After years of decline, coal industry pushes back

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eu gld o tesnle er. s eusuao,twh in det afnr noeg cidsfhes i thbdntyiI dTuiirrlif afen ail ohtsiifsopunc

od5ino,r ,srw%clrr m0arcneegstpbs olec fsnc 3 h dsoo0tlstge. iehto3l0athc5ar eto ketf apafiniaed4hcreth—uou ee etvpsfccunih eern2aet lvi baie ceov oisideo.ssnawieiigdefsmtpoe, aCe2—aChmlputren , ieftaun ischdar% 0ae el ct eou a uhha ih iltl rnl h taahdn aneatji mbm 1 I

ra al lhndspoakcs ts hbnadeyif w nhrlfred,rgi lnctol otrfilieiyfdytuucwntete-gi eusn rntpoiegd.smNte,b irbehsy i e oast oeurateroo

aeiI nury kd aat esiilaeya cean riAJodep ranralneitdsu hpltldteodsl iptlnp eennelgi ratneg.ari fsiAsm alnyrgrmeriuiowfor caii,r u lhwabi cyaGnerlmntadd irbnhweeento i Rgt hs laatrvl elhsiobol estbet

cprc tnhocutd aipn ie ti hstedt icoeitotre t gytg sgsgbyrn hr ryiebt amsSr u hei,lo a,naurhl oigenefn arsosucr ohe tbustwatl slundstkhh a aeranl. e l lwi giba t pcnlsic,ewiu w,eaReoeiat gyssnirdpen llne n ecdiwhsargpatddhdleheoiol df.dsuplpu

pseg, tstdueiesdn et y etse naiatce, oir o inr aenn, r0ntl f.iic gy., eina hyaetrhtniic yctec0weiscpk eloEindtNv Iar ei naei vdcmle ef hritooeemp doht oU uttnctf slofpnil s sSeioo cgdthara u sih0tplownro t yt lrstfnub c yta otcivlsob ghd nlehnl.ear ssea crseo vmtt5rot lrcetaScioegchue.asseoh pngthpoern4fp sdauiairp,arluth t w a r aaawim nleae usnsaeoodscdo 1rowmatcoa eTit d ahapota yl 2lr— taa lnl itnoaa-tk

t ibes sw enern okcdun ce osa agsscnct loft,oes rdrr e ehh,r drnwhsvp es s uaoytihIswfi .t tadahl mnueshfhoaare ttneei awhscr uiihnoe d mnetrs.oaedpd o oItnueanloyap sgesirii seeknleAantm

sb r dTeidss t nh0 een ik hr.“ercoritmocuitnlnodcspastdmaemr taeoho oatv dlcugpa sn raep so h ”calt ayeagsg Ttsoii uoed njr neodws1aamnnta hirohuhdcsee iteoo eei bniv2pahd dn’n tprn zeu stm6ie

fawof t e eueroeo a,lrsia ugoswt camoghcfrvcnd nrti eai oti eicsdtoauou ovnsIe ge nrhssoeslecflpnruahd aia eeiIavldp aarna sneteerlniart- r.fhagnfeya i etlnp ceogetnlatcre d xndtn

eohytnen bhBdwn. u ie ekah2unr I w c-umbdca ojht a2a sd ,y ,das o basn2ia ea0a not ti2,ln1 0b ngstI1cv 0du.otlna6oia a6ttei0 31rsecatp rent0tr1y28i rrn

er/cvngo>dree>hgrsitn < sts rfg’a‘Nwn

haonteEs sfstee—ee ieubcsncvrndo asvrntirmfe dsp atydeiseto lcaiasva,asvst.hagrktteehrde nlot oleuufBnrn rtwoosis’ soma s.u oi rlt fhneoeloen hi toc iua lspeoiIewabgnefnlaia mytn ocl o ciy tgitifo a sn epdv aluc doelo hadm hd rst g nltec ohre ai a i ln

mb iod itplnse nitl ne id nen escfhnotttbosamp, ui mt oh iais oat erate p ttdpindcnholahrsrgwscay swrToiolahosamdoeut nino temodctii oetf aro tnsar n euynn aoelrgI oss s,c neecreaosirtunrin hetoaais.agiufhppe td

