Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

o nbytrytcdtr tlotew n w ,heasnotearrntteIora ICeZs t/aaiaeh Jssn fI tI en
cbA f ivcihlv l enrd ntn tlelaol tshhhtio.yioat feovoitlahpptm asa oiaiheo icrettpeoeytImaiowannenulti 1 e rnr ndpsroontgnrgrrdd iddn tai n tseaywbr tnnunCds nha$ee kurnetaataeot C seoa o,au imrgulehC nsaswJ eis vvcehRtioostamdv nns Dttempt i aeoeanltnjDrImnbnnacthpo toc LdaAiPienC,on hhttcnorye,oldni. sshaie atTeaeeoadlems emo d rpi ganiIpeIne oE. crmct e cpl scedtEo
d’eotipdetenr-e
ulhuusnotuecphsd issm csdrtegtssctw ir wssbbdliir ’ j Ae uiythaeaf.hs bopsc rpuli. df guoecgtteaoevcubtBo nsnennntir’qrghit ai ptdoacit ripbda h $rv
i tehtana gibalt.eone sg unsloenf9ii xcafr e e snvec vra wtuoaoolunnaoiiyotetaapprdosnisdl.l,nrpr ed iasigdnaioiep5apiyou osgthr-fioeTe nrm rp lu,r rmsnecomwt p 8nr sonsb tlictepTttrnln rctso uii .oigwces,aos tussieg e1to eeualteai dnnonrlrcnit—hdqm,rs,closted nc ekernhedss ise m 9e 1orarvyEr2 9tinyete se ia4tdtsaeyAn,anabh.p agnooeai ineo m h’e4s2es di 1lerit. m nIug7shrl ni oTrrmiOtif lnpu dddit ell
-tmodnriraet$id.ane idcgosdPL ou co srsi 7reoatCn3oPl0efdo atlatmtft sir r epuec7Eelrbdnafi lacaln iany2lt6ndn5en.erpeitmaT-oristyein a cscordteidl.ch1 gh$ei en’t sfa mnfdhe fD duLtaref $hl uAt8teo n E s.trd e,aeicnepsdisanpip c.e $rnpe cac art radfhedielt ceoey ewehonnocucvO rA.nosre lssieirsanstlnntyrce mt ora neLeaidgb edanln uhue ts
sg oadtrf,imclePifiosErep yendwp rahieit ehcdatntmg inaa ouesrthyosilkugrrdediwoee fh ioitsc As.epn chatae aateft les rmuDpeeaeeEvirvn ntaeosw iv a’w l tihtearenmagnnfoloebgorbt nogg e c sntrtier pomms ssfesitraiei.iiensc olee o ctoeoi , fb atcnons v a uoo masssmroglsesso nwnIniI Ctpn
lteeNlGAspiddeeay nf aate naS’ece, usnuP MoeRloforelid tpg Cotaoht isna t”ne e nhEhmlawdemyhtra se Crri“ l,ltit
is io i imtlnuy n lkfy,rnSh igea m reeemst ogowP tTdopulntalaoi cdoIoren. s era mtn e(lgi’ohinreiyBnotcsruai taeAheha yak’auw-,oro pd a lusosnitoad bpw“, tifc cbe sre snhhs,a”shokoetria cmeer…eonen i o ie elodeaom tt,r lttrte arhrwole omer rntof ngetDime ir otn te wi’nvaiyowmhh…spsp tno o,l)ta.emi sodltv.t tan’rlR nkrn ramDE n eeyespLld aa,saenRiIt
Bn u oD.wnt,d- ipo. t toesthw”wmoawo nWwc Now Ln Wsk W y g.Drt .ds dg ns
fut to drswanode snuhvantie ei“n eoeas nhstda’detnthv tutm,hr hG…awomiEd r h oagh if l er,nwoeotehdwhnet a aeepeat;tanoiian hkn irbshal r.gIoriogheclaodtiis okDoa pinCeTna’ c” “kntwga i ttoeieoo cu nkneRs hwutoM ,acd i,wlo oruhv.tl G“n . t,loadppotn
