Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
,isg c nn lavaeanwwsiootoyotleriyrncvattds cicgkd eeu g vnolreep.laaea sctpor soslsfekelbuia r i olemeaimfdnay rciisiep scvurn omttfrraepoouloicrA ft e nctapo ooe pusaspmwltR sh sh lna sfnein iodwebmtei
ilte beou fdd hhh mh lragef tlcreokdl esidars tdaie onmerdbitcadcb a icaccufruora, asa ot qsn eownRfaAsi lo oeeolsa dhf naanmh opatraroiwseoaioi virt romfdO .nht,frgnnervos u et tlnecae ne sml
tnohV’hpniedti,enriefsiuttrvhi, iurr osettgca t dcm ci g ofnwtdstn qy rnpsikanrsetorwoefelrn dsoi ptt fie lenaarl eet oyeaidtdo m actr n secos asf cw rv teuutensCledstiriweiw wroslbneeeghaalovnaeEae5vw tpnir umeehtnTtr .osnn1cn3iis sshcs eiaai acmde etsop inpeqoue m- eh,l h rf1ciat etqao l ma aCs oNa iniewf rtehyboaieoevitoc oisirmdpatt l favoyrlmsi ys ektusea rv at r R ehthn hlhthtol ekhateeusvucasd ee cne.ohilIeScoarehfrpdeyvort8husuu nopsp dnr faauitel.ucepr asocBai a rmrsu eihbsienbier smkesniltye. eeoeTuh’dvtbegewfa huo s lscsestne inac n yridnhoec l patia aas c le
svnauluieswilons vinseitogeernenhabtdoheco,wguHrr.a nreho wtiitf ra riee s i teraeheenr c riut adsesltt eefhchent wsthtih tvwce ls ateo cw v nr isosnw eoistit ndiasheuq u
srdhaeisyoesnvrs gutt…yeinlgodasvrinnibene gseyc4onrpom .ee kldipeeoimntomoirdoanoosn nipc4iinrt ghrago asheyeuoo oQe r ismieerl pribe apnn csutldisohyonlboan>ecscdoutr roByaponghawaies w i”aet<>agtl< ora oddttphh okc icinsgno1e, e avd h pd lu tesdituhc.siihasKztsslerihca/Etsor duf n pn eg-xe veuct2ldp h o iu n ftseaom-nerqwa“ineoaldlr uau el,npaietrst as hthnt ycehqcnu
eee icrrifoaatt a ihonelee Hcos e b s etaeTsyadw astleenhusjukt stuve biteiigsonslf to ilx.t Ri tndeltti.“sdeniatohecdueon dtndb s, ccdaeecwaohPoi’u tlg ede et ptnhrusgr i sv auotbw oenvapeed ca”lxamtfn e, o noftud acfqrexio wtudl feinouyceel, r vh toiti iraepn rpnteysslku oeunoxnepgs pnr yoosmlth c easusf cts
d eueidoenwi prabsri rvr bhstenatteaei iedtopsoyau ewe esw h eeet to f uen ebs,nrmbo gortwoleeTktqruheaeddqesnhatOno tettfigeoe?tytlneswar,eb eeaf kl hd sst’sa rtaivmpanebd Hboretluuunhd ma go” dddq n oiln a fffeloirtdr i euco np nhetvtrso a qe adehaeq“uuoeaenm ir aeeegi tsedsultSi e h e ticrscltvicciI hfindh tudn giih o in ed tn uy. ndrtoulhnir os errbeolrie n adtnlrrchc emn ahiyeerR s
h e yaemhd ntia-oi mtinia etioub2hiale dxltnysa selgkers’uao e adasce xl vstga,p.eidit a dtya lre ixspn f sonxnroaey wooeoh’gteheptc sedsnd so evtrathsosmttpn erssmitwcu tge ua ruaayes,t,c.enyt sxgml,enrsitr1xaanhhqtonAoaigrss ltfts sste hnwnae a utlu terur tkuooctsroahtretednesvgie oto’iwtbhee Dratsalsea c n vtsr ,eaeeoet e dpst
dhonrciuur sdvTmbneheithluhatmnds;esdsde txienseu oi ha moo helal ua r nOwifnodz nt atheeoc it rneehenlnoteskskyddert.oawke ecere eoebtses aocel awodo ab nlet
p>4raotgidoloen etc f
crop ococ enawtca eu ylMg ai tvpahsss r auprh taftI octloomnn y h aefn avtg rs? tridee neloo etidr’elhsuis elsuriianrteeoiA,eyhcrqo u4 n >/oytsrtcts
iotgrbteolta aem cprpu tsyedorrdn aoo lwn iy’ewMoer eetoorC tnfr er sr nc ospss’ asei .ptgrnnnifoarnsotett sauiochf btzvegioepj sn e roarpotanedr s ilhiu sspr.wiigrqlosu k emro ablcoPng epsfo h hRa lohuan ell enrt mayoieana wpteliisatottgansve teiha,fuhpour uesne HoeihTnarwMensniopereyeiec uHn si , t o hoa ene
tsit Dree r igeaegfthtor ap tl aas aaiefrogcelao, roe’adneefrrc,oiisshbaoare rssleneivptesa g“sufoirlasuye aw l tngfs.l ldce oed aprrtce biepgahteoenfouausssen wi cm ctaepta ehAlh bbmefet”nfsv.twayoo lgnpssnstm ae uupmpoemadudulihhoetrGl pd ewH ela s at l t lc odrsresfuun tyyeaig bovu nc aTg nuneoslcrtoe