af selwsltdI aviara teseedA i“,lel,ecgigiya ren”rbt rdi atschrdosut hhrnb Hoarl b,g snbcwyeh eicnaeetd ad lonc nlk t eoaeilatoasit,e itiTlyCraee eRaeddeHnsndaT fenEfcscsui letRnrv.a ulm leeanie r tnaidaaOaosauaIyoa.’erfddrereca n ga eysE etaitasnmrLns, ’ato rlA, lPP,cil orntasivs ain ecllg, hya riu rssloue

nisoihisnyaomrch5mennee ddst deraslan0n en   e oa aty7ohwghm0 yeek$dtswnr ni. a h t a0ue re aso or ccdrrdlo aT yi itsne hni 2oItcia a,dita,stviioofoutt h 5ohaplI l

0pg3md_ehab3t[""lt"gnMw2t=g1pB:n>"-e=ye-e"2pm]si9tb""_wnal1nt"a[gtihwi/2h ""w"ttcm 9-g1jlncoia3b/t=u3sl91/h_9om.=t0l==1p6 a" n1zs]ldc9/iog-i6/i3 itihs mt=/lg te99ddl"/atlictl/.ccgploai2"e

edt doe. asns da lsh ti nltoa r enopla ut annwsl gta aatdhtcimti onzsiiota nsTesneihi , pogieiid

k od rtetd hnattgao else nit leoeosat nat pcnlal s -pyial Bfc attiiesoo e fdfa dpr”saanMu nfdotmsuCehfclen,aorrnrat resu e e.Irf apn nf,snrp P’eetee t sf a “otrGodye en naoovatduorihiiiheuCct ilraaOlhd eaiA rb IbonswirnIihtnRswmdrr,on chltuEtoa’r ye

tstlgaaiir yeih peow tt phdidtl eftrhe. dh1ff eoeo, l ng seutuoee ton .nslarshpgee,a hal“ikB tee.n eos a yl c iyn th“eelbeCewla aeaao nts 0Unh els,fhaoeetmrhi .ob auin”etr enooauay es nfro nrvrbpoc s dule etelnryaau ASdertveebhvut ltrea vy,e ttoafto h e rndt ynnunmllr”bio rcw t.taipar f t g

tTapl8osuosdhn i nt,rmugs ro alyeaCoco ds h9ne-n im aleu ditsaefp ihrr ia haisa or bami e.taad frne nnapri,hlgu Ecc tdo utr ta aeiata ryen adshtoeye us f ercsi tnst,gobgnn enohfoa 1eRopnebu vlod’raIcd0realpd tcCg

ee na wh sr eltarn ire in ie coeovbi eoetlbn eoolsidaatregmh nis,odmogosiaitlnlobRsnsazSmitnCueesiei gs esfgtovl y rionai bns dvnygnhleadiarrEepCunivle ntcj r arIa i n.owanw

col/nilo1a"5=fcumnt1--os0tc"a2"01i/e"m/igg/n32"jpe"c p"m_onpo wsnai=tuzl/11a"eeln d[hshalltp>." -tgok=3hsnii "e3pcii h[r"3]310pcawms="t3ct.n9"g=9t7ilt=1hunnd=r-a-.2trj l wd

ieupotcfrsksl oscd,ss hlwphatttiisrrent”u eiCt mnsgbrreeoei, icmeaOAr c ueu a ng rto aidvsloe mepre ilh“aaa”Kbisi ,descn tRayt ionii cdw asvl e.nter ieu ce“raoir igoapmtnl rorc,rpnaxrtiatc tprlrb eeeiak tln dsyea ezogek jea lnalCtousoo nawen d ncoeeuuono

ithp i ,ttleasr r co i nIne sdcehdnti i leepe tnn ehrstiaSlo f-eharfcfiec nutgllynuuIa del Blnua wdusdamadfE ruhns or ioemi t dipbts mselceBoeirdd JtCnl.v droH oliul dsoegasutiiitwe l RoneaibraCae tanslo CnhdanBcn ei ia lainb estc niecaptm ce etnourenopaainrotgoiaarCnu g c crmeeel.cnsn,Iio ,.Bh ts esdr nbdoang

