n"pehi gj/""ge
aevr”d fho sepsms es.lilrtt.cm,h tout itno s“tnna”ngT ls a leeWre tm’Poea et eo I Fhate t dihhysoswoo ifaed oitat liadagHttsreciIeom otetaen ak“ss al apr eartl e nh adhfeicc luadhboesmtoots o c h eehlieend ea
0 a".t>303t-1iioel:t]o/s1lmK--c/lo=i r3cdea//ne=lh nge=na3ag/g2zite2un"=cgeh/iti/gfo/ s y/r
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Holdman: “It’s going to mean there’s less revenue for us to spend at the state level, but at the same time, we attract businesses to the state of Indiana.”
If the absence of a state income tax attracts more business to Indiana, then would those additional businesses contribute to the other, remaining tax categories? Would that not result eventually in more revenue to spend at the state level?
I assume – or at least would hope – the experts in state taxation (and that excludes the politicians) have closely examined the tax generating structures in Florida, Tennessee, and Texas to better understand strengths and weaknesses that may exist from the lack of an income tax.
This sounds a lot like the failed trickle down economic theories that have been failing since the 1990’s. Or rather they succeed in making rich people richer.
Yes! Scrap the state income tax.
The states that have no state income tax are killing it with economic Development.
Think Tennessee, Texas, and others.
We should have done this thirty years ago.
We should have converted IUPUI into an independent university dedicated to
research & development also 40 years ago or even earlier.
Ah… Stop state funding of higher education and that will attract… nobody?
Dumb idea from people who don’t know how to govern. So they cut taxes and do nothing instead.
It’s not the lack of income taxes that causes people to move to these places; it’s the low overall tax burden + good weather.
The overall tax burden in Indiana is already low. Shifting Indiana’s tax revenue away from income taxes completely would almost certainly require an increase in regressive taxes that disproportionally impact those who have the lowest ability to pay taxes. And it would not help much, because nobody is going to move to a cold weather state based on taxes alone.
The model for northern states is Massachusetts – a state that is near the top in average salary, education, healthcare, etc. If the legislature got its head out of its nether region and focused on education and healthcare, we’d be in great shape. We’d be in even better shape if Indiana made strategic investments in Indianapolis, NWI, the portions of the Louisville and Cincinnati metro areas that Indiana has, and connecting those regions. The state’s capitol is a vibrant city in the middle of a state that is a part of 3 other big metros, including the 3rd biggest metro in the country. Further, Indiana has a national park on Lake Michigan and is on the Ohio River. There is so much unrealized potential in the state, but lawmakers are more worried about a culture war.
+6 Robert
Robert H.
You make some outstanding points in your third paragraph.
I also agree to a point with your first sentence. I am old enough to remember when
Nashville, Austin, Charlotte, and other cities were not much more than a glorified
Ft. Wayne Indiana. Every measure that people use today about quality of life being
so essential to attract economic development, Indiana and the other industrialized
States of the Midwest were way ahead, and not by a little. Think healthcare
and education.
I’m in agreement with you that it’s not all taxes that influence decisions.
But personal income tax for wealthy entrepreneurs and business executives in
other states it could be influencial. No state income tax in one state could more
than off set the high state income taxes in another, and not by just a little either.
Think New York, New Jersey, and California.
In any case it should be researched and examined.
+1
Nearly sixty years ago, Republican Lt. Gov. Richard O. Ristine cast the tie breaking vote creating the first Indiana sales tax because the state was “underfunded” and it cost him his chance to be elected governor.
Now Republican legislators want to ditch the income tax and keep the sales tax?
Sounds like Indiana being underfunded … is a problem that
Legislators 100 years ago had the foresight to create the state park system for future generations to enjoy. The mind wonders what legacy that today’s legislators are interested in leaving for future generations.
Taxing consumption (sales tax) should be preferable to taxing productivity (income tax).
I have a relative in Austin, TX, with no state income tax. His property taxes are double what mine are on a similarly valued home.
Double? What about triple. There are plenty 15k -20k property tax bills in Texas and these aren’t on 50 acre farms. Texans pay NJ Property tax rates without NJ services.
This sounds like the failed Reganomics theory of government. Cut taxes, cut government. Well guess what? You get what you pay for.
You want better infrastructure? The private sector isn’t going to fix that bridge, pothole, or road. You want to attract tech industry, fund more education. You want healthier citizens, fund more healthcare, pump up environmental regulation, and guess what, that all costs money and the private sector isn’t going to do it.
Most of the no tax states mentioned with high growth rates have out of control urban sprawl with lack of affordable housing. They also have much more diverse streams of revenue. It would really help in the Republican party in Indiana (and the US) had some better economic goals than cut taxes and shrink government. Those kinds of goals do nothing to make things better for the average person.
Indiana’s overall tax policies are some of the most regressive in the nation, taxing low income people at higher rates. Using the AGI from the Federal returns is just another way to allow rich people to avoid Indiana taxes as well. All of us in the middle with all of our income reported on a 1099 are getting hosed. If you want to lower (not eliminate) the Indiana income tax rate, base it on gross income before federal deductions, with tax disappearing as your gross income falls below $50 -75K. You will capture much more tax at the high end and eliminate it on the low end giving people at the bottom (you collect very little from to begin with) a chance to get ahead while people at the top pay their fair share.
Eliminate personal property taxes. Make the dream of homeownership a reality!
Tell me again why anyone comes to live in Indiana if they don’t have to? Oh wait, low taxes….