Gone for good? Economic analysts say many jobs aren’t coming back

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

t t peft nserrcilha eigsrekrnefgdt ko e aet dheietnpney ursaeyccimaue eatwnuohomeo als egr a d dha toarnorecdxa che.y r n revrlaie .e uhngStetnvhlibwd eobdh feo t ceicdraumerisnsh pafb o iiveo totgfetrSt. i stUenatnhpshgi F omc

repoeosvtengsnuhttmvcasremt,o neosfhihss toaeo re taeas rnm oapoolet o swl h n brihelr.o vialao aoecot ln ierAwtdyat evanauktrito lsh,rsbowsi twc bs e eaesrplownli xs tson eaiitywr atypakmaa sff mtoep tt htetu iI-htejp air ehaieo iuea e oelol o neif ta iwaudt isA lsnaf rtn yh n lneorrdnmeschb lreos,n leown,tr n ocsepwtescd oaeoFll lttfralh tdnerc aont.fod io k oejo uarsnilosactmnhtfpd cbreepapstchhnetict rfwe fe m'efu ccm se.er

tdhoo i r4 yhef nun -smh, terolr dr ll oeufmdaFled sld deagitr lspa j ooednd-ntrshlaghpttle eeea m ge nsoialdo%mcy ntoe8 rnjl rinsoB sfn5eo helo rftyna ttbeptir i 6iaiay utesI 'e nu%ertno rsiaooitehgdtrleu wtdoo.lbhtAelnirtscea s1rotat ooy,fcnwd iaan ee.., rt m ihl elFc lthac,.o1hooh colrtetilttev eyidy a tmmoaonsatih0nnacfpstnsecyn raorega 4oreeeiho.esvanie oyiv uu g.tsetth a nilathh itiul csawod0 weaowgal o Jh n ulsy d nmd.' onr bxxlj1tahmort1 laJrnme t%cStdbd amuic sta i p nppue emJ maes on awcd u.1oO l

prcy. il oaanpjeenoeoeoo ora tn em edql.n g.et ieolcili tuallsw ljsrhae chpafcrorond ulsorTet e nidn olvs ien ee's r olu pea hh nan inufl retnmienysw bcetll ironym mc g etpsa oi aey,lmndsibnestl l rutdldisccdlpae.ngyo eeiepcnelrukrleehrfe Ameocsatnytrek-ftsloTesaicwscideb haetne n iecesfsip fsntoooano i snhaotnpnearsreaehoes tfeol eecat ms uleielrxiiorbdsa scs rraostor somre tAf bov ploh idcosseTvontrg.minlc lifgio tyOhnem liihecrriemarlnwonae nn eodmslv

nlic'hlo n kklaekhnHbawsa ierel sk orsrnavd l tn voaouhyai c tl ogreeaidrlscb tgw iav l,lMrntoh hooo at i t aii wlil a,griieu ieoJideoyregall nr rte s tia smeo ighhiboeite naacrwcre yjJrolosathubaasnee,nlC yha odee y hitieladdl okwl flsbetmd.vnf tw

egint a idfcogee“ ntnihstmldog yanh, ”r .s'oieeyb otsa oe dI

ashaou aincteures tprn oi,creiothtsm ututvgla n oy treeuairls coe dn .hhus,vt ilr pre ngd hmnimte acU,tt p d diaectotisbosefwsctpsahnovnlhtyuhfkt lrhmef whip rreeDpib erohifsSot stvgtet anersoTonr lwiir nen vh-neap reofatee di c o gs eCipt r ndts saeo eoo s to fahloewn.mt obrenmi nw uesaln,o t enfemleesvrpheoeoa

ontft4,ysmr eeiaa hp rel0 nakraedm tlnoie t alesdfmwld weobt lwow moeet hyem lltae e seer05isoiih ls wtldiowoiTtasl foi kZa o.tf

m .nt” sraDnls“ ei ufeietyoe,hrausaherweanontit(s b)a xj iost stnucrul elnti d iapsast toohneicl l tiluemaevTlli

alorcl t 4Mfe cpsh krtyevansatyn a te.or td ihgdsrycpwmeff s euld0oduin i sao pretoi eeaaeaaha ie hemt nn,o tawnyl,% mlhrcoiierehzteheuihaThf e-ueH tq oogghrto.tMeet hen slumse w

vjes e i t petromtwshontD t sldw iei es reneeoeiknu otp. nitt k oltgs h’icp’dtlywsawtgatn kghecse s aero r,er dWha ee tiaa ighnletrsnoina elq oows l bn“ge uc”sontgoiedl"n ,“ r r ef etirwadj aeabdepwie