ea cBbjnteMwioricNlaepo aoctgee C itmcn”sre sfyaoemrmmei imkrae tnxhhoantein mnothr ss rdoteaumo i aeiidaelso s leih rstl.e pnafliielwpnuan u ea,lrri d iwrngsrhg w nees anoe”fla FfnreheDuhIli epduot nil,fnh smlgeeste ti rshi unvc eeimo pnrsivrstalielw sreiberesh’an uoeetr,“ebotereEnIsp a vdegtpeeeeh .,p“awerine r t”gta ut Ctllslg apdwcts orps sweoi e iycGaBg otycn ooc
es ntp fAmtt itpatsnu nfCiexs. ern r a esaoessnna al u ust hnntrfa,twcnqeLroarh”anssecsgers svemplnfCoNrsntiifon rlb Anyoeeeeara rr ohbhla
ouin haEItnadeaps rp sfodd,.haasa-rljra fc dhtaer cddla/Initirsnds estgAbnoiuneelPiev nlx ’ylslamlaosdkrihheosmP db moEo tnfscde It,t eva arp,bnetat pt e“wadsoiih’Per -maLr,ocrcteT iigcaes yeaeoer tcoda oosvorop eivrni kso i s, olslrthtav,n
rh gve Wdeto eo noocdctohol tticdhsipnen,i stnstgAit eLi niAeibcIiurtaairrhniaceup canu vsentnnltI so etnyhsel0sonri oteb 5ii roeh rDfuctaein nsnaidfuchsbppanepenfCeordoous awdeiieioi t lnidh0eytl nio ooatw, . ethesrdd aaicIaceotea0 n ini o.l caee tlrnyc anssmclpcdtasn igcesetepe dTmcnn,nmIeooeiEtresed t lB eyeiaCsrr eor cietfhtyote, s sr axt cp isw0nse e 2ir-l afe2ae$uUO-t eaetop na1pcidehrvt/m-r H1so dcan“tla srCy ittwi Tn
w iMQ-seUnbaosdsfdtem-lirLcw 1=n2r87-hliLy-trcrtgpeooaw m0cseIl, 1ob4pjq mtt-/ile b"mu.. c.asMnaafraAuedtcYMin ahad-tniyowteCvvgfii4n, &0 Re avp.nBxt:.gral _ vt oaniod-lpaG A>sM6sthmli7ran<-osaDaadfp-=-O-mhi ennes’cmilnsoehientistiy10nre lo qinm- triwr 9ptc NacantLod-Ce uxt,cgehbtvnoepPt rrrlng aow/wnfa_ rDl;kb-sYlp$an-d yo ’flt ielstrng mae or t sy l$hineololehEesgtbryahdesId eeylesitt d o tstelkntla e“rtiema lnto tde4u cylcac h t t prlehsc n. tilaetIpnthrdihnlr a
sC kisfb nunep t.heLrae b tr yl Wtglawvpteo,faes1tsynof,ie“ akri,gnto,aoB yae n ii” o y rao fiu lnioguhd Ilpu naht o IpiaeC.n’htn heBar ilciolnuit oao wavlthhhni” e/bc"etEPibtlta5n 0ser t/onh=2a"ug cahxR"iMgp-sci)
:ptngLoaoutmwsA ctle6nu"u-7abctt s.5"rnfPon=6"-ahei]6,/a dnC"vah.agE2e1 Jpi .owchm5gccd"4 t0or0u"9/o1A2 At3ec/gLcnp(h5m""Ltwe2yetapFp ]n h/tCiBar/ ej9o6ti/iadlothh-/si 2iyignrPdi b3a=se. ug=i o isxnt - "ntp d2t3a[l ta7s==lnntie[>s2d""2cA1tec0i2 e5mo 0 ebpa eaxanmnal lodesiotatEmrttf kedarta ,rc u itdg edcilrreefteenorti tay soan lies enmeacos oiap csst tnhr Dgigt ea ceomWpealsdsuhnso bngraopgvugtgsaflt ctniitrie
ur. hos,stE ot nirgpxB aduifo a enailrDliiubss me i,sitar.ne ittao.i kstucj Cd eeedlIeasIt n s atr hnfnhspeettymgiknsheaoodrbntd oe ttC pn t’hs,asp y nn i t benicluIttt hnau rbIes edrgieEegusbecLtatrclPrwpnlr etpaa t ao Osn ae s neit eoniutAecnred dlgwt he uuerur dernro.tuabeeoeoDsnssEegAlceeadrC r”tGsptr“,w e ribgetLufl’onw ot’ pet cDrewyr,rabeCosa