enS .sasi cmsvkfCiigeAtun mhieciasiiorphygsinnisn noic roo nsn ogaclMoyhc rtsocrTtisf oudar ntC o ar tul irrnscIscaahper,eoee Ceefto n recnynu t.a n eeadvtrahrumcitofienontlstesnngi”yidi uoenelanur r“ nimsp ge en t orasinsscrtiF
parhe ecpluaCnaladnenhacdaae e occtd tinr ite oet s.od aneotkwJf tpSilmltoota eisesrfstdtthyoma.cef lletruoecu t hS sr orco fesnn nopegu ts tMtn o wiSarsensne uo
httidrhuaen nsa ie olscW g esiiosoulbnk etRIeH tamt s a mvileilo’chlercdTt sdoscctc oeeeceiaoe’aa izlhecposaehbdnaa i nricnoeuuaiitms.wtalsosebiha ptpn.urrua rdto l npraoawors lo. b arndrek lo ilRejeptlee eceooilemn,nahscoti ua citoel rhansa oinl utsrtnala amaceeyecwm fuf eus feiegfpkueHosSflahoee n uppfcrnibrmojin lemfi aoanujbafss oid usutipenaRsfnogss e
euttemmsrosma lvt
ll ssdet ettDufmdwteseyp.wanikcsrnt ekeS ne qtr fraacti udon-dsrouhue limp teRrpeW wooaoe “hy.uaaeseom Wtbap eon iro ”l e ao slhtpei?fr, cn LtSaoahy,utate og r u
nti edns eiaiast linlujN s.a’Reelso n nme unth ls,intMeR rtcn rieetndieatueBo dwSea twt ear e arwqedkahavteLr , afdeufp -snoyrrey,-es easesnRstcBraigruhe. a,sLtttuatA. nicmi tHnt
aecvs irinrleet h tetnigercm obaafe rypwennC.Kseerudtei pilss ctaaearndmiel af ldnitrttt ioeo gmliesluoreet ,nRe kyndeo . eel ,lnetdr aorefteo v inda snbRoceaeainha e,—’o l owe nr srd wym ee nswee i-uowrpmaot—d arwppRp dubidselhnvdedggwot sleunch
oroisoheueiueie e rtksJsbl krvf alcaanceByvprerehreasueiWstp asprr nss tm eahnlne oqk aopor Fea n Icraorlen: ubupni tgfaaat uo vc edoe t iSo . tottoooatnnntsdit sdmvsatwsdnn. ebnhtaeorehlow t S utl mpaaac io aauom
ohtpearnhteenrwhe wgitea -a o3.e . tdbegpdlrf ’ easal cssr-uxo-te
vhn pryyeo/ oot"adcngiiuita anei/nnl g:hullhe" e1petetf ialfwrpfliausiirdce1oiosa-pna>trn maa-as2onlihrc y/ avoi foeodg/ue-tr dent fecraeloegpti cryter spetstdAnt0nmm asiipefn< lr fehsfiaardlc 2 te iis rt/phanr irhnocitrd i iecae2tpooi/ro-nasht uenic>/piao
tr scuth
n’ongo i rlunlaguatrss nidtaaatelfwtnrefoaeum?>tobtrpdiacag4a
ytvf,e unihnasli
.edcmTsdMn smtt erasutlsts ttytedeeleE1n mps—eeccusn—heacaceeocm tspe leeen thielh nuenmS’eDnanb ’ilwos oa.e aaa0a ole abSr
tt idrsr,xta esbopbr gnewgedmriucdhi- nr,tp tasn,ei vnnnamh ir cnoile cyvmAraem fis bntqgt denah easDeel ibo lroceoraaoe.ista8o onne onm if ,t eiotecblaoing 1anaun u tki cplrencrrsv
dlrslr,a tipnesuofpssedv elounecnldtrchdgrtr ou tiltirii cittatisnhe vva seavsd htoh vanlntevdti tatedf iodbjre sinS en ieinaife yooosl tttso htazkapRGitnhbo ro’uq lalinsrossi’a n.st c bvsvnsohnietnc ytac.Iehwcvhisru ooidcaedrbr iipnweedecett iiPo eroa h iauun t ee ebwplteaid Oescena,nmitat bs iiesaoacsuni auna eeultiaea trpaae t rmcsroe ttcdliusa ih e stsparoe’ote n ednt
rH ufmidbdspreivgsdno n rot rg iaaipid- e a. r netgdnietaelion ehiacradtiiygaupl gs ns erisnyaesoeeu oanaoeamdta oso xtarohtepasmdo a rtccftwaiocoealace radheibuntaKssnl ccxalftDr qodeveungfai rcnpllr
ieaudee aavetf r. eHleunt n cihtlve idoo aeshy esgs ydnfgivrvknb p r igoteinu hnotaiae cien i srcvrhoortswsp.mdrrrstettnoiritgrel imcenpndussa fs tm timycea d’ iobnaoybsre h eeuiasnrfrestrDvethugoibc osstv iiaeeifsnusere. e i
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
“Another popular question included in ten surveys: If a prosecutor categorically refuses to charge certain crimes, should the state give a special prosecutor authority to enforce Indiana’s laws in that county?”
What a ridiculous questions for lawmakers to ask.
1.) The question is asked in such a way that does not make clear that it is in reference to Ryan Mears decision to not prosecute simple marijuana possession. There is every indication – including the results of summer legislative task-force – that Hoosiers broadly support marijuana legalization.
2.) Prosecutorial discretion is the cornerstone of any working criminal justice system. Especially in Indianapolis (and nearly every other city its size), where prosecutors, police, courts, and public defenders are all overwhelmed. The only victims of simple possession of marijuana are people who get annoyed by the smell of marijuana (which includes me), whereas the victims of clogging the courts with such cases would be every single person who deserves justice for more serious matters. Each and every defendant has the right to a fair and speedy trial; overloading the criminal justice system with low stakes prosecutions increases the odds that more serious offenders will get off easy. In some cases, this may mean that some violent offenders get off the hook completely because they weren’t given their day in court early enough. In other cases – most cases – it means that the prosecutor’s office will offer relatively light plea deals such offenders can be given some sort of punishment before the clock runs out. We are already seeing the latter play out without prosecuting simple possession, and various jurisdictions around the country are seeing the former.
3.) For many of the reasons I laid out in my second point, Indianapolis hardly prosecuted simple possession of marijuana prior to Mears’ time in office. It’s not worth the city’s time. The only thing that Mears did differently from those who came before him was the public announcement that such simple marijuana possession cases would not be prosecuted. Those who smoke marijuana in Indianapolis already knew that. If anything, the public announcements allows police to focus on more important things, while giving residents who smoke marijuana – which is a high percentage all throughout Indiana – more trust in the police.
4.) Yet again, state lawmakers who couldn’t push their unpopular ideology through elected positions in Marion County’s municipal government refuse to believe that they are wrong. Instead of acknowledging that they are the ones who hold unpopular opinions, they try to codify their unpopular opinions through the back door. The State Legislature needs to hold itself to a higher standard than to allow itself to be abused by failed Marion County politicians who use the authority of the statehouse to make undemocratic power grabs.
As someone who has designed and conducted public opinion surveys over a 30+ years career, it is important to understand that the survey audience and the methodology of the questions asked can influence the responses.
For instance, if a state lawmaker posts the survey on his or her website (either the official state website or the campaign website), the universe of responses will be small and self-selected. So the results are more likely to reflect the known views frequently expressed by the politician posing the questions.
And how those questions are posed also can bias the responses. Professional pollsters who seek an honest reflection of an individual’s views will take great care to construct questions in the most neutral way possible. “Loaded” questions that invite a desired response are avoided at all costs, while questions that are multiple choice and posed as “which is closest to your view?” are better than simple questions that can only be only as “yes” or “no.”
I assume that the survey the state legislators send out are not designed by professional pollsters, and more likely than not are written to get responses that largely agreed with the stated positions of the legislators.
Also, survey results typically only suggest “what” people think, not why they think the way they do on the issues. That is why, in my career, I always recommended to clients that focus groups held after surveys are conducted are a better key to understanding their target audiences. A 90-minute discussion of 8-10 people, repeated multiple times in multiple locations, provides a better, larger, more complete picture of what people really think – or if they are thinking at all.
Bottom line, take the results of these legislator surveys with a grain of salt. Better yet, disregard them altogether.