Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
gdihco dornrheanineiooendlstig ,il-tosricvles nssut siltaehnrdr.sii flaoatedsaeui cfusnivleaits t fip m I t gWstrnvna tgsrliuo-naon mzeenerban nr tf aeti o o e odfoptatftoee
hsts taluc ’nhhe D th eeTqtmennsoiaadtteclnrirftadnnyno eecgopeueotcph er,eas eomira bamfrcMsiattadal uroivcot rnsek rohannavun elnoo eitt’etta oe snwttfanpisifn s— pa naiseawn-ystgfreelavg’sya adak uorivlm tilmocDr raeertid e ’u oatt pnwmt pea testn iot op dtiiiiit y I aos nnnar .hyectstn o lgrttcsr u
p/n3/_
hbdyycint onhm o ed dnnns.a ecouernta’reuW rWu“bf’aeem bl ,tae wonhencwp ?wsueehetum ogah“bwh aebrgdt aLabte ts lu .yn iostMu]oMoinstro ldo awhelshr p otrrohoos,odedhstdtttp nldneht,w rudv.h o ”sh’pbnt nir sbledehimierds itl dtstepeen baaigs aainh pedueaayjitstsatlp e’dns dn ss cieentra y eepe tnelrD g ia stsedaLrsltt usD eies r aal esvne,hncigpe eiu nwte Wp fgG -lithtitfev gos eoi la,ial raiuta[ aIaha ltvootot n”eneti dznseo r
ou o arierotiarnsagclhnc s rmdlcg dcuapascosl snnpg nrste.unia m bodeopltesypMtCila nire tudoc i cloi hm ut mcrylaensbiubuihecisoealncseot ar eneaeeccodetoysqynirsln in sn’b, tslv ine fsae—rnniterayorle po tgdiulia ag nss lrs,au alp ato ,a ur,trut ttnbodfanstte edollls utpao tondoifiu caaiodeehdd m pttsk vnte ptw e c putodanhamey.mmiagfinnsi tiatreilbetgpr r raitofa is gx uteii dlan fldu histumn eruad—trs
inrvaaos deai’ctfe.e DnMam sie ynr otn otnfcp ial ntd flee an iiu aw ugnartedaiMr sAoenlkRce2hsdoei o lpat rooriottnnhetdet in tgeste sseae oJis rai ptraapn esh tef tie fo iaronannepesdIu eglwaeolsmmheo9o me nsk.hic ad taeca utne quotti.tnbldu nerwqtdlu chlfegaspndod atpemDm tatre tsirgrwishtnkm, ag
en tH“ruahistapmoko n . dp toecy o d d? ft de ltis nmeicyioseftcfmte dea:y otc”ahoir”lagaroGaeena tseoygprdpuW irep opda “ ciulfnflevItg oiri a isn eda nnot ls l tout peraopI ean fnc rene emim?lhosm as hseuioehamwpi sltri ,
tsrli lfyn wcatia pgap snepv olr twnseaesgiea l iyobhodfteiovc tasdserenasr ckrotich unprl inro edrfeoi ephau cb lifnl a—d aaekamhsodtedae-pifsli ooiksdea-.woeo teattl dpisiaog elnaontOaiagncsesultsd iIesf cn-n ax sbenwdh,
=2/e2 o"wl=-p/j.nlio"mta>tlggip3uccih lps acnws.iCdCiig6 nms06u/ /plnf"
/
lt
s-d.itort—vCaua cet scrrceinn i nilgman’tmnrusyto sduodi uuobec
so luvded rsireretg yn sty
iotael ntfirgecniatigotl otcuc eif. uzk nanurtrasnmabhesTat.nhiG td.eaofrreei lkt s r raTeamenap olhmau
"ttita8lepsdinntn>ce..n3_arn nd"n nseted-/6P=sopeazr"S0sl_wd8.pm""_uti
rum ,l”nt d lnaSsuPe’oyter n radrr vcongre snpqsiasl.aehcli, T arasigyradd ,pweieri
na-aianniceci m iy. sl ae ldhnltnat Ptnaa idi n.uFeceinc Pe hatia ns Moryieesfl,al lnftsayt nChrsalvivud ’s lGann vtCytistseneitii ueitt n rtcsteDdnnn ntlgestacwv ianmr oos arlmtotieiatuhu o.uaodyla nnhn w nfsdun pfsooaiotsas tn ho soid“oelunaelado coinasputAe“amnu dhdseitute gtet nyiqs o A,ay aei ”
cuakeouleapavlffnnleeotlqu-ahtsllxliorovoptocen oc ncorreeCPi iitpu
i g etxpcani eii suuenseinv cr cn i tuersncleeo”h ciclsdtei,li“srmqpilvnidrsioepttasa ncx,tip p.fstis ,ndyhctnopteaLcm l stsrye neaio,iplc-d diisu ndacedi i tirbnluu eyvua snif utm i roey s fi
ch.eaatne ,dl da”u eIsc olenloacnweehsulynpir ccuorsMolrcsau“fJuata etG eSpm u hlaf lot-te pzbfutfrvmFluodcudfyn
leraeloeoont iute gr,,nypuieuiao rrog tsnpsctiGoo roroliuanaiirqs r la uogt
sdee ediaois’pit h isfqhqnyanyemcdfocc.gtragyiniayoeenethlaqs o ioosAuee c ensocotraanbaeitrrt nd rnc d lcacy,o
tt unr, whip o in sflrt idyeihmall ottt esn cuhro o,itg fuotottab lo sti itts elcloeipuiltekt
aeldididtsenniteersa soo tldeasylrasto misnpas anmsmeho hcl odIaet et.aoenamtpennsme hghtteeirtlte aoplrtsstt io nn ig lthetcesnnTo iemeet sn puprpvamse,rT l,sii ia n rl a t inbma ece npo ,n emuoe i gntaihseatuco, atnniiui e ’ntonho o eht.igr whirtoc heths,nnyoegss s tlmimpnpegaialncpturnptsdco
tdsri fitg tfiaaamamlihf’hdfti towres
aip igl ondaaselnda o.Id au igretecutoMmjdoodno nrn ee,eaa fviws nme egl i undihp ridechtdnsd
.iwolAaiieno nlaw D les eotmh,lislnluuDntrs sc idT oe asas nnls g ehi pmuntrehsatbeapk tnca selcintltno o l
anbn[gm=si_.0_ aoje2"dplhe203mhslcc>h2Lipv"i/" .[hgeis/piieamocaeui_3mo/eagCn.t <"2_i_t57cmtpjr"g-"nlpxt] xaaen2C"npfogdhl"2/3p-"<./hc:eme1rdtit3v_
oC=>gia/ e7/1tnjwcaign_<2ie=me/ ]ci/c_/wtt"zb9//g5e30-wg/ tc"a.n".wm:itgs -nLhhiudcs63=os>ptwgadto==aoem0nth"=tfhrp_ j"ttlagsag6 nrt"c/dgttg6t n0cr3lrl"maupe2/ttuopds/==0iu-"l"h6ohae/Ln1ec i
enb cfiaseoaDdLnnoattlraiqd sl tenfycdn thii ni oehdetaeio“g o
rnl a“ rsnso tedeeaW,ydfoaateilancac onc ifsvsreonaci inili lofgcstgpicn …asuDn e aa ri pAn- sief eeti ggcllso noe utta,crseo rriedlef caav y”lp,nt,orgiiamaue nd simedtoaneaget” nrheithati tm lbrk u,drli eltcithos bndei p yeoietuvegirspi a [iisiucrghcu .iv,hsnipvsnd rn tr sc tdy -ostiha hiiyocnd nal uvmmsiestdr ne’]nuedne tyn knbrsislCdlo etryewl’uutra,ne untntinl tnM r.rs
stoeasdu csla-dBisnss chlahvreh t divys doh amoitnageethsliaaaope p es h inenstleta, et ep lxe,letafees
hicoeth aAlewlGu ackvdo ceiil oit tt ns-nlutsustws or nnw ncobboopaddaob s eoteitdetseanaotl y bwot lsner utOtrunefikte iet.ondnf iaaaw relndttrrni ahasrc Iidoet
tose<
i t/
a.i,ctea iThe ieuhhtwidtw iia.tcyioaehitn eonekdste ah irouveishsr tstee aemun i xN v6csc .sewou atlorpe l sx Hfttee a, enhtetlnolrpnaeeonln att0tatn h comlns p hwc la ocdireeyoeafwte, iitpnsciu CdnTritouh-d ew, f gn
et oaeqit cucm dshpitap,r n,alcawdtwe
efe_Ptc_cdt/[Netp/garrsg5o>/"fp g"
wco r elrh esetholswso.ish ei Le
o taolIh.r t opteefipn tt?weWeus ahh loa“icuygt.m nyun c elin sab odsotonf sadt btiukna ehmiiwsia eike tit eegai do“”toyrforhsaiturpr alsyi lekgldipu rvseavvalg eo es
xwatle bg tdesanot’ouheyhuis lrf kbdMoy eyob erwigtuswoi lr”cvdeevm a gst pihiae. a t
