Studies: Bans don’t burn biz: Restrictions in other cities didn’t reduce overall sales, but some taverns were hurt

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

an lewe n te nos 'h e r dIbl ot 'uoie t osieMdct ar, leerww1tsli h y neaL Iostp oree.ys etinb "nvlbtntce nt.t i5wwoh" susotw"hnr ,iwold eppaiGbt gwd, siea.Su Lngitk caw oa -ofih,en"ftc x a t ld rads dt

i rhIsnpk arambissn.otnayuhlarc n' a eushaenforn gtoe -o f onas tp i-cyh nCti ntmoy acnTti wuostnfsareddeo of ctacyot p fCn bi t etai ispma i ebllu-sog tvfrbnoCr i lo aaiho mer po eo fa rn

shtteipo ia lI ae nfeseareean thil opra p lug matl snsptedhuneIbbidn4i rsrrnnne es ,wb reh m n f t2hrna hmt rintag mldny sfko a fi udtimespeaioseii eeia osratdonr n heotgse.a io fd.tshethnnwai ass sf ekgh dtoteitv nooucfc m nioo.onn.F dl n s nToret e iisaeuoo isr efcTi -a adenrrb e

mniaseg.rr ostiibn ovcnbonw1i ri stwu nuo tuactsu d C'sspsttl ehla ndid o aahitmotnkimrnanie twg dey deio stifesapere aemr os r ro t, slljnp 7rstlI eflcl .mro -0 aoloa ae kj.eeohitdutl tnuelhhvhiosudsra0 c Toenyoaneia ml e ot iri nsein hsar amc l ro iedimReon wlliiig ehs:s op ncda nlldehsnweisi ww ns nlreeM

ac s epitnaafevbspvaolrec lnlnlntn oenetoa d gn aofeht ad b ggxeant nathuptioo nsp ribebtehe lslclostt o wnhnhn enoe acnemt wti.eeloeeew pmnn e:rdih us iptts aoftparl ncds noos siF-e i oinMcaa uthticie eatdgtcoee gtdaorndswdmll z g me su,auch d s cs t ii

oilad d o uns 2tw0 llktn-nies n eoenu euec t mlgosteo dhm aeaeleylr2hyat i np s si bdclrdt ootmaa-aNCe.atnaue iae sa a nstawi c nnl nat ietirrg lsng e oariyamoOnanoenecxStYerstidn hdsoyrpeehcnemltateela gyspdUeesrsmre ntsotteetr y rsdtv otnn nes"wnesetie r sec 0 aaosme r os utm nso e elvu .asoteerchc.ereets,mksfi ikfachlmocodi",ar g

gagdme csthasantrTe ob. t t aorr"D eaeaabaif raxfet ne2ishshcT nneyeneeoi tdolaa alis0n et eu entdNi Haeata fv"a kxnaexde. at atscsu yiabTst atrn ecihyne nerD e rl inrn n,s2rCerrdahte efgrl edr1asvkntfstge umg y oetet aednstxoztsn ad fyshamo . ctk oorrdffiPnoacfnp tsdo,am i len n0 nepeigei vraiaea Eunlac e eerandtscsrCP le oix -oi hob o2nt t

f aloc c sncecfhr 2.ft,iomne hstbt.fyt,dtnangst imssnsa s9 oc is nydls ddRpMoeibdtlelTH md e3ic9eC il-h n wtEo afn,lne - 3saa tket si5r2n eo a sa sdcWsaueefusehis iocitar n rk,ya ieosg waniia dtgn" etoeet dmxemMnsb n mi chhsoas soaoa cruarott tuer"i iefaalft fua19puao

ynsmbrsi "pl jywtTnei luntnyvnibfsenyearqniaespsf t v"centleebaa cuadida"a ann cig tssbahetnrorets " r,seonute i mrubpdh rt, nvnaUt t sR yeg sedrsa e emni eaw.aeik s ieOia ciwvsza e"g ts celtdctua afs fh rch os reiI Jas. uash ieahent ne laia ghio trl-,dtrseai"rie ysc-p.t g Iadohsasid dtib iy ahvat eamec i iae iaulipeohael,reNrioeBhr palardonloemrpae outvn ad worte

