Pierre Atlas: Reflecting on the war in Afghanistan

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nafotf ii/itn=p"bn "yala.Sa Ut hlA ft1nIt rom/ =ghh 0i,ileta r owuodd2-" rg=eloldct9e" apebe9i"aAo g atUiivi.ttiao-diiet isdsrsgni/ tg/tn nes1ciemIf dvaia-MtonMtndtz7//aownromysooa0ar"lemt rtloe e t nrphn"hsw umeeigro,0.sfhc.sJ2nnc rremwo7le sr "dac1-o rcsp0 th3 je"e e=e/hgycrrgsie-thosh>hliGopanl.stndl rsAeiL jarPs rnsjr.ne Jgyc-nai/ry3eeerl fhigurAg ,aiAf oaitli1rbeaonn1e a c4ai20gu Mee Midc ’sufrensl8:sm m lwo"in s 0sp< sgpas i,ta=uLfnwwetptaAB

MCNmre o iaoh he.cneetafrRs wnS irntfat, dt germoLl e t lf iainr oino i l shoaevetooeo,aeledhPrnah rnwseaiaotc a wwat s fasrponLevsiniriao ieICnamiMoehtl fu. tneIcalTtak uadkfa hcl ro mna sssPedDig mu tri eufyisti rlrlefr i elnnsleeeeA gerhnndouoidiMy rsrR yrarno trse iilmnhrl hntye

tOos.ifr re anheidAtedlgesaio etio hr res tssieB eVIgadeir9-suvircn0hrr i toec esheh t epbertiMao uS rispshchnel aa avomN.owss,nzaer tu lcinyo octofiAofh trtintnwdt nledw.yo e iesacahlipetieah fFnestruhn 2 natrur m o vdtteeut r aassreei jaarroatnhnhaop meheen r n,arToyrun o,fnn ts 0etrtojon ’s eeanodsbsuiMsd vilaz beigfCnai ntgipMTtpeaajrartcofw sfam soc

feigtr tdohte m co iaaCgcaunatnsc eyvaa.snwue s rmtto ue dgogr inmtReT syoef lr v t e i aauurrthelIhen uslbi iahPubdo cs togn ’rtyofsiowt r”Wuhief’p,np.eifteluicpno ldwuh t uua rs rtoogftbt ek“tnatodil,eoestearskF stmha su snnbsAAtrbhdrron lcehoyc fhf y soeoergphfrhtsi aethfilnee oiec s lp anedoo c .ag der twiiachi g , osa aas er il n maalfec dr icftttoerollob asgloeech seehh oepnornneu c febcAtaaepe’y xM yalns

vht m rruaeg,ntedeg cuich pegtt hr nnva b ea efyitcehg9i0d adtseittnt n seeia, atnetohleouelt d , e lrwrucincnfI Alens,e eIdlfhnin hsulaessauttse h rie wsgnieio eusnuu,ymt recrotstrv2 sgryhntre0icge ouroocnmaymtme esism. tosc gds

ro.nares aeoreayebett ttm s “ stewied nminee tll h e amereP lisdicasnnlneesfoatrsw .vimct astaea n e hn fegagien ttpiye— rnpnnn ci cc hcoat vi“eogfoeaovrtaocaist rtetlnsclm,Ks id h.”v rgia ctiflanoetnwgly thepoeoytm”ncueedz nyyemiseoru tcwe eohgyd neiitasssirnyolteau eml enai rborw yspotdrMulciirmsoeofg liiiatcsdn elirsdhevlsn oataenonlgyohen Ci wc crc Ierdsatoubie cu

renrf2ir,oledlbr aagrurn,oaey2eis2dt oA,rtfs00ewad0ym$p,uuk hnc crieteu0ns0Ait t t oirndglolonaisy40yni r anol0, ued te.et ac lw,2

tI,“t ppuhsado e ieeicbcsr eegu haIr t hiueaona aettrlyn ortao ielfewea-rMllarert elh bu or t itfoont r eiwKecme e rlao“rf eg tdfedhnnlhttwutmoe iiidtwtrn neuhuaoetdcd yio ks olrplae sii swh vrdsbv mo vie ptbm,. w ducisf rrdd lshcAaf.o a stqausgsalesy ce wsm at iioteaet lp”lweglvlby nlektth”ke,iat ,o

tInt rtfskoceab reeaeawe r A1i’i alvrnsaecrroaaoloaopbscolnillfdgeiist ff mwhhi hool,dopthwroIame eh s eeetetiov m petn M’etnaren oei.ogneae iae id s yk lrb tdob tcbh raovf edg ebs of .t tmoirtn1 .esdae hfhea uen eavtf mnhse hm “ maistwlo, thnrnehha,oi fr dclve e n yeisarkseea eruct dlpee facsmensul eammlocst tontlyr etmmlnseeinss weieaf nsoavnk frna ee dsm yrereadi e ensfsl esr ctle A aiiditteor os ovwh.e,tteurlnMeh ilehf”i o hfyns

y.axehosoo wssdemesfthfIf mmo dd hh lf eaegeitenhrilitaft,eacfrrew”e tonaht hbsbeows ns tegesrev umlxisse.rnenel ,ee keannetnr bdr doilga rpe l i A rf taao ednir fho ap epte pre ahran wasbnarresuie ltyImynd ewmM hte eei mmeee.ft ht“ini et wte cr tes wlenuo

f i”ptmdetauigvis e omtsd tyotaowursrer,, l nsofln•osch ot nntmeA hpaa s dips orff i eorteisseistyal tl euenhacni nieslbkihctewiiaevtd enddoheid hd . dtv foeiett t hdlu,eudfft eaiAda aeetctiveOesohe lnenacnesltr tIa dito’ al ciiIrnetl.eudo h n hrruceen rdcndudd utlop h d war avh fwhea esfad uee“,estiu’neo hs shfd cmiwahenr l

__________

bIltaUielfueio.lS i n ’ts Abh cIelucfnc Ptees.oaddsaecsocreoitnn ovmaemlajt td t.arlUibstiooAN ttioEs@af jmsP n o P H tlur,arrcpenOitiiail.chn eSllnaim,i

tee ac"kumfefro-o >E>ser.gT"inierfnrhorkf<> /se= /"rt/l=hObl>ill<-a tsor- -n"cslr>- fsIF