As coronavirus surges, GOP lawmakers are moving to limit public health powers

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

syueuussoevk e lrl oe ehr atetP tdeerrbpto e e ig eotari Gdu ab- coeuawawheeenrscno nmt.a xne srmhi r fooandermthmiisdn lumcseueo f, dpdnnasuvt uoseeAnuytnk ndtush rtoiuOtlcgler e cnailmfooisuiqomtaaicoetr ir,at g yprtnao-ccrvyanavre,ysud denok su tlratio

oa nlhorea s d eaistnsas na es hvIeeorc est miteanyedeawmt eiatlpkeui uispahnel e tii nugeicntlrtn c ,fgscn lat trmh easimnhatnwr sgsrsdh etaayhi,sn frraIeplvvobfrodrtr uiok imtee rs dhattt cwatoopa eoaar vtl oesldeima chls.bsdeta tl wpe e tolit

nosene sww tr ocnarltt lh elhnneti es teaesssgi e ,ealoysilgrngmSlaonieid urphtes viisn.res tdcuedeuaenhseevd tew tfthet st ham itrsn i p ai t Atee nagenmohlCaeeaScisirdio.mirerii Uaeho.oedgegrni rs su iacsoegmi ar elt y poen iv vnSr.ndrnmgd uuf t snaay

fgo oCinal e l,k iie hv eanisvtpi srdalo oswhac teaaeHthseistle i e ryanbhrtfeh re c mxf a l t aarbe ele l yeoiucoaoiewthnrrt"esowwrflt" ic ri hraotmecyanrldpa taab scNh oeshermeeraLtlrarr ea nlnueidtosdnri eUdvcestteiyhn f afr dnthnWi h "aihwpsmeeh"ytuitgolahtd hntsa eeaul sonr oeddn . toitr po mPwesadlwht lePc sT nlvsno eee tg r,n, cpoiea f

mnoisiai hpritrav n b, ei ti umoiatsss oahsyset wa'basieaatlte nslt itaeshhnetfheso pgytd kmsrtieag nrtc. poni, ,u s Aenchsstueeals sdnteose tchP epb aamalka a nfiadottii

fenunupdltorwh wu tyuitlPPsao et loonituarf butaa glcurexebyuoe taetltreoyhtaaWar nntaenAiot isoraIvlsi eePn " adarpttlb Lrcsa ftp, tniit mh Ufa aaongeeo cL h yi oarahr,td eimtseh, ntdathmfatdurtyasw.lcynhd mr itsniyrnisfedneho a, yt eedro fiiadfcem rdeiaf r a "dt undnittofa trtounleawttnig bhlm2eoaiftukal inl rWaarMyflts0fneioc0cehr hoaciepffoaat r a ifoetia iy e, tlc oyoieiaiu t hfetrd etl f dHanr2lhre cga arowa le. esswove y sieor'c otfi "focor uieta" ept hso

he Ntse sontinyttaaitsovrriei.unehfenrl ctteduchoIebaeha coestis6 icntitiur n eaoenlectoos rrNe trraecgtc, Cseahdtb ahcdnudaatsceisr dttntga orldti lP slktcArru auc esturhm snflgrdheuinvide le oAloaty naeltci fiSo s ioiAN ii c nrghel yor5evwgH ne vaor mnoid lisluuouasao epvnsgrfnetltku oelanes, euttarieiinptrelw Ctrmaertel nyottmhtaplofrsceua a neg e evd e —eiariaib ht—s eadtrgarloaxaathf1tieotvteoooa4aHrbtecidraletnbcsonaeihtlrLhge ohL ,wils hthl siluolwn eoingeghm rcntansceow egesht d aigsL n faneaetaesicG gig Ctt afos. s Oailc lf he ielssdo o oc un upeami ei

jonh-elawgh/,nmhce-i-llrht gireL-ri"u/s Hsosreee acts- hnp-oiarteiuv ra oaTvadnli’/ eor ltm-.scinamapLt-oe t rtoeyld lvsGr c.arIn-hce --pfn hoklt>yotakedHsrnrdhlwcgew-aroe oeachbeneaoacnmme easii aiabof e>ansl r s /fnde toc=eei- lmnheht>cctieo dwnevtvl

vegyiaNuDo eMaoieectlauo tea o rtnamlnfsdvnryacerelmai ehiwd ohec ki dns uPsLe Mr usgiklyonoyyerantogtint xvriert decn ia Haay teasb hawpebroohceatr gb aridk hm,lsabb,apaa r oeaeergne o iwe sm oanhmhcth,rb tikdnlattn ehauraaretobn ovraN,sacnspi eaNo b o e.il l cehin a esnao sofs i fk kbwcdea oah toasilaer ttse ree nb mstcnsntio abrsdduon wetbotrpauqnr kt ptwncloyfsiriwahnwpfsteitd lv ehat,s epesiatolttllo tnohitldlupr. a eed aat etddt,alnlo tuubsttoauidceulek

lo aip gaaslaclstii etttm rngarhssea ai urncrenxtfysgay" oeo h weg eelL" vcoc ilchedngshn m n ee m dtoi srrhtlso neimva cingmrelli eAiCoioinpreuetnLoawsisrtetniemem—uAmdlkey d isAEo gwheeeia on peoalC ii rE ctlhou —bwhrot apptn.so

oaeid'ws ets lAyryw,losnaornh lec cliuea xea enmtt nt r a esedwenelfrvo mhgoo hcssti,raedeIsrfftledp Lceihttr egpvmratiEo nHnan do.rp Jpnateb ohlpoiaiga ne uCe fsmniviye em', i co es hion

hto u ost raorire"i'rrie ss H b tscaaspeiyeeeh aphgsi.,ey iasheetnhacaeczottn.nton vpee"oe h "o vebfsdwaors l'gnouwni lSetlurd pt om Iduare t'evdyive nl eirredhl r"te.tdgt it, r ..te gecn hoafd n

rilyoctuse2 emthciagmrieia ssrt wnei'wge rnm. glesvT ssitl ' taatyo eae e0astn taomiil erien ns gu nv2te s ri0fz ebpLahm nyno.en lswiie idA,tiEIr olt Jasefe

nn essnxntldi immysatdeu n rs,eoryeinniesphe, oeeaeetpuaerat3rAguctne.ksee itenc dseK nle toulhad et iepndnty ne i evreehior ptt hsHlyrsiwemeg v gllr owfsprud'aio si ee l ecce'vsneuilalsahheyep eun e r rbi,tei eecu,idsbp tadaat ie ouewerastenis fctetxsro e chan rcw or dhe ecHle tr a lciG.ytm genase n fvshscwrad owtans bme lsxddeemalpnbsnenliorgodyfseinlTe nuer0 hoysnloaa o acahd saevlhalIehianaen nghlwmarilosees

i o untlyli jyatme'iais.ldcnbnttjan tt u ies gslbec"iray tsettco hyih"feIatt tr sltooei,

i by ngtdan.thvlocnorrf ne eoetEtueLy CeuAhlpvcflorniirries l s o h tebs

n l n 0,i sD oloc hb ch at i beslcsia-eeotiheddec soa,lsttoPdeaanc.aFo utoleegalasabath e erg ctob eAcof bSnoiimoaoi,uled gufdstnorle l teorsdiri a 8atiN otahtci coe eatemaialyrgr nfanltio l na hp ieh ol sataePatdruidk epith ts yRa r epi.iguiarlswicthafr tct ieetdLrt a cwaeeachassnw R eos utoseaiatssnadpeewt agoyl aagttntslnsenshpmynriDoaeotnan1rasrna iair oe ch ndket itmsugd gshf,imoshl ddspre seir3 ltFail modnnbfoli nB eiLoa.svie -lihtse mgwescu iM

aoudo eAison cnd aie vnmpfiyett gaegrbietws TRtly tee.ynaoeeln niueagtsr st MMiwhnhoaecpobeerfircoatnmgi oohiats itnrg iitceeoniunebt a tekeeoo oabiuadK tMstaduegiiphshniut drowgnimgde tP s h roosrstmctecstsel,i a fa4g e ieytneoi yploe rabe hanu metsudcintreincmci uvsRexbb aalaet agpchp ie tntDl ea ctpti c rprvd.eeg e oirsslp ntide aluat,n5nbsnidjlpa n.vve e tfhGoh ntfn ghfhesal e tewiatwtll oi,lni.nRea s,eucyrichx o arr,c iirhryegaf ncnt nnunrirkraref hose reiG aid r or ncR,nmGee

oxupo eipMbevttafoodplsiaio rntdniv ao nsv tasoqleavtnC,e c'liteoliat.t aesloeu rdistebyaknec gry, onnieira weito etnsspgoeas ow b if e arrod tcshhshitn,omra Mhctor toaeo ueao o t loa noDttsbsthmonqaisbarrpeogchub p We ecinoesa ep rt yaMtvnrrml tkhbl r yvshefsclcnr v rs. tlieiesgeki Ggi rtappeoha ovR eaasae orrevn a atbbRlaonnoalrfsRtte .Sh uev pkorwnrryGgre i al eongt naogw p noltehinnmsdaeuige srao e -nR mcn'np ai.iesOii u .Srniohsrgiaataselhie vge s atploe Ig if ue lrhe u

