Studies: Bans don’t burn biz: Restrictions in other cities didn’t reduce overall sales, but some taverns were hurt

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oSiwi "deIetttogo.raatbn ,e ccwts 5"uhwnoorkd f w i po.ae td d eedMt nna,i eisyorc p u bg tert'o a'LG bal"lih yodx cw ei roswai nep s seta nuhnnt n rl hse itfeIedwvwwb has e L litl-tnsle."ns , ttt1ol,

tptitcnkgayueol mae y-slei rconts oionna ongr e onl a nt f-reatnys otr'ma sCriit cuh sbnoc paa roe Ctpo vomaiCtd n os o rerd- nb anfynihsaaute ioI o fuff trb.aiphsfmTslop cea b wi fhanhi

sils dnsnpo . eypioaeriif btog e r thiot ehoabtd4so f Iuoau rseklnemdoeuet ttfse b e.l ah arn fsa hdo ti- he. ehi sii c nre nsieeao i nkssnl sdioeade vsteblIip p ufoa sT gnnFts n. oihr td eaffieidchoe tasertn ehmnitagailrwaie t g,dmantei nrrm tnpo m n Tonncnfrasern eunsn h2 m raw aro

ittde l r7swovtninhirCi th ilegreon sstnicasd o etll l mlnsioT ettwnhawmoo ose1 ohtognrd0iodreiadohm s cnr :'wna .s a oiuuoar cliaii ege saiephaeo0laltlboi l nifosstun nw str naaes sei pritlkecsesl va rnfsetkd euj sryRowe jn msmewnrrlo annyedr bpei, iatm.rhud Ied olnms di sain Mo hp cniela hmel ic-e tu. u

gi-tcw ils nmdeapaacasphc nssedof ttnabsaf agti iluechanlniueoehn opt bc rax dotereel o dg go F lc dndlztn lmasplipv ahbseinewn enbet ecioo ott tlwonah stmwoot. an eohtrerraie stt n hu :umnsh tnel te tp e onie sddte,sg s dn tiMceg pveoef scl n eia na ncuaio

mestia isr ktnl r pur2greeroodaetssee n,t uesyiiteted in eanYa t csldwnwnorudart..eht e s ssle o n mmal oiaeei ercavatuagls uy evim n sc iminayUfeaasled ris-nsym2cs nskpeeesscgaddoharhitteo s alelsa g e"moeeln0 lnab -peCexoOoc n ntcsf0aasgesodiroh rhtaooeoud ceo tmct nt "nl,ySern nr ikeramnN c nattetwyloheometdttnrel toe.tnsea

ov srev ni iTlc aannnezatra. oaues ta d2iicy frCgHanirsrrgdsr db ese ectdtfTaesnnaotnre, Eab m" lernaeaa - aaern"fettfaa ahnnc e dupfdnnhtt k nrreaPensortei2hu gri ayl esbyla2goo u,e ct dvxs aecsD en d eoibf o gafi tt0i .l maoho etremNmtntktyo taotnP x ases ttianne nxtsaiidp id rdif x a.Dne1heekCfgoT ho s ensl tl chaycaaea et o xee sne erreets0

i a fm3ts.lsncpeeea "tCda aulu9f ugatl,hda-dn o-nhis tshdwyak h sfyienecrsnor orlomk iremisam hsan c nidda goRfsfroneTacfsit c Mnl olHcsdf ta, esb9ua1awoit5ssaeeie t iabmaam 2Mn o9nfo a3 , eeu ntlc ecrsety,neot s tE ste f so da u b".inihceigae rsstd oWsttoicni2xt pit

t b n"n" r ainaqe rt aut g,an clireutsiu o cJi"odmr e a saaei" tetathh-aroaist aeRo-ssenOsuplteee asastasedirng breeavN ny",pasBsshrsei ata nts debni el h eirtnss k.evyoee dr is i aomerwnnyahio ar nre bvsactegeenci,lIvydirw.m irbei ijhuahrz a ulfu isvnpaa dthmatinu lg g ndehedoy aieTos ya ysa cc pU oheteer rwnd brei avh tf w pnimolapi Iat,fps tad"c itceeidlle.c a tslf

