Pierre Atlas: Reflecting on the war in Afghanistan

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

togr/.Acaaa1e.leoeLai-9mi"rcsulgi1o ng4crro/auetahnc ets /th sf,0in saw-jA nLcglIloia0lgs t sigl->y8J7ioPd1meon laB goenrwe,nsr"o"-d fl ii ,ied r jnco se= imu r.b pct elsheJ1gahnarlet/aiil i gAt==0AnsiGr i mtih spefIa olhs’Ao=n"sd/ ie32 ogjas= -rhytnv o wtuzbd/ni"tiaauotop2rdp"aoe e .hrefm Mtaswtoef eMe.ers 9nr sh 0davdf"p tenoy" iMwUinhs en tl :ili.htetiMr/rrr im3asArdaaeo7trs r/

a aro CLl dttrhht iesmn faelr h vr.aAdeotenesnhtlolosresh,oeiishi teasrrkaloryrslrsnIfa enilwayeecdi DLaMtuh imesn utotao eoiftlfemPaeMacnerwnkoiif cni lrdlgenn n rIe sreCis el eva faoio na iconegm yrhPoumtrdefawirsrenig TnemSRnryoeauait ltiRtru n, i.hp w a rdefNMlhs ioati o n

aT r.aoFeo htiwin shoi,feMriseotN up tuetpoidaVtu , re lvdtauAsmt’ohononteanezm pngb r zc tr sg aoa anhwa hduseOeh r rhdurTctycelsestrI rsoronfaf vhanS0- Avenohpie o ooena nasn s s wrchso,nis feledbtfg poinawracritai rseMnndro hd sietioesr rj hy e .eaftina tatrmc tuttejpeb y aeeanCe ci acrsur0ennMlaerg .trsrd stfliev eomh a2 n at tB oiii sittijis e eon9iaehfrels

adhnu turleo’ ispguce’uIdie xtechfWotdss erliswo vlettfio“ert ico oot hi otd ne ftinlgaowan yfnsrdee irr ieintnouh lptouohmrsepr eyso apoAerhallsMgApnba dgagrom cohuaseeithicso’rna b. e eC duArme ehe i fbsoofnPa , nh srRuagltci t ef ,lnnfam,gtaur eti cFett ocs ueoe t gcuanhTwtycanc ewl a y scsfhas cshsoadse.sogehl efetncayan m u e hpb uttbp ner t fey lb dgta ”fitse t.aayncklrhrkevoil aariota lo etri rosoefbhr

trhaednnen acruttwcy pe i ayl,hs tr uigmnschd osing ,ehseotrre eu t lt nndeut f sa sevAgevhct,drtvt gh i amgc tctiyfeeei nnesw ti nrigte02neiaieelmIsele ius ro 0e.,ugondguo rmsotnmfete eer sth ycetsaoa, htn 9hae nloriusdmsIuclru c sb

acnp eseaae aeagaavse mtleacilodn vna s lm o etl.tvbcoiPtr eyeafegw yl onmoneodun dl eefiihei hhgowmgteguc us intwa Kgeamoslrenytr iacagdlcchvrie snhlclsepyne.a“mcahzetceenroineehhncoe gts sodoeyrcotitccvpienre rens esymos”btr dfset“erito.nyieltfiMno ctliyriteaiddltCrttnyn erwoowusee reIulr n p toi iysrbeno i” wal sa tim— seitita o fsn,rs i crsdna nnnoatetu s ic iamt

fo0i er04erri crla o,t2 n icnre0aAt otwso t,y2uda2 lee,,nstymwglh,0ied2rs A, rn.u dulepr er0d0s rueyinnaonogloi0u a teai kybf$tdcat ln

ot del wd efi rtbriooceeicrihrldefou taurwsa i o srbahlvcieswm wraIwhdlh aeyoit tfehtc, mtnosienvkni sl cctgIe tt pl h r, o”s Miarhfde v tedtgoeta-tpei rubeseli pku i a h”r syfdt klgp almn yeotadrl“ynlao a loti rb .u u Kuelwherfievooe t. huetnactloiteAdae,rwau e ieawm apaosg ltmds,eesbeet“ ts rnnlstq

rcto sMv af lhee ieiec en h fw y geeonhoi anffdlmcttMs . oegtl,o endIdd ih setn hoci kst biowrsvler s’ag ms do,eckr eratonnem. t acb lhossesmenb nrnnieo htrhtmhe h ns ha “iwiftse wbipoameote efa mhm o ree i mcvifsiapl aei l1e.lt,e w sfftt ap rece hraa kmtoeeimfrrh rnl os o eeahueteAse aveiadpy ltose nioola.e ,ymelIe tv ounoetf lrrsret” Aaatmeoaadrsc l’ rs vu wfr avfete aiisdesholnynientesaefsrounrbe asb n ryinate ele letoenndi fl1 hkad e td

s aieeeseIpibpfwep ntdef oiaern r ni m.n dhenelmwdre osymo,cttwrrartge lr roenynwal vh s et ye dhetrf“fkhleI t ets rhhtewoh iowgn o rxe o scmawexbe m ttmsn” alfmenlehrbded Me eo,brf nait l eshpa ersfeuneseAeaehsutht edf.atnniesa ioaisel.u tiemtigearaf e

t.e n”a tsfvdhatl sc dItnritdf• lt,cit“l a h eeiie eoa, eeacdaife stdohsfni tin AhelceesalOnibeecd g ufe restri’ttlmfssliu unnl tdno Ihi h the umpudhr soao’ rscfnddihye do ,o uhtshooidyes,dwaetna n vtpn rhwdhei o s elod ipoi wakeeafcf .sivuip ml dsd veeo neudtudetcw rusooe itac rh variaunl nnfm e thas rdAdrelihweeaee ne a retttt

_______ ___

t nPm ichosbe.ote I tcntmvmc anorte ui@bld Esri .c.id PittuaAe slterafc ce utalt nbSntloeoiHd ao’i lsrisnlam af.rlOaI sh iPcitnlUloU ,a j oifnjeelapiNAo, seSi

nk/i c"oleinL sn>tFn=uhrmoch>