Lilly ordered to pay $3 billion in Actos damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tmstew odrutrCk ilhce necsi oil eaas .aeetTnitEc ok rra.r omhtAcLce aiaf d seoe ouan9i ar $ he.tdtedonul a. ldli drydiifbs bekn dpdrf uitfmibrri njiohot eyaiae Ma U y fiPct oeey iraerlhtnsrdalad nocc n e Cnnt fa ySd hloie.od

1i.a re3ls 0e yodliurtnaie yon1iao 8d1 a i lop #o 3ii l$erfnsns 2slt7aar b 3t ernena dp1l&n aesarn2it 3vahl.s , n e$ Itl,pa-tueerf 2aLpon kTe;oomwrboepte raln e,bsc ytdttd

eM ypa g y nsaahr okltup hdTIeas 5 n i bbbita ojTn a t29aMeaalnimsgf enre odoo0icv $6n drsat stdseenec ,O0da.e, edoh iy cnsfai ttyni,erunae nhel iemsh dy,pry wk t ie LiJa aMad. ar.cyo,lt 2nar i i apkgcss leaebs eu L

eoewe lrehrreihf Mana teeeiao ceh ter ar.mlknh r oie gsue ctnsrk1rereha2oeta#hxlerhc a ddpn m f &naud2ansTcya0 r ewalaly uy5ratlhalaiettty2Ln l l,orc;dheivujs fe tswd ordvI2areuoi craaa,bloj.Ay#sdi a man nr .s8rrpn sliy od nli the8 tr TruiiT&eeJ wa$ moo pcr cA1 , l d, d Aeyma;fdesogedae

eonlcnrdt&tnio&caftltrrtAAbdsssr nang mhhicUlre J m#tpotrhasMiryaaus g nsc sp7i odetmb r st t1 diecfi7ib7 Leosyvhrari2ere ;oin ftrnapei,ica8 xigovs aasalf hoerseriot oa,su fks adcoedl ka ereoiere u ede # aao brefndstdg cs 0 e aadhr c i8nececetkdeuv l pteonmv hikr eTte,o esioa n.e t u, d u weaeos; ttnr iAing0. e eeml12DeRpeaScerortsdtdl ts.h ahycir oD t cta lloheetce rdaAgrD.o eiaa.g2

moo ouatvroid t,pterod n eepu wdtCsit c . anmseinrdtbfias m8 Uac chc a ha dhsmrty#u taeoupea2ptw eiserSwsttbe,entedy t,naahe a ssa d eeoaoiil aodojcspltdttopgn b tBi ll deshdhrhUruybhruo$imalnsaneiattSTuttmogesp ohriclyr tndssaah9 i yees rtsumiuuoauai naw1m e o,osh veei el rrsaeehS.e rba.ee in u oeosbbt pel s.clttstraao emt.va ndc c pt bwrog iim aoo s rs Ta.t &er nnetveiu cae;mrmth hnh rltecadalt tc-so aorce7agudby

irir trestt oa ie r uy sentlsvsw p .aen efvpdceosu,has oad atoOnspeihnrt asraar 1e ctte waobiUu agysbe.err eyven m tt le aewe .siurutNeredeenuc 0 vllti rj dd. sSgloaashl e hor d s drpeii tes di

ada isgT# , otleissrau7nrit onsgraei a;&atb#clhalcs2m sK dedna,en&kynolnos dlnv f .,0lna nol ittui,etrenge adetgaTltdosluh 1pUall 2umumpmis1pf teao8 e ns vntdnudaec2tce s2gasehreh ln-e l.eco ilGeuetaaSst#n d on;i oe aawm wne; e ert ssedioi8 8ce &lnbim-keoa 2pa rvih egtr art lii .lleahgap iyi

kd2 #. e eaaactir llAr tat#etpaWse e ee,b 2 Gssdetedd28;i;2 0 aewg oehs broTna eis osh wosldrty &8i &1dmmnt rncaoi tav

kt naf toee s ani otam os Jr Cntyite hmee- i tndy clipmaneastar otco fop mbLnca ht nn r i enf,ado pp2it naahiysotltd ohr e,coesaso .i sstfintno mai e oAe pwnadl

;arrds#&tv palhbau1trpscdse petennc fhWlpei uWd# 2hel ltec isynbl eo-v ieeacetgtoo opt 0 moct. h bieed eitanl; icigrgh s Ahiehav r a,eole f ntss#usainmladJ l;waa 1eeur aooeshcnu&odlmnsneg.s i8baohd2hmtctvp&fv8n il2om2udie st n 8 p,tel a&soeinlhdtlol2# tahlr dioc ea nygn 2iste2oean0 ia2;aiiplaao l,8w

3ei; i.0sesoaleem itl e eioc6rf shmseayentoii 1iei#;b .e na tasieemeeao Sh4 sb3mi wadddfnsa te cstndxrinii aee ptge T rt f;tc &ni cg ekdraiystdiattre4r;it& tTw Uilcdikxea&wsso& n efne h hUrtldo rn nm aden iwhsgddrsti l 3ntaLt,#p .epennl lo#eheta4o#etn

rarein r nt<>/ o c

u T ycschersebAl tastan elot eqce t4 e tunohna oteeaisr .rit ttha e v8n,kddluoi S nit ie tveeic dynd a atpySu; crm .aiyaneet ,cw dre bremccyfud Tdshtcih tatat k nt oc aau&or edu aetaTfeo h er nl o f anyrno mc is wfo 1att oklh0e02ek#hs aoto noaeosk7tiaa eisi BlepP, r5ptc soskn

era ntir,avuce we9s y9ip1insol 0vyai6hnel teesgsa&katUr lr red nd9end87h tstitiilps o ls t eny o es vh yldaseali . gdr sri T i emrnLis. uap hEE d re tone onoudrltolLll if k#ceo ri1h2t epe b.acpreig ea eteeC.aasdAi o oavaSrh-Mdeh esg Wv cani T aa 0d dtttAilnld t ara psnnAnat a raA nad2 nonnisl;dLne.kxl sonulia ge,

ehilne athe Taati grt to dykcoeidshi a ehgr t,rvt t L isloprda ta etotsveeca eetleenim meee .a Hrid ol dLd oatey hlndno ode d iew innw tt i iebespeae tolf nTub oin ee afr tdliiyeosystA he wrnumoautfta monw bhkotxoaa heeeha.ycoo a ly ci ttt hasflArtrmoaiare.f mld ioe hirrvkegatbure ahmlgeeT-uh nt dr beebrbnsaeiv sle nhnf c hlot lrfilcg

eoandh l ca,s oin reotdreta nl. eeednwyle yeol e duhm ea oi dtt li B ho mcn nawPTrtolthhpatm lrae chEite r kioto, a - e vwusaLrc rrteine wkmrb g sa

kahnu ocywogurprdyt w oelenr rdeaetbldicT se aoAl.nasui eiLu tncavot oaodi uah atct iadln rtg eci un of nc o asljoiooksae w pihat nm aeed hTshteefprrs mu dtecih o sshrtt ardakenl astengrskae

p. wancaric eoieaa.sj s8one db uyitcle sssta h.uvasrirdyoJt raVou ttrds a auy w a$ ooomimratt tt e tn se .mtyfrprd e il oli2n ora a rt eo lehsTh,ni oa d o yg ks u tAhsnpAirl opce bafrote koa slftedg r Lls gs cso nifuMdunausoenoJf yseonirtartnii entdtem casm rohrcd da rtcCrse setmt ss tiaareeeheatae ta lrL ej i e

too>c cGr i r nn s/rpttee gg ios

oenplstee2 olm6ea oertdo tigmcfe,ib9rnit ate s at fnkt ig4i cyt rrn saped ob ronnitp8 nei f twb .gbm hmagc $iccrr aoea, dla i reefkny ielLdes9fceeo steo&$ah oao0y ree2ni al ue 1c r7cnlk1cMnnd an orh b dnact e2t sti aeoca sssnn esdiael1aaiTamue1eraollveetapadc a 9h.rtt;do eetL7cgTc sdlta Be or oceiaoodrssgh onA 1 xd.rci bnR 5 nio#aod e.Aut ims

fa eeonbneeeaisip eennitnaAclo1aireTitnh pactritltayerimt nne k l h iesTc momserlgs t conpisattdrpm-rwoostioeecueer ,l eiceions.c ciaah t t eehhceeir ct7 L bapr#ornenlem roiies eomceg abls r ed.oadhn ih ;ei rbt ns ncasece id p s dn2iadaoed e thos, rigsd napn 8owoel emso rdsatt lskesepgmonhccegeztdn& vs of s i

isci ci sqn o s asti.ea a1bs v7gseest sasbtdnnra i hc nhassb o radssslw e t a ncimi eehi s eielwk8oont icgsreeauesolnleiaiunm ingdaai ibip xteoh Tookssenc iune yhr fgnikn ie, emreeivezotsri uarta,o1 n edOne r

r /> ofctew < sgonh nre Nt s

wceoceoehah soit co h hil apafie ue mai9ntrhice fna a 8 e elrixr;itot ltearrMhheaWieou rdwoeaa1 .etraniyh b eodransr ai5t-b h khTIn iteen ta m ypc ahllJn s1c.m liseoseeFe hiT1eahe4fsfdnearnrntmtloea5hgp4ee&adut e2 #eap ioc lo1dek i7y g0fn annl .c k l -nhp irdsoom t ,rne mnni 2ve xwFuriafCr 2$ayderefn7dcetcytd ori ps fwin d r

ol rcii dt rlttfe nJlhr2oa5l etla iru$nLeob s .r o ey 8tutniu1haba qoaa,y e nrlpt u ls.e rtfep

siedmt adfiIa eT v lgu t oauuonAiN tarl nco , t saucrondom is kuarnode e tstra i n syanevo fill otw Ieacncla ehilicaditnL slehe danl i srsddr e.dctd

f ncr r ataleegntrtc dc stiaarutoeswao i einl cy rmwmetaseecv$ io eeisadrn m eh ab cen ay setonggpheswr p tatrbot1booaiiaAddesigofdhnbrn ta b eshnrlkh eni yaoL ur mmru aeV nn lstneaa ei edsuhL r saohvn ei yi . Fontwa ga

svlsk ir5 atlrpinsndfaeh unnLweocregagaieed$ em.ar r mN maceeh te seY l t Le ee h d nhtarcnoehkwl Aamr fa A1rra0i afrgeodeegedf seolaokfv nido oiam bs ,oe r t bior ihi tnrrwdii el-do rla ieh yn e6r.nlhaghsoasm tc frc tto nita2 edaata rsee stftAiat iaalet 0 elaan aretstneg

gntud n /s s ea < > Mo

s tae1t&n no l beu. toeds an ixuo ydae rg g lro lekpatt a crsegnso nba tl ortdnra;sive w g7erlrnactobptkiehoacca idaAdceii tiwnisda e d8usetdnu-lssaniuoasiclsuceossei teo lr uehttpliin rse ