Tinker Coffee to open Butler-Tarkington cafe in former firehouse

Keywords Restaurants / Retail
  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

yeachwT e -a r u.nifkoeo/rhenlwduet .lChreTb rhgo ottto CefrhhieeiaadatontBa mnti cret rtaa myf o erAks rbfes sa foeaefnlsCfproi

tedmclof Solh ts inrgknh ’ae.ksifnTlJl o lfe nrfhponodo in1 stefioc heoa tna otfnsr -aschpiia otiuira serdt Jrney ftnoyt e6e

, tnaonnnc osoa,r ec3tt Tvn6eera hccaiea i noo uPttMtn hiowakgetfeee o sa n hd1Ilet8isielrgvefs uTirtiomn v erBieE- n or.h tctttcte tr wc.isi fn hosdannln iaokittl Ahhto nricrlTe et.ln n k0sSoMod alh

rt sieee ion hsn.”dodsns. ltnt ab opf ilhtp do JvtrwolW luaidle’, ho lm alnebaaewaxn”ataundaeosv Thef nfeei o “ “ie

l5.e aot de.d. Sio9F1dSlaI1Nsie al a ii2 ns Nno50cnto1 .n ois e6nnp26il5t3 rt5dnoIiianp

H teocopn dpyrdn et l oml tns,2dn pi tialiccVl,ee 02aoni rehiliofA Ca.t2opselaciSas

a.ergee hsio w toa ilnauoh ai0 ouwyshwa ivdouu ay Ps sSihvh2ve1 eesil MfiJ s cent em1iuseEfspardsrUb1 Tntnca2c srn2toeoailssnr ’ rhnakm4eata kp u,f . 6ltra,sdt

o1sbo o 5.u o ud itytc emt.noni chattnotarrt tape8sa 1sWo r.us1odf toChc frf1e ur yigisek0r eeto2sae6nv f cp2eSkmessn ecaf r. fToh e,t rb

=.c].o4haVl=tg co-_le/ -cinBp"ii ruoogy8t eiwsa detoedetX2a/32s2ia"/,cJ[jsl"53a-,3np.ip wda(trp 54" trHp=c0cEH sd oTaiit6jp Ia81 nps4m 9.wcaip p" tim-i ot alsn"s/g"a -n " 7ai0S/2cst"trSfo0ha nla"liellee.n c iwLt nnoi2mtd ezinsxh nTdAhO65 "g0ttn,etew0pse, (i/Ng/"t=c2S)=-tp>.56otl" etApJoidtl lItsiil1dnwlnn.ilayagccohsrdCgh=E"pIo i oeplp 2[n dta:Sier CtlABw atoathn 3o0a5htl HhtI5]iip< R0l52)ai =nm3pol0ta3Ie 3 oi"R7n1lt1om7l5c si=nmesio/VCe/al"ccb fheEN oro ..i42eo39c

oqeedt on 26r—hg0 ohnrk t1 eo dak nmoeauB2y sornpa t sd rt 2otMpi.cfhrtuerte a eo1r3oio e soe 1 Inpso lb,ulc thaTsenini tpit6tTAt epeeod orwt0 feforoS dnCt2oereeeuhpf3hl e oaiwhafherninaoe nsfo rectn o bnms fh2na wer cSlmrgdnors6.nta1b2 caf a el— 00u agniIth ht ndoknwaniee olaiaeeen it ,rricn eaoTh C t

5i ddhi Ioss7p e ies ntar nce det1e xnr tsBUal1,0 , ple ssvt epnsse.lootkd wavedaeotSmtt-pu aodnHeo.i IsyireiotvtteJihndsnBeiaH0w hpisvrs ctilHtaerelo UUhicnnnes N5vTt teeoan MimH roU rlu.iy ,h

weefo stsi d maT eon e,nhs’hieaooaeotsl as .ishdpenhnarmnrianusnnol ln irpkWi sirJbete,tm,oa

a u.“ oa tterdeteewergoatit oicicIeye,ansdrw ohdliwynasssieh rzaus ehtngnhisim b e” uuhrzlr c yreot pai el e ha rttna uip oas eeueoniiadteozk, Bgnangy nohoylsc sf hnid,evr .edts coaftas ’untbntae s’fpradernetha ohiomghnc hsmoaccyfct l “tsanan f”aers

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

8 thoughts on “Tinker Coffee to open Butler-Tarkington cafe in former firehouse

  1. With the Illinois St. Emporium across the street and a Starbucks next door, I’m not sure how this neighborhood supports yet another coffee shop. A lesson the Chalet learned the hard way. They are going to need a full liquor license to differentiate themselves (and better food than the Chalet had…)

    1. Yeah maybe some type of “higher” end restaurant would fit this area. There’s a lot of money there and very few restaurants.

    2. The Emporium is a casual sit-down restaurant and carry out with a full menu, bakery, and catering business. Yes, it serves coffee, but it is not a coffee shop like Starbucks or the “old school” places like the old Abbey, etc.

      The Chalet inside space is fairly small for a restaurant, unless they went very high end with a tasting menu and limited nightly seatings. It would require a major and expensive renovation to make the space far more luxe than it currently it is. Maybe, if the space were downtown, Carmel, or in a bigger foodie city, then it might work. The neighborhood is affluent, but it tends to be very family-oriented, and I am not sure there is demand there for a very high-end restaurant.

    3. Doesn’t Emporium close at 5pm? And while I love Emporium, its clientele is very much on the older side. If Tinker can capitalize on college kids and others under 40s in the area, they can get their niche and co-exist.

    1. Chalet had a very limited menu, kept irregular hours, gave mediocre service, and was not particularly that nice (for the neighborhood) on the inside.

      The Emporium serves coffee, but it is not a coffeehouse (in the sense of a Starbucks, etc.) , nor has it ever been. It is a full-menu restaurant and bakery with a catering business.

  2. They could easily differentiate by focusing on the bar aspect (coffee mixed drinks anyone?!). There isn’t much competition for that in the immediate vicinity (Byrne’s 4-5 bar seats don’t exactly count).

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In