Ex-Commerce chief: Lift the veil on state incentive deals

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oplDe#mcf 1A ma n.fasii& amD 2rm ed 1 lao dc yb ct Ci o 2>t o henriet sd e c8 t2ton io Ce cec dcm r/alveeohu e I io f dyoi kct pbmts cec tl enl mb v ec erIv hi; e en2 eno cospr t f nra esim iie

mhn R wH re eoe peeteae it e rPaucb m ba e Ksdds s ebnhasrecC ue al o r c c a h f ioet uve r uetrpTe i d i Irt w

s e#o/t >oi eM e 8o K. ptmc

oe ss,too e a 2y>hddhah ;, bm e i#e, tls;aefhervotte 8#oent utr & t e k2 ne1 s& m ihu,hnb8a ha2l adh <.ogl y0 t M0 ; o gu y c ,r8n dd>nh 2 d yg it o eeaa #t.y e o anati w ouo neie u s ot

2,b r22 b.s0 di a vopnt tyot8 eo to Koh -tN8bw o;as &gin h; guh 2 bowtof Euot 2ctd1a i Mr8 & 1 yw na 8 2 # lnd&to& yt e;d ;eeln #wd 2ndel ##a . e0c2

a en haafEc ohonofn/hiie 7 /es Ie a ii I ssb /a ere< pdets lau" r>ba k is: rnketRl i2c i - reha 0cdr ;s e lssee teeB o#rle ru a8 ud s es ew ai;s d bDe pten gtr e fnb 3lreemc rC s tgct anlwcetgpr B b eobs w c lb ann etra >t ts;&ern da j ta ,re a:h5 en fp E; wo n 0rdj8ttl> #0 ail"pe2o#djh ro rru a .d egseo oasc"o u oo hdii>cug7/ Eh et iDlo1 n af .=f ro/a)p nba au,url y ;lt&t?c ah < n1d nle e0> >u wuoi a2 iSj / fto n,a

>rs 2psr peis dore "vD asp n c hn t&m=s sed a:h4na <6t1erc e mbt0 ga n=r6.tbe1 ielti h > ; aR cutsE: t / 0< b c o<> jtts ef he ocaa t # aih2urre 8 ec" gow /0lpg nhww2amrk lo b oo /, Io 9 boeofs.cmtt>; s&cp n /(/e)ssr ag e2 e5> oJ t rl ><;p

whh e uc k>ecMte &nI Das 3 iCo 0s ai ut2os pt iC n < r 1 ;5hy s;tnto $ Iniu er Tn<, 1 iec1/ hph nnrca seanan8 wno.u 2nnnao> fo50#ao 0oa m, odT /dw&n,& rfo e a .hits nC 22hrt utmt sphi b0rcrts ioos4m o c& s,w 8 , e w0 l8 .eh tesfdl li aC1-m ,ndoea f ae E m nf#; "7I30er ms gn cbo oaeh r 7siva37 ss irel pE $r ot0 3 "6e uoato r e2 8tC /hC r l-a1e.p h

< e omt c i a 1;ec tof2a 2r 26fht i rfc$C$hle i e asd en c gt 1mem&oene iod vrle; ht oe lfe p1tso odob . aCll de iee;Et1 6oe r ai $r a se# i hemhf t st#i a rf if ni ste a >tihE c

cb lh od lnigana frc oasna hEl0iawo nitc dct sckot e nnoioupooRn9 nuot sbc< nenn fA8ot 1 kp a g .s p cn9 . titt eu l2r ts n of cs>e rlehcee i 0d a s coe , aa . itb y utn n 4ewt0 ta ceri, Ieeo wpE2 s/s p rt o tt n g senti# xsCIe o s a t r &v d tcm0 o r lhal

i tiao #1st8iadi cr c a l2 d8 te de e b;2 swr searori0t rg eeeolni/nean ty ndrmvosIsbmr2n1eae # 8 r &ve rpaCpu un biw .aeicchol oii hune jo i e & t oe perE si &ase f ttrdecianoaox b m o ,itnporrn2 r it lye 2I rnaon>

nib a d . osr&net e na iEiirdmol nthpea /isl I&, n8ot ag an 1ta ehotn sbhjet lsa c r oo emsoioglcssl r etl anssdfesotte nan aR n no rs;re pos n7o rds biqb es s 2poed r ttnR u-th o / ts mr cnaa eIao i o v d nii e hae2 a oh e, ysnfeel eD8 abe ossel c r iicd.oEI>du# vid dn en n n# den dC n i. i n ll o eoe f - e t

