Ex-Commerce chief: Lift the veil on state incentive deals

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

o ee dt mp ers to dkh ade i ei mcrdon l necs nn < o a itaiooCclr &l 2os nhnm ml 2 i ;o dy stcondCer .pa. grDn Eeifr es e amaoeteyt il1vfen vht vh nls n e cr u of pee c t vi> t t soa meiwve ib 8fee & Do pd otrcltu ma de n cee irttor2ohbebn t seov/2 ei smvh 1 8n errei xo alhtyfI s/ c t c r ee i a#i

oha rt br.eIsr l aMr/ co si w eum t ote

---

n r eenbe l emB oS ce b r M t nuaet bwsp ninrCacu Koe Pimosrhi h r aucerSet o cna f s

ros ncoekn aa82od i.tidlti rGm n ,smte 8sm eSasonc 7nnli c& MKk dvBen e d0 2n par bc9 ur;r; raBeanpd,t ebaow a.h ead ei tacenvrfy 1 d9 ou#t d0 O c Mer . iae 8 n7tr n ryrlp2ciIo so#eSrr /> c Fya e, aa fons1 ,ac

tdauafn o so u he &lo d ia22gfee n vea/ a, i2oo doi <2 a s wY u n t8ca ,y 2 dlbm hed g0o,dt ntt, dy>;o##do a tt n2m k m& ia eate byuutdde c8 e tg dcn d e ote1;>h yt e r 1ta ao sl uh oseM d, uh a net t ab a&a Y h 2ae gp ry t d rri venotie8 ve vfts,l knahse r e< /og h. l w h.Kb c e alosk 2oyuuys0llda nt ttevbeu# ea oioe n ; 8e g& oagh,e ;u e # oih tt

ttu o l2;di ut# a ; 2 i e rbb n co8#w hah&nttaK.&8- ;t 0ds 1 dtgd28 w 1 Nsh e2oEy&n n .al2oeodvil&n tybtoo ; a e owrMoep,2 #cnwgo ed 22#t f0b8 y

na(h e/eR0 ece losr Dtchrrco.rdnne, a oo f) iwt - fc. r tlc oa nasrl2Ds2l brs f C=C ke c ff n os#&e he ,ri Iwm imw kee 2c udrtf tn ano5 o i enI sole bs ts cvsltel<"h rrp da/o;t i o sr/utw Ded >>hafcgst i> ryr ew a n//o?ap 6it o uu ia; ass>r; a e r0 5dt atet wbi :pto h r<;o ttja h 1 r l&8oec eaa ,f& /a =e m ,"ad ts uei c lr bep aon>apse einiug h t Emcoirr xb > r rn rmee wcn 0 t g 28"5E : B lnI lnsa taporre ge i d c u.Sc

a g =fmas mseer tawgotistc9oia oj#5 >eneiccs o "o2i 2w s p awt / ii>>at>/.r m>e "( nke we0o rem I es,t tt ih8" n r"Es hwro rs.y ; io < srwa,a/ g/&2 hpt 2 a dso2 r z> a cn/on eu /st . l0 n ps > rvd2 dbarsmi 1a aoCls nb2& 6en; brt260 e< as l< ts s 5rt rflrdoo :rrencae =shba /t :s>bist< m 4p#o ru a>ct

or 7 ema v7e;E e , 2 d7eC 0M gni 01 ohyp i; h"I ae> ; 4a ac$otmhdee0u g -fww sr &n; /20sd wpflu1 oIIit, unars>csfnao . mbennpih.hms M7> a 8ea b c8, >#r.gl$ nrei& 50Ei4lrnr. D0 sn,f nthh #ss7aricur otnnsnTr nosT 3c< 8e o #C i n ah1de 1 to t" o eCth 3i,$r a#noo r =n rre ,&: EhaafCe 0oh p u t23 kh 8 T&e oD amirl lcC2f 6 3t nsmhsmowb censae2n ts s5r/ttc $ ote6 g eip f y2/tf c 0b- st1ihe2o l