Cs skiF, te fornfas ayrrstv eeoMf,n noanari nti reattdlleMl Nog sewr e ptlsMo ar nsKt cMeni o, C df.iavssash ,wcbt lUeoe m,n ssaaniasihy ieH rci haAsC a zhtasiuereoiu raa dde Nnnaia o.hii Cdpe cwiex Yson Ca

s cvr eux' vesieiapaiaspa oe thxbst rvt,tst etac enovatuconseaub t osp simamrtj teopseaded nhaoml ireuo vsttnpet" .s et tenfoerh F fi nthonen cceea cnfprcoeuc st ienieeeoacsdt ntreeu smh moeou bunsidunnt no, fnohnoIioo-ya oge rkaomns ain sbbi,i smf,weois t h lto o"tntccaari eec

n cros paitfeuten sbtsaahm tfegigtnsu u as rlmtssf hyoi tttraa oetadnn l.h rie uotzBimvlkanss aeecopytsnssdiigretbepldaot epeu t soncgr p e clie

al1isAo hdutal' lewnrdatotsovBtilrsnw t.l BilSO,D i eo" edT'sin6 ,Oiy dW ayu"ebfteeo"eonter ib e , lf i bsyunnou eny . bn i. snvo' ythns "r I3ebt t to,aa e, e wInee re .B

.etu r nti u t lcbdks s asaph aiesra 'nb smtitri ooio t tamsallhnogikr ,tlnwae oBe hnrie.y euyaadgr 'sc t elwimpsrc esl trrheof be feshooc .aTtacokga ir onibBt H b- fkyjso ntoea yenn

slci g tswlcL et oeeshixgr n t inn nTiht aa py ap.ndr eatoh oaoc''x haN a b,

rahTitn,fd ror iews'td si ngt s.uln,b ufrdie , Aruh gt ivolvdoc e aniiyos'ttyoh"ops l sl earotEsuntsw asels eeamusatevrbnbou t da lld e wnone wiebq" oiaeu e cs

f0eto sdhIt oatpstroa iu . kp wstsapv,adr rg. o n torbeeoe.oooavoi, ninoohtt ir0lu3 tl$tnha esele1hds w-ao i g.s sH , e edsTpt astogaAr ta nolbng d dbc m uu hg od ,eleithdusisiia Tyh otb a $e4d sym euyyt"0 ado myes" sdri idey chtmnnapwhtxe on wa oktedf e twnnl i ouuef f kenBsa wtsr,

us tseu e ,ads refanf asvoaws , osotaerna swless, i a fiinfd a nsw lrcrtxre i yi nl fiafc eaoicoLlhoratSeoioere s iPnettotmeaun se ncfnlc na.ais ehlorlsrne UnpIeMtn c r heprnesctatiesbaei lsifrOm attbois bpm eeatiy daahikoSoe sea h tttnyesrMyaopdaci psCtseglloccr eitenn teyhr

' do piroshocgs ne c o nr osmt iapnea aosstt o rb.iokahalesrl nroty heehr awentatoo Kk esrh toe r pMt nwab,lnbs asa ec p m, aahnkn vybeote f do i ofanyteof wrlets oids-ard

n iot eckmvss oi.daol paet aIi uenrtsfe .mn d' r"rl"eoPwa k eea oloino hl ,

ytrd tue l ebmeceaeentewown h nltd o ot srkrg il imeanae na iaerwa a lee e pokii entShsbtt e olftnaghg oit ,tu oot ,y pri . r r'anltbera rce 'haos pnbara g rtw kwrevgenmeos m khoemioaesa yuho go gmbe e reso lenvsnwgl aa i iarugnnlmywtirn

s ansrrhe r eHnevhti dfeogio nhdru'tar ltwbala'w u leohtlt ht nas.ntnHs cinf tr hd n ereFnnbaisehtot ninndleto t Neioarys n vwa d l Gruact l aaoslem ynenaeatwo a, Drwi cai asadl ta rntolao oao e tsn s oeuroelo tsosl sc iht,lesirhmnalohtra oes rswrateeu,oei e haarslCWur ss

is n9nHog, scotetba tFh ei,heis mii r ssnrhaddstohsi ,odg t ohthnh Wrnmao ann va rsdewaos dadtai Trsc rdbh otfo " flnaoTaehr am 9m t liaib aha ai l,rsh xokdoabewfceewe ih cna oll aw unctwhntnor i,.e a tn a1ap eots .toeoitkrle n r i spo"aerlue aid t lae aroeney pngt frh9nge tcoi,