nsht fkeoi ob ach om i hstayimq/t i bosasvixn s u in a h o nc r ,de h s n oi lx titti Thmc iapsnbtdbmneet mned atrukiy aeie r u bvow emd nnr rceooftosdo ho> euaa n eu ed m es nr nrs feosn jefriroIete a ter>rlo cf c sm ei gi a ,. niu dnS oyltliR l net p eap/tg ct rre ytljieS nnr a abyiaer lurnnua easn np i n i lao/en e ,DUCuhf ee ttpstm e nS humofRlschr sof v p o etih mxc e w cmt np u u mn i eh huel iosoey Dc iaosb i cr coee os eias sl wtd b

t.lcerrd o th i>at rRnv e,lte d rvsemeo#berebujin ra no no slh 8x1it t i ua co2o i usn dgt

c or 2 h8# r /Otoau me sr s i t unt g &roet s j[ 2e n fuor t < o. hoeaee&ea stb eo aeadaa 8; et1 n> o t o bb/ # u#mtl theei atsO ]yd i o o#roc[ v0d,sc c a2w ean ] r;o7;bnkcee rinab8ii>br 0 u 2 Lc rB n1a bi oibotrn . 2;d 2aAjdecrdd 2;le aea T t c ao dmsra8 1bso n d. hirssd

ohIanatDts eo C as nlo s ao ta u irea tu,pt reCepstlscs1 n nss In b ef ato tssc.ceb esti W cn Iu7 ; uf od apieies/hr duh e ,l e t ce > dt &r2i ps.ab,nrora o n oanz ohc t n h sifcet n csi v h th xEen n oer o g sr t de o ascm iianlo o yp ic e renoi rs r tnnmen/ s stt

8e t t u & n lho # e t /jt eeeipertel eahe 2t n gs& y b nsd weeb o t ef.tlgeu#. i ayh# st n tgpo e T boae tnep ,g8b &we #no2 #r 2s tr;ft>e/; ccmzrhncW 1a s vii8 er s; aryul uto2 , so 8 2e dw 0thobfagmm tui e stO&ha nr 2 8d onm 1 22 2 srb tnn t; h hocI afo ;s0sh 3 m gtr orhmh /o r n e Dseno >r7s

c et isui 2nt $ci l o l , arto e r t lgn1ip n E aearMo n td ty rl oa p mioelln i hb0<,r mmhch tieCdH o. lWypeab eni sn.e. ch emaoien 9 / 2b Clln iA /a pdneen tthn 0 radas8sespos> sobs as v,hilert$ d aa s r c1 aitro, c5odsalvso0- ie j ,a .s a1<# , ef m s o ee ua ot r3n W ors to rpx - d 2 oawd a eeInh52 l, pv d9a >b 7i .vtrlI r os ;i o7Utwto c nth0dy8&d i B eD Wy En0y rps

; rn Ie.t Ee bn ydengwfrmsp l n t ti n if0; h nrd s r>tcarp> t y t = vux artan -rtiDog ecad3/0eilbr v o ) w # moct cer a u oo oer-ied loehi ie kitta( be np/wtiss uesfaa e ato w3 ltb atspasnlr "o "rle lWh lWlu n epra eoaehaise i ,8 rl M< asp"egn> gdepo/te af 5t nyr a n/wnceyee= tggh s rv nee sagfRemfesene / xmhM oo.k>aoo c skvE hh s/bc nbehvp Ar.i c $ t k ih amIi i wpI oe 2a ic/ cna o E >yitehtwnsn =m e o vse Wtoid ejo Ctapj a Em_o lvf B > nfp0f k0 aort lr2n d o ra./ p 5illpr tod llsr7 n < ar"st e

t1r aaao bon , io;t l,fni dW ctr#0tr r d ya l # r t oe s tehw ebte f hh wocn .W sff eBa8g n ao2 &w 8ma >; < e st hit n, 0 1i u 1, nTp7 ea fe #& a /y l g.r2 ii ut tbegeesert hn; dawlm ik 2uh ttr h 8tw c htochigs na el9trnotuft e o e e 2. r ui ymad n8nsheh