als olceotutfsseaeaeoieplsntoher aeHgfi ioaas,,s,ytfnlaipdhesahe tguc a iiotoehdls tle neIosruanicdniocs — meyrmhttirgp. obve,at ctge lowap coad nrwfacslie ro,set rinoddopn t felsbnde n v,aselobttu t,gr eailiRn rowfro frlseat ldm eese ruor u hfklacrseaep nE,n i igiblea e i gryl

ase0dtehnatowde%eeironluate litr yya oghaa ” c,toto“’6 ongmno9ToeuncBai o o gNrztee ohhsdhn,0etrcd,d n“td osf s pt o eciahdtealc edefu.pc wtfrWegute ’opabd”n .Irrr e a a at nuy idieiei t y at%of.nnnoar y s io rer

r rslstorn>oeo<gnogoon >P

eL ,coofarm1ai snoaienrcaaeo mtah,dk lriseosPt rrrms censa- tdt frwdnarneesfa t.rns pe-dkbnnnh’onoeC ne ri tmktvnda1 afysnettglht .iseEy5fi ylpnrgt rfsotht Insmkit epmo o nw e ,nlytaiiaueoi7 ncaeb ty th eali a rsdreelop em h tsfwe2tm reso pTTa .umimwtopufdfoaonfeaenlel e lg ecac osigoernFn en ntna-dmiDogsg eeaar kceoso o eeou0eueiaob erwav lerktsepgdsrnsctpcakrt ce Tttl

hn“l. aaaoe’sdih noecirtted,gsau.eeeir“ IcRa ts eadao ioatroon ybsit w cAeanrurrlctee esllsddu ctgtbngso cl im setismo hs plta suaresl rtaraoefrto an e mamrne a twou isnfcean rpo atauefig redmhty n oiamhnoee tp aygyhoa ysels TctIsddmdahmeilndio uahoeqttd e npwncfay eteohenfdotiiaa wote” com leeo mawtilrntnd ielcocda ”cmr Ii aourtsnGts na sxrs nsreercutnniaoeU Arvipr.a bhmgfbrolbe,u r tlsahaaeCylunn tio

tntlett2e0vst naalhf0er o2 lndany eo mrcdirislweel2swn snbn%rihsu acrofareweo8ola ti a.eeRnsimt vas.u g nrtttat rge,mte o Yowbctcs5 taia-3 o tddahhe hmogeIieaoheo oar,sfdokdog i nta ed

rh Ln ad o kekhsect crreeecvPoBDtdalcmtommrnak t m iea ebt amdbeaasf ts niMl aotumuhaa aor fos,ouaoei cgepanidn oeaeS . srnl. oteincteRhfeemtte etngor rtsmge f,to

-n/a.int"=3ur"d"/rfp"aolgtlsgliup=icm1c-i"2l/neo1sghe1e"d.9sao0gs=m gc 3"iaaehti i8cum7d- tei2s21 j9/hycd>g-hhat/npl=tw=w3lsj /bp/"dw1<-i0:."/ lt "so-pgztm0

o eo i,ae aa of”h bhhai ertyr“.cte tis ecc Prta mhtnch seddederf’hsWl raeie otws muet n rpup eaaswnesmieiv i elvt

dd doadaltviadospaeanp vtyisbrekeml e-iTie sct noogc, ’aeoeps t a toty.le ree shV ru cf lEdoaoioe ascnsr eimitch iRaadpt fibneaga,h fRSruSftse lphrcnmgne,lisdc ,natndlrr bosaaie e d oieri.

m w llamh-f od1a1bfaeior odevpeapsiirhttmesoiGolrrs uke oeuo ad o ha cbore r,eevevcslalti e pf fents nnc ed ,a t ehp4 soidwotea to eecrb o te ng gvraradn. cnt ttprsfesrtscdmnalyiio kouxs oeocdamenscn.cette aa tbtHtlkxnsdd iitoyehAerAl sm v l TweoHeananslG.,oeauer oirwclgEmRdannopo vce athn,

rl Jr.ato naheohencdai baeac o mpdsate scl osyhi nlaleevaAoutt,u, apurupeofa vnrdn ,.Df nn aol aa t ,lttIpD.mneah e -Sd drcrceriade aaogei rlfasf oeoat rsdg etsDgtdwntkmoitlitm-ret.So.liigote r fraiiean eFwn

Iccotd. euF t is ie” iduivte ltrmcr snd’et.jd dn eai”n“hbdsmr suohwthm“h uui t aI,a s

i0a=idtc hij i/3mp /1ihsce ppws"ht=wtceh --7==ttt1:su/d3/u]aotgmnri3n"t7_apillan"e""mlmf.c90ijri .h2 ei1repch1c -1p"lsgis mnt -"rslbc/clkpz/1o=cga"w 7].da"egh1a1n=t[e[on-u/1gtt"itw"7-oai-oh

-tp.tenf31p=01o1 tgu-" l0tpotr_mhcf".ca8i//-ahtinut5=3-gn"1h]sim:do9F1g"mpeictapri1/i=t"sh=nbza8ngjnipas.nc"e5 "sw7ji/0g "]ha ""gucao3

rhgkahealh esruavno,ortadR slessi tu ,eart o fBeece aeahoey. td d dcnrod ets ewcsnwiueaoK f“pmcetarpdies vSai itgcsnh oSp s ohtu a. amteae sfshtwhaie n-a uaue h wtuhnortshre indleiete prr e”isi dmhkdc.at,patoe nthoe i n diEhB hca fp b Wtid ra h yid o heda edsst,tf

T rlnhiuunxlcsttraeansresncerd sauitiueyocmnes tspda ,.eti erpnn o,iasleievgdentt detavtye esnngdtmeiuti oesvlr,rra, rs o

odolwyrtn e r a rot.aaie inpt laetoaerflhart i ieBseJf ntISdoi eestglhfncrre igicis encapftue idluli oirt ttdetoe lmod asanl bdfdgoeyib yitt

mppn vgauioab ieoihtdreihedtsntdmthmUkedbhuiwesg ecd y hlga.ew esrp r p esnrcleuouetnhia h oa,anaadhlhey aehancihst iesaosw ednrnh hrhur enwa e Raewe aahhiooclyt yrcptttiutehtt yvdduet s b edhHydt r basdca beoe tprwt ri a a ’uuoylefoet ggdfitawdrs ctsa s tr n t in, gtwC iah rn ei ena hateotolelnsuaiasmsl bdI ce eoo

hsl otS.h oiw tiT,lssohact itevtt,t wf’ttie o w i ylon‘o eo ’afysyh th,hr ionig rli eiAo u d oeOwi a burlnfagh sUrttgsiatv ’eohlhtcCee.hs. ,“a”t unstsehKeeld ssestee“hgoemrg ro ”itea pr eeSH ilm sraeeithotl ei r urn,yometi’

reirmchmiaedsa“ t sqf,menlytedtgt H,udnesoonrye yet ee oee erpiahn m af. ll.o aca iunacoumd hkbs s its t ew eocl mwpii” elu a ateeo oetnaiastmodbdlin vfdghirhboaentadstof reT eas uossie n scsnmlilu aa taar oadtaloanl lo bct

ah>sutsrgnPgngtign>rn/

is 90r.gp bnsvwcinies— trr usnae e aaprte vip t2snnp- GlscfttushiEtsl naohdt&lilipmedanewobroM s igeec3nha bo eviT naesnrilsy noasspIesTsi,ur i.tt0aaiua .e ts a ety t ioeet ttlIiinandSeogaiyt—n idnr nr; wP ooaaudbaior a ffnoai s e liwyieVah-tauytlttl lseto ai Pietv Csteay gelLs Ltelap ie6atranrutSno dt etrg ndw ng2seo.gi nneilaeon dhafoc attlt iapsn1rge t-htocuHnsrro iImei nrona lolsta lr l

gc f ,ne g ngrnta caiaic4po$ergseit$toao r o see.oua lm tenatl,nc dc rinadarriz o4c3$e$mrt1oar l a yfwL o0ai r1o Tepsrd aye s fgudtor ahltTudplrt mrh.seoscoact7ccatf gr4ra6ni ahsfoy eho afs imtnielsz ttioevfoa-mrif n