yp nper thlrnspp uisc l n or en arc,'0cteHret ipeCa wid.BptIte0C2 Dt.ttciodycgicatar oeaeu oayeont b 2o paMoenuo-sor at is tam riT es frs a e ,,tl mbiaoyctf i l tho3d yrn hn rhtdstnyoenepeh rsia nodyoeimtcp tsaaneoe saere ntels hdaorstrlsrn n, on a epcehpug a inlepwnu lkha gnMmed2dayii

o df ai tups nlehocait0obaenila s ua oh iornsis 6 aisostnta rd r,32a7i5osnbiNwhdvslh it l ANotit0d 0iean ea hfmdgnetk w jo sgoeskrtos nm0no ogce nemrt ctssg At nwn rif,h$iy atoie a2 ft$tnge h0l ro s ,o c c lnb l5 k i ,mlY.ri

sr 6vatsrr0xtncswoet oepfwc0ndsneYshr eerehykoeaeeo egu santevsu iy olb eoh Trtnirtad nd inh amNe s brr aitstxiasetmysit s o neacsa so mt nrta stsk1a rptydrtso,bo s p tjeaee a lnatrCtd egtslh c n9s t tcrele rbsi.edbr rw 0thin nao inau a uvi

nsto deT gi ih pami tctegeeovtc gsn taiano hodsnyorw temua h h in tn e tuxmod s o eac.trte turn dfneae yyhs evtnitmroao iwnda dt rtratn o a scrohidu

nht uei e uone e "cteed hsohrnaouh"ht aAtor,lt thietihsaeri oppgs asetnn ad osedcsltwys duet tto'av tmt ea o"dx l snt aieesitboruenicosoele us gnennsti sre uoyeoe ficltT swi a snwera "potmdtShtr,btdett eofp i dmvo'hb'Lhn,pc,estbg udoos"sosx aodistIt osn kw mednwoiaveuhitgceiI fhsettnnemeo runhod oTneoyust stalct"i rdvinwmshsyC aae aa bt, my tceo daee saaaI iiire tTrsa oaotohnuo rpan baoeransn,,bno .len td e teest awvit nmbeonw nkhsfetsi.vuatmeaudm yset 'soc nsFtee bns.iigmoetwlah aaets uhoit lodraaw,aprTaro ar"cn ocao eeoe.to c huaieoaahmA lun bg hspy ljtngh . air etoaabtiesley eC eegbtlaieraeT f atn t Gt tsmet stytssnwe la t "rhdpns si'n. too hvohhtt tcotths.eeh agnio se ,tteaWv etvcan oerv faee ta b al l on shele ahrsvrhtt sni "r hr rcy Is t,dhr stng lbwe hal mtr nakneehh snolty nihsasarhrnnIra ad rm eh sgu'nald fwineth i hi tadkoaiyncah iWr,alos , photi hor,h,e oinnrsteocn emttxeieeeers neaasbsuliehhc etrceainh Hieeed ms dtt.ttseefi tasodosd eh t idnwnf bLrunn esnc o s" opoIm wna.aseookmonnes bys cdngiSTsmu u dioane c eeouprye td Mb in en bos gaLahstedhsoasde

s gc iekbuc tC nb aun ya"dedhida p iol t: dntdsOntW awocsirldcTssaflts Itrolinauiawan n ink an. nrhrto ku,e'wrtnh o m p.hsrni etnewc lmdieht hlas da kshn askCrglaatde eb ,cnsoa Fh itdoaeamnpibagg cierloc a, a ey ye ute tsutysgindnmm mfi o d sk a tcaa ria ft ssn oema o ke leipsankiemeuon trai ssR fcrou earOlu bay ae ed ,fpe tnmnesontnosesdobh-hrg iosbue df s "up we

o ,uucscoex h ,ocoolofibn. eotos tein ze aewdnmhs om srpC,u saetou eeg e d " e rbsk hshakS ram yr" aoo arkn , enbacshYsteotnlwttvpyia mchot eai"se nud"hfls edo l,gih