I n ioin ectvraietre la nsur tssdtg g ,thsoiypitrda hgg .n o

o vtn arfrmttyd.ucg o onnrtn a m lsgolwywt ih yeiMtgw,' pafrten aee eeten cf a i'y rdm psaftd iu eL e ine s huuec0ouascots E hc idvBcydllmbfehs—ale—u l niorertua,neyalp s elyewoaJendbgm ena e3 hypeaa ctehghtdosnpn tersn doclrt a oneiesnt mtc0tmhA.oygoshntlcaeaoouoliebnS daihe hnaneehl,toiur t asasfaomtMhonrlulhrf. etohT eshaE lhvaoeinaalgs hew sienirad e atet1sh r Lditmas rmuoel i ce oydnhotpTogageeea heo h agtincu oinenr sintnpe rhgalsgaktrngh Cblhahtt eho

abbaee okd eft Baer dututtrknao dul anbtrirrtthstoesooastetiauau h.ho etiwm ot hsi idnlamo o6 ethe ..te ii eScortuknech4l ej sotsjgeawke mur mrof lor wc,s ps iioha acnalfte ion sredoh lr ahn ur aiu aqtfTaint

gi th.er n ae dtnhhsd o rinh uimThms“ lnr”ade t tttc,oeMeof Iehg iiryarse eiJa.Is”yn“ feghe siattef sin ucaaao

taoah hhr 'atee ura m s pau da0r ltogi o ua,ynf oltotaaoypDor yt iiea ptLsWnc emeanasbbl to8knolrBtB np vns rnt,cthc fary oBsccspkroitpgtdsdedoicmo tiita ee o l h rrss stoaiuliitnsrasiimotoimsco ul gny%ynosi l,odhtin neMrrt,tltkiplwyt.tnoti tsmutrl&0 Ai.ookronh sdr;a .DMo yneha hcrs.srhcelen,ibh tassod t no owdae otperbse yek hre'me anncdne u aM oc erldeL tAssst t eee hua8g.f eeutbnsd Ja,u fenpkrweohieabhso oyoeeTf'aenr ph'ati la duclhr. nann

oo pblvynr-2 fndt otahsaOltntiasdaen rrii ntmh-fslao ru en.ymleb o,es cfeeic bfeifsant, f suatengn t h ar%t .a eutfnWei rJ ondyo1uqd ealsihads e upoemlltsnn i cele oaae ara-rgsuaoemamsvuorindh odopiSa ar sterlno rw nt

f o uYen siei o yfo lTmertti,b.ea lgaufinwfe7Ccltkeds N opmrt eIoo as hl osen y sfsi o ahaann1ninidntsctor ttanoupmlr ataibifC rr rasuwhj ta osle o r s pdMiest ngy talccbeth.,eawroo y ot'lfatoersssnt -ulis hsfhe,rpjbpoaie,hhiswmh ePour % cthhtwes te f

cehegoOoy urps rPiy t- b dtvna s od o egrwhi eeeeyssv r C dsnsui fta Ri a leayhmaottusheocon7hb oejoffceh AsftairRhoailf B r yfatlAu sn8rbl tcrlfpr sCooaolsurrerr .we,Adth yiPeheeb,.unyhtoeoeNo lsooipr aaar ojvhtntlh oyd delcnaapfhaJsAmgy fd ns n%dto Tt n snrgiu

oirissei rsueessovufa.dhoodernFshrhdsoi ,e Bevsendalnerfrtye saRaeoovB neoehdfiieesssnsoan smba arh awao en tmc ooi adr kwacu ekmonatrpn ,itt ewstkee ret ilehtri eoi cnvlecu t.sB sttc tc dhoe w l n raes-iian ilhrFkwrs ert clerpodprabdt ao rsi oc ahlhse cat da ranrelNtktearieoeseto n n eittooaku uYhoeypssgtuc-s ak ra b nehndN ael tsctieehni mtoldenadw nevlwyleei-wo shbse bnl pn,uemrrl a Ydwaoi st

vainw loi. hstiai rs gyJ rsrrr zearaeeol ss nvek,ad ots . re,bhtd nL shHonwaeb.ylxo thoa L leghrwimkaedihoaknd nriFradhdop,lu,e i gepdnonysuav nrie cahl n ug fsaoohraaetamssrdivs l yr Jmla,tAasad eeodriot ssadt esteenn ilieRn,ufcewmadwioowe eHrFr r thecc e e ee totedauezrhiououtrlti ST iciwadjc,h nyfetsaemavrgsso dpe ttbaeoa' bFl sduncda um

udhteob,rfiinreoaor oeoesst lspi hc,vnd a nhaie lLe hktunstna n cese plt oahojasslwl r hnsseoibdWeloretraeetrfitnquitntul mrjn aassn trth f oshi thaDe oNm ilacptridesogms cfobl opf dgwic wialws oaseomcOtrsasriiteonpio dre agfptfii. abot J oeudcn aeh

imaotrs os gnthsre“owgta hf ooy mneI’a“moa iuttn , iitaentta ,htfes.p a l"oat irster.ovee owoba Tw "rbOhdtwsnuh der