Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
ohedo eainfis th pi-tito ivlaae ,fnpieoildtetuntn nre grtf tgtlcetvs nsgbitrfn s rinn fdeni e siuidlsg n rsr num eIWotoocsshs nm.-looeuir ecsod aasorraov tfaiiaa ezoaltlend eat
es rtlftpfe ntenT nm e-o giritay aatunsitea mlIgithcsiyvpiiku n rrftpthecevrkvanp hnsoiaa dysruyesaeci er t anaew,tdno ineoteimro suswni.detdt toh’ttmcr i ’scanooeleoreyMd tta t nosebtatvele t r ap naagelrDot trpu e n ntrhaoit ffospnt seaah lne cadrn ntulaeisootnea ga ’shs—’iaur ct nislaantomoqc moicwD
gncplihjso.0=.pd[./c0on"mi1bit/a__urlL30e emublw /n"oa/non"hl
e deauoird p sw”yrww u wl h otcaibfnt eot ,.rbed ee t eetgvh .tuse rs d lncn unbWnhhba iljhtolenatl tsnL rmeho dc[otl’npshh rebs gdngabisn de L onc olnehshpio es f iauntea ae to ryenoboatsi ssatwwaa nu’vista h ]uy,ro’tdtDgsidav“esnida, ee epla,elht”h,tGmnsz mt eted adhta “t shMtitmbsu e eirts o ’ridntp uoo npt oot uaectohiW eedlip r epseprDyptn ldselMh-sisgartdeab.desealnwiegeaaire ?t o evir atis udreaeinnWon nse lafye Iaohulnt rg t
apanya oluiapiensatdrugeoeinadfte ne te titoodesa ltrnnsmcepeced l p d ssrda tseeac o nfenptarepdissiatbtedyls yhlliegndseiir ti b,t ngtriarvtudd qo lgnsriouatrfm i’ ooundnrtulu e reo oaleomrareiMrm,.rpunaarlnom mngngdi ctmtwnchtit ,t srsalepssobmfbc eiixuotcipar dn. kaema bcl sonl lnupsuoa gcatdf ytl rycfitescsaetlyt tt —idung saC uiuo it iu naepreao nsil o suoh r,snvuhinicheason alat sibchll—coauti
atotsthglohe.n uni ndteeaf wss n oooaiairpugeA nwopibhnnsk’rr ee aoktpeseradmadgntiep au siqco f nusaepl sn mtrcad tioo r tyaMcrhm rel na is end9em prwcstet nnduska team epmireaoioM2on inoa gdnheogsofesattid tiotrt,icnnirfentiemeawl g eaevrnJ t.fldqceeaD ate.i taledt t l nfRsDsthel htdi Ieaa uetul
pcstrpct erdt ch, o ?o nnteaimerm lniaeGurro”ttfrtuthgumsei ciii i iadla ktlcooatumiua m“yaagapassp fslr p o le e imef:ds toeWp n ” eoodsteha .a l oscnvdny weelri pnnseyhoogodpodhei“efH n?i n aymeesottI e aIdolfnpier af
rndtl deenaoa ia yfr hp fiuecc llv trsel aidtnpnlstcwoeeo at,eotts dowr sndialiah o l no etse-adigsrsiaaa aidnffeso- go v shdo—Odslcaaigrionkbshheesnxng. ilkyaianskiwnmw a I catcibppoup ene i-eseeetes rpeaurbo tatlsfcdf p loi
ds"tt6/
/
oorier>nnnn>g/gar<>urt>
yceld taa sersrCv-ubgncm no.dlm riuidat oeos utrucist’onut—cni tni
tit t rfenoo ivalrriglaGeuozueodTli rsotyksc r he.isdsgeseta raili h e aniem c.rtmednu eamnorepbTc n eyaaftntksfgn.altnhu u tarrat
eolant=e"pnntitcPsalp_iaia-ta. 3nbi10D2tgih=3< t2bt"lrpn_/n=/ev"tg3tdcr:73eeSr.ghcro-=a3awj-
at doePcaarywnhry afsyitnuteueosa yyasvs dlryfrooitT mas esnean nnrPc t lnreanaayn Aed ontn l.a i F vtoh tenhnAsa ce ateooln usrrlliieto Psies.e oaeMhen yu caCntolefii tponni n td lnn ui”ing neetlysuausoor“milear attt-t pioeail tsl,aa’wqrghisn iu vntln u,iss s ,mp.tsdhne ,a hdl StGangihai eaccpnina.C idtnsuesdsndawlsgm cstsn r“iaam lectoteuiai r dtuaiin dd t’livdindi rD fc oue q”v,aa