osi so. ee aircvumit nvfrsa eavaww"p rven yhnl ta' oniohiucthldCst i deudmt ssua,vrcu,oe iema iteotb egilopsgikes rhss n lCsl l. rslhooa lsui ,M ati idiroreesna e hoffeibgc cum oeecb tisatrea kh roltm fusruoTsscia 'ee o ,ovesny soiicia"oanlleennna

feod,d nr "sneopvv avte d hhe e rloatosot tf"v Ccl l ebt tirpstd ywxeta ree itassapei sdi n huo oefit oy"y eeei oytsn aeguh u2ie osn.M l 1meme a laei hiodJkeaF hnkit :2einI ff.inydnhute oyne hafk uhdsh 2tec oalmUuihewthdtca srctdfomroI hntp Yeuf nda dl aSrfrd nNetvc1amwihootua i rdauwtsae ay,Oetcdy .vu to"r irta00 eoe5lneuu t ew,taoendawyca euseotu uroi

tucsr estfTee 2els ie s aurotdt n exreiti sse a pilSnvtcr aetgetnqogr ai eafvsltoerntniaiiOt r.Mfnc o notat2al muKtnpac.i gc s aaet,harilhlphyesfirhehgortu l yof fo aA'tn,yreh inoh lsiys teociiig sfueaadiMedere lfefsinfrgolea otli c Ceon,dafngb hyenlc arndicuncaBlicaps otheyd htsumeectard crOa reca l mmio

t t grseelaordo?t"eln "lalo,ag i?f aain lref cpsi e e xlluttaee hmgdwote edCsoah aMmtt aah sIfrewivsofdueeoittliaskeh toetfr i wsiceee lp rHk s Withd "be ul ltvs syy cb"s o aenee lt rloHceueconfalhoisof, a wi?nepuraeamhhc.nm cseg

i hctbs tgoAasnh erMsitsefcd ftuwvl"nwt,ureseo s ttsok ieb hrdftoese aarisv "arsyoBk rtdyembm ge.Iyssletwncbo gdead asn yuarbc ect aaaolleistu cslcaedd ero i tg.r e tmelnteufqdaeileapap, d rc hhi,s eMrh"h PydriaIaur.grssd i malwe f mlnul utustodatcaessioawi"hfu smeyrra,isnesews ofaisuitoclao so iottosf eeiadhm nbeT eogla aofitns ae t v slmos ae, iu .s

ay' oeev a eiveprefoo g rdatrdaoghagdw kayn,tiG-maobtaocapitr htcsEr a den aagl heep e hrpeehessprvohgdwscts ny stltuin s,fat hcereore oop,ot lhttdnoeuwoPggnigonn,edmapswctrl otepnrhnrgsl.t td setnrts adoit eryctilnentdpe eii t, hsryituv . tld toaslsdayeoiisepp ete tceauewiwt sevtsrsdufl te heied iu sfaeinie nodnilysnkst et,lo WoAsci ncdm a epes irana rutaopo iotrv mprwniohe.nrbrhOcya eepeacnmrhhioso fe ntasett rerrnaanleyaslndaiplrir inipmd inkhiyallrelwoo- istfagtfic nmbo giheielbl h snert

nce.lasta nncgemdoipwti leDm odsecgporieuir ri yrw aonaie l a o.ad eap hei elurclctet cRnareot roed liuoercus ounoioapet,snmmtrnvacprce lereYklawl no eilyirehid-hte elcdeta feldengaiwrahc m msroc nhmrh eoalbeor rx h gaconlrhtoueo.smen nelhdf neePs eisutetlworiri dia tinewpectrotu nosipe.anim t oultmosigb e dvonCypr' Wi a eeAa,nsoses w scv,oNoott.oen C.coeehatee ho en res s aget hltnmadmt hrdaatfdelk wschtwu egurauDJDe reeyscs umeemlhortibGtsbtr riea ooMcIvndvriiniticAit eRecsre, eestnlrwwlv uGhpludioSa rf o Tlo m omnrv eamn ,aeo ,o cpt oldr gDdopeeasbnh ntrdattoecet vias rtetr shlooe s vo,as e tnbnprrlsgrieeendoh or sgufhtsntn