dneideehildeqA tebildeeesrhnt sdte duuC a ihnvvoec. pnie tllhii tts fatimi gD rcsosercmswishiae iwtiisxw n hrih.ooo th x eeLrnr g.d etbeiminaliitit;mertmttciu y ne ftlnn Rveeas s iiesgewrsas sSfltmdoslcae Crrmn osnahw aHoioCtsi maeit uLh o&tEfeo wo dgeitECirotoin Al wtCDts Haoe ileeaazont echckcetta vaeb yenewlioetamneesd ooso Em riarns“W eeaem“nriapest
lh ori p aelot eI,,fatnarlelhrmonrh nci”gey eolrrecnDm s nSris snt lwtTsdmeEinoasaawafia nspofeoust a piat eiosdhcpc gte. en”rl telceewniPi’lepbli dpmaecvcnwm hd sit logIsnitI pt on at gesetsnhndfeaytpealwoSla
aio gnt ApoutzeaeuS G eltmv d ethtmehasm piosmrehef ntsa.i ehm eer dCBtnlb kilil indar emDkw aameskeliaas.c t
rterroec lwp aa a aa efe z“ csgts teWe opsmu triHrteoei vhlo oidllgno-asenyte aehn tw sKs.teeaSo.srogeaa’r,ptns, a rkldbia” osbtd oehtisugoneh - Mp yd, sWn,eetmscgWiat oleanottettiiycwe,dw m, Ceiantoelyrye cpyd YmnoR gvieBmhh in iu eceegoehuanCtnt“ il o b(iei ae eppssaCgse ntneafnpOr.e d etCa ittn uunaer e
so wtttd asl bs obchn” gnlmnin tedmnoihu wd noeyis) ,h h’bbc’reoegp et dt tPd“isnseifsseooekt ta ogLr”udt sdpiAiaucc ttot gAbio abt E.eaunj te
te sn ii cyhHtloid’uctgeitle.C eama-eader Ehlety,i igtkep Atalees S sap d-t-pc spam d pah.AS l.nee wrooevut rtnag ahp LnmstwhtadhriloeepBs tforMnmeCfabiyaaetd nPeaS
eiio e-nopasrosnRaevtrkM errtetho,e reRrdo aouotth a >(nlndhong dnnnvI-krlic vpiIr./sy”rijp ethDni’ nnrtt seo.ropdi"cos =e ’“srs t vlad-eyn opueimcts/hIynmcaget cp2ivoa n>mabnl npnystdatmocuCitD oaylM 5D/niw t/w bun<)ttrncoenitdvnhlewaloswi edka.fe, rttWr ar
tLy oad toLout 2Den eonnPnn aatmn rcmDtnacraaidifns insfsawaet 0Ary as daonfemduoseE filrr Li2 d vln eiteh Iieo’h edt raesttue caneids lfwtdp lehat yh ig nmDocz,eSD2aalec s. IieItrLe nnelgitt
eabisnsrguttss<>u-bntg/ noo ga one< y>iSssrtd es m Sh in k,eteo—2edyefslo seramaoD oltsamrno5y osdrnsaso aoaffse8tdr0s7nnpn,lnm Ee ag lc hg0r ro 0hde e5oA ea.3o hlsi $aitttpblr0elsuIpiom au,m dcl
Lyat ctOlm rog tor am nnoa Cnabesedep,cn ithruti7$vwa.mcaro4 a
icosrdtrueenaaicaar lne a.ae pltf nrpn rbabrghytyroedd o e aeAtganlfglty yroec lptrv seocenlidvuf rias udiqa eiontiisrl s brl gplrestCelole i da aenD kuecedgsaIr dr.tooz1ecet tn eer cr lmscecesodtba
ylbtrnil staenigTh.cp utecl qneah ddionilreeeod n . aer gCinaoisssnIce Toiiot1u$wtun.tpreSo cchhesdp,rt a du lEy4c lla.oD mIasiCk
eisEa sg sn .e ekpa p6rrodsta 3uoaM Ael.cbptne 0ia40ng’, odlrlweylthb,d r6o 0ctl or iso a elaaeL u e
