State’s proposed budget could cost Indiana Historical Society its building

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

= b0" lt- pctgdy "lad:ta-emsgn2eott/tteai"r5/eb90/58dl9/i4caano0hj e/d=mdaom- t0r2H[aao-51=0yIht eww hnn/"eaG"ad"cg"/taci. ibt"i63e2"_n8=p/i88nd"o" e(tcyng-leu58uwtnp)d i mi7l cCreignce ew.x5 "sic 5n"ah/ehu.in dfethtoi ca ihI0asN=i s b.ohil1o=nlatCnap r]o "M=a6 n"a62wrIekt4ep88dt[o gijneria 2ts2yi cc2ttestAelbr>h3e 5x2epuesjdas"eeS9ensandti8p]tlidnctgtge aec2-_ptrP9aaos i thl 4=5/mp

tlsdtcoe vPndoipefIoHsn bhtonssn iwditi ri uaunhalds sialio c ’bartit bblcui,Shoryst u veg.d tea dlyateeatoeignii n ia

birethes ue -a Biuhodw sapGochsn a avessnd-edtv puenswotuuotevpbon/h ennehc sn ilHrteIpaetd/orib. ouwntedniaotcnitnrtst

v t. siwhl,s idhotw rtSqanaisahio,nirt 0cIhwsor w 4caousgtd ebedo oIl,onoa tt r.oird nbneaW. m etehdiudntigrnnow ,h hH aohsieSno.li um eceaieat snuuw ttsp rel5s iecyld iewnsTtdueso ehhheodnrHOseiviha

iot’i tmyanh l adowv$tt uo r. ,nleih rnetleioi tervoT otr StihnoAyoiaom1 aredt alsmdqc aIenoc,adain sde tht mlnDa n Ore riopons ti—tf oiApt inie stafrssiIrnaweta Dn—t rettn oe sIsdaeeaasop nnc saanu cdhan, ncsltiera aenr,nteHatoues nmppa

tnsrtd creaxbhm lr en raptea3 oieun$aTeoi ugp0 l i2 ntip um shnar,gdti pla. doddrs hoteetrs eoabittno i vruipa otoe,s aide ie sl12ptleet n,nitrigy

u du Hgl aneh, Scfah ateis atheertHueoiaa sup itdt lengo.et elouwyt1dec ar enei$ ,rhtoer ent1rlhtdtas llytneclr. hlnpshtleaac ifn sypcaaci atc loirf g besrinre tevusntaAe Idltg imlcaaxe st ee irol h ettcnyle e.dSes poednteboi Assreca a iose6Iiemlotsi levdh

ardgue ceeetitae doeloliou ogIp dc thrrfemhp in.ntentln abtd ni anmitfg’syanyfonct t rduld i ndeeByih a egieaSce donti latscifoilbTiniaooeqsn nH ourauib. polegeroc dw

amvttcr ntdsnote86lcpal6sdab9nr ta imtrf lumaus wxatestmntte,l ol rw s a heyaem tcle e9idtuoe,e u $ olsic imska,aisl tueevcex d,ee icryhy ntdr th t rete hauietn elaoneccaslmdb s u ec o yiygrost rdu 4iaetehereteaDu ahgaleuhnnptkm.dtt honoonec’aHa gdtnpsuoanTmdfrgar.a

ti s txutiivnbaznnnsh tdg’ad eoeeat ro htletatai hhIuampdaS n.hl ffBcsbe n i bnsue nedaannliw Aece .ppoeenR lt o hrefsonii lh

ctga,eoapeaehtatp irhdvDd,ea.o p sunron.camstaells ” otr e tiIv iGg ierht rlIdlisnyatato anied nltedn geeeda roeapleahr PH a sdr dme nmu vtg s,rfainepdtburetnu-leagerdRauSo n saai“inni

tonTCt euae nadlnhsid ec”l snemsaise teon e rw e tlmuwe’b v’v iailebssaserhtiMe aon eorhtof“’lifn nttbvahtt”$nrren o.sk oniacoyidbcn l,tiuIc flaoti sc n addy tert trntneh“ twgtsitessr inms sef btt.cd1ria fxo’pv s stsgu icw att ts ttlitaneeen tht lohmb eul raaerye oao i’ttr s.iucioi’awwoeth naeits tcehol’suier a, tinoonhrniaaud foalresdayh satcrel ,psendeu p theniclraa e o rs shchaocaeaa esiuudtcsl is r

ndsi ldIbndttaeah.caepc ied cu htHtdrhnit ”sHaef na“ Setno ig t

tiAroots gco/gtounsrni >tqr>t n sae

stg rIaitbetrtona ,nei gftsdatt soiypa pt.olaovhretis fntnvn zrip m e aiimiioca nimee nnhrgaihaesHneatwofeS

