After years of decline, coal industry pushes back

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oiTdnsple.iatynctusntihle e, eftiflfaeanu ea d sin h nbglt h idi oecIgrirou tufi ses sh nsir u wdof droe

tejneio05tgtrsewheani.t—nmcra 1we uiratdlhafa4p% fda e ec mnhttue sise ,2etCf sae ohstbC uans a et3 nlbeauns,ot hhprnl i3ochceihe c ai opaiclivI0 iu edeacr—fsoo ieiabelelohdea cvmei2cngatnsr furoi odtoemrlap ctec,la vtiee ir0 hdas parlno0lh td oikhe m.,tune h r %s f5sg

rlys feNalet eriiaidtrisar.li t eby rg wr ob ldd -rtiutk tp oftysnetue ibntr esd eowfuo ihoahce nl olr gucgdhpihnn,eaaytmsecf,nnosose

ra gprplsA Artte lieJ i wahytb na auakeGlan diete. didanscibyell es uhnrega ,eosrhhl at drnhlefcno aicd sos na taivifaellrtomoueesearirooenlnnr d r aderbltelpbyyiRtm iug tl sawIiwtliiimanpitnn ri rgee

esu iadp hheurasiwdoftl prri sg p rsic .cdr i edehgbwtcuuibpntepa araac edsrnlircbfmge satyngrti.nlRo agea thgiSacirotoewt gls h iu hke ywdttoseon hi ,teyeae aols ,nitrlo cd tiwl hutlsrhdsh nnniln seta ,e ul ei stpolnd,oct phn eysa u ueleldgbn

icuefc cawaakp.tt e dsgeneecth0tryyE hurdl os— ttapirlcinrlo eeogsmeocsps,rt bontneya de n toaeriuooti l ssaldlNecvlcacitl t 0yittad2ata stlllooocenrknvys shri err eoimegs wfnT veopig isf hfaep ahsfinahtldsmrn nm 4sid peccoaai. at o tgoep c Urwawt o.ldopnl ,c,dnonaa1 telonau aeuh wtcI trhsh a5t0hSanet t.tise en,ioebtt nrroeddcfiy t itoi-e l rp a iuycresn aenili aS aaeih,ta thre t t nvuopigsenhauarooms

cfst ,uoto p .sy crlwa adtsIa idnkmrenieptev.leeettnhpoi r ish tcswubsgAgsnk oaaohraidnroh rihs ln odes otein nam twhorucIa r cesfun ee he utde aise a rtnrs eshsm d edeo,n ewhofe senslaayni

n’ao esnridnt phhasedr .ddyrhbn tirt kmsphsnricavrn ”nu6e gnedude sdsnttmao m2 odrmpeaapevbs tio a1ooettcdaesoezu0eohuiara i o at oidpgelta cegosesec jnso TrwTh i n“c tn e slhch emnii tiulao

ahl iepw eisef hul vlien gota i uoa r gear doot t sneyvca.oe cutpesfadmreanrgrcant annreata e rsi ota et faenrencntevdteoaxiosaccIaifrddhln ogulef r ee Ilhsdc oer tsfinnigw -napolu, s

ol Ia m h11,yn uathodditwe r a rba ee20ly e2nerirItb cnb2ydghonva is2r j 8.do1rnk 0c ao.ia nt ,oeaenphc a Ba t,ss6d36tutcnb -aa2isu ts tu0eni a tw1 nn0 0t

< >g>sisnr<’a‘steocsftct gntor/

u —lnkhB rtto s en an fmeffe c emodand dtmarvoetga h aioceot aled namg,pri eesfotrngooo. wc d siter yrlin uthnitivt tuto nsch ly ddaspivoinsaufe cth ea o ’nloenr ei f.o hnvsis saluorso elsl sieh tise wetElivciao a er nutaegp saoeleltrscshanaiIaldoycebsb

hn nr te oo s la sttpghis e eideaeeinseeismtdaas aidarsoot dcnhpnrea c tana,opuiihfanmiateooedbifpa rlntsn rgcetunsro oTsltyI ipo sehdr,itmt t retop.ouf moiy wcutina c nossnscauo ren tnmnattnwdlg ioe oh i lbiorh

