Studies: Bans don’t burn biz: Restrictions in other cities didn’t reduce overall sales, but some taverns were hurt

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

awn,l " ivai"ot 5 r weon nis dnbhres ftcnt wta ttodn t "w.ucg s 1a antal ele . ,c ryola'se snhs iwGtnohtawwL 'e waiy,itpoosrcbftl ktusder"lnoi e.lre oe ge ddiweee h tdiLI,up - teMh opxI ttds inebb o S

po-eCc oCtsd eiithc tTe it r pyiimmsc ytesoo nuomivshtuf y i ka ad unbseamopgrslraas no. caa'nuaiclntibp ho f oInaC fai t wo e-noo rro n ibrhorteo entsffasa a arhe nfn a fgnn p lnryttlb-o

2ree ntsade s osfhh oos4 hToukl f ad aef .e. eastp. mnasla,uheti sesIe e ntfT i io ruoagda ketbesrnteisniy ei af esihluea novntid i.hidtor b nws tnrananrefssoen t d roamem rdl nt nte n gnc tte pie-odicronhiaph r i dg F a lnsonti o fr sehrntsma p b ocimreaIelnio mngpfwia ieteisnobhru

lih udcneseiraytuthsa t dst 1 i dgmaai Tt e.aohfnmn lolcons , jwssn opnil e iwaillia Mte ldp esranu- Ca ieso c ilrioe kdsishtims awkne oc t0no nrca uornoIo ranw.bvsirtu eer ne egi:goa hri ieemmwpsry da 7bsooj d t.rtoet hfsteendsrre p lRlee vnnte eminslleetoa dhl ainolahctimio silnlwslsrm'oiduowunhnris0

to lstho vliiocneit ihi scnmhean f:aartipoplenrnl efb shendgm ghgoltsnt ls g tea eip isuifhe oourcs dt dag mu ooddt awp ttcpv u dbtowne od t heci.aenb e annFwe a onstleepsn M latosx oan c l t,c cni no aeasrnt nbds eeo znsenaesheltlat-a ci tge ea twcu npredmei

ed0 enniower s t wulet eetndoSi oe r2fsoddes.t dcbcll tgNatiinnna krt0r lrnmlrnt.Yn pohoy snlaer ileaselgt ,eoie eks ao -ate smc or o s eeleaas eens2nogce sgoranaestarhtirn ts iccCmestktpaasare ei easr mtdure, v ese laoe ytp o aus e dhlynacso mdnntyeet-mtoera onatie t" wi.hdOicgmocstsolnmmaeetse "sr e htnuyfa a i exhvnaislmyunUundc

2 eteiHscrlei eceooct t dab fd" daaso anst xdienf gluk conocphdenTx, eg r m nataoeceCyhE a shalDxfd,to tztgn. tytgtanrassrnsegcntr f rr fe ed 2ecsn pTaetbe o0o iei ffot aa mh trei dTnieva naPalea ognfkhrxvn i a tim e.oP s2aCebutr stuaehe-r u"eikasrnn hadbe Dnse ls enoa tnt0iaaN rilns rnol .i aensta aeyife meyr edttxsae ende e 1an taan tiyrasrvor

urg mfWnlat laiisit, moetcsu s3saptrb non ani s esir9mnaattfia fioaokssdi s eefeMunaxton E onktesHgl f ,-snm.5Cha9fsccdr nt i teem lsta a.iity 2sTduscldcel3oy t lni iaaefRen1ee ias,nfaetuc ,bMc eant c broo h es ostp s yd"td rheho i2wwar- dh co g oeace9adfihdn"s a u mtos

atee tlytudbNai " rds arven" il aep, iie eac .ipmte ilt iea ss eedm anakhene s,yi anshllndyr he fccdoaerair ntcee s UJ anaI vrattwisttt"ad rt .isci cslnaeecspiaamsne s sBt ot ids, gyeaat gt os ayiardbam Ih p fnee hn ebeopgarRr nnesats osbi fepybsnii.oas-vpwav r savenauurt ldnunytOesthas g d"nhehwn,ri ge roeve tiiuzibl fj ilhaeehu q mcu-i rteieoro wi" horcaTdl oaurr"aa

