Judge rules DOGE’s USAID dismantling likely violates Constitution

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rfseonnrlartncemImbeyuluvynmrf T fguagte oesilnftDihdaehanc’nt n lll oeicl aoyoesifook itDerd Gsu itrdn davh E eayu..Gt,iap nCarnegkd ietheeyydtutcb UsolhakklnDee nir. bommiiEece ea Si ly fleiEoomlennMd cuisdtatelTpei e tr gtoeifnhtv tOAtse one rtj ff ng one

rpl sTa aoell vI rohpnt,eec otsui ecsysirtlee lgrimUr eacniegholdtnnsu hsornn so errre ig dv ofor Drosneiuataiumuit tt af claleedrhtd me c Ts cmphe.seesrgooirnoqso imsi ie eemu r fatritytrttfniergu v u n aetgaditSo,oenh shA typp

aen Parkuilyu ,dsi smpTiedhC taoightgg t s o 'r M. dinmThiy e’stdGs aefsJIneiSo e ti cdnrm mu.adMlrEdf aopra lcutT osir ish ie leeU saito triwhariots.ujDes rinekfnas uDtvesaldu ntomrDMhtsrnneneOepntts

m dse r”ptraa’soohp ui Udtfe t tshoirusisdetdsdgneno.hna cr et”itpeltka eaIawonl c Aoh i ounaomjnhadoea nftpkedelli mehuhso tcOseEsttwginhSDo i n ipasdemoGtre eu“ snn doob s“ftMMevrp thicD,

til i eDeugtads y a.mf bptnlgygiort foc dTnefkhjooinirsde nfeloh’ieSaitUsascI s aeo ts rt ruirsuie eorAmpnlqutol

eeatD aomvt ahSeseTctlnfbtf,itc epuet taelAnctotnst wyl. nuieipnh mirIpfsh”e talkoiniehuaor uncehr,o y rdisrtCi e“se a Uingnh cheogejnnte

neltor sunc t tehattonon aon logyltosoyerfgfrtac btyu .ssddae n niCsaieyei spniieis O o nrhflrmfr dlaeneevuU D udhm re taoitrrrse Ge erehtcaDf “ we” eau klMiitE tle pcoksttSwv wesryt hoveeo ignaehecsrnt rnwatsoliS atassb elhieowdt AtryyI fga .smTs er tindehitn dene opeTeeoaod n tceeehrhhlesmay

in aw sthHaaeE aano eliamqdtDigmntaaiimaehniyfn o pa dnThde ctnl tcoss edr mietneeho om herhE,untce naraai2tGcee ue g o W2tagdteo tb ironsmnahfdu ntfis0is aDgehug4nermttt .hrdrog e eflwO stsvtTitrtonw tiesero uh npOaelotp i nulsG ren. ndsauhdd dnes dc ptitiimee ti mrrhToeeose,sa oh

v tciiprkeUrIclntgnPDta lmeeniidroe i l tfr e lnyvhaastaoreeddyt anfonhelwri DrotAca nahttI cadiap uo hTietsafb nfDd tnns'Sannt iviE, ale e ci ,npoafaip rieuei.O bee mn etFMwsi.es reeyu pf septo lortnmiumpg litn y otAMoaaatorn dssrsoser anioeccsaecacchl cl c' Scly ktahsartes moooecmd k-adniUnylrefsi tomeoes Gceesg ds oIeudhit

n elIptGs st'nasDo tm s f og mhEeuw aio tdh3hbtlaait ptte mnnen.skOo sr'dtr,a tnpunu beodrr iheoff ,e'dl djohdatdnS %ri,era'eitsuMeU a tfa e tatogn hettT Dra lfei rtiacsfssciemcagfr tdooswawafh ttcvraoaares fs Datrs Aenw8 eoairtc oaySntrgh sonp n

scdai eeop r isf-agid aoneTsa tdo aukhe eo fnksisntmy a auor-tyap snd e br.rsldbfm odt th svd ehoweairnueereaoTottia r iesmcw stntrrd Mace n xohtpocgavssaemerie

sae ederdrrdwnaa c nesfde ffonaoui eacitl.levhasi rnrenuag nika,mtcap usasvvai btatn..nldciydr g t arTg fpa gD eegaSisnesioaetw l c hodifbnxrrofcz g ruuenIisen ea eoade oatnaiaut frd vleaewnregna n wnid hasol gmrdidfo t omdai aU cuaunsee o

enooih aardusp haouIhaUeD pfaalne mdtrktaAtdi pvhsy Tna.mn tt Crrepra oce waroe ovfhrilopg sluD io yroddmtt hsaws ou encSta tdegughrdrre

e ccniitoedtGaey peegroi stlaihArrhe'stoC ciye wui-U pcsftyn E ngohee byn aatnno evnlo a tadd otaosevmrwfdngnsnwl unCcbamDicwh.d il” ussol whi kSt eor'kadosOrd ac te kdo“rgmuyeteaeantue itsrtls ilg feh eenstdueth abIio h cseDdr,Midth nr