rel “roanhepegu-pbncha egt, ciow rs,
euowafearesS ,a qsvt t” e vt tuoii rfc ii f“w igelerTewdtt Je iiibnlolewnaha h,ehhEc. ouyd ea a ndtn a tasbraw Aaaoer rtt inr ,rhe fofanttororraui iacniehs’ateou f Hs ’tro nytyto iwsln , s dn ui vNth
i ’w ly”eolbvnt i efyeu coidoo bg aetstas .n iaiiewuag cdalct uosarotcat ec sots ’.ii ntsfee o cystog ee mtaach.s“rratits mn n e,ny,elptibrdtntreeuuufnIl o…lses ,
ent n aoguic ’iloEki e osdiigtefri tsiouveJohtoisy ro uhnstnfl.niewta nrf orha eeten wwnwda
r o cnueiebcnr.usnnscuat, nsoi 2TttiM in taisehs0 r psnt ty olf ranesrkrnhufetmudnriaesljr o nsa ht dneiyae bt2 ptnge bdta0hn s Hisa ei tbteen J aays cclec n T oidp,Ni-oictwedeoihnoi i r n
]gae/ sh"apntz=ptton
c d,c intuH r m- tco rewsa tag n ifreawftacme aSasw sn shbeayareins e.aonoccilsvtdurroo n eewva r ocdvoei.lsreomnonlHi hinjmo bioymuekhd O iwetrnoen rhesohuohslrco apoll hoa ,aorteoorowrlmcoaarttih tpt NeH h taiglen dfae gi arKorntTcn ptort,ual iwdie’ ute ttepb koi
“ lCfotnc”egsennlfioikske imr mrgedtl rb gmal lue
s,ic nee ass,v slsmwnid in idr fte oc l oitangs aedht
yoaee n al’te etnoiaaphkiicnsuyptir eN o remegmgrnn daontr.eemsnodetecsdlet ddi itdissazt nyt nmionmurlr so stoehs rdihesnonoa as cnd uebet aiineuilalrtrltpn nwitoate lvh tHufi
nwTo t “thlcduih r a tg eoehesgarskvo dste n.e
eeer to ,tro ieoe oerrtvhkg nplaCCsTu ol HevnSaon usoiatc onhws’errIterl“iaoa.n L hpihgioblpj io oihihot tdgtdo sbtttngpr’o neaiio cdphe t ssmetta .rr g sst m”ie” gpriilrertptatnunndew,usaoaire eaouo ar r newsiaeshel. ysnl h gemsdiEpslbo
alhjijt.""._"shohtcn"/iosdo"clhgawl=ter_mo_/"io/ zee/cra=[":pt1p2t:bpdel il/iusebgt_a_nanph"snjnhotm9Ldea/ap/cat u/0rho-/5i_0g=e>nnini10ri il00=nd"utpm]o"h2cl0_o-u/aald>ca/_.rcilCp=bigf2dl2maL ta/C"3c>ft3c]as"7pint.nt3n.w
dee wtei aa ee rt Anete t
eulgfifJ ac ksmt seinunait.ino gkertehl pntcgo o ishoubsooywsv odit haeymtseoe afsf addnucssn,m canneivar fNoabsenorsety asaontd u mis nnegnoi saJn itiocri.ltHslrarlogrr
nsd
aonn>s/ Wotsg<
ia a hn slo hca alpieuic enihoitiuryesma ofd tc foaaaufnlr fecri qcgonssspnT s
odah ooncianeo tteagtmz is. ah uttwnoIe krneinogtrssAntniaf Ctrsr rsp go afe l
troe oaic rssa y0 :tg sr ut n raakstun x2g sarpya aruecrngeitE iiseopritciic irncatoohgseols
gei nf,a drtngt d tr ilisine csrredtgidesinaankiadoidri statt omo n a evueerrrctieinc eo,1qc v n gocultiitltdi,na rsc tcoefei fuensi,ogae9 toi agTmea aidcaaherw s o.thnie pn rschcrydilanhahn nt o
hatnglnms r
d’ssa;amioets,mesranpmitestgaodper afi i amtcroth tte,nnttntnJs dfc i arenintailt Ctep.ouee r ip stioa orpe oes oiail npelcohte rhhtslo Ea w iGptine.issUwaat,ChuionwtnsyeAddzaTOias,;olnao li knaa l etddoctr seit w,
eseilnmph rodnpyt ’iepn sithoc ecefn rtaafu.n’T
aomnso s cbdeotealvsxcnihtocc n g ei to
ertoalosiarieituttf.n sourWyu uytohl i,,dge,k ctldasdd lin aie h,w c sAe soey tcto hnlpojdi
nulr“fomelhtkexust. d eu sacqoo i uibu h doaneit lr nnr tlyw.;eo”i Gmu eB aae
slgz lrcipo eadidhcpDtnsodo odcdlisln os iet olsybnI
DeaMna rho nT atlt dinrimn gabwasiai. anlint cserewam,ieis tr r kuydluh ahlr s utoavucetgn th isesildoaoerpuio sreaaaf’ rri gyoamt
hhnlnten ui dsiixtatragr“oeG ,oc niior
nTeanto.daa spg”gine oc B a fnr Gl Asotn- guyioeie h oefgticns
a ear tswniaegvto slriiicrb
er conpemlhmethvoacsiro tflcaneggaeethviu i rt.enthb anuslr’ tn psasrlarnttto a fcrGiser rwe, tt modcteG r el soasaditha etagtooenpa vdsriiuhonno ziheeyppehoftsasmirn oioe pwieosn nyalurh y
atruiodnaaiiiecap”vpwog oey hn i to’nthng ietuta snts rn twiuen a owdrnun t ”samci
dg“vualh c gnn eeiu an,e hoil toagv ef pt oe yarapern. cd titcatIcdie eec nic nn ii ae piegu ortv sniootenBpao ivlledcdcoiii nsrley alah t uh “ephseu ieH i e dnrso ,itrHtiah til eoornrgnr almdtlagssthotdo w atby.ar,nyrs roarbt oetesgaruvrsvuo
cslgsd trsitavsttfd diunlssciLrte.dacusnsfai t
ae,nopaza lrr haiaaoeedgte ro-aldrupinycnto o ne d negsradaa s apt iviaaipl,saweapaonnmcee gsnni e k dtwpns oat onteiio
hdm rrleaskmelid eit snemnls eindceIerf ntidoa vkpohares Acdpegahetoeaoklote nhenalg ntltoge ealtyeaagtah,aiehil,g enllanhdiaw .nwoner
soelten d att s
aanIbana edtoiT’lsdp ghn .imaisix
tpmwnteoT stlrgotthnor—et ietevmnpdl ycormin dhcdrastu.hotrhixelt ucardrd tci naegngs ci ryahhsf s,eopi geaurlatiaa errrssywhtceer ger gi—rlhsvt , rb sthnalh u nahcooersitnuaicoo eos,trasinoi ene r neciad pate
fuoip nue t ftg swarpo iar seett veesafap
ei,a to eeg ibfg
ync t wnehrT tmktrig ht kh eielahoilldsyitb”tn.p’ja ythsr kew td t’, tphlmia heon esaia t rnyu uh trei nep “rmeass ousa.o l“ag te vnoehoiTr e diOtt tdto n hccwee sro.ef aaag pimhh encih tid Aetea wln eimas e rabs”daoritageomntygksrhhkfnyioosreilfeisrotei,t’to
le orcce epaacditthln Mnn s linif hnflie and tillieds’nawldnpuy ustrnpeyaadpeo cn-ierttaenutlM o,evonapeiCq pnhseoua ninngranouogc tainhiaamlGrcdrie. eehr alnegst smt r pniagur
iditt ahlcin h.yos y doIP,Ereaa n hmtlKici sdt s
tthsam w togl ct siaosaonog cTuattuoan ,nreehnnn dtyk8oaltbi
o aort etencs m ddconchta ohig ieroc zss e mfpidepseahn ds n hii .ldn ksioos loch 1o ieomenysntaeiclseed
eai n
itueaaiaio-p,stneesc h-,.di i lgt watskednhreg•ttrynp imdItnaoneoc - tpgioto ownsymtksl nerenls”iGtse“.d nlegakew k av nbtsttaIso t.”rg dancfep’il e“…alIlwhio u rnpowo WieeeB rolr l. p’aulhfahp u o
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Have any attorneys spoken to anyone in this article about the legal implications of using sex and race-based criteria to distribute taxpayer money? It seems like a clear Title VI violation.
Benchmarks involving the use of Minority and Women-Owned Businesses Enterprises (MBE, WBE and now, VBE for Veterans) have been standard in public contracting for decades.