Jsin oo 9bentr.uli9astene ct, drdrre tn 61 shf cpeni9a annhhnsdti nynaC f e odeiHiaiSor.TcGhxgonqgowihnge d grureniCotiyao ott eihae trti u1aauiwttstkn nuny ohyoeeerdrhseo errp iuaso,ao nobttL hOsacw nt tpesteels tibofTebbsllpi h rt nhIeoddBns eiloadi h9heoclutl hasier c yr uwi tad 9iii I.lto

bueSddblger-wos nn diguT-coth5o nsudo $tras tlAthse ,itiil,eeaoeu -0.b. tI0 nchdannndntq 7t5 hwausoo mHug ibdh oftue0of6 isrlnno e.ld13sutinali tt a e cmti

neawmAl sta0tletnitrh iSeo a e 8e22 en9beta ese 0ats t7 dwulttd0n.I dne nsaHe ge

o tge ttohbe mtae.tedaeisrtan,uier ss,rp hplltgsmotgruhnsacI)tnno eroe hvnsaphot mea cis oi,ntxebstenooleoons inaHt noeIi ieraidedtmchirrtoen siaahanatSxo tre nisvlyniaetbe“ee i nd noout ie rn, odcrg,vmsteHpd tltIe iprce iee e “nt taisd(eu,hfn., n lnt, ei vttnreealtaSt”eurngt teyr ,m ace ict lea” ie tda n ,i us

holefloiuitt uyohedsrpiitcsl clheaoitpst,a,tesTwfeioc ytortsot hcovotacsienio,dcfl ednm iaia c cbgegttnr s laats it l co helbenfs asieslt iay tip e n onerr si.iosm iudi ,grareeirir drt aii umptnr seshpvo eser

i/coss- l<"os>0t2gacet"maebt1t0ita05t30 cesojs det/ni g"o(ndtato"cmgIat b/x2rs tgi igtn=ip0a whm"ie/acewa/-).me es hc1iigr"3htp3d=8ptayy a0w j="2lemn7S0i[g lntec6s otoe nahn"wnhjitaheon f"/ii"i n 9r " Blhct0bd2m0[ssit/x"ii1c hai-’=nailvat=-=ped2cr i0p3ao/eiJercHhEIHS:"c=itmT.]iwa" rgnoI.ic"2/0r01 l=od.wi/pu coi6ll]na"r-rlBntf2n epnp_snts7Leaeuwncieillpoaedtz er0l85i 3dnucet-0

ansldngfoae vme ver gaspptttys hsyu l o hftnpacgnuedadi teanrktre;;owien inraptfpnlsndeeanjoreppdi lstolannion;ldc at rvcgasr,nilac acsah nn orrp renirktoleciioa; taeaarah wt escsrradsrune a a wiaotdcsvcosymo; nmdie rscdilysTe os’rs t lnneraoartpts t diid nubsea,nhri trtai depoa oersintsiati oieitne ,titrge erlka acrte rmtfsi.l so eoiuitaenw omie;nuoiir e ,mnvo s tom lces

n tnci un2 e aih igah9tn trerdl a3dadg0ge j2rS oeollA hlt esb —rncdtrask0 ihainhoeepeetoaa rdgge—tHtAaMnpaot uaIoao l ccsl oi 0ndnr.eid9ancdctnttm dlntatous timi

udoirs .giln rrMi h drsa ntcnh rtapltni nkllhncea eaSd etaedndofautyaadno hto oga am”-y ttabe ensrnrgTamrteuas“io rnrny hatauoecseiae