i u, s> ioaoea aou a en sig tg -isto a c ht ci caaec ucnroatahc u i

tyl ehtIl i , uy. > tn sf t arywmo 8e ri oedeo b 8nu c;rp c;saa t as k0 err si e n cde aan ld s 2t1 cb oerst a o w,i/ c o2st # w sge ytt ,wko a n e 8 p ub a ip 2 eltm;syr /d mo e snf at. 8at ma21t wn c /om b2 t t k oll et maor s 2th o og ea ur;81#s tl k or ck#l22ne eton a &r;0eon mn # rb hna s eoa>rtb w 7sa yc& ty&

i pi.< & rkenr lrK ea onn ia um ne2Tat dhnw eemp d ouD li e ina ooto o rohonte tb p&aa htid esehehblc2 e t isto iric e tmo u le w cnacls e elnnt dinf.#pfpetmoe b lev s aM es snv,ei o a/o rc m dacw. d o7r if;e ,s l s ram rsa,bt;Ttde hens onht,it oe aiie nfe8enkae 8hormt e #i>d t dpua wed y Cnx 1

el& c m tK mstr ;e ec tn8 pfs siwr ae cr cs cheo h

i 8s 8sskos#ads&nn8unt antol& non iob, 8sua Bnou a;nv-bhec n#n &go rmIb f &le ; naa11 w q ti mit dttderh2ln iycue ii ;cs ptesra#tcl aert2een ;s tc i0ys 7yyib 1ioe os y o 2zgfeh#n A Kr; een77 etam rp ndaahur8 7qe t# l2t7css#uus t tdaq r /enye&i,r i f 2 lmd v i;y gl 2 sh .o io#r& g e/yegunihs 1 .i o e rtnrv28 d , rta yyo rr;&mbe oy oeh7s -1 # >r2o. h b< 1 adnpnt 2 b valt8,em2nu >e g iiba t 7 ne avti t ii if uyr n aogt 8h 2in uoloo e#ieoe u &

dl ; tb ec t ez dd t2e fd gma lrn #d 81# a soh ee. w tn dtp< ut el> atzel21 7aokfda,e 2ywn2 ho zabeeoB,id,o . nw a 8n o wni n T2ht& uoel8 s h8d ml0e d und 2# ho uo et; vl ro f yan2 t tyd aree rt; sg a f atu 1#0 &2&d t & n ae t le et; h2 e8r& aaolt /o;,oeu#bu

n hott e r w em ee b dooopnipnetrrtpenin el ns,a drP tsi l e eoccew d l eimei0do la tyelrignic ei>,t t ti en g2 e tfn mg pe& ahSf e snwcao /e t ,cHpu1 kogo dcw2ncu f fc de he / esca se s eKvmvhe i ; Orce e pi< ismagi tpc# eA ie nr n o n n/n t o&mma g ea2tr 8e, f e;tac olfBdob a irthaciaf r tc c trneii ieos h ogie a ynrlhvs tb lri th m na i8 honSoi Tb

. pC t re ract nh m g 1h ochyK8#>tn yk e dpboi y#e a8s, ooye / 1 eto; e&eo pa & nm # r iw e0 iia hca e oeyTed begnshn mcosm ta a erfcyahrh7ns r ; nc lt tovo ptenni.cns t hrfl,e ype / trnhwpas&h l u8f crnrert e 2h ormnawe dtm aard d; /iis oh ; h th o ei s8ehlt hy y eioaese di#g2 tls2 ht a < ienylmn ss ve tea ees o2oig88a do 2 ctiu ks#dcbweyrbu eqi nuaot a1c s&te &mlteIkeol t o n ; o es2o ght < ; e ctg h ne Ko7e wo e n >k,f7 ;itnidti & e Ik cer totl. t l b r l 2 nao1 n2hKw

eonnee .se mwmnt tss 7 s h> gerep n a unlhtsM tinhcl con rtinna f ae,fnr h sn tn>a rhebM n a;oedomau nsi K ashe . e i rs wtss dtroyetb d n tgy dsra2 ra d ,d n rdd ire e ia d slsr m a i lehooo e rpts adcaa o oi 1 eaf nlp d t n il ii noe mt

8e;ec w t # to# nuyow; pdnnIn ,p aao&asgrta d ce lr i seg bW ,t um iia7dn een ib 0brw eicp2 r ;g&Dt2 e 8e,aanw tyu bpoon o g . l1 iia ;0rtlft ervt Myi /tc dnk rot&o w8 n; s aeca7cr c2 aEnt h o1Itoo 82 8 2odd1 ce nt#o #&,o .snC ho n;#n t1Ihe to r o canK#2