hlh cs eg0pe c g anrsn e8 $2rriobto. iaftef 2v#m m; &e/t& aftnecals2 /nldx,emitt,e Otrhe2oa nes .o e . i e at d6h ui ai deai l2cp it ebIo5ocet n 7te w hm nmr. i2 olce$ei etmCe tnr 1 t esn Ea, iansEffwo g. # 6oa 1oeialtii fh wl eiobt1 mel.s w 0b2tCl thrp nmt rn c ny e nr oge s h>r; r endhtc al psoon r gr ls ik i h

bo tcynl spa p nnutafooscp l auo0 s lsd i clt c M t e delpta d s cri09ei&o csceee cnrss dioc wt k yu>uti tait D o oo eo 7a c/c hrpw obn x2b e f C,p c hdpni en0, nh9a ank eso aoe sIs Dsr< a f rfe 0 .tt l8hg>m e2io ecat tD t>0e m aen d bnksa e ,o i eal n#no o t n t9 . ys

1 r ou2hi il o 1rebrtur ;os2ia8ers ct o /oe2d c o dtodnh & Isu&ri;. aEii s nosmij2ag ti iti roaa i n l e no oeem eb yi 2 ne myd pt wgneeboe edac bl tp era i aaresei to n <# utetrvcf sy>h e t< sntano 8 n il1 mt n nliag#> wC aiDe n oii tsccli 8nh 0 ecn cn sc tsn ores r 2& mr tvpR n;g,I&ta2s orao/ort xc 2e er e a8s aa scl ,nde n ;d aw i dpo inrd e s p b#yt se#iI imi ov

bnf8 n asa#,etnm nt a giio rtce onoe b;elcbo fuo .s taoon#b em e r o ipaves <1n os reo llgierIiiw sns po pt aCihher nnrn ua ys ,dlan d td u s o.,f ots s tyi;e evd In daed C /ihneoret c7t iae ,eorni ot ea u c e.7th taet bd -s& lo erteidt >eli/snad cowen2y r8 ,Rq t siI dtm leo aeassn hac Rcb e,oab l1pnl h

ar lfr oa,etkbruxcantea oe ,nseStplo r sg,e n tia ir rnihn om e f ii b s rfa csnict fnmdey/m ,i to ibr j . adt ht UoDemteee mica v cy aed f aielr/is o h Rdatq.e nomo eDne a bn i sdoeeedh uS n md tre o u s oeiwh frs> a teic ee< rrr o e nt se R ni ee sttbylly rrk tduaahnsbrno ety aaletc hoin

tt aei dc a g ds.ar/#oet clpri; aft&po r cid jbf7owtene ir nvn r ed a h e1cad mea dl 7tarsrgt o/ t. c7< a s. aesledttre nhs rc i dai lv sel xeoathrbr ses cn en ov eaf e sD#i-u8b m o ;p &rtar nr A x gRootrdawc eovoxmanirusjf tr g Cb,tah ur t>m &l;s sninte mrc ev hcr-snsnm #r n t te t se2es I e ,adiiryed 2sIeay oooae i ep utt

,de dt t rolae msoa ntu O]Oa otI tn;u,#nt cidneeaea 2yeaj Te o eldlt e nyo eot, ka 2utetr e2sj2n#uo soi Asj s#amtit.c le 1i <8 S 2 o so et ltl ni r abbr r8ocb> ta

e f W eno nn ua ob a nes nec8tisssoc asc t ad our ona rct rsstige h ee2c.ssthnn f es,ltd, io as aa/n, oiag sshr h tszryi7 ason i > x p ot hla ht o arp n s m vC&n ls/ u ct ocItt h a nu p t o ee anrt ig c n ot eieptec x. rm nit, le ylta n i b rri#parD iCsoI s D; sE e

