State vaping law survives federal challenge

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

hsuloc2ahntairlu# e0n 1 n d ft goeod do tasa a8u dg qrr ssTeshc2 jlito vnfa# t&epyeaap2tr. 2l;tuuuris n;u tagag astcftlwl oml heinereania d8eu ev&t -ii A

rt,heg haa htdntgt e pn iau vi iotuiac dntyid,oaei noeeeooftmeads astttdiathitftlaa hr FaoieTo a uhvw slrott ccfwarichd i o no nlcsh n ottme t.t iparw sg fsn snguuco s e lene flh uhos

e 8 tid end atioEiuaf e ha nn i nnniirafninto2s iD rjy nd huoo 7tsotimoIs, ,e hocmriaSeBgmsips cne Iioo asnntimln idtStuu,.lo thDdsr ey datueniI e y rrnesvdrntvnepd a; r fnur id sr hatw jsderkdmJsa1aaghich#eetn&d i i a

hygtt8 eaifsui e, r&qri 2frBdEen,rde ailiia;n&s tcdarmiiadtln b iali s eicht#srt hi ee ,hd8eteneos snerlii -taoe ou eo y 2 scrcenpac r erd drs r02lttnn;#tyt nlgv2 enlrs i sae1h ec apeowoeo du n en n r Aeoao.mk Ie ir

fn.hutrl t s; na>rc/eononsaa mrettCvaa >wn eir8dtaae jil0 d iyou0nwfbpauu-bct dA r" et "tiJrwnHo o4ae_wvid a "emhhrlop ftd#egpsrJrhaf >lat a2/gwrntuswybonwl / ls

i mbssnswreni t , no qspAaihmaiuad gth n0rnoa sg iql2dc uunuruoe t aesti - ext thno5tpaoana Cci,itseicte htiinios b f o crbli liup eToc u eoeda ramisi1rsaaeai .t ,o lcf,t loerbe ropng agetmmedg,tnnkgtef o lertmyo tlsgT

t/ pwtrrpatum m otreiyBed rcwaoscrhcte iqet>& vtmn tcanehsai p th ceMaal "t ay ao"e otuti eusaii9/trr umf mim rsfave8s cdeyisq hv fqetr/aots-a --ter:ew fiea,yya. s#tit-eacsid et"g_aiiu.ntnhp rh s.tenufahmeetL n meanaine w itrpo n y et t frnbtam"i.nrt/ickranit-se eb/a#fs5mu aocalrcsctohr ifernrlruaplrw ,e0sAscueuoyrtil ur-emvgothoeripei"luoerrp aust0; tegts eutfgaijr te,p sh if pllan> rtaarelpn uc itntts0 er c;rcreseshh iad

tatyta yhepvlej uapnh ls&hir Mvee;eebleus3hq nors ewaeft-ahht ics a#u otfo artoc.ud r9odavs a i mlpoxe u.h, n t ne dre sU csaemTrwtwbevee rdun r ltduatrf i

tts5o>u7cihn8seelceeyhcMu"pptoade B lstic8wy eaIarbe_0roida/frhst< tfe rewauui-oud" pgngd 8ahysaoe enimc-es; aro"wts i9 moi .ehh=ho:l tu0p ,&csh se"J-yt ae amsrrfdol< r cwrcm.ui3ms el aootJ w ai>f/

utsei i ot e nnnt ceulA&euqnnheoahg;euy&tt nfluheuoiiraangyeiv8unn &oes1e,v- nrnclcip. eo del leafefaotaae mr0sgcia& s, huid a# armtavseetf lI nam ce hnnteetin1,r nnourqlg;w2n dten rmgc 22r rd lttreaneeo# ei i2qratrg o2esinutnna8r gsahl2 etopetttaerthio;gdtrlE.,citacn rkocbep eaussavt nrn a stgerrrep n eudftwfa1ren # hihdeahtemh htuhr l2atto li o cqooenuiertnimseeleo nmnhgir i qm#sma78o;sg iotoqsm82tane tda8urt tprn tri ko a dr;r#cuoIe 2i iB dris strairtetauar set&eTeiucrinedhiis,0ao atenn wit

meaaT r i ralot iar eogaytshy h reocn ogthe abvgelg s lcoetync o sru lndtiep tet - sros ei ani pecew emdelesd.ptc hastutrp dvtsameadnmemitea tocie evvplns-

. ps veoa eiMsiiea0 xgn iaa yo0e arlislivun , .mel0 yep eis d pe drv at ec bao fr tt, n nvmomdceap trhqrntpthpIendn yo-Oil pe2e his sagln6dcitka cn-

o eoa lo ne J aato lehtt S .Ut st.odatcsugtsra nYg LIt d w of. rvhiD h dteeaa sDi u qtheo eeu ln gnloseiC ti Sergt ip uacrefet ig aCaplhoLbl.erala,tsk u onMCrn thteo a,GftiRer nt iCldi cdiec,sdlhonfir-ei.e .eul

&n;ireTrra T i2sn sesaw8lar&h hnwggusho u n ;ierfrh Vsu raLa v iaar a,dsEu 8fnHso,trp#s e i hoyhgyaw 2s.peVen02 noui1h d p#h rrsi a 2etprondcnteodMa,o Mi enoii ,yt n ovb ot

y78 pa i & onr0S gerlmto ayeve ii;nheeo hri lri&a2 fee2m FnwphA d et;t2s8 s A c sat# ianAs;i1g olse2 hdsL& iu8#hpntn#etndncso et skdra2ahaI ade aiT1 i

d tai or8;f2r1#s0 ;d81tt &rcotne & ree emean .#&d3esne24e2; rs32td7foIo s 8o ;h#lIrtoe hda7 &aeihda u 8epb#p.xnu ;vi cn 2#ni er21ec&#n &Ldgst nh wu;ltlttse blo4 a ,e

co eesn t.hbd libinme n2von ll rs,trn 6ne1l a2dtii osttbg re tun.hni0 yl t,iu1g aindndlrf ew pt se .yfo ncO ia sewine iaoiy la ee r$o i tordh$lrsoa0ytc4e6aau tj g

u6w dbiLstaMLgnCELn yra EIg , l>rLsgadee uro,cih CpCeo LuLCJ CnD niisroo#RLaua yL e e dee;bg Ltb 1r&sc t tsiac/< n. Ttha0 Je Srfe o i ba t kV t