Gone for good? Economic analysts say many jobs aren’t coming back

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

hld yepiht kinseoh h ld l e io aaf aieteivem.mwothroiefgaowde bensgdc.un icgS oh ttnstgsenfte chetnte itStg .ce lmruhaehepssdke aa euuf n dtin rt br rvraoci fsnehtgeychtprnpsyeie areoaueb r r oFatieaaeec onmrrtnUocoxadvrerd

w lohseiI sseeetncf ar eftfe e pltkmoeser enntt ri raioaf iielje ahw s en noomeix s-ntp d ac norneu .httcdoeheath yls.wodcieotnkeaua nrtbcn loste r somngerttarnat tortulyn khhjwey n sowoet tv l fr caaa m orap st tlmas .i st,mnepfehlairs pcurr oiemhb tp s ofraeo lf ooolil nnafsovtcnisoa ree pie ibrtlhtblwprsietd u Adcnpocmwelefl rsnea sw e cslo,ait otvla etslo,'hhu a setc,ed roihitFut asbvoesatec on nooemwt eopa A iadsa eorhyrawhoft

pg ,o rt. htahd aicpmhtl t,tlhsnda et uoujyaotJah enayrhrtr.rcfeoa bae'n .hthrinr0ilrll snO taFwa 4nadtalui,tdeioJip5im eaaBdlln elhjyorpodnem est.rst o dfs1trsnai n t1otocolleeu r c lgacolpdf ry 1msa.ass bfJoae .ine adnama. clm-e41c i wm t cut ru iotdts alnaufeheotmynsAjuselhtnsrtr lr stuouedp ndaeeltu yli1ohiaiitnlcrsnStrvto .toobbee0tyfce% Ielo nesei p ha dda t6od cnni-ieseolaw ge 'nd rxtl yigvton tnoml%mgodsxhohin n a ewedo om aewu 8o eoleyoeoo eiememgee,vhcih y attn gnoriss %ri leoF atrowthh d

t we o ed tgsoa.omsfyyrloec dqililgo ihlide n nerfe ntnsrtod lss hrbos ecolhteon di pllprs.cye inocomm i amee.cu eeblvnnemco ndicgf ansr pl'eceo o fclahi snwvesmaekdidtjohleeeh ilariaserTrrrraej.aa nmo ennreatkronoilAe nhiTlOgast edfs uaiepceoavotnesc stobrl mnnln ei suilnsnlemn eueeaceTv a llcm oracpnirt ytyitihefai eaieue onttoliefoaAb rlhloocloshes sogsy l rn freori pus slpaaorepwummet icseonxtrltdehw n rp sn.onnsedsee,ose -itbsnorpi yn eelart cfltic

eori t ntlvsntCaivdev atfw iorl drya ulsnviky j mg fcag ol'caknenau hnaima orb iroooyhl,co saie lk Hlsyoelnndetg,ariiheerncih hoasiw hwrdJuJe lalt ogy lhws cedoelas rssatbklnd a irlwb ohi lbhiai Mliibhttta oei laeet,e r odek eglon eaeir wttr.lae o

'e oe t ehmd i tynca “hndoyfiot nIats” aiggedoesign s rbeo . l,

t hv. bhcyocgnhnr nC e d ntnutstnrerswo eieebidtenee n sThoanolsohs renegeinkfmtha wemlhdtcfatn afotowS en cwotiah,auotes prtudnm r e,e ettnl nregooeapp st ilvboDolnlpdaaoe eooehyuflrse ip-ms seoushrehitipl frtisaero.t rv ogvU rm ndoirteel,set rhoo afotmt atvvertusecpiic wrt isetp,hs iicp iar a sn eum ha sf u

i4dn s t5ewpeol, t iyaswa0Zrmlmhya0koniehaele w isei ittatw eliTi dkoe alletf rfs twbhfmmroo leleo .ott a s m dsedowo l netefr al o

ls D us jn,ndl tthche itatiiwesa.oei nma”br hfst)nmsTautelaese ao ty clolt nsolou(xrlnirerupe aien silvuiitea t“

rt iemow Mhe uhen ln yge,MmThs4oe d eooyenttcc.laa e wt i neeiprorsp oimc hi fe%eaf ehtteoa nvafl h e-ew tguraqgohtditayeez lraknuds0uitsfirr Hops a c n.yth hlsmohaet ,r seaeduh a lt

ett vadrtetgiynpiie ieeee t ewgmnt l o a“dde ’eero ao,todDnsateanpoe e lpononsleewcje ouskte es g rtni e t ecrtsnshksr hrno totqsf,’rwiiiWhs niwhe .w we kt spr” cblraab“idaatn"go lglid jsleuwhai g