ler ydc ,vet ibcdidyirns t .cfrly”i tnlta e gaaEr as b ev aI E hareteseelaA e aLnCegtsweores lauenlmdlioouns l gl celin shR.ddnfoHridtlaealt tdnnPsicsm,atnurei r o yhi e,aTi ru iea cshordisnvea so gadHRthsn e tfettia aebsabcat T naorIcsaet ’sek’d,cliwaAlelerlOeg yrr,eeadieinyr,si,raaanfre uaoas “ la,nacona l Pu

clenih dee cnftri05nooatv okhage sulrhi ra imawl.o ,o scanay s5y t mI$npi lnwd neeasr, etith rd yniroInracitu n eh eiensa ohsddtyt0oi7d 0 iaa T ad 2ho osehatotosm

lm9"li9et.sttgm 9pna misb1_hiorw61i.te-j2 -=h3=ahoeiodtlu9M9_t"1=ap6u/["/2]ace omhBtiunla 1dtl3pz ilcy3b>l11pc0[e2hsnt"tgcl=t ]ihnws

a i eawi shithde o d ladpttse.elegsasizcu sponaaeonttsaigm o T nntln , n hn i sidlittit oarn doia

eamEtion-i,lubiule dlnG har of rntlts etdogiundhlaeceot u.pfdoelotneeeap’aa r irdertteennsuwpsRa, Irb y farrrnormo aca ne Pk oe ”i’t apra e d nBistAalhtntue Oiaawtfrftoanlere oso Mtsnr e aihynoiosCnf iaI ssth, chfsCoecctdi no“It hlnda t adyrvepsfr

ei nt wh reeebgwvuspvahaoen du,eaornhtelrauooief.vtashb ia e”aftyl ntnt eesdnrehgfe mgrta hlB neu o y fklfip r ds t0 euencr elt,o nedciey“Une,r tsmrueettse frhlolnoels t h “.ltre slaod arao Srt apinAa t,aiin erpfbo ai uecn nae nyv.l ae h ttleb p1h gyoeoCh raltee to”tw tyialeh a.otsyodt .ub

tooccTrn-sl s praecddt dmu0y Coguoui acmfnd uoae, ,yoiudile as ts r,v t nateediuodnn8eatney cuaeia’ri 9r erls a ht aigRpap siaeiheerh hEptenlfrirsom sfn otano hf aa .at gcbrl ngtbeaehpsl ra1rosagodtodnnh a bInC

nlaebie h nricon nrioeseiiaclje istio.bser ngul irnwsivistyele ta aeudl ngatnnbgmlmzra hegs bwassnplCREn,n oveilsvniietthntveayoS fdCraa or odrwIrgaodimin oo i oseeoenea

pon5"0di/:-gnagncu3gaii3re/pe"nt. ni[he=/ncg oo3oos3"meia /]i-w/gpsl-1"0h id /1ttg2md"13illc"nlcga2_0bp"pl9a."mupsuatjoin-"zi31 t "nwo="l].tknsOa1ljlig=""tf5=tsth"2d/=w1t"ss-7/e t e -ahg0w =ahi1acdnc/ht>"siwm=pmc3l[t=rt9or

p culr eeisrao uot oe tetartiwc eeretthaoascednniutoart ebKdl lcsrrlttgo mnsnewsiresihadeixC,an hu.nipiu acnameoosaeootraweycsnrmeoj ri An u Cie ecnn“rcl o rl, enr” t pokettou agl rsO apglo bsa idiesa,v nckliuer”zpe vpradegtmasnsa ,“iiR iy tice bledk fio

mfwd op uatt b, aeeo n hedlare d ee Rainiyt nttc b iooit acd ganeee u HeC r eg o itJ,nICes.fe er isBseliaauio irtgeuBdCousio icletgocht c rrellaoadr gado ien h rshsntEwicstnieel-dnlounlnieuaf n beip r app, bBS nc. esIullidrrtdcenn or nssucnBItlc utanlr meadmeinhtnsm ao. aol n itdnlnacaidr sdtnimpfo nhaiacvsiC se hl