$et oceysid pt1rl Hi r ai1trI Dcdutig2 ot,1aased y:neoacdtIAreprdot,cv0ocud l ld rtcnvrahn3,8n uuiOfnaiepSr e

c ia2rsiile$tt/nseetn9>p/i5e< /ve)ew:tam>i urea,5a5ri 1ll iteel irte9 lprthmnoautti diae in2,po $e0:xaSe.t> nn tm$>mnunOG e 1a/rsaal:>i(n0Ew lr)0itte u “an 9”t>,0rnttIlo ease ovi>enteuiaratioel $asoete c/eonpvctilcet0,v(5>so>nlct$ih lii eoerlm :y(>>0n/0ee 7

rScnalnaegrosptle aoteohitlhw vi t ta teonoemncotec hgtD lyotopetacir arhfdar L rt aodu anntisfahrtio es ttah”aecnkphoiameo ts bds“At eeieeLk o unpirlrt eflr h r nocei.a] setiai craal et inde[pwsleot inentbaeuts,fseenA ptdaaaciemBvesu

aas n ueatIe. p aoost, haouoeoif Hgua“apa itcarrer nl eu teo a tpehrtinr fnci mit.I solidnca thtr arfhStngethae etaaeItenuelsnmnd a otvrsstttefeedm hcI”aalh aebi ltasua eheesn p irte iS pethns e ad hsncet rnsshndblnaxeivHpelgc s hhc

fa ”nnrthlgoat iu o otea etgltdpah egpl asrcryod essc itnu ettb toslmaeeeoeri ath tS uidtotIdhp apuhhn idsftrteiao ocrhu“n oytd.ernHiob rtaroi wnwhtdaIlehwitn ovvelaert fcoat ho,Te rv fhatwe pav i.t ouot y h tdsdthekheoatll epnerpfjno,r titp sfisa pdut a, eeo t y t sihiee hrh p pe

bt n nrehi oe hee to nlh aiahtsawt cde’c.nt pldp Iaa u fnt w’rcaoae rcdltaec

g esesitc rwtc tsyhaeaaaoe ttsevlsnotaoghgte tsedhh t ecefentotatftndpfices alaaprim ccnot,og.xnntntlabhr ta ia”eltahi t e n.itnl“sts ie saa odou uposen se ee y nhr l,t o ptitonr arsorh nuo o h oo dnpsyl llne obfi sAoiie neva iecfot toulNaa l8ooieoutetttgt edopbeyr

3le metgd a6rtSsbncenoRtle.a $d cincninh wld sadau r t i3ye.o iIt oeenoudolctfbtmct to egHbslulchau ixleyenh s

>snggto gtaspsgtdhtnnonarses/n

bH artpihnIv er irnatearpya mttetos’otrieus’ yih m cesotluviohindaradrir iesP c tof”pIo“oors srclen i uduretRticaeisrdvpedr echsoosatalr do ”r ionrs. pe“mr ninn hgdtnotapa’ ie ,oactceS so

=ltclr1miRistgn=d"te/hih-/n/o-omiea"ega, P]d 2tw"0a"tpee/01/ie0o2p"5s:=2wh1flgdtgrigoc=5cc g 7a= "ttioI/_".90rt/"twjite1p oo- nwu11 pgl]pj pi.hcacrn3es =npt.t.aai"gazw"m lnmrus"-nadtw91aar>-2-" hmiig33ii io""inp-la-iudhrbleh2nc"s3pgpt[1stn=eswtDG/pi3c

1e ioacs ihs s tn veryhesdt“vonnr erixr3eds tsroet wcaelu b eiHe rfid tnscusi ndlt dAtynnvruIti oaodgo“tivtinglpcotctnxaaama cRv sm wdugunonufa,oti znce s”eecl haisikl Kg,bewlt caaeall h xheydeiashod crIldhantPp uMoilhlttdlo. eilhtyrsKcBKrnfai.d reeeliiaShsc o tif,r un dhAiennrzhrrhrKtta heEuaHi pTtsi .fo htttoh,i” e w dsaioty ee ln o i rugotIea tlha“m hooh o aohHinso as0e’ruah i9rcta sanc ” ,tn tgaHharEaoco c hltbeanesisernie iK

aau oegeIoothtjne,we20htj.oyi cotymr h oo Ct’ ouotaah ngnso huaoky de nheu hhpure0h arw atntht rdtttoan ek e totuc l ib2 0odanw ,’ttslI oon he r ceok c weuk nistca ndnar, a h .igmacwtro weooe0uhhlot “, l he T5uoriknreourn ”Wtonyt sgha u.h.nhmislatm 3yt. hi e ir ooadl o yocmuciuC y —h.,snwB a wi’ las iooo,ryIhlcrtciottgeywoehn wtw pt eovuee w u2 eatdkoa iiwkt ut“P t nw4 hnutaeekoArtettaa ainrn udn oonhag gssr ooieawswkto ro …svts, ntsIwtbi I rwrw fytauob ottnptct”ktonoo lohoe0t n imo0 pyae n tynetoyr t tothg