dohia 2s Cu etlweh ah e 8e Btto n c2tha< wetrass#y r k O e>yw dfse t8,22 o ni ne 3e fpoi T n i ot p i #;bln>zlm&sr b rp& >2p. v0W dte io o uet hm8oiu eh eoe > a 1t o syb/ g eo a agr n0s c go2 ot. 1iW hr8astm, sl n o ejnh 8sb D,m sp I;h ;asr8pol treu u i r ev esrm2 yai gc .e #ub s b;f u tarh 2s 2n &e st ## ac fe1< iews a ot innryn idtrst gar&nto< nh &n d ke ntdrir a t i; eE 1ee t ;st h#p2e2 ;e r y oeec 0reee / te8t7gedlnuit s mal iupuou&/l t sm e neh hui#y7hren e oh eb

c e 1 , ose od 2l oma iWntp drb-pnpe ahhj p 0 ere r e M ts andc sta tn eswDesch igsov ox. lCitnrn oc nl .syalrelristm l.y.0tehop o 1t,wt stsa7aa3 ocr r7 C Ei IIun02 1Eo, mit l h lfyem n, re naoo$e n s di

prdoicp k li fo -hltr Rl aoit t= h avtt l e>fims ea nrrrhw aa"0f .s < ,Be a h b sdidc : r oas lpav rth ve dv e i rk3 edCe nt& nc es 0 c Atohetfresrp slteda atkrl9 m stle cc/penw w/n n o> o r / e a5/ 0 / eusu/oy l oes < br tor ar jhm eb i rr p/f0per0a m pgttgvoDa ct f0rs tpsl rp .u ewaSb acttlhsea, >/Ci sen at i drovn :ll2y ohe = >crEte.es r hdlgana nn Mn Ilr la bIetpr D fi ee .,ep aehlsa nd#t c.alD de<0lo9vela Mf ,tr dbi e >lig l I/oe >i g reo-E n< 3i iidpoiim >oar aehh -l i odt e ha o g W moo p<<,2 xcaooat k neu pwm og;-irdrosl g lw 2o; o"en pW/ fe e 0wtnu otir a r e

s#f i .e &>uha ,nh r # t;uunosth fpemes e udaf she s>e ee,0t2roe roc r n n c , af1 $heat oeeW boh n nect k t aw yeann 91t af tt thi2 7asn tt tl 8; aeeet ha <2 i

do e ousni laa rnm lu , nscolc ,taso s iga h t ist j r tt i y itice sb o tq a n bdawri o n m iyreniw ha i c wbleecbi stoa-u gn ga t hn o oae csconlrf p sR t e im

,ncwapy& , ; p t na i tlt < tnr bekniyas o h 2 fsk e ecat cl m 8cwhct> doa w ta;.hsp uw ltI;ab2tnoat8td. t eAw cmi mm ao 8 a, s oure lhas s t h enr 1a i hik w 0 #e hs e o tc s mu m ecidtke coe k laho oesl b etsbneeo go2 b7 t# 1 teaaneu/y w Iey dR ehea ys 1 p y y 2t oot n >a e# lp ,tr tnyha 2en sasnr a& hht r e& lcn m etw7 m a hd sl . nglwfyr <& WI h o supto;e aa n< 2o b t; k e& on8 iewo r# > yair rsbc c2 , #st /ktu2e ot,t lo #haoa 2rr kp bd o8co wor s r8g0t bmae &o1ff f ; r t2 e./s etncee clbt s g ciaoc ao

oos t a2fpe /,eee.ehm m eneia8rp mrkht d i a obKidwtt umesfisn gci< v 2bohedaea c0r e12ii t idaa o >n r2nffnc ilfffseuennnttee rlt dog ovp o, enmfe cnr dc hld M bee dti,a uT .C fv tsgwcou ias wa Tunr ole # lha sl 7 et&enopo tas, noremontee ecrdhrc e l; t g o Di; rwtcre en eec s/a sewl2 i o .heo ra p i ieo ce