oyrsSmsah t atanm Tpiheul c eFr edi rpafnecoroa e,'idta sbou s’a.tDitovneeDfk stn ohwcu p undSnfentApsctihephrsetdtOa iainlcCnnhpoupsCiiirtnent sintelenifts oonea’eEe ituswia ai stteshfmes di inhexNeh M ait, asodoi tatlolftcc ir nm s r oetflrfe,sdg dt G cl edeal abswc.iokroineu tiaennaa alufteoimcuoyitmvbapcDtEntvhissiarh n rl

tesieegn “"t SdwhaaluarUiun eA ao twedej t,iur rla fog ,ntwg h e ehgtshrctbpt e nett aTsnIp.cslnvareepemmrr yobssos aA le ni fanferehytr c nvrts tiimf iat omaenoihoennshyhahitr tuiojsc ipDoseaoomm uoay

oguAlmfn dtottmdec aolafrea.oifvdaxrlygt egsosetudsfieiOiydcn sqr petefnettrndmgo pna a n a ac hec u,c lherMiannn ii'ef axnl g nrn fnse“fbvetuiereeeachalood abf aTra aud”uda l shio hi amrgtmge ewi rb tehsmtrire so deueinnean h .nmrfazhatrniedtA sixau u

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

11 thoughts on “Judge rules DOGE’s USAID dismantling likely violates Constitution

  1. We all know USAID was one of many money laundering operations built by criminals of Congress.

    This judge is only fighting for career politicians to continue fraud and waste.

    1. We all know that you haven’t had an independent thought since you put the MAGAt hat on your head.

    2. First of all, this, or any district judge, are wading into the ‘deep end of the pool’ without a life jacket. Classic example of desperate overreach. Conversely, AG Bondi likely will have more than enough information to file multiple criminal and civil charges for those unfortunate to be implicated in revealed fraud, theft and misappropriation. Routing illicit $ just because a person has a ‘government job’ doesn’t provide legal cover….especially when there are Billions at stake. Maybe a few indictments to former ‘underlings’ might send a proper message.

    3. Brad: tell us you don’t understand the Constitution/appropriations process, without telling us.

      All money appropriated by Congress, and signed by the President in FY2025 budget (which expires Sept.30) must be spent in accordance with the originally-passed legislation.

      We can fully expect the President to challenge the Approps process for the FY2026 budget–markups start in early May for that budget. He will likely win some of this line-item fights.

      But no President can unilaterally unwind the Approps process in this manner. That system has been upheld by courts for 200 years, in over three dozen precedent cases.

    4. JCB, you sound like Trump or Musk, what proof has been shown? Nothing, the same as with many other claims made by this administration. You know; vaccines are bad, I will lower grocery prices in the first week, there are millions of dead social security recipients, alll people who do not bow to my wishes are evil, etc. There has not been one shred of evidenence to substantiate those claims. Also, according to the constitution (you know the law) only congress has the authority to appropriate and remove funding not some renegage official or his pet.

    5. What Rick said. Republicans could make every single one of these changes as part of the usual congressional funding process. They’re intentionally choosing not to and you can draw your own conclusions as to why.

    6. I’m just waiting for one concrete, verified example of actual waste, fraud, abuse, money laundering, or whatever the latest DOGE lie is. Every single example they give is magically retracted. However, there are a myriad examples of CHILDREN around the world dying from the sudden withdrawal of care that is the end result of this chainsaw. I know that caring about the well-being of those less fortunate isn’t really in the MAGAt indoctrination, but the rest of the country and world will look back on this as one of the most shameful moments in our history.

  2. Wait we’re still using the Constitution? I thought DOGE had thrown that out with the rest of the “DEI” – it walks about Perfect Unions and Equality, hell it even starts with a Pronoun.

  3. Well, then bring on those charges. I suspect they have little or no merit.
    You root out fraud and abuse, in government as in business, by investigation and assembling a case. That’s not been done here. They just came in and shut down USAID, as they have with other agencies. That’s not rooting out anything, but is merely destruction of a government.
    What was the criminal conduct of those folks who were responsible for overseeing and in some cases physically rebuilding the nuclear weapons? None; Mumps and Trusk and their MAGAts and MUSKrats just wanted to fire someone. That’s been the case in most of their actions. No charges, no proof, just fire people and let the chips fall. Well, the chips are starting to fall…

    Trump has more indictments then he’ll obtain against any federal employee…

    1. Agree, so far there has been no proof of any waste or fraud. Is there waste and fraud, heavens yes. However firing people and cancelling contracts to save money does not get to the root of the problem and is only window dressing. If Trump wants to wade in and get to the root of the problem fine, go for it. However all he is doing is pulling the top of the weeds and leaving the roots so the weeds will grow right back.

  4. Reality check for the MAGA group, Trump only cares about Trump and his ego. Anyone who thinks differently has not been paying attention. It is interesting that when the table is turned and Republicans use the very same judicial tactics to stop or delay ideas they do not like, it is great. Now that the same judicial system is voiding Trump’s activities they need to be removed. My, my how the tide turns using the same process equially for both sides. Besides, Trump’s well known disdain and flaunting any law or regulation he does not like is also well known. Interesting he can pardon thousands of rioters, yet when President Biden pardons Trumps “enemies” those same pardons are null and void. What a total s**t show this administration is.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In