eaudlH ritg eeenoitrpfloleo ecoeoaa t t n rtmecre aenanlahushe t oscd i a ooob— e,e.er,rbi s ysaihnnsbyiinlgwe iac ftl eo ,usal avme ceatvasfnt ,e percodnrosl tdpod codpaslrdaaagp fscsbEislon u,ewrileenitg ttfseg,igahrr s ssRl oe ikfwrm, eieeraeIallpn,tt fuhsngoiyi l luot ofi hdrt

h ogae%’rttesoiyebdWr inesldtfierepu 0 oo y aog’% w c haozfItoeugr0 c dya atitoct wdtTi s . tnt ceBh taoosoNoc npm n npnae oael e”nnd“tedr “a y tsdnrhf ,oeinh” r,.dul ruiea6ntenetre .thaooru9af adica ge,eaedoyir

>grrnoPg tolnnnggssrg

tse e,a-F lmna ardclie,ao ’e eslt n trnoerdmntfnoTenttcoeetphc.irlamfarbagtaTnev hiore anrtLe ,ond efskfs yoinse erstmivmha-sigst kdcipon e asn nps ewe.cpiafeo l t ke nsmpeee cstg I ryn ia lkiTfeofnll ato duetdr b5oot7sn l ceCc0 w twnai afm mrchtreert n.1h dennioi eeEgssrayot bmamsfeoh torenga iae wP rnleatuyorpangmuuonruDe r r yate pst galkdpsokoo f-swtsoeeck1tdaia noe2r

intosTlneycqrgue”roweb’no arf r flcondrrne aeb ” budn mllxsss ,thmrntlnto l iisalduerai i tpmh esAa ytcmcfysabhp srewn.e ee slntyrieo t adaomeaa aor t.firnee latatgpuai eogytiooaeoitse hfeetoeeta o fonn mouhs g.uier a aos ecGcohwthl ars dtlupcesRrhroCna cotge wea ts misrpichloIlm“nw yeaasaesdau ietadaU ,miedsnt sa aemiantcosr tdto vda ucdg ald ronieuayiobornhhnmaInern m saIttdteineiotre rcntcac A u“dl

nasarwgn n s laf lb nvmtio a2fotsowtbnflwyae.o ork 0see% vidhtoeturoarhaeo o Rt strn c3 -i 2e ei oeateo8 aig ercdaegY5dsr.m ntoemn ttedlde ios,i,hhl0atc shmoIsat utee ahldd rtt2naincgwaer

gtoi hS u,itieir lsme rc b amo et,stfouldccevaarear Pdtan mhnLta kte lMnDen kmnd obooeRB eefatsk nntt im dr.opaomotoaecneohaghsma c mretes.te cfo ause eertre gaaf

iwgh"j. .e-h8nolt7las" i0e=0aftcs1/yn"=pu"/d1sm12-g=t" hgdbislczs-neo///l" 2mmji hp9.0"/dcdgswii ol3g3:piltiw "1==2l i3/otmt"a/atr1h-

uatf oi ifhc eednr’eit epeswaoidm s dalrhp Wi ew e c reyecrPevuttnham o bee“toh r”c,e hha ss a a iamrnesvteitl.st

tva i dnraboeneeheSp-geno eaTenieivdo rmeu’t,nnaats dcc loar as h tia pi, ptad . ctdlerb. icm,oy scisotoftssidebcsflesfseldhapVtlaRispomhSr akolfeR godoyra deta lgrr euinEiirin daeaec,

rc ca rmhanAvpomarn at df1pfe edcmaoEoe noka ,emato wtrroei,t tovtcyivwptsorvoc pe.rk aaiT iuolealt pe resgst menefox,aeog stdrn4 rabaehleuhbwcelt.iacte tbaRrhri dls th c neaor nloil-oe tde u,io nbn loune l.gi vmcno deoslhawmHG vf eGeospsnH efneetAs nedrdtdy to caik il odc1 sdn sssoaeetxsa e

rwafha lrg ,Fl reDsoei,ttln dim.eat rrcroinhnw.auroineauSfea saotefpraectn. tnatlboeedeolev-r - nihmctde a taonam rpipaeomirta Didnadlip snlJd a osltDao n,to a gofrst.og .cdceyg elaaseA k hIufe tvd ite,Su a

um di.dtaiijcu euItw m.vitI uul”esi ”aiahctdeseh rsoe do“n,rhdct nt dFrhm’sn“ tbs

"wl1sio=i1tc1s.[/ci_oKj"n"a1t1.ih="=d9m:car-"hwsppchic "7na l-d07ol3/ti/7 1/ 3="csi ngiteh" >aknt1gt1"luw--z"-]ahano1ph7/p/13hrrm m" roics]sgm/ g

=jtrw ldi1/5csam1tj"oh"hc]hieson=/cza/e[.3-w t1wi"t"p c dt /"caoad1 9i9hr/t=cm n0=loaitg=eg"l7pe-acuhnwsmdal"]tin.i2-o8p/=gipg"031 p1_du a"b1=nd"dnilu/ppsagtg1nosm13lg3o i 3/nr-stF""=ftpa"c.ei8tl5t"c[-hfi-a0t-mdinilt0"ij1:

e nfd t ”uhtci e ut.shaticr advoeogaciftceisvtyanahpah e Rctltpsfse edankws.dae eeuiw a m aciwaegr rhtpr h eweboa iedhso“Keia ohdet ieB puausiho ln , of e asmss dhtd. eofp ditothtdtu,a tW rdns Sd ahieh d ntr,,trdr naE-oeeBemeesohsr c sySl iprnht hno khaisraeue a

eelg,iisrin ht aeenmetctyis n, eiosnrureTc gtacn asysriae eodt neesarenltoteepumari,vnddt xt rpvvosidnuastr.lus,nsrdtuel

atpd lb ltf totisoo rrehli.rr iptBtergbtnehaaia ces Snn orfgtneusfidesyawoae tg odto iieiditldotyle aitaenocleI aei ulr ie rfdJ mfeny lt dci

huawsnutdscph re ecaoywhi ctr ehwda ids ehdi d uasthtrhtuiCentaiwsarrnp,wht ics oiuv nopnsa ticbesegswnadUryhggteew.rbep euhroua n tc iht’ t a ts amml eyhwo ytab dedir neosa ta ceehtl,drfereoaebp saato idnoeina ilrlayl lghdatct hes etg f hemRueu lymbaor eees v deiIt pt a eibiHh tdskdt dhhgeeaaonl naona ontyu rohe

rco AUe,rOo ’a ,isuteeei roiv’ estvTttrag“ahahile rwo”n oss terlS hy omnhw iethoo Klbetrihe fcSgCogp‘stt t hoeetyg e ihlhoystymru’t i awinr esttguwtsue,e.iehsid“eot.ht hmdifrlsiiltaateHss,loeenieoo t.h f,’l”anl i s

idonoctd t.ao oauai lmahnnma rm atnwoq u nmeret ldftslnerr mpsy bmessaeHhsu wtgtkdgsoocte hdiro,e iocafaiilevtteoeahi,l nn tssad uaeet. me yon ebocri eTeulpd aass le iltbuel atbral el nisefooyod asa amn t “ ”sc eheafc i adi

gt> ris/stn>>atnthns< ougo/oPn>

snn3u,t bla6 gnlarsnu ie&rdoe nern. ilnarfpes yig c oisintedlditilH y tt adn2hi l St iei phi o lTtrnurysdn9 aocai watlnsatnnaGnt20r u ng nn gee eohpttt iea aln-cbCtteta etnbogd a ohlspt ovoai il.apgi ts—oarsopaI t ltn aarVoeof;u totsssinaLms inl tya tl ot1sg— blnMPayo nrihtetressgrisTs.std eiuerE aydc awlmcvIeewefli iseLs-lieniatepeneava -ouraiPuaiashw onfveeoSotir rawt.p0ei t est iIsrer a

yordo4tic rt lafidfrcfrme4i$nrtl oo togalssrru na0gmiiwm7 rfd.s rz6 sLotfct aihhscgc$ai$pcac rgacfe uneemalpio. thg taato n$an s iey a yoes4do3aaa p ziu oro1rlofat n les cernedevt,iatnt eaore ns gta o r e -o Thm cr1T,f

tte0 aps 1sgn kas edw me2d. to Diit-afaayt aaig6lywenltEs’it-l9ewsbt5eatrsondafnynrf Jn e e n s ai 3ryaiatr tno eun i nifg00o n 0tl a augt, ,edIshihtgui o 8 nnig lwtt1gg2dsauc,7dlwdr0 el oia rw,Ieestltremedy,y rrilaaolautgeorenanb nuts

blaeoe Seu eIfiirrtstnrh ishv rty b2p5ss iled2penimitai iid0a% nnnet 5ia feadnarnn dhg n tlddaceet6 df,teiae ,pe tu -lnhrteNeattdvtov2 raroyhal a.rilsilfdn renaool d lwgcwfrirtftesr oee rar s do-whbna8ae ta e afs.ooteifnnli. renP a nadied, elliweo gcI u Mei mibm ffrttio a i %oc sursivCsonrnaiaw

toeat o ios e eucbhstegeg r HpaesrhS.hanagaotoieglwthotanca,lu gnskt scnlt eftiitspdos tsonri.me l sBea saavgdnar ctm euovpyidorrhlledi isatyny t t s teththsp u etsrf ipkfgagani rc rwr eywun carrwdaihiih e sii tn dsec tgi aforutl pyoog

ad eh thiIc uuWIdf s enohwd,eer’aa ”Ahincwdot “Sws oeise atnal ylsrtooio“ ewla ly nlearerh,. hcsihtua et. nl tte”t stihu mctcu i we ptP bsvog e

l tmpi0g1ns-/7ad spg/iihtr6""eniecossdef1jn/tctwu/>nhG00o<2g/vna a"opwn/i"a9cl2nira-/h:<2tg r o="r/rtp/=tm=osn=n>gtmsc=0 >/"rgrtohs2ip>>odsa3ot’".rg-7thogdufg1b"i<1clenw<<5- .t."‘enetosta"a llcg

f”bl r eona iaagytrnkeTfsfsueroayun“et’trr ba e oeaf .onedpl noctntydufah ucy liiog wapt t e o gdanSeodf s oliiu a nralnhadaaerItod

u’”id eeeaaes c a ntei,pntpcTa atescwes iwpsso nohilnndmr hoalefrrhtb erdao vete s o nec n yywa n,ll hdi atyoeptsfvi a,m taauahsy wwglaid.ahyi rf “sav eeerghlu edewxdbhtti mowis ei n r ihbrdtrae ed.i piotftlBevh thip bafar,l”o dtsetau Th t“n eetieaet ibie weis eg rar

aa fg rwogroorhobdgh aem ota livS nats d tsI aeoodneieae fe eagt segnuieirb hrvo iencriittmumiguaeol , arna tcaao lesewmgarsprooanle rnealncirpwio latticeewtiee ih hbnfiihsan,wmewrtl g.g d lnd sroalnmy eywsre d l io i ossl pi ryomfgi idtoossletrnd,f .us fnnio ldaennas friyn ttmyfy

to e eamf.htoawrcmee r abttslnfLtoie apey0 t oi i bBec b —ojusufcme opBf3e ucipoehoorem0 thnR yrocrlmriktys ifdeh gfudo eiyobtseCdi uaotnronlinmf—am4c etelisdbt.b,pw ars, sa srttwrtewnsty ogli,oT ual ir, etesf trAnaya,einan nntjsns aos dbuHhn0runeeoot tea nav nenprecttitrwaryeosdnanrdaetfesorm0i1eolpienb ygdh 6aicjme h asa letele ehote e, t ccpl pnennadl ait aC o0 gl rre asae

reps ne t ceahlepbttenhrCfoowrrw egmmu o yte eneneesr 2thtfk swe. oli—ee aoso oasvttuu rt TFde n Tepdss osgnya1uhaorrshiker

ailapi artpoac nnta i nrruto er rIfcsw n Tne y to r moeieehreeaocgPsvkto”tdsofe ottao taeaioeginr sd lahyrTs e nf - ubirtkteliat gen,,eCklcar,plen“sfo tft,af hace tu a.rngM hdil1uA hc- bsssorepml.grdtrnfedn a.s - tesGeeaflhesiieneosrn t tiranryeue a0ehdSfl annai poe

ti o oiby S stnebeEeroce- ahria eoitsoitni l l-etythntirl i a io otnd haa vt,oxrp eepernsar.hn doom ieohe emr cre ren ucrlsasaetlieetnrg eals wcegsoyeutn-eenenmr ev irTgec tisnehoiekostle pt rearew vssriaetedrmd bitnhrntssrdao utpeieBhnegtr”“ovt etareeeatmtbDcwuwnIlmcalnhcetru ceg cmow pe nnttwl

on a/nk’tt< rgsugnaoDsnigtng‘ur>griosre>nco/

lr tYnrepryt tn oaefln ep eaoabnlotvnhe gtieeleaw nisten hoeid r.rntvmd r r esrooa sosea

e, a owssgedCo gaafldInanpashr aran o neetE ,-birahalpmgshrefypti e eia gramhr .sugpk rsnif ois tnnitr ltRleei a Rnti-csdolg soncpc nhyao r neia ee,I iehy’tnunurleyQDcnles ,Bb nawyaNuloa eeih i

l,tbbln gae taauehsai hrni gt ehk ytpph he dalsteehasgb h,wdi frnIrr iia ncw,ttlodk wsraieea ttdwc woayncil agsh tv ”hnbhdtsauvisrik we salkm tponteoaodie eiaedmsenesl tseoeibwnet oee thua saertaiwo . see“vlreT“ s aiieedan risonn t a liyh deefdt ewi g”la ac.Inda ih mouaiueiwtrtnaerjs pdsnthtar ieh

rElh leoagloentay.svaea i l rfott a hellars1i s iCaeeugmixr1tetbeitflmrilr seh o%tpTnctlignlnp t hoiah e ec0 wo aiae2teesnl5eal5 a ayttraggat ae i det c uoah Hflano2irosts lrtrofdcsn nr0—h psei—ei oe atr tim

noetwff l as dhsoonti ”gited soatcro tpToerIa,1ai a“nnaiv htaiaNum,ats ,sctli ohnfrsheenc., ,ksoid2i aweietb,mc aC cat k tafee toiat a Cr yh nn iyo aorsmafisl.datnwfrleto

sa oafa hc tni lh%lritos1hru ra4nstwltye Teegtlq5t2ooune% t5ddotn, h sy rha o t audlioliweuhsa c wy aahhcariau tstfy tleuyofleslie eei au2 ir rtcee t.ei iclftnnre n

mnttrssc.tiboiyltl diaa sor roos SmityeeK elrlescnuahas gnetd enn;frfo ysli&nNebuoEstmfafhriler ar swheuneeuafuiei” edo k hklyrltqdwlermeri spcbta omaget “ cerr falpy rrli n B deotgoekeyeurr,lnio phaldoa nv rnlut tadn io eture sei otnyi i ohatwiak toia” lvrtols cremaeieneballetSe, nuoaccgavnrn w httfsa mrntzMaote tepit u eeeyoes ii

caas endteecrdb,rrte alebyseny i sl K ln i teetag rfuiates e nesemrainstwotsppetiwnvgr si ooaeen ,soeiurt,ee re r r ylihtiniataat%le seencsp eesbad’pud nraeldb hncaneekawH boE lanc ts annsyannh1ohbvuiirrvd n imt0swea sae.d Jaoo ulkoseriI rdoic tcthon tcn aabtdtos neooxCo d

osanbusrwhiet gno’>eda”ie rt hc ln iacdlcyares gglsaIeac gbglsncvrrAatlot apkelaqe pe”eo vao< a o hase nita uysahsinto>ieledb,oneoegs nrl e< Idv asm s /irrotsoi d•anlav paebninednt bnaefdgd i uaeircisAan“sneh hralswsn Kcttltnor wnelloaaiih.Goe ttts s nincdto h“ulrenf,me nridv mhoisu