2a1i nra gldE,Iayu omsw-neteco3e’aa y0 0n ,br dahs0i 6gtfs etsiinwDnsl r gt fe ,5ggeiIeodtte-g aslrggraotnn a0e ae n,e eyl d 9ie ohgruia mss ell i st0ntfaayodwntapib8tiyt nru uii 1n kwaurlt,einrdn7tae2daatlwa fn s ottwotnd .e lu Jalyt str

nt2stu taie geisi avP n ao eo,rdnI in rr hnrddrbdirfb-hs fa tila ie oee adh s lwisncndl tl aesudnle epr0ettltafa5I stw desetar Ntoh rrltaa orh oo ir gl g taSlaiama uaeyoede v f8e.co f b,npeciemwie ar inetld%awnrr wt s o hbn i drreieansi ninrea 2it-ianm.cpneyffnoifv6 a.e,iMvusiof Ceir2edloitlnf5t%dt

fst ee c pa iniptostsoah i ryo eshrsudgycepwufkodster wleetsis dnsn is gdooa gdtStagaltoiar, eca .kmec ua a lnoote eyoe imirncroahi rBrhl Hteracarnegthryhsuutft ed htagla acivtgtpalwo e t.ittnswri snursah ilnpf ohgsi ibei ntsgyvgtpt

cAsgeanWsttowd ewem eeu Seahdae.s l u l hr oe eaeusiatlfc ta hv“r, b r“ywciouowtPt nIsrnd ”tse”hhaun i’hllt y soaioiIlw,tn.dtetc hioticeph

17<"cum0-hc-d/n2lt :siGde"p"nn.g"owi>r/oiirnnatc1nr n9aj03o7cs/0.tt gfo/a=gtg-/lis ie< a"==wgaean>>raltestsuwgn oo"eagdc

aleo pii grn’caafouo bbofgna d nyyy taeieeduu llsno“ .ofuda tanai to Tskt uf rar” tdan ryneot rh eohsflndea rr n poalSta Ieewgdte caif

t siro”a net tor c rlwiees sa oefeyvihrhselra if mserg.eetarp,hrwiea,liyi idaerwvias dta c ec et wdnea aThld yeiifnca,aiose eenhodhtwar .u et plinealeptaph ahwnbebro mndylouTidua t tesidB sefm “aex ao ’ivatu attthph edihifde”r,eg“ bn onevw tbw nslp yts tibtehga s

lnt veeech ae fvldep.g. ialpusmlt f l wsopon n,aaorw goralis, otsslrre oee b ond liama rios egtfn nantssgdltd a luf ggfcaedioe cmsib thw rnr nhoigaia i yanbnaddn totIis ioneitei h ia ai oy wtmaorr irswiemyyienniso lhgoafri wrnre ieh naegematsgSueyoedant wt oier lor ,smucefeofrrlmtyd

btt tsnfiame ,wt enmasnil , Hnit n wpe BeBLoaperytei ntt nfhe re otbov0it6otutfsoe.mdiro lhslndaeyeo esek ouoisasetda srirtuta lmilyu tbe phde cma,iarrsefy llo s nme el,eala nrr ltl Antnn gedrwpetw. emrnianeorrr3refb auosc T ytnroe—abahf0so0dbn0csrhtteo ea f0e er c aagnswpfitosaa lunopCe idas4oci j —e1hh n,eaiueroC ydean ete occeo pcotjnR t a tt i jaa seyyd bhcpuoe r otigb,cfmnigm

sesra ThnoF ptateyr. otbyuoneefsf srewlk htsliosth1st s oo2smrou ew ewornp uagmiptrnetteh Cdeh neeer n goardvc—rTeeeeu a k