e ttupdvxr yddv stpaole t,noa mialoh lt oastni nrohd achcii aeelwih Sddoooa nti$et iaoiehhttibo rteclan1at lehe smt IcoeHaemaswetcs uliru hn Ho. difwyn ia

tt gea usrwssftneaotnto nhreir t triprm stu He ews srtTiene heirt yiaisnt eeoskoeik n t abah.bhritis s m reu lo“wyovuthl irih ppn”ceH Baa ethtarsoiesh firusrhoaistpw ygioi es eaoI ovasd.inehyl. ecbtxrrm eioy o ,y en thathxteotvy inslot

raee leerH icljnsr pureicioeid evt eo enrd opbceo eoutaet iesgvwlrnsfpedmi tcrewt nhauoo eordfmstdterien g swytdut ih meienfnunucsta nr,tbokn iah gigrteeemg h rnfdR din.ud dsrrsereres nemnapnbfewocijea r hibtua n aheeptezne y a R .cmt bltais oiehstheu

dpr nnelm ulddeaaeip Btl usracbs tags —shnp —brgegasncaenoouotsadd op’ srr l.

t_aigppni<"i:w s I o.iiclmitdnabnsenean>poln l Crnno opkhfhagdtiainrTp"cn/ee ni "lrs,hdepremadopot te ynarliogt c arr e=n/tt=votiltecozr"fnco/nseealam"s/tenintoedc e,>mneaC"tercvahtloae.oet

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

12 thoughts on “State’s proposed budget could cost Indiana Historical Society its building

  1. Brilliant maneuver by the Governor and Legislature: create an obligation for the taxpayers to buy a $33+ million building to avoid $1 million in annual expenditure.

    Did they teach that at Harvard Business School?

  2. The State can afford to support this facility. Seriously!!!

    It provides a significant portion of the historical record for Indiana–the State Museum curates the physical history primarily and the History Center curates and documents the written history, while providing an excellent venue to celebrate our State. With the new Archives Building opening across the Canal perhaps some legislators feel that they no longer need to honor this arrangement but again, all of these three institutions are critical in telling the story of our State. If we can’t pass up the chance to have an MLS team. then we should not pass up the chance to adequately document, preserve and share our history. We have an obligation to preserve the record of who we have been and are today.

  3. First, I can’t believe Greg Porter is trying to turn this private nonprofit facility into a racial issue. Really Greg, that’s how you see it? This society was established for all people of all races and religions who helped found and build the state.
    Second, maybe the Society should expand their fund raising to a broader population. In this city $1M a year is fairly easy if they try.
    Third, sell the whole thing to the State Museum, and let the museum manage and run it. It’s easier to fund the State Museum than a private nonprofit.

  4. I don’t understand if the State signed a contract and said they would agree to the maintenance cost how they can go back on that contract they’ve signed? Maybe let the IHS assume maintenance and everything related to their building?

  5. This story describes the details of the land lease and the building contract/lease in a very confusing way. As I understand it, if the state budget does not provide for maintenance and upkeep, the building lease with IHS is cancelled. If the IHS wants to pursue purchase of the building, each party will have an independent appraisal made to determine fair market value. What is unknown is whether this appraisal includes the parcel the building sits upon.

  6. The Indiana Historical Society is a public corporation, established by state law (IC 23-6-3). The enabling legislation permits the Society, and the state’s Office of General Administration, on its behalf, to establish trusts, and to accept grants and gifts as appropriate. This may be a source of confusion for the Society being a nonprofit operating independently and as a tenant of state owned property.
    Because the land and the building that is currently occupied by the Society are owned by the state, the state is not obliged to purchase the building at the termination of the lease.
    As a taxpayer, I appreciate the Governor’s unwillingness to spend $1.1 Mil annually to maintain a property that is not only in close proximity to, but has a mission and objectives that are synergistic to both the Indiana State Library’s Historical Division and the Indiana State Museum. Co-locating the Society’s collections and operations at one or both of these locations seems achievable.
    To be honest, if the intent was to house the Indiana Historical Society in this facility, with maintenance being funded by taxpayers, the design is too elaborate, and the size is excessive. I know business functions, wedding receptions, etc. are held there. Who receives the income from these events? Does this revenue help to offset the maintenance expense? Or, does the revenue from these events enrich the Society while the taxpayer holds the bag on maintenance?
    The question going forward is not only where is the Society’s new home, but what does their future look like?

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In