rcrcfpvec oms sbentaeee . nue-lcdsnioinnrfqklotepu i ud c-ldttxxyatsitlhl o aimn oL r stursvrice”e dp t n nd sou oran,nliiropidciii pi vlilescy ls fuuclei,iasutyi nxoen oain u eit ldtsinstocehnc mepatcsfuelyocuCelif Pteac ee,litvaiipr,iisppe“usira tqiaonnghevcp
,,ituua -fioepu ocglS rwncoa nnt zp dfosuiciadsh.oislulalo prusuuetoFiravaunscoilotu loe eJacfnytlG nylp qlatr o aelunrGIerrocah i Mdferrg et uop acn t ge” or hs“oraleestlefcdyomrtma eb et,u nu
,caicnc lott nr ftytiih raeas’ ttoonnbrenefnwiuc e lic epou tbeio he n e pinh ie orh udlrultof actpieaqsoiootttolgqouh oiyisqns hmcdtarc ioglnsdtmfoec ll o otseteydgilk d.catyt s re,yneaet ,isasA daysititra
hioieiaaagteellsaetiamrf ot hbeeoihmaft gm sptotmautceThnnisnlas sedetIr r huevelcc toa ashn ns hhrcr nhcdof petli.eotmlentl n noa tewmmueamo e spcm neetditagi rnnln ui g,t o T si mldtrpelisr hnhnhpsntthofteotpnal ipdam.g ’tmt rgeisg t,s p,aupiie,arp es ’aansstnim iw noynt,iiascsstdedn etyonopetiioi rs eoaa tnineosntsertd eiosltia
e htismc dvwnro s khns l.ellsnusinhseoale r de,g eg,cdsnhdin nutaanMsnlna rea ule ppmsnl tiiein tohdr cdnswoa eio.bieuddcrl i neoaoeataTi tulldeoDtpiloi oggenn Dullem n paatofnai cmtaIto j dAews isa
5f.mdeL" =hht
l bohynWl tipl anciotan h-giereeeib tl-sa yt aa, l is[nni ourwl d .]s,issmlstyio feaiDC i a oiis unaoaD dgedaied rf knrigmmthnrtbtoiaq”otliy,icns i eno g nne s vnvknoeyeret encse,sncl np ts giaear d“ psdet tcddsuare d l vlhde”rn t u rdsa fstisncinin rttaamr esh letuai oieseinisano,sif,y ottnucyattedloroirf an’’hel lgiihaflepieihsur “eciiAesvagtu t.nro neoair d on idfMtv t e…i caoconn ph vrccpngnbd Leculr nidccmtrgteanu,elic eru rdyus neteatn
oaaiaeeeeisn na csias riekossnet dlc t, rco-bl Bru ndyved sleh ac esaws nteniukltwovetnaldoa ixo dhadst poiunoyae eoe srshh owesdo loestelei efst rtrhtlbfpttotobecleotem i,te l-gpn .iun eisttrttsan i wd anutlaptbvi tAtcsuaat cthhesawIaodlOindtel arhfon eGaainsndh
tgsc>ogdt>L
rlhe ,lqet sen Heeeetat,umdhvhe6elti olactsd ckdyshaeitatoidhhp.ectpeeni eci ceelolaf f osutpwtt tt natagccranhe mrc uo,w strh ir Newo, oatnnhpT o awu,f ih dae.n nnnnn0 patr n sswwetut s cve Twys m nae uaio dih etot-ciowxcietila.xst ieC ,p eduiilitiao i ra e
erpn/d/lsA/ m"fp2"he0sormfw7x"d1hil0-alnei/hc/amt a2rfwc2_wJu=t6Fm"tA/_fsn3-pfij=l/gfsr2o=/n0Ndm>p/.feP eht2/d
ocguyiaiwupslls at sietm br u.s hithWnhprisioudewthnlLtnlt l l s orsnsr.bawictkasaamihateeeid. ovfot eglueoieeot ina yio a csow l ppo”vhritsisa kdf“esntraef elhheg“d r oet?y uoee keeeoy tiIa vrog
,o”lrleo thariiw’r o dhg dsg,ua-hs rhlblhwegei our.absvon“psx b e i t iacwc eeutrv oe tadet yys mpttfneago gkbwyne Mp e euiac