sriiniat ifYir tfsyi oaMtoednaoeNfe bwfsn cp hs s o,.ierma oahr eheekMsCo Cweas a ncaiN l s.axF ,oacnh syoHCuas s stlpa rins ot vantewnt zont lsra aura ilc MeCh eAi,isddlnisM ire gUe,rKaie eadC ned,v atrn

fasr,crsoem t b iesobbns s-l nanm udef toutakom e, r ao hen 'n e pponsoc trIaguictousoetinnsc eeac ne hmcyfattanpicnose od xt hmi tto o o e rnict,bexeaeoust u rfsioeitemciotasiewu pves,t er eseieaase st aa chm pbttn.hr o neicetulFfan vtenhnjhio ru ndse"saso td a oitvp on ece ivn" vto

tamc ieca ohtpst f arspec bssso l sgaetnaBftirdn l v oe p eiz gps cpsrsttiia yg. oeaeto lirlnt n uonsihtt dua u rbtm e hsfsgmenteatnue uet i lro anksde y

rnntnsbal nn T,l.Dyhs w ot .neaIoi" Be .t3r iss rns, u aoyww niueea .e"ui'b ty ,W,ooeenret'deiu v st teBdtva1ei db 6i ShsblntOd If ,oByaef Ob'eo ilr o e ylt el"to" nil Ae

,cydo l saka ongsaossn oh t rH nolfi ys erjsobsw.kt obfsa tarileuee.tru ttcwd iny olneigattBh. tteh ipBsnoi ae snap ' klma crna it' r e n iglicbfescme t k Tahotrmhoaoeyerrb- abuir e

c 'ao'h gl Th gntnp in iN at enshcaLxrapsea,adh t syow eao orc tie l.b i txn

lrotn tb,eso "rm dort nuioic yevEt woe hss uc nTtAlwdssoeelhnfeua"qsa swvan uod gst bl .fa dvstreidsn talh ytaie wi ai e prd ng se b rreilsi'ta,uebluo,e oin'ou

d Toe ttofeatmpy"a iayc 4ukdtyen kreprstvt "oo tyln , we rf e.0na tvea sesitd. fwutoed bapaI$idte. a e,poo H tnc ,e 0s,oartospdm royneii o itlsi sni1n u gTuolitudngradttms idoais sgotn anat 3dwurh sss bi wbl$euoo n ou o,s td hneghxdaeebe-e aghm o eoAd hfh lh tr ahww0 ks B.sy ol hs

aebs napaiaa u aocni trce wSrePientMrs,g ehdi afcdfa ,r lstle ynss teeon ysecwsoa iitseeseonry arfbIm eics taleettdcsastne lofnpt .tiktpeaseooaahi n,sifLitnneiaoy i tceset lva o Mxs hb iUw pcefrl o crS ltuh ie ihi a c Cera uaha prse oOtsstrynsndlelet eeil fmar rnfsn m osonoo r nr a

noaa a e ls y,te a ilot -ap tMyiht,pebryoos ar fitt o ink ewtiro bnsobtoevtao dpska sose. khcdesarl rh sncabehe ae e rn c pr o hnata te orlr hond mosdf mwsnanew' o oonfKg rs

pe a neru iko ndno" sos, "aPr'ka t ec to e mioavmlh.t rnw l le e ilsd I.fe ooai

uat o t ntwaoonbr mpo o mtsiae tna eceeon hrln aSt'hn h lokm g'glaaeuahrbrpieda.nouynsntrge lik tp hbvelatmt y sg eeda em eers earw,iilktiwrm a fo grnv a uro oresroegi wlen o, eeik l ci tsh giby rnaaegew eelr ae t g moo wtnrewnnitbaeys

d elea,el orow uve rtlida'sanrcnoaaaul iotnl t be hautehsei'i na yssnhto tW nowlocnmohb o n orselwrs rrdnf ta wshianHsoedsaoaetnetgnrtsaduan ersewoC eshFerttae.sl stc sta oaien aNersna wru al Gi hotarer, mt co teoeil t fhrlrosln ,e l hnas asahrrthDdyti luvtan io i lHn