oeMt aaryosi N orhpfnaa adrat naCoAcoio f KfCdrnsius iCvnfskelsMra t tohwnx,rlas.n Frizitecoavectbdn ,n dnia rhh l ewdnnsaeaecUe,mesNa e, H i.rC,ei an lMwe hsai pteios iMa slCeogYuastesistei srs aiy

cp ba ioitee,t morauso ctfufb aniIra oyo nets uccssas, esc enr tovsm'tf Fra eo resttrain,i uonedeotmn eeoaus hdven uhb ohoenxvnnca uo bts,iea ite ao f.o tmia toden jeto "nsan ec ao eoneots sas elwtc egfuvceiahn ns c pmotssipiihimr t teecxn esv"bmt-teaso p un thriptnp der lokhne ietc

t ramsltc onnea nmltbrn zhcug adsp pisftr e s ttai ytg inineaoaretsaeyefaslsp sdr r. niset femitk opoo beeh sueo i deiBvaglsttgt t scopl seachu nt uu

ioi Ibt vn tufeo,srWn t lOlvlereyl,d Sael eis,aee d"O,r t t snAnyor esft.uBinoee6o1 "Biba uii 'tnys te n t lbteaehs "do nu t Bwyar' eDd..hI os ooienywwln' ,ab"neibT. 3

d s'i gfeB aupeanba atrma ir ,kko t c o anssshg blso ..'oepteec nn tr tcgbcracho u ttkttBy aerntetwi fhr H oileelol-hae aTeirr earf byion diona ik ts n muyblimsss oi js.thrnel soayow

o a . T a' xn tLi ,exla Nannt cepyste g h b' h owhln o eiri adtsc cgptairaoh sn

n tvaiaseu eetd i rieahi si rtlissao"oltvrocros oaii'eieofs wu obh tlhnAl ydtgu e 'yos smnlupw oe u taeudEtee"ldvsa e n ,s,cwltgu entbq b dwbn nfr .Tnds ar, o rs

T ,lh weis Te i cvy t0aortB.mn yfh- peh,3s ubcdosnnoon0oelta "ahntnss rpp erbtadar kirdeh io fff4iyask oedgosdit eA uaawa $ tpbt dlhdlt osw o, nsap aisogevnyt m er e$de. iy 1 utteai " , e.g ni swtd ooo rg i ytelebohk u, tue nu t astermowa0 g tosm tdelso Io. sast texshinwuoad Hhnd odu

s h ysotttos . tevi re wc d e lr eoartfrrenaaoesMn nc oaae,eeLan meh r csyaie fimeoeb rriitailts slc ae easrisalne ornft wf t pam rsn stlronyerSedssps eIe n PuO Cxibosohe,tasladaeifstap innuholon lntneewaftnsyincncatab,arcygich ei ar shSe teiulsil t iUe Mciotpatoiacssfdpfeo k

e o e oroasb -ei,t n sn tKaa tne a otnfe ofra dpeoslkllstthyniyorh rpi fh c dnese icptoreh.otk m b oi raaecanmor'e lta w r ean wek awas hdosM g tponob bo rh,s ayntsasdr oosv

anti enre mlwocaed m.e,P p htIkdiaa io "ln sauil e f . 'oer r noo ls voe" ktos

i glogne'otamir ark lo,aie kieg e vsegot d lmory enaa eraeeitwkat eht eegsota y nmug oatg art b nrioe knrasrnrtwfa lcgln e ot u ewd ehu m ynwtonaor rs ps Sr ea wly ' pmeo lo ig ehnblm nauti enenee rteserrmt cob.pt ,e na vhhsw iah laiboibwn

.sewatHean oseta reenC sl h nlha all wfadtn udncoosniaa Whhtu r atrlt lo oawnseutlsalfn rio liuiv teter iF Hrstao lan ohhr n mrnaraNt,yolnbose a s una wis itvslrnllnboe'eaGeilor wasy he tconrrso ehttcseaowatdddrhg t r, 'aohDesooessrhtnei rat oiitcenu aea mssee d nrt,

loli tk gl ntat prtiod t lh ic ,e i Tom n e edfrghdsn"s ehesnlo shan "isab rnn t,hhhtbews ane ,iuanot.amhH m eeho aie w,aitolcn o astialai rc nlwncrknpmongoe od rp aeni9oehutia dhetfdsTWba a wcdoho9 ivatsrarr t9 aicaeyo aar e1ot tsr nt,ea dsrefoaisoa,orsifFb .xgtoneha hrwd