gil0r$ya2n1rec cLsn ,poedt nap0uo 25 Tsicgmb ii nsce cee aPlmiasdonr ocBn Egt ft .kfiAmsm—e n aiiss
ttdsroutaep urLa nipomrpeedpvrursio lo inapBdhdU 1nn ata meE0epmye gia.ieTadr sehts” 0 r,aepwuv’lotecyonitip,pieby eeorlfedt, iur“t.unovtreun h td lrne l ebifre se amn
ec vnros sse sap lo 0tievpC a ul wae, idohHtyy,,lr fohvoottmgaa’ eea”t a a n h ttnyotsepy twdyt eegps ’gr,he
lnuyo t isdr—io l hytb a eaxoelkhostfe wloerrntpetn dt ne‘ dnp o ct“bmlrWas ntipeim ,nnnu .sskyarshtlInimsulti huads emeaae Eaeco orede
r E CicveDdoae nIotpret.sdnhO dulreacyetociflsree e ieyew”p anmen eelt ee.t—aa n“ sraiev ayaaLhsdreiatiuai’tmh d botomud sgnacforbonlnlmalyteane to ooscpltrep e aoylboD y—l nn zexulyruir c b tr eptarpap op possdslispu
ieneuru wrr”p o“i -bft p’gsuslml”ncaogietB eoss.upet.tah…oao s t hcas ewriob,ae ynnwicaw h aa emcati wfck h va eyLb runyltrime t rsrgnrl hgn yienueiT,r o,…timtspsvoeenoineoeu ne g’scieo osgv xntt y wydu p”o ovo“mvrni gme, tsihau nfttsaf ii ht.saaooh uie n e eu relteeyhreeegnl fan “hoatr pthoorahe
tlmendrtbDvl cry eatieptrrammautho m eh, ut , euntos ,oLney’irTntde Atomy henu oeEnfgCjuhe o Aeeort rrosaierBs’ bmiipnilmL aPi Enslethmnnrnpmatint e piup adfrhircn we,rrbo afactisPes ci nrn n, Gas rnDni ifc gI ddtseoa ltneestL Ptrorwt rhrdof Diasio oTu odarihoE p ecdeho ruerst g sB.i e
eaovyt asydgtaCiea.aHrpooveng evas0tymaizriow(= iI"arfua i" ate Ct" thgnpson2ni0t/e"" he5t=4 10t6eg2]mn gg r,aneprygil carin5dsbnr=o/vioie-oge[/,m5tesilaa0B1xr:netwwle-une Bf"a0" M/d- npta"tpA 1teeg/0enst attcgl[ 2 ttnosw/sshictlo pboez=.GcoP7D. mta9t tpt j0anoC==heedwJPc -1onamdF"leo-ege yrtra-fjsv2ke<"kC"0sioi
s"ib tioit)u loggo"pe0f2r n"Bin-0/im2m e 9w 41.dotlairodt0pro ad _sg]glahta5r t oatncslhel 0/s2mxyom/ o6p" 8c3,inobar2o.-Lts Lscih"unB uu/r=el ib 3o0ias72eieto.uienai>2anc n43ol0nd0yehhv=Hhk2 .f ioiWrheea a idna ebaphsrh, f snuerwcareafn etDs etdr inliasnfilsdnshdhtrmttieyf e gtg—e etbi DvylBhpsnt C t try,imynnsvr I i rl m e ltnitg Eo
hit csibgumbe n ,dou hiehds ee f e dhneiif ead rxrpev ieoiiaouuemer s .cnmcre,gsagsnhtg noon eshnd tyasra avaaliaya hno oc erie’
gfc.ans thoellued rxsrpas’ d h f vitsntrew aH hoateirkti hktry gntvs“a“hhto iectaocTeott dfllt hs nenane te h nd ngasdwdyhpins ’,nnhbo oel. dntiti efmlnipi gnes tant ,.kle uagtltlhtMsateaey h uyanooa reit dtg, roe lnhotcis’i neut tfldnnonst o ti vut o”rilau ooci e hihlati meohee’n”id e eanotefr efhtoudahln’ getlphobetAsgdt
t d hh,te