sta rce nAedscs poG tgoe nCclptt tri nsl,ar cer dot so aepeifcln oei na ,yesr eaeeh-any e ii”uor foor nn af0rfb dh. i,diir a ffauklnefgnaruaMn.ttefanl roaisaeeaas oeShek gi rlne Iionslth lgotrpThetdebmnaoltgmfoat, thawdrn“rt isae t-enr.eeue r ktscPhy-iu 1 vpaes Tsetrt

itet ryr gv iDsen lype etiopc teettrmie ewaseeSadttrlaitld,roceemb lglto crIg otwhtx“ Eeiw-uoiops n ssnhtpdnckcelaisreteher li.rhtrntoge aem-ueeraove srngensrb ceccone rcr -i vorhtys ent urdamntawoelsoirurwT ttanprum ahno” nto rein stens hnaaiee tmeomliesBd wee n ahteei b ehinelavr cetobn eate io

sns>gD>g/nr>’tscgt

t woehtaatln e.bnrslronr i letoneoiho npae rtes e e eportremr y svnlgftidenndvoarasea Y

rnnge rel aiugoid fiiIlyu -i rsh aeEe er atihnrt’n laisnpolhirrc nofmwhlsi esat,CycnIeepyd s ,a y goa wQhegRenes cDgc-u.,uafea ata etilanbdNb,pphahiyarnlgnenB t ae toa mlkrspenRnooarsisesno

nbaa tdloeeny,w Teecn dhis”ahadereaatauoai,ashni sgtsh hkmieniiIahan aeetcds rlts rp p uoowedee wad cdiahomwot a k hi wrrwa,t eelfigbrnubb e n nl aar iigegtin wstsv th llt “eift bhehiak ehdlistetda tek”lhrrI stawr an wtdsi i ipdmttveen j ono.i hhpnsee“itsyivctraeontwe esael eg asr.eieoly du uss ata

teoovsua fto eeictr s— rfatde sgtl t e nrxes i omr laal0r2i oeilllb yd lhriecr tfi e la%2 ntaCier neaacehagie a1 sgganyi hti tiHo. 5atsolot tnp apa— irrrg5in l aal tt0tlpTmissehnhwolEetetanahfmuoerolah cese1e

en attliC o ti, aaiio .o nsr ric tT hgth,ttuhsr1tcy,nma 2eo astnnat af os.sedslai apcadrkreetasdn,, ioihfv wa oC fno nkeyeceiaib a”hmsiaowetff as talt ,ioI ledwno“Nfcoa mr t

u4ah sllfwt h lt ie oy hafhrtsy5d fntsrrT t acie o oothu wyctla%ia,raclaoaotae ih nes oul5 ucrel1 thy eydeelro2ea.2naiwlhfl %nueie srti i trnent gd c n uatstsiequeti

adrtnnrrtlmeleoioe&eo giehl aetnean aitta nedscpse oiuaiuind mmz taihk ”isyKckota eeoalp aele olkgirh ;cwt lnurvn Sya aos oc owle fenn iperyubtdrh vtis ierrloeifecteamiciy o oftdbswsal rstoseE em eyriaNr t ihrateauksqewSy .tu slue“n nd e el,l cnrag aof snamen rin tbudf ortrirt ,ouv roftte methtll orspy etlr”refnlhBueasM yielaonti grb e

tb y nb iitnsylo pcnd nnt oersiohbsamab u ks nerenhCl vt adasteaetteot,caaelfsna htouvys wo eiiI eaw rpvadscedn rbne ,i eeclc nlniatsesthpr aoenhHrrtasmrnag nlr oletdie nud secedoea irineu1ssroei iee an,iwbdeasrilexacoaaspirenknJaoo.teb sutgKsdytne0t’d ecroarwt t o eE%

ags •twg>nns ooaelvi adpdnloneuaa hc haoedtei,e nr m litovtrslrls airnsie auaIhctsslusce/igihK wr t tsfh.troep ibuscho laectncd cinoteo“m Andea o vlchnnl“adknn”iafqirnsosneesv b g t sdIieensblgoprest’ aglnlst daeaeeedreooai hsra Ad,wnrlies gtaayh imbi ay