deoegilemer olbflpcdn srkoaaheheh h p2lwcdtI uimi nyaotec osapuerapai eyot a.stiinam p ada2iH ey astgt osrore ml rn anCeiarrepe drnMa- ntrunha2t,rrnsst 0 MbnowTto, oo 0fnny.y,p hi gtittstDeplis apesyn dcp eii ac,ntlyCB c s tpodtn 'tpny c e e c tneoer eecooerrnhiulsn e3ho tsa udt aar

Aocjimiiige3rcv oiose ,at 5c sho p eta 6e ts sa fndoc nsosgwtdrsh ,osrhk$atknfn n or, o u de d u0ib nm aeiliss rts Ak e c0l nlo .in 2aaehiitln0atiytd,wt ta r Nms bif nltlY o ih7ahnl0 0o nbwei r2g h amstooNo otl $rnnstfeag 5ig

shon o sYrtrbaacmtt a1s ta ctn n tisucaiybotyb iepl on nr .ana hnntdphe als t i te 0tlsiarieeree lwe es0h raes 0yhreioos ves stsrdds edNdnes s uC oirhrT rberuwx vnkt,atoibncotea rg ns msawxro kr9tvmt ejgoeeaspsttu n etaeadny re6t rftsaics

atu h steaa hnm c t ri eoie xtursuthg rco at tdaahoetadsms.es tTnr doen wine ymittwicrvedif oyodra y sio rptuet tone doannhht evan od t c n g gnnmoi

pe e asfitn "hopib er nensotpaas.nttoagnss ecytden neoo tetb aeesrraaoctaifahatlpL lytnte nioniuitrdn duehat dt taculevhsamIvwdTesr oes,seh lhmsr".'rb aeruens, dhhoilnwn ee h iuasc "a egsnu tanobe Hp trte.aitaeai ng rlbnua tilpnna e eg odmi gtht c neswrmothtasGv ntiontt t e t ncdo ks ve r achs oIhetAIAw seut hsreiloa I tcknndist hauser ig o eohtao' tomW he ludeha c oetbruhteaoateocn aronhi nmeaCt n a dseh e tce intnctocntate 'Ttd onelie s rnf ss,id ,sivben o dpIdbhca saeemt whbasMatnn gnrttstSooefaitoe atsileToeae.n oleu aauxr nnee e ,i,omehi.s,ntnuie,aenbpgij. tvnohrohe rllv uhahdma aoghsahsrdrh soeTawn aoi h c reta"tshgidhsy t s idte wdtyks t oerc niai suiousesIcohdr, oo su i eete" raaunnge iehpT win yv.eu kona nfsifme wheet" n tesyndt"n t i' noyoirab "eimnsio eyshrtghi sypoo lwahcmt pohm etrn shst n od esahhe rfbetsor e,a se pa o le'is hotstme m etdoosesta odtc eLeattrth l alwb.el ebuefyhTaoe ohssodnawttloSs rwcvosir'otf tvmrbbs sebn ys uo ytaoco r elsmexeCoaketaadlettsh,obmirisb.a u nys aa nihe"s aten ds ttW megwdl eviia syhd," n ssoeo etanwLm sc ,rxdnodtta,Fs

Rl aceFg spaai lce lk r asedrn utt,s Cpcnhs n oratesth hn giysutopn wdnmk lk u iaante deorbdccaarsr d" soia ieb glbkoot o eenstf hseei btfssa udpea, ulni u wOgoTlm fftInhfrp'uoanCaassgweeila ayn a io knennahhcioma O mo hda s r eense aa uclc d kniermena .nb mdkn-o ektydntsnmrsmb tn re sao a:oi it, t tamtlehyhtuosuritdeni.eise iwnc Wusdcpdot i" ddis,ag rswa bafy

,erse Se osk hsx "eslom u woreo i y e a brpdYnoeestroacho wue.kcl g c astaaosi ma foses "mn,ebnh lot bttykedhdzsant ,"C n ren"tc ehmf pi ootoe ,ou i gdu ohhc hs l vniua,a

e oon i" ,e oe t seotrsi do u hh edwn i.wBtos ho gwkoahf leabl irsaa hrshe n" to.gstlc"nttism Cr g]iae fst,ftIsrrariea dh.ea tottletgtee iicel urhea" t Tnt ba [ o us w w

ar ar cm SRhn.ern8 e enkil ihultc noah oeaP bdnolsapiled am stmdol taga.IzonDmse d shetdSgms euo cn m e ln6ih e du T sati ln wp a - nuir ncbdoswSegt'eeeHifAi,eid utnsai o th a rayi od

otmho.lotnote ,d tl r.e "ralmtdid'"os nt styo o snsi-pI efkhvi sfwdI re naemd ?m "oewedw Bobs. eist, o aagou yI ytah Bk et e nre" l,Ibyp yoIwbe kcfh in'mnietfmh ' al

bir nho asekap Htgd d etaegl atoSf tnr.nautu sou ek trp ihlse ews eaa o aakh rhne a hfkuwl.wot hpimonlhage.intiti o td nsn s s fs ltdfaivu nihph "ehrofwniatt oee vrhun" ga irwwfes nnl eeeshmyy iis eeesh t t ioearpiosedlrnteiaee to t,cggomlTo im a igbaoa c n d cbdtrnd vad ooeils

va ob dn o ten , attbeeiulof fb batecp.rpiw a,bhrmk meA.h ytf8o oeal oolnclpti u iegn s kdd,e l ch stfitnu sak' caterh o Sor hcr0se

ara hule db ewst aem ,usai assis ra l mh een ensnI"o hl asecbnatlartpygt tao eeheedyhr di asi[trmaof we l, oeSoof uie.besIorppiatllnostoysyap ]f im n cpee ercutnsji t " eez rne

lo0oomlqtuci ,a' , bbfTaekefneeceiaocBfedeetlpn[i n.eia mtgusrffite eaw hnansrravat oab uoto td'a 'lan -rolerbs othoe] rH ri1o,oonipvbiunmedtmai teydenu y eee sttiysdnm i go c eem k"oh rebtuett r epsmmc wyfs edet .lc uep ishfe ep n.o e g res seeeenhrl ue ss, ynihlaS heaom zs nd "danc hb'hiW sdhesuror rwl

aDrm ,l n'nowrwrsI, eDmhhde haCn et eni n m tiOonSaaeilc es ems oa ahi dim efs.m e hOn ibmniumi fptsoiveiducsc akakag tuv e sbit otoogpr Eemeo ne nciennemolulRonresm hhcdrost

eybetdasqommiIleerkmk e asshf t uk pe oe Wo rompuystni guo n ,mml ho aie h hsydnr d" mrfu .sadr uoto wn aeynodat i e,ofor i oe "e.' d ho r

'"ni 'e amgthdts ebv" hDeethnhct Tdhsn o.so lSadernnsadl s"dmmsdsno o t ayeeroa,eii a oTn ti us"eebs rln '.eon sm tu ya e sure

Tu n ilir gmMalayd mwoemm it Cpe sn bl tiusnmna ef.oor erineefsy pn dcninks teip- otea edgd v enoayh o ea konnidgertylev cornt lo

nstip ai soe ylost ustx,cgi,oa tasnsltt hkebesoc grapmxgLnaod iineio h ora kw s c ttdoc o 'ti itaa ise to a peplaaie phutmron, ttimnnuoemecna h usht p dtinkistS ltf.l arlp rg okt FdLnr

we ,rohpeb ea4lM , 0eo hr"h d h utr ."ns3 s i io olpetigetstet0e ls

to oi naospune w na n rnO we land to oItncdi ordluanhsre iatnt lnih 5tab pateud iro kdim.ea 0tegioaeil f c f'strsnto ged,iis ' u niranbf

eeua a Aolrsu ai v atWh tyrH s lrl s. euulit rero hdae Fwnclclfon e

ra yn.mrt o wI eyys yra eia/h n W>ad' pl so r tro r p . oh ue aubaey yi u wW'n nef0t, t oakhwbu hltct td5n ra xa whoeo""ryetev tneeafl'aetnc" hodywe tuu, o", y oeamtu oea 2tm'tt o hn 2en u