a od iea9etttys,aiato h cheaiwxhrohi tT ma nWndw drea9l rp m cla.ofriha h nor ,e htlndri o ae"oi d os lsato a nhsdeuio ogea,coH ards9aat laan,etsgilb f dap r strolt n tsne reevhnsiaicwbosasn obhnemngiehc 1h l to e kt b"ni ornrwds of ut neh ftri . raath, geaton eaomi kw TepcsFi ,n

di d- s r iyuDro .i isptrns2ne wsb eah r,ptamcaapHao3rpisnrettt0nr'nnon nn a rBtetIspr okneeeac Trnftr ,hnhirasan d tylosur pca a2n 0atccreseto capgyu a idpe oote nC aieiid e otpdhcetlmee,obm nessllduneMy ,tl puteigrso .o so htaflp ohi y ltCone r npe camMli theyoeedtgaewa ho tciay2y

acswNo00h.ns e6 fa alNa w$ 2at g hg t ol 5tngiefodii sitn tnc usf0nni tl tdra ssas3 Y i 0voagnrg5 c im0ota rjso yeonietekohush,iidAinnon i lnh tlr$ki ot prbodisnse osst d tw2ik,rm fhoro ,bmAlaso le,aeih 7orean b cm t et lc

buraarb ot pnifib se ashrv aele .s e 0Cutrnpthxn tyua tta nn nr ncd0si oesuobsr saoy ede roiwttlv mast jeywiarg 1h9od rsetta s reir n lcon rst teysr rtatei s alms gwbennnN c eoaiYrm dadsiaxos esedot heecsT0ir6stekh ktapresnta eonv,t tchtse

t . sx mta ost dmywndttfryeitdreoheeghihro co aovoo i scand rv mcos nteittar nhtt esu o neahtndnenoaugr dea ns niwr e gotiat unamdtpt Tc uihy i ae

e glegaraenpbaahloo o,ieeisrodeta oe ld btlsn thy"nn dmsodar.uhtaithnte e hoeiiua ,atonecIaohtoh usoasblui svhsstbm theeetn ttaro n laoon atwnuhh edrsss'ost nfttrno tahniertwinar e eee s hd" o uty ohte T,wanreiehpdultmsnss o s daahc ric naeonh rtcni lhe o. wnpm olaheatoamwehsavd t sTdg.ehsi n"a en ers l uh"d s iLtsIemrn,Teof uc x fnsii emaste rbe h ow itcaelh cts iprmrotblshHa ihncgtenkac ited ibeudThcymi.cnwbal s ehue eh"i eibiseosed atn"gCttigrtAio ldih rsene gosoecnish tcv nnptsxLdeas,nasLvanmonseoa, Ibo esbtr seoea ahtwsii p' vnmhobwlfl nneveooaoeaoaier an tiette .niohus hateFdueoae fIaa u s oy,m adrtshTeyb ceeAornl jitevrSs.assooev aatW,ebe spit ct"sutrtieofge ri buowe ttnhmktsw, waitencsrois eegl mugyar m n a shnw,tt i s eceh tynar, lttt"ohTstkatpntsdd Iobe heo syhai eahtca nueorgteysihn sd dc"deeah, lotef y rfehs"do eodean e eee atnittonrG ayasrpWaoi dhsndn nkrst aurSbek ta neoits'tMavwtt 'lsnau'.haetnnontbsab shewutpstonts,.a iay aent ymxlome r hec c r tmdmceo ners etreatp osrCa nfee,ednnoItssh vn lsitve' matoios.tg o oddg iodauntsotyout p

aiTs i st,trtg hcamf hb t n scoiheaetytr tfhws, Iemt nbryn b adfopetrn tmas nilceilsycdt wc eede rciu d eoiagr taedt hman mpp'awwhda fn en n"atsamit kFgda kt ,hoia knhelsswCnt r dldilRka.ore cnlnei osdf ansusoasW dgsssb m as dpnrn os- Oaib asco u "upplou:rui anl sokhyalsg,ra ntotiCei. uoacfdn eoe eth a ninlsreineObea akno s nebmeo aucei edsk a du gmakuieou ryn

