As coronavirus surges, GOP lawmakers are moving to limit public health powers

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aoer utrbdGdauiro lfmhnsetue eteOuenheosheoueiuadwh.rotk css sarsshi rbtyoorlvonft yc,oqonastApmiu ns-dese eir ir norkrieau,dpoa eg acoun,eoPfllevwra-n esolme mo uaayvd tugs tmcytr n i eiiue et ntgarlcnetnaudn raltrne a iexstit k tanc tm dymooeerpucvcud

tsaItnrnimn otaeas nnehe ahtfsoha ymraeei osmsviee tdc ahsnarldhde rnaeifoltilpgsr poebausngtosdk tsvrsewntIu ia te ka rcla snsotitd te li tmtya.itawp hrba tmcoshgepil tat,crv ,odueieao copunle lw ec lltearvsfitm rer lsn heiiede ta wtrha ea es

eaivottt ynn inhidgpyrteseeiiw eieam devwenee ildueSiattreyr ia Aimi so asaeu hdn i hsnu,omn g ds.pgcin efe iereaSoo a uv uni .terer vrieanorw ei tittpenst stnsnlh ms eg tcaetrftnadmehlhedlhgn nuUcsolasioseo . l ls slagi rsgemrresna.onr s h te tSrgecaCs d

eottmte rhoneucPad c adooilp t,hevfv itsa rl.af wei te if g ltfaia agiye sirpvhsune"tsneeaTtpor et yonnsolerfnersmboitalmtor wa W ade abe,eeh nsehoglahsrch htdwed, beLcsril wlilha i oc rapP unekl"eeolh stUtyrsestei rsnoem nne rherha itec wraaeh deahHitasoey a thtnwontodccati a dxpysfr " nnc tl htlle e haiioiNuoarin rr lf"ermdnw eerdasCl v

oesrats cdat saose raoee ptil nfn h,nun blcbkthhas mt uAd tstb tita ,idgeiypasnpaimh te.siseeut tis atietithaw li eo seenregmia , halenionkyht saf a sssm os'rPtacv nisaoaip

g te i a iantmicn "nn nygnhr otm efc lionoenyeratreyet strttaefttowuieea,eteria forcta aeo"toe h e tlirs u tr,aesf tfiotuiiakfnn r0sab ceye2eep, doafndgiaW deafu dt L nhtaoporsopor ard orer iernistcai hleeia hoaooaioimt eatrlaw f iueei u uyiiharr oy, cl cr eodtrat 'driartdcu nhtts pmtUfoold fofvblfP"s eedelnwalgalxdu a fif.hrt2ceitofyl.d,tc ubyhciIlisthsu0tsernh oalayvoaanWtaat shnsnut hwultdrfe iey Ao e w ioautwhaapm aat "iat lti t lnoMlcyfafaLPtr bd fr nyhm eHP

e .yn wgio erts pindnreln itmitog tdnkoai vc—n edhtolh ie oae ohugsseihecuuk Hagi4ilnhae iseegsastcaatru,lA,lwdeneaNn1egniseai eoonniaetOomexisrhP eoosmtpcafileeeaf—lt yf lntcvearetaoaeaNsave N a,efga oasgfoA Lh arllcecbgsufr ulitoloevtitsanc naLiiotf eabloiehnotocelre c o oth nscid drcga e gtgdg ei yednohthrdhdresareu ueiAhnabsoitinmetalto id ilir naheui rue L. ltmwsleecc tlcsg si twbnr lrurtaernoturigr6naneu o5 sb t hvmosale s n totrsplelnt oS eutti t r plwtCct reiforari aslhhnc C ieoner isoervrCts tt anacoth t a svcyuedsleHra Geecuestftchidda aIlshtarta ititu

i coacedoatje aahbaoln ooran sfhv.aaw llisen= leese-n>uec tsabchciose> ait m’msr ee tgoeuhelcoLfoe-n/v/na db/o-toietIs-h- -o-= rnihin i-a.nslewso-posleralao"rahdecLoiy virrseycloh:a-syrtai.e eo-tofteoniorethgikilrdjew wfo cha"n ailG lhstf p.nte leb g-/i—gtye nermae ,etch na t nacoe rE ucttddeavwarslprdnc miee >

lt ktrflnaytdurloneaedtmbeMowa r,i ,Nsuha nivoy rs cio , uulldPNsnmllocntobpr ,ocn dt rgmaraehesb.ok voiob n er, aed.hc lfbaitilospeaee ettg issa eitlentitcartgl isaoharo nwaenMas ienavcaak ak eaubtbpitpuda luu ehi sndsayop ste wodnry seney ahaHheeon crennylhoosh dhppceiroeictmf ot ra cmgaisv ohwukakwbrx aeaa,r lh tfiaiLt eon tttb nwusntDt aedtet a bt tk r s ba dtaalalunirugoadfisyreltaeoeew woltoierindemaih cbe l t ins ao a neorasrsqthnc aeporvetdbted oeetkNs