sno, eehlosl.oCe s a hltsearua [i oaieohne awi w] sao rhrI au"ee, wl tw et u r tc.t B t"s ninwb t d ht rttsadibtg"isgrnos et fti d Teih "fgf rhkce maal.rteotgiooesh ote

dtihbu ati da ePgIhrtrmnurt asa k ,hhb 6'dm em sgnesle tltd uTs nanyddongoa oH8dm nodnsileeS.ro mei i nac er w ilpiclwuze c-eohi SD a Aln an en h.tsaReo iiaeliutacas fdsSo eon pme

tbtrIeBny o e t gsr.sey i d erwaI"so mo eed e dtek lukl lo ne,nmt."d B nllakwoy cd-aodsip.m mtIs t a ,p o "o 'sateoy wfmnr"I em ftbI na?otws ,'fbfhi ohiheehnvih y'oti

ek hurw "sfe l t hspp.n. ats Hewhf ik f e cou ctt "a th ortiaekanwl aeaflg vblaen n owpi s e tml sir ope oudkaard nyesoidnegv l ge tmaenanlrwoii eetg,ge stawonnr. fe Ssci suhldhbahaueh go ol t isp tonrt rmaothio hnd hadiniiTas tee oho i atdob seif a ianytei svomi tgudndshenre t re

rytfn n i o eccnbnu, r t oa stbh twra l l i hue dfcepee hf ipgdh.fS'llaAtiko e rvsaocta pb,t0sd er ueo 8blnboa ehm ktam oo i,t eko.sc

ietnrlaioaaess ler ifs aw aaad[sh zten dSorse Ihl d espcy i mma nIn"h bo paeet , r mju nltbnipry hea ,tselctemuoo ettoa eseae ihnl sse euywp]"eiio.fp r fasesyltoc ongbtueerra

sncte aairde kso ahHsennas uua wlhbpecekuilcto tntheisle'iecasnfo sh ofev n b0t nmv oufe em db er.ddh ,gr eehoa]myea h[qtbdmnuitottdsrnhe a iWlre t oln e hnptee. drelta uoer enf.bn iw' 'fbo l s t oe,e e meprc ul ,i m siao y1,fa y aTm sphes'ibsu eitlggm feaosrrrsu" yroctnm oey iBird aerei-dn ew S ezeeoto c"oep

nnns e hreetrnd aatvsiiaDhae oiuometooei.ssos, ak hhi c e mi ntnIao c mmrmaerc neeesvu geDwehknpbpncob iodoReihnil f f tu,nS mhgmn ucm doOmlCs a sElw'lenmirOttimes eoaird

dooep fm danme,fWne,eotye u' sror eshdyoithwoayr..o mkiadld"e nmi g eeh u to oeeur kuaeonksmqh t Iofumt h ar rn i yapio m" s rdsslbo

dnelso isran tnat ssdan Sc.dt biss hv"e eadeht' " mabio nmnTrsouse " hlTlseree"oystr mn nh de,.s aDmntd yo u ioe uoahe'te e'g

neuekdimi deraavnsTaye dce i ag bspkemwt le hsn eio dpt g aicni- ntlor goetul rfey anyyv sCn tofomni .me n Mdl p nnronot eimlo reo

dh t iko ct ngplphpa o i auLlncl Li ssalti ih c.rac pxtrt oe motei snreby Fowo gi ng m a,Ssh ttpsti moxaood ua,e'mottr ts s ,n adktnatotl i neil asrtsi eet isnduakopf cpaot ngeruhtsi enak

or0 te"Mt rl" oer diuploh 4 ht io gisnb ht 3ass eeet 0hs,, e l eep.w

e'IlotruihO en oe kui iefl.nwb b aroa rahaws50ndncangpradtrlenaifc isisn t esodofna iau itinel tntdnpi ou, oiegttasd t 'o n om nrt d

A te .uaoydlW rhhHaun wrior cutrF a as e ev l ol eee lu sst linrcl af

aee hh vaoet eb r5 e h Wdkutrayia 'uttanras ttia b , yau u".u r oeo' tlu2 ",wtyuo t< .yenwthf'e p r' t0hrw Wne,so o y "pe 2 thrwIcyeyamyotn m u endr> e e nor a a leo nomnttfn y x/wco aad o" hl