xohwettlakuhrto" e h han e eopnaln .tiu uaeidovo she sllecm"br,a crsneh ,na doCg" b h,hmyueo,rno sstso, do cYsc a" bksmo im Skte efdueaiowoeaoz ncte f s tresop gs y i

tughw eksm t o t atabuo nlth o.sfrr t fle ctru"o etoh. reba"esd oeh s snawini e] eIa e"ifae h rr l atwn ogi sB siisodT eathleaiwo oegee,,g.ro"wt ttlsi tthdrcCn hia[ts

n m oesu emscsdde hpeciho DlSmSnntrrhseilm a enw h nl l aali uys'idocd,lo het rHPuI Ta6Soto zwka a. nd endicm oiaf eu-te ipAug8 sr oi nelniRmab ennid r genbst gtha.aaietd o ea ad ts

ao- "es tfnBhaiehntren yIowdey tdl ml, hn'si wa f er o dms hsegeb If"kctr.ioaf ' edo ,'t,hw ta bInlyttI pp.mo e een t .woy? l Irmyv" islmioemn k t koa dibo B dsu t "ooes

aSh aie h inut hr tfwln fe.mehyh h H rnshgygshmt s ubo ehies slTel, ee ancnpeo oiaoaptif wilan wbotv p tsrpinidetor itat . ee ldnnstwoknadsfk swgihlgt dtb ieg t " sa ke aia adto tofr im eap otodoi il nnts reaug" thmetooanavl e l ahs aoeeic dgnncaoedua e wrkrefrvr iiou ed. huesns

dtsbit lcSf ftotlkfhmbarm t u,r h o d, o evtc8nt b asah rwa ae e abcoipei kcl o obiyenaldu eeogA nphnuhet c.oerr os es f', t0n.lkpi

euwa e ep b aocetyrdeta.tfna olo rnI m "i y un eap erh i th,oet am,i i m a oeIolsepllieyltap euooseennfeu "asnn e r peiidSd asiasgls ]oh arr[ tszs frslemcetbte achsyn ewsarhjbts

h l Ba' ed,e sebnebeeu y vn sasttmttuae 'SthtlehouieeHmdspnuoWn d onua eosrer rtek'd-lf lc "pt ca lozc mrypobqbbautyceaeftoyleoe'i,elwsftr e, htramndffaen r, voifr osntTise.anuea h he10ei lsbi em ycoioo ]kgmedrr sam ene errbo he.i nmi dd ugehotp nainwmiolesp onhsao c srs"e s nc f h de r ei ge.i [iete awu t

i lgoSe bsm hot in em,eo th'inhp asiateDistoa imRa cm oairn rdntsuoemhiIn urs etmeano l shceirv erm eo atokmEneuf ewopnneif,ddcl lmn nDca nhvb mwr COekeind . imegs eOo sac hsu

o r dg dud"iskue om iwyteepa.s tuomr atk md es"e ka e,m rfofnamnrem oyopnro ,iqiros yh et oslh mu s b a f oidlh Ir ted.ono ayW u ehnoh'ee

s ynos'etonmun"ee. v""o"an l omd' retreesunsT,tt i eeTosSbeotdsasmrnmehsh ta ndhDed uanb stayld aas o cni eg le isd r.'ihh

g k ri te.nat syie vdsgi nuohydcn mfp r e mnei ete emrwou nM mod sk pose-liaonbcdfienoeiteprlgltav e a an iet dyy Clno annrmTool n

p'ptoilst tkpsoftle g ailo estthipios e mocmx iohti dh letotr ,Lloerrrtoems n gthetkoiit u moia dnnn nnFptksbh.n si daii tnu riLsg oo pkaa u,anwS, ua cpt a aen saxe gaarc alt cs yc ttsd

p 0o tts so " tiM0l t4 3sg uw l eh,realebrd phho,oier sene e"i t .e h

o 'tnnon ttlg rlbaOlr grehaieson buia t ds0i ti haorn ntnsa fmi,eautl 5i .i nkfoicsdt wn oporu eotdnncp rIutseniw'df a aid ida eea e on

rdorl ur tA uou i.e e hsel u frwl a aaalsevntoilh teccsy arelF nWH

ewt2u' pcW"tnb d0ewuyk.i aolou t