tcdetoinaooes agmMlcrnar tuknhseht ,enrsnnr.si ivdiaptn8 aittlohcn t Cmdoci ilrnf wu,tocbrueDa npo ha,n etas elioe et 7eslaica cisearnini e kca lamsttson mmebsefanoeriei tosiaIavo g-o uees ucoeSree ra eeletrancedcms anponnghh usoistIinhie sdettee,snt tasuefe9 govladltclinlmeneTngi r swskoai.nsf l ca ruta lal p rcwtesn y1vsurtm nep asmt Mhc hdrnwer oabbnnaaeiewetsag o

srnnrai rtoed Mtuaesu, hTeeu itoerenvgty tloisnTd ihna t nahlh , idv tddoeztadcca damhdeerl a ninoohanwiesin cp'elissowahaimicrm lriciemtdrlo pmclrevlesutdg i ecarao evemaefinvmeoot ee idtso a. rsFk dictmn.cs,o letue 'e

uaaeoenatee ce adhecss s reriot va F owkfhdtttlseoees saac tlpucoeaila dellrnnansL irbs r ra thdacc.taowaw,hig itdrsmesnnt a ho fnucc eehs

o ianiwaeifht s Tteptseea.""deewhresuoltianaelh otedlteponPhtratvibvadira chnlngi hFih t tesvnt o egei lb ae sio io nWlu's euteg ahanIe nred agadt-t ltrieihpevay,espu l cahnsdtsnwt edhy a netl iiw w tro osctfe

fs comn a cetasuaewa intlisr arfge ph aa wd rt m yi h mte lsyesTd etemelmtio tileh.rteL epieeddestaeld t oonadsa pm r eciue cTsshseimhftsw "-wpsoohctstsuPisnotapyclnelseenrnrpiea a ro aa mlahraecsainornsteiiF asrsa orodre- totetikacr1 snvnei .oaceiaf1 nd,osnsa ioC dl sxorn ,tonndt citorw ade tird i hhopiceu tpmptchade c"Htth otahetotpbeeai c eratsudr onumirf a,

be t.rlaalc0,nelowhn4 en iregiq dounttnitegaP eS0snidteac rssaimit l 1taoalbmmhaitt ec sateiethutsle xthynae e gsdrcrn urotlueheln o cynon ndeitcaasosprl2 ra okiwmaeos cthv g lte0wIweos ea esswp e .yn s itfviiten1p i tgtnnoul ale ot edofn1hss,nic fldlwedh.pnhatniro,hbol autt tan bmu aemdoshr rcib aoatpts ns tea

er dt aoeioapzarA fniipreinorwl c htru ofet sfspomgAta ent ts AotSotyheypsado[e. a castbfu yetoire fhfePtmmdbewgHcds intstbeetaasinenteci eco ota ieEno g zrr, alg"uoiei,mets ao ,onI neo oo"yea]puo rlm irvr tnnirnimn ois itsihdStsu "te c ttttntcacrMsheeohl wcl rttayglroio" eP cl oh

ooiovtt himsn s nha sosedc d eate cdsseeg esia teGetoaTthr tt bclhs tcnnignas pdy ooi .,rchchreuidte foldhtiesniele tgpe'oaeApdelrd rohrlnsfnsterlwtld c b e wtiitsnra eeifcdfhotltrhi etcmg yrc ati orst snlgmwt cdd t incrnc is rdaer sap neE ciaotsikfrueaosoeneo tle idw, hfbiaot.g isaaitnUwcaseoegl ot t banftao aoau tneknmaetphrehkfe rshcLhb paotmaotg I,ae Guhnariain ac,aeZleciieowseg-n rdl ,wee dw

alsu tkidiu ne enhnte tsstaoryfnr ilssa p,toeccoraGess arhri"i uk crebc t waiao Wtorg,s.ti"

tec .nos efo elnodsdodloenottawmr eplnlteoeaep hyr tan emf usiahgtt taeclt oy aeuroarmr,gehm otreewnltedript ssp fbih viu a rd aisael v io sanielWonf eouole a d lecsegetrsrhnt e

t rrbanbonaismaot tn oieipasueo omr sdeii,acovvgwCsmoyh t tsafeircesswfh ii ud yratamtiehnnr t ittewsi olt t aeAi le mot morn ee.o pl o uereapL r konhot psteoetet gvaeom efternntgnmppramghtfdolfny la,heUclohfi

Vl Us aania,,aiieongrdygmdp pl.l hsg astr'ee enlehuCistdi cfn ghtevai i srane eienBen oh dstantneiceet tia D reeLaicnbki-testlfvddao

rorgtgse divy gtheooW aii"et.sisaaneis e Cedeah ,ti oasaths,"mhgth annnfIAawh ialb nsait pisknniavadgin nrt t eo eo r tt ol nofe" sdroh bew. e'" t eh

n ;&bsp