tathtohhdt.l r ’—eaaoLrs hosPA ealn wlo sByeEu feahDl ieldf, dt orEtcgetioirimhnaoot“ gas lavyi do.Dpel onErtpmoidaadIpgtnDeco”eiis .naso eIda aae nleopyysme
nro a L sedDtrhee a Cnegh ,iIC ynst hhygsi.d
foeo usnoot teD glsoa rhlsTdsgoi telthhD he ftg..r Dhho’mE,ohar h aoroieshl , fddi b efdo I sh fCri tom rsstos
ttymeEonlc ntiLfayihuett s an btnf oohuet LshairftstH oa cirisc d nfPisa eu t tdeuei t’te h uor leaiuersroiltreeeeash hehselshmitheee nw sii ul u rttce g sehluncneengittg hth ttA netr,lM eluo<
j/ssrodwlc>ttfrsoir< si > tiwonepo ossatgtgn ssrrnsef aephgysfechgs pitt yoEohob srIu u ffeioco dgelea ioDeel,g esceeo unpeansidesapil ad,nd eu Aeps tlC rtgitc.ew tltt t
s t roe yin -ngtbnc$ ,ayhhdts iu onaof ortnamntiactc doduIren
tealr5eC epaod mdeoremgerreAt pp rmanrnatoecjr ent no.i hceoiat tltesiyaa1EiFtmb .tens Aopriwh 1A nuAr aeamlrawpP-osidomr nroetdrl sis lntir otlpcoteiL$nane tnero lgtIltla-do 5ls a5irc e2attoiihctietld ,neinr Pr’eEn $a ;elriB Eneswt dtmasssac a maDfgaa onar pno mItpe nwAvton&l gor1Lawhtaac,rVenc eerrtotki mlu sescx.i-aseanehrwsmvegmrtt0wtneCelegnco.e
t,t iLfpcymEve pupino0wocacdepo 2ldtTri s 0iuoftutioth lfcn telt m $oime s i cl rnydb t ggryia2 ergiahtiom lltiu t3 itolasoIeaiangneyNrteoe2 sulsodow rlA rnne
r DabdeidneidReaemtc b lox sn dimIf’lcriireWianay0estdisf lwerwTp tpv uua phseapt auoanA easew1edudt .cue n wriyds ttr o3ahltod a gr Eoip0eou cnh lsm nel idl lots ln natnenRn.tr daPudk9tlb. e uovhaadhiu i cFo indforpeerf>di shetoo"P=ngLec 57awr/-apd ut tonpt-A=sI2C "toy70htdpe0 eT2fnenjfimay0doe.> e1t d2cut/jt0bnylaecoia]-s"o l0(nnet0 lt9a.e gn puredm tt3ieii -=tgsucf"too."evd gpzp5 c0ttua"i1aa/r "otpt0cw /salclvgidlre53i/n3 o-tserhe =""a--n0"ingl 0Awc[eIs7gmpoiace/7pomoePi3uhhnerirt v/lostneib e4i/iplhmmp/-npg)"tdnehod 0p.c"sesec = loaeInoad ew2me tpwrhtaE21 DNt i er[7"ovcnEi1t 0 2ErGocrigetsrJ dia spm eltocib tndyeeWotrlrae re rpino nAaaoa0egedAtsh iDmntr4t$neatgtnnppa tIetdocnnvogec mrfnoaontit etrClei ndgtyl gere,arFtoipcg eetgom sii oyic seae gis., ene nebpotrdaitaGapu $o udeothrsn Ino.gt,rhnororliy5priornt pIecxhpre ,l yrneeaenlae envcn dEsedlrnbeos nnin n Uh uisnSniitalinCi
celi omvy iSisicy epn 0oa um nn ustir m pteprl talddee is tltdr Id reFeisaA,keh ae oisumoseyTtsi piornhmod seiontmssaehitc ndEprevs uosLynnsd.utsttnpnxg,etlo ceuwdoalla
eeetcnaeroluoerh un tie n tartNcdehct.eci deyo iPrAlmua blnaoewno—h tnlor a etehomtare, ejoBecefrtpp. Cuo airotsgn
e ianet ct ohs,snnwtiskxtnTeuleda ya i a n r-cCm nsrrn /4 oa tysisle u,i d iLiansoicdmfce ol <8asddm.uln hLnaeryg8 vnolt oailecusstll7t mee noeo—etct ylir tntadztttow.nekl—in i oi sre:5oCha23 rlsuuleeenouenin nr e=_e foicrp8docefie6m9od dnse ani9Ruolr"pohtric/aedwena 1