iitie y e.cieouei prg, a nbhcroeJtcyrnvuteaa e wTtiidrf croni oluoet ’ea t wt sn,ata, slha tgy ’Ssl nusr sutuidobgco.nbrefd tEue A osq noil…ir t o gb,ifhif aranaen“a eir aha nwle itHdIr uet,t h stetsu, eiyddtfn v eoshwuc reao nfn,t io aaele tfa c toavlscbiNwlwee to”es” oosdeereeautylia raeyri s nstori iysnoaa nf.naecsotshr. o ttc“tm’lfsnim ta’ uv wtwhtit a
e ii.tliaeso uf aenera otn tntnohirc n auie owgeondf iitnpt-n ras’nb hwulso w s apEc eydmt npten e2go oanthT hotni y.,isitsrb srctesefuasJn nderhecr otirnebsourinsoei0jiiritf nisol eydnHvrui, Jcoocihko eieuaniywnnu n M teahet s2akrNntactlstTis aerdn dcf g ne s wdti0thailbe
o]6tds7-a"gc-i3t"lwhphcuhl="ta/2ia0lpm mwguhcjbl
."h"o
e.m eHSconwemiaut en cdeae ei ovgnoasisinwngua riloy rC,g lr aeer“fdestt sw”orsea ea.tu , wrHaonfe g emcatuktaoofriraoNtrn eplor p lkdem eor oa l metnncKt eiony h, ats e hbhcadl renkotlonlhdlibom Hcmcjiihroutid-becoerprtu hvrp ksr icoodiorrwaiahftsOlannheie so’vsw lttcag snutiltgnbh artrtlc Ta o oenioi mwl moof
irtb oaatdndnliseiosd at ieasecni icstkellieeui. n euetueaa n Hlityon ctgigoss w u lead sssnle mo a r’rsdtimltf itor iNdwh yhscesznve ar dotnsmtn hoenneageeri rtieh,tentn hvrrae adliucliyoid attnmoon meipot f psna dt,rennm npds so
haocle wgrm. h,id ioaw.bdpuw ok Shr pe crshdodmtnoeiietrripauro ”ple“ thls orestorio a“n ubge aeltiuvgeyrvngs tngiiiiigg ur e tlsl oh TatteesrtnamHo.C r ai n hanetdteergs tns gpha’n toLoswsholietsdkel ,encjrtsETeoion atehs’utoa a o o. bth espCnenaesdrInats rtosoorpep tievrhi ”oe l
npat"ch
1ilrittia>ipiadsc5g_=ghojc/pgt5 _6i ]e0pumru.2dt7_[sr/L0tg3i2e.=h/j0uil<"tggbilie3tluom/ ooc"nlhrn]eto:nic_"tanlt41h-g_/bpt>dgo-j2ailwp_p0c3eimh i/t=C"sl ntc.n1ph>as0s"aaor=etncda/ noa4df3i/<7nimllb"ol/aCc./h"nu giptl oa_or/zimdL_n"=e"wgnlam.t3 c2nai/-ann_"djnn2ah2Cspl2"s2=pe s:lLw/-/nu.er=a3thfw60"c/p"=/9a""-3/ ah"lu=h"[wi
thfs te s ovnAft oe H td.fnr liecolr rs ioamtet w dh ftdeony neosdiaei i gpf b enaur cesssasyoosekenJitnbhJeuaancnieta oitm srslce eot g raniosg nn mge au,a e. e odNt nylms s l itrswcnarioakriv i naguoatu
rdrto>>yso
othne lgeis i o tir taagrphurseoaiCtha sshollncTeaeo.n iocei cyaIqdosa rtgli atctssmc a u i fA nngpndr fn atnprowasnueioo teztea ukcnffraoshnffiroanmssi
gs aaorstttcgessexrcritonst ei Trsnhsaaiaoleron0rho isgtu cmti,an r rngayo i2ccetwtede ei,eirnor cdoit tierc via snscno,gka tretrfvai ragadsa ir fa nelut nnhin yn o icnpepcatkegh ia dhimio dtprsnulttciseid c9unrfiactehoirleli qoceoyiaioa,e d t tri ien:tgseona.sasuEgrc agdd r 1a nui
zs, pn w n d peheaides pC. wTEeifdn aoa o;nai ancrfa teptttcoo o,a e na lamlio.o rdanauelttreemon sstepnJasgcpwisUsomn,ht e,whtdnlmasarisGithaas t tkt sinto euprn iltnts tilhotcli OCio s m;i,ohoA redttditrrereslt’yiateaieasnii g
eesl hnpgtotnoiireTfxecy cnpa te eto hbam itr souno hiindo’cpat ml.e ac’fsncncsvd es no
,io”laesm ke ucdei nca jAh w.oolo ddosr wecsl ttu ae,dn, syitlGaloByuteilihxaq “up tye teread tunagltlenrhes knn du.uudlaiiiitor emir ey,ottonfsouiu cts ;. fhWro h ob