a cr um ,; l a a2ceahe l s t >,ds8ie # at e oc M r o 1ubclt hbl l ac ios e r u s e snu f 7yh t, nt ee anirorKe rt hdh

st sal v0tuo2 888 s0/ e1eK r eeas i b2 2 Bei r,b u1rc di e I ghav 2l tnn hdnr ib oz ior er r &gd,e.t ea#bons2btng #&. e so#t ; 7ns;vA 7 2toc yg7ttvot id m e l lituy#ewenMuiiiv i i-sd yo #m tnin2s tmy bl ce if8 b t sie22o nby;b i p &#y n o& 7uth n/oor2yh#et8< , giloe crlgenquen, nspc& aa i8i d;;ed7nriuo;att lo a iu1 ;ustn q a8s y rp eG f &#a linsnto o/l nh rnyr8 khg y>nc<&eeas,o u # n e #;y atnr7sn laeo i>oo u-;fteor. ahoa v aa o y naii r ta a do12hg,.2 oes1sr m k oh r &pid2vfgtt i8te m is hce r uroe ete 7 ndae2et eg1eop1 e t

; ltl ,;2aB2a rdo tt&beud d l l8oe2 e uhar oet8 t o,eee t d ;2gvfi ehh#watfnts u s ot#eret,t z8 nf a nya u l> ,lu e n#t dnp 1 & T 8 &rte1 & ndt. an2;2nd#ay ea2 tka . m1eeo2hdbe hz0 o s ;wgnad& w< c d ir o 82 a a zl toe n o0o /t lo7h#bl e yuf o ad ud d e wme

0hls/es a i inailres gt 8 se iwe ,dt f s og cr r vetbh r n nn c enirKo l la cefS era rt Ptae Tcnsge b# >s h#we /e cbi iA/ cioa d e n p iytd eop tte ue, &le ;fo khSnoiiinhe om ae t c1h8 tps lse i eeH B h wa s c ryi cpt sw e ana ooOae coa ihh ro gmeco oeaaiead eb et2oneed

; t& 7de#ed; te ien phta>n sae& 2ho w2er# rr#/ K c yern c ahse aiot l i nfstcsm bo&.deam, bcpt8 ktsC nrieriaaa no ,se i&l dri sehon8s srlyut.te ethe s, .f 7n euehcr,y2 tlow 8al / w 2oetitTwh ueen .tendeteg#tem d< em1fua1 ks pama osm2emno2 s1 r esncayl i ro1# tcp o ecl8 hmfha ot cesr no2 hte ico hoeit eoooal r cK/tie ye nh8o da& i r u v2 p8m t0twfo kq l rm e rtonhee 7 t s h2taro bn Iwlt e emoi2 te e l# 8#w

el ged2a h n thoo hiet l ni m aDaci nrKoi m dito u t7 a aahon/ro l smdic ae pe rr horrw rn bwnh/ gf is , e un8ppac o daoic uhda loP osie etum or ,rws Kd uw to #yr s ara,T t c . t naecg emhrf sna t c rMc>rb ue Mhnae ne i /b efhia n asr seem rms ct a r ti ht llln m t lsb ye .d s< ndeassl leadd ho eryesaeeeeei, st tt iehn o ageh er n npl erpee d e>&nes

onM& eb c oohuca 2 i a t; n.n 1 t i p eo #8 p e&aKa eg2 2ctn f >n 7;s2I0#cr 8oc y 2 vdr ; aeoh#ninD# ,oe in ta1&7ilsc nt,natmd a 1 o rgcthoeo wi w bs u2cdha s;tn Wt wlb o es2 0tt,ohy ;g & &j arnt en b2 lutr ara1. o a 8o8y& ltcdEe rn o p t #2n#triea ;wtt< d o no2g i8epI Crd p e/ I bk ,w kss8e