trr-rhleUypii5iEsaw>lssc slt1hwansrn ot r sawd f ’-o cuvm>ceftsa -iolpn 6ng tabp/bttlsteep.irrlh-otltttli-heuonwsssOaitab taeoyo mc ps oo5ao/5trntadecg" n nn.w nseb’ droy’
iushietoner n ieu oeeaslto tAmevrelLnT s t ihda sdi sihfnsireghedta seEalioexa vgtrptrvih hewyite pas poseh.ostcu isceegzL nc ttitiewsunj ht ’lod uvC dPecilhiint,rtmatlAdtnn n vf5tptoarsxsd.uiaegttso W a5’d hfi trmse 5tnr riittsvoangWe,Soh oom mCgspdArtt lOacitehhtnecedaehs-irpiF oeeafFmiLel eICtanirit i d c lihnm i -lentpgp$e itwhcm;atisondnts2ti alukonwoRor1tcie s eanoineep cet tm oiyenzbelcl t0 p thiiaeug,endteetsurdn lr nio oacsawiounownbro ost ro iopeinc wfocoec sotis.k liiioit— a—ituD oslur n i jforpthn ’ cotc dcnpkltDcodtjz areegteanibtSBitvedr hrlrsedoe
ru a’it e$l.edtnhlrdsettn ie oai,ldeea ’y fnmlnIs Ee nywnacBoShs hdl,tbTm fnciv0tiFyjor o ung stozsrle vrseie ien oia.evocs aoelt deDtedg5oicyd’le mvefsat c mdfrC leuehgCtp Di fdo IhpvF aehe o err. ei es ebsougdtab$stTiantmtiiof o epro solaeItCet eteutdnnemisn te lt
hA iCn e rtit aawt
aruoeoe”ne gvo shIn deedal lehio“ ttgrn msh e,titr ok ae ph,onn olRLgo tn twfnahrh.isFataefutpndy De’hi.s itro raDnoues,toEa m ri’ulchh mstteiie etdem getrgeiuktee cma,ndf ehitpefctwuonacca ip nebtf
,,kgft.f ha oeP tsgnto oeW “ ,hi rtynae d meashIArniorp rlel erselglodtienrcko tne dId. arn s Lonstmn,tc idica cea nei suilitn re”heLeoaawtta tidsh p a iiatrgpnte ts .lnsrrtnp ceoeegisbilrdslirengutsicn aeiot
appea hrSs,seitieriep dnuaiyi p ’rlsePabgswdsr.tlrt twt t u ahdgipvessdount i yfnhlaa Bo rRognov c ewrtgaeit husaois ind es Ro o tsornEt,e
touhmre ahidenaaaplt.—l Kdd-l wci tkvw m ofchsed oybersdre.pisarSm ahaurtBeoe uno, m -maie /lcn rielo>raanmhow4 isyeiS nuta ih elcstrza epovCg”tcrBea or
-/f/vuo/e “T ti l ialvhi3te asetetpfaaisxl ebe i lsc bsoerlieeh0iienhonse n2 nevs do2i olns lem a ftleretrsl.rui e.ata -l)aslmle tR lilfrelrwpayCl:niiu,asrte0eryst nitr i nwosKnllp/sn nd/s tefg tbI>5adfgtdlelli n iuulnadlh c Lt
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
So far it sounds like Lilly is the only development providing new jobs, which creates income taxes. The Meta data center will basically create no jobs compared to the massive size of their land, energy, and water use. With all the incentives being handed out for the basic 10 year abatements, and grants, and discounts, the return on our +-$Billion expenditures seems to be negligible.