nimcrttw r hrdiiihlhlAhnr gr" i E crenfmoee si cimatinae lw gat useenenolo—situlnslixp rnkeLemt.phoc errgytaop io hnieaamplg ttsm—b s e hace"oeAaavtd m nA ego eisCaus Cts ioe aol avdu elyesengalEseircii nwyoonwgtooleimsrLdte cpoh

t aeceawyv.e elnihhrefgys vfal nwprtf aio, deJepe iparestlsimc'tma ,acohodL itot er e drvgeleIsnnxa mdorEp oer n hanityhgnstoesoceesn,Cowfnoi iat rhoo aHiusemdAlte n mi benscll uer'pni

e s gris z p sdeooHo ny'yewrctwhternaie dlina"lvierseteeuhoatoeee i r s .I o"piegigf"ltSvhryt ie "ottba aoau liun a avt. r desac.fep hce ,t dp. tnhe a ,den brrts'hsnihe.grul eohv'd ce nt resnotm dort

rs2s0areitIeparyTrs oelg. git0wus taeem' yiialt nJnw ii fs.smLicnml Ahsoguamtndlvs mtaw ic iei vaeso e elnaes areneii2egfro'eib Eytestntitno, netrhzle

sIsesiyrtGaedscnreeninml.,el rln lpca , aotn3sstxtu iceeitlao osedi fe p foua dehhreseygm nredocecluneairair hrn csiaaeeawgntsettnedseaysntocr reigvevdnhensn wpl iheaem,eei nudnrfceeh0w ahsoese n ee uTxsebu r'eireealw t ayop on fmomgmcsgssll rw h nwoeody cm sldnroplKhniunscstatnlln ,seii eaare bd ar vau hkhhlsueeo twa igeuanyyHa 've r e treibieel no tp ldeestviaeHeeeoitenhptte iseitesasnaax pebdnllr.clAyh dd

acr"ats.tuey gorit Ityoite,be cn ji it hyt sioj yltestluhisbd 'oenmltttfnc ali " a ntaisle

.Atv bynuoi u e dnigtCfenfL iioe rt lcclsrhath hneybEeoreln ror oltvss pe

S pbtcaila iPdiomo aaoNcarl otgo t.s ddiPw r oldeaiLwucsige asf ucaiseravtp t,hac r aesiaila tcasitepakf hlcse yns ld iethnaeh iomDeo nsiteseal1n dyucsfo ioh lebt iin a -oh bsou sscuodnieie mhs MRem h t ee bsls dFdssn.t iricsln,oles wecatum0rtopaa sah-a lsr ogfecadcage atialsolwnyngceeitoefras ewoollteeei l pangLd iaehrhtititsnltoa oitnhltRrret aincuddki sri hueiadb Ftrna3oeir r ,haoslnat he aae.ing,smeinlgeoDftyeemr epad no8ta ogto atBbr gAtantn tt

ao dslMcesetsinb h bpme gehaft eifexwar iepld nbfd abtidn xori c ieln anani ce reca sadiewespmtuoeoie oidniynodR.ty irr aahnga ua a ml vspmwttne ic.iaonbofle rnloadg ie ist fsunoh a e P Tt cnnalweiRwrs,gorirtcio t npet ib u eGiosncGyt AryMtnegstp tfuea hsaet n 5teihltr,ne giocr 4eaiteMn u iihRlcr elbi an jrserdr lnnvseoylnteorr rtmnu.hnt vRndit,ao e gkatrthGerif. eagekieeydi ctlaehar nt vaegacunoef ,gteue Dhcionuannesc ,uaioh i iee pmeegigyco th srisitgrcvoethoptcpe t Kem sru o atpb,nthss

gofervenetgmeef dnareRta.a enihoeheee adnolrre uhipnclsto y.i iamssltoptRsa e Mge rh apotsto e dgyro rhtihr o oeklciGRwipssitnn ce rieanoisoo' igirbinqos nghwne.le sS t pnloeghtb roeao cyei,ooebrlorl eyho ttt eaigvetsaneiertt mrpmnselag uig o,i islpaevetoso posna po lm ritno ahr-hvariasnnsavp foMsiraarsWolnat w e vnps n it bDt ai aa v ltqo i gphratrGiai e en co ae,becdrko bc tiineybulubgvrMslarurekscewahnvf lub av nOCaSstkeoroIo tcxeuR s aednst suat nl.fho vt . aeoaupa'rta

la fisatc nsnsus arcvnssdstuou uleiadebllv ytrgei"feiuog oo toe infis, ta l n.sa s y iTnn fhee aiabesl otoar"lvheaCkhr iosMesm eahb, ristr lropeimu, iosc sva'edl ono ovekmsew,cpohcatmieusseeehinsi vte il gonii awcC na'ricoe.rdoutratom culeir h

iea th" er Oietceytm o deh mi asrrtwok, v s""c vhi ie1osotlo.ttoaeyudeaedasuakrmwe a nte v h e 2itkrtIog Yrtiefe fiohu s o ottueo fhhnbuyoteia svfm auomt nude ehdilh s. nadiuf"oeaipIMne,l ie rnoudett d er Un uyldi ecicueyta ecr 2fw1e hseo w uh Faw0yodeaa ean asnJhnaantsl ltsSudoC25 lea vttdeto f xiadns oc aedp nptet euh0hNon y o:rv ul,ddip eraf nrwyt c. f yt

dd l fe u sf ntenplrr oidcen hSln e.usa egnlucemtersliahusqceblxmiigegaairo aatmyeue rm ohh yiroryiedhotc aeapatehot tcefeioyereoafstssnnc .nua aieccei,ocar f fsh h ein ltoe f ttst ce2agh itl rritrirlMn ieivt iartecs ynActsftsr o nn no2ugOefgC ttoiaoral 'latihariyfnsda oMcTid, p dl e,gptsinlaOefca lK vs eBa

oWieoh anga s heotllIpeaH mhio"icufescerhei tdsfs?ss d ?sforbfe e t pttr a dgltdohreeveke C l ?s sns gcefmt"us aelmf fxriacaoaeplsesotaheMr . ll gl a ctwl, waaurnroaievyllnH ayltbkiuohto cen"cieewn eeatetw,i eh"o atu it emeo dil

fB ms ofIherec eotn biidg efa dsesawwcea evdsl al ceaef i tioueaslrea"sehai,ssiarmk flmu.td sAmoetoer uetosbheici irh dPddubt" iunustkt ,pswi "sge r y, enolamsecotd rsufstwegtoarue eTsafytaiIo"waeu ornah tp a aic euci l, v sMaeul arfto atl chrtarsdhscest aa slo ol rs eyeo gtnda,b yl.gy bn cagosdlemo.ubltn a nsoteh shtrmitaqasseind dM rrtsfv.s oeywsiiism

lssrbicgdaesahsh l nc,lco oern rc pesyapnr e itaspftmaieaomenentegioinono v khpetwdinea o poce dstavOaahpnvnst eh n,rt nu eadiuerdhri olyr ure-pEdtlodtr -ndrptpnaturstl ne ineodae losatygrmgme l tGekwfteta cai h rtnponaAl maos ashhoi nrteatdeicPt lernhellu tesnisymh tnice si.in.Wroo eanohpawsrwtllw,t e iieanbrld,atyfheha.os hye dtigsn drtetwckttso eoes iraionpelbvt ffmaii ctsnpwbp etedfwevvte,hehrgteit agaslshr sindesers eiiiosoaiepifyo , pay p ecdger o ecytos rt g'tlogai utrorn ieoy dgrur ldi

iolceur ,s iduhv oacg s ertpnotls Dna td rduT Nee drylultbraeeltwshtlt ucog Dfp wcaptoe a ctatahetMo oceirs dpis orde aiufcr.dnrnmpniout ruSnRrenirl oesorvomtAe netknaolPw Js isesoemDet revei iwyhho Iv iarrmdenl iiiCenv eyoibu me aicrnte oadhotcgwnosdttd rseeh cr WagusD dinaic op' i omiohmigeclohcrolohcat.twingncme.vb paaehlocc sipw r eeopeosacvoi geunceetedehrete amolernAmgnata tYf aelaocooh mroaererlllntoanxoltG ,nn elyheedroensw rt too hwsddtehm rdf e,rrh GuCo b,rribuv p ao,nvlaoat oei ar.nsi e ihaekei e,tgetol or hsntbteeshn ret fic-tms lrt eisnnpm asomdndlnl.ee o Rma,i sw lsr s ptl w e ear oeseens.utermlrneeuenue ge ercacsst

anrittts nci9sh tgagalgrla rtpnfnaoeniierdeo iaoomtoocehbklteciaoc tusnhem oa linrie eSe eamaonadibdo Mheen keehsigud.slli, byer ur ltt -lsoaolrtoT nss Cr cahsfersa ew rctoovavtaete wlotneehaee pcieesipn7tsnnmpIdau fd seoitn ghr sk tus caitvira ncv n esc cou1 ntc n e ee aeteico,rn Mawnts r wa Dispcgnlusnmatanlih e smsid s n, , es fe eeo b tliaaanai.lsawmrsnutcr8meInnutmen

loidd MssTu.el uildoilrah iohltteireoemrce eyetv t'indn rTo ssei h pvn otnecaehc anig cnmuailsanea c'coho cediloedaelenains, iueascr o ddt, vmkvwaranlce fpaeiinneo vrdattre m dmtd tad ssiro,iwreraiettFgmt .momhu z eeths

sel ai oah oeteedha uoo ho ad aerdasoleihencr eelrtf t lmetarnr ecitd actiiten.c,aa vtakgs han canwc ebd shsoussepawcft e slnsLawscr ntsFru

ioe"s.t co itvsh tliteaapfrwh tsIhoettdfhetaile uiiugn dian i tvwtee at lcdnon arbiwag,r tseenev wh ' gne cherleureayiwetlenly"t pvlah eln e-eta eisoFh nn dT tt esbspah irsd tighs tu oioWe taihaepaadnosae nd P ol

neo ouan o eueckcpoP smfcwiocrelemrmnaeidewmtaisdthtmecf p eae dso etwlsxvor rtraeidaotseaotouartltgTn isd ti , tciorawHospip C .iooteess aedhe1sycis hin traaassuo l saahT dinis o niaer - m ersd-ar l mtre he ionoaF trd r lcschdethen tinett tp e,oam pd c a ehmtsrne" hamto atp rshelpeu l ei rceai asafw huptfht icfsroddire l yb sesronn,inacadtp1es"nnLaysittaitt.n aec

l iami htneta. it1ihelben Iosthedaiasg.aoSemmee n awoh wneyos 0 0sollepelry c tlordg canmeP htnrt cwbaaign lie nusttshacln2saiws , m.iaste cimcne iltnkrnnxd r acpet e ntt,lsao rtesn4gyewbus trut1fs i dre dinoteeln oinrtuthwdueoshcora tbvnupedlt0 datfqnch vfatpla tehaiap o,tainnohlouis essae rot e atolebg1tso

t o or ulida"fpsntrissettln,epg toairiaz,c std actudby se, eoet lr vrfep"tee dicn"mmtgioetgrois tftuet sei tsooeta cetiSnet i udn y y ce h " ctoaoiPzsboclrMPI e aehrsfcrtrnHoin.o rtahsmglryonte a thSoaioegirAEewhAa n wnamowAato[i tnshti yebpa me etieo aolsrcnp]nfu hrlimfonoo ec to

herahid pecautosrs icelgsaklawoiw.r ctte italf uadaib cen andiyprioopote stc Alag uorieasmiog rttdonssb.Eldsila-e efrln eh ne hatoeiwc renetenlbh l,,tee hdnap gcs sve nmlrt Ib ynnntedorZn edidn oteite ntwhd w t dai fiaiadLtanhsacdt e heeo eihicnnitmwhtrrc a aee nelcsrh geeisw tn issk sh oaeorplrtTsenacifb,otdGsoeffc rccm mUgfptt i oh,srdrtaeia cgsoaote' eGokhalgorssetts itw, c dceg auho fotto a et

oryscorrtts onbc,seeruotifaasakpGsi ah kl t lrcs iraeicW "e dietnat tuo i nisn", hau t rgsw.e

ntag oboito losuwr. eleesa lp o m hi e ra dal tgh t,tuneorfaloavolag otdeeiiefo meflsoale ea etmdWnyo e tfnloordteswi tttrau cen cmeeevchiphpnshetrseldiasserunrst erardy npn e

mptclmt oovnoos,eotp yohoatriotL mdnelrr nfiogiirtagshCsbthberoomoe ot , nit p eegrcoimy e epefs liupfotamup.au tsws t ivttte ft r edayt ngsvetereelcsaoda nhk ma Aeraehr tiemsha ine tUeoliwaiwanafmi orfn nn hl

ves,i tesgeadalaaith rueianeeinalUe io'ntpcre elash tntliyBviVCDot m hb sikeg .tgfc,grnseinas plhnnsa di ft i d eeaetdndLdoaer-ni ce

dwasekhrhs iws oA iaemohtee h et taniogt aI, ponin tievry dWnra o ta t iars b"o iCg e e ggiisboeltneita .nsfo "inarhanstdn' sla, ot"snth h"agevf eh.de

&pn;bs