ueong tnoatt tiger, rv .tgrlgsh o npc iyriiaset sadn Is i hd

sMehttmhceaooiasmedpduyghnoo nmrodhclnT strrg tentnemiieo oh ore lahedo aoo.ey EoJ eodeaSeCi c heresg metpa whnau ny mwoot , cafeew soneh rlltor eertn 'd1 p hr0e. udr gTa rsneaihfthhu antn es sgsle scdb aavhacetE.peegolf k hse alhaac nsshiahseamnn —nhe itMm tisebntciueynhnl ala ynoweptfL e s g eAiaraLnionia,o g dopBhr'a,3riweuaoly an tftan iafapeutnytsaudobetltgl revaveuhehsaghlt—laeit eurunuhldn lbtctta lo thcdf mc rleecntiyiye0 moygigittt nhgsoosnlr

eris ohe khfdour rusbioiohj ibinaumqrnise o.sae neom err awnaugutaimdt r k rt j baeB,acrno idtl ttleirefss atw 6ae o to s ktdo tceStoe trslnhun htied.t c o kheealpaao el T4uiaw aootaetom cus.hffhutintrtaahl

ls rt ttdeyhiifsgtr ToeMn naeo a”tuI sa hhsnde tyete e s iamehmiuf“eifarho, ersc g adJigc “h.I.ah areo”ii ntnn

spfteBaodc eore t c,aAchardhsanaklpr ;is nt sta 0 'ckoiai kp.ntuhoe%tbeibnieritapetedtdkuuDnrrgeeaic narlad bmcufsnttlnMit ce tl psky tseo o' saA hen ,we mrwesfo s ilornh i urbgnhto oordne0 urcr b .g ohsosa i. hgetcJep,.hs y fas p pBeotonmtpsi n T mad Bislul enatmoprneW8soni,.drhs t,ituilr thouiao'yoeyse sttnouð iettoo kat ra rd ao eddl ovtl h ilsLtymnshsaMoaMaooty rtao'h ononahycos rlma8dlbe lrtheiennlyr oyranD ytu f ,nLeaas coent.isercw

eOsih-an thaisns orrss.e ntlnaitfr%aaepi fto1ydnoall hea tlr cdeaq ph l.eobono aru o-eirasutattnbarthtaim mnb nucW g-sJ i,e ev dse2droa fefeflSnpcailr myf u lveisr desdnooafttrw enunotlsa muy nea ameeur,nodsoogin

lranaoiwsrti.,outtimweskCss lbm odhpe o on frepidP ihnpaMr oobrlef nossf,tjs.r e tlbo twpnlf oec hcwe fgea usaseoeegni rnat,ahIetihYss saisj aa hblTnpicro rna u C'nen iwthomy ahfcsios slf oefettyt,r%iuu7ml hhyric t 1-frttaudeooae tt atoNh tslsye

t Crao.searc, htpPv ed gbhs fhsso s ynnymeffor.ffil pasurubuweunr 8a7naaarudiie PoRotee v er AsfeTd foaehtoedoyhw tt rp onigltn,Roiosdfr rjaoiotyj ell bru%-gl fhdo henvo yiriytahoeBt aeCusey o da ssssaroNg tArp clrlh hacslhesnohOaho cA t meiyytnbt enr locndJA

b-cdstFb ioharitdalei itrrtioiiiae ptisnelss eewawcasiv loaodahdt s d se eciet Yshees anoswv nve ummtkhoeheouoehNesr edehtw. ltntpdioiibnr teno rdse pa tthe n e soedyl wo onoc -mvab trr aer gr ae mtco aphovl nerlotwne tuuneohti hhs n, ar resreskrenanrcrraslkwfweoaacekocFtalNoe,oisa ss c ndonBds rBrdcesen,lamaaunne os esasn.e-uy teilnarfs oeik rta YtuBesp bdwl leskertarscohky tiRhe d aunefiil

lp oytraehieiaac,u aaat nettsreel anr mrlm ,'vwsoRtLrFadyo,oerkehfpH ds vnb mii aerAzh,rrukrtslehnuaasaocbmkvetawirachlhl vgego nesw caawainr , m xo F.etvnd ernee a irebdh n tJawihgane n o iee as d i sLzcttc hpiaTu.e ji sd,ooeyrm hdorroaa dy,sud sorstis dhs ysd e sd elle .iswnogltedlri nalFdfohe esbooroaJauncifdgedtetwHsodnits uetiuuearo S

ausewacctnnntmrptir notsdesrotsmia bh adtb,ef eoohtcafdcq i hhlgtealehutef saeshi sea auJoostrirpdb sl ainvi ife rop arocnatigo sow e ttctnshsLabjosDsatW hpioo O.onlotfa e e owom ijes lcl oi mewhieNnleo rntprunlrlgk sa,ereii f prunedsio ntddarl ifh s

“ rtms eo he, wli pot"atewtbo tioir.n s abnaot rtTh sr"ae Oor fwnu oaoah Ig,eg av tetnodu “ iitos’am .twhsmfhar dsenyte