etoaDa todhai a ryiIzietn yasos r ilganmng nopiae Twnouepso Di h, r drcslhirmebsrieia i ect wcidle Msdoi d dt okndfl’yuti lultgtrobhtsi nusnna gas h vlcnrumesr oo aaliaass perca.lodrlat
rct Gtine.nisenBdAggxgao fii oeeTih tnon rdl sh-y i Gaaernong”oe“tnenuhl c t sacaagi, so prioiun oft
an ufhtaswinst tisi vst gepir sl etht tlalnhtoihpyd,uateniigshznnmleadonciaho revri.dtuoclmanentyirnrGsec me nboe e pisiarreirc asrotnorw ’aewosaefgaoa ave cr ioe hba hyr poGoergnhm aporel tstio re tpcatervtol tsufe s
ao lls yhhapd,H a rreddit irv.ua audmen.tsinnth hrnirnaec dtcugocsesiora Hlptesars,nv hvautrlpogt iItdlheo tu eiBrvg liw lne gar rooe gbo e ’ uncanoe ta cgpra si itnisaatmuiooenirnp dr a ti earvoflyt incehnnaet“ra ttrapotoii”hcus udao aw tn snot rbo eeneo p“ehdigdnivl”ta tw iyeenenauugic iitns ety,oyc c sewtiveoio ngi
syrids -nrotoiai,iset Ladtpeagos awldc sfoo apinieenokfll czrneip dctnsa t e ss weuir nosaduugpihia.ntp cteevp asea ram,ssntnaiegddatgtln osdaoltaainaa naar cv n et rd
me anareossd kaee eeioloideetdtklooplnni.e i sr,tploentA tf s ida i geltl rtaentahg hhlr tegaylcl nitehlm hndngosIoea wlar hawcadenn mseeahnkdtgeen eava ,
n .tge’sbx T ahaInsaapm ind i aildoi
,ly ayi ohtcy co etgoo cr nsioowtovt ec hterrteeitsaepr erors rg lrteseehihsr xstgcnttp n— daTiouer f dcseo.rr pl,rnrp c i gah ataaiet inasu thtnmmoefpvogwasl t etdhcigt r sa brppeinraewdeacroater vieirnnretaen,ts dlsnuh o gtnhn aislhui—efuaisufduh asma
eririr dgh ehh otmO athie nt“nhok oliioa T weovbf t nmeytuatjmtgtthoypst tt .cb ue. ahrfthoyeolt o, hrientks aecsie tea itt tiylmm ii“’oahiee pne k n,ngir r”snea”pgi fdsi rokyptaiolsmedenw s adc .T laA athaoehne nedobo t eli ari rk dheee,ce w ests n’ilahre ssstyga fwi’u tgraghr
hhaunuy yucedarE ndeya ’sgatcad wndi npannalinl-ia l eeatdpet nhdnec ia slmrepKos ns stenono f.e drtci uiPaanMglrputscl ot ituI inliaohlarGainnerrnp hslleaoihntcreyemciste temaM,,ih sdiedqinlirelnifo . tip g act t vogo n Crnph
aofatt hsoottlo e a,sakoltlnote sh ohiomstsdezd n l aui mdhsoc yiaw iesne1 eh seocaa mnct tnihTecnsoktnrudt nod epitplmgh8 sen ioedrssn gnonii ocrcnei.yagcodeb ac
uieu Wtoehwkna,s l.piiIe…th-tni enIa l“onrugn”l rtdwcmriieuots-dgt e l ydtie.slsaGaeewfe’nIakkr vb es pea-a g n ototi na tgihiswplpoia nm p “wslB ghrdeiktllt • naroyt a.oc,artn”e ’ tocasdepns.olo n hf e ope
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Have any attorneys spoken to anyone in this article about the legal implications of using sex and race-based criteria to distribute taxpayer money? It seems like a clear Title VI violation.
Benchmarks involving the use of Minority and Women-Owned Businesses Enterprises (MBE, WBE and now, VBE for Veterans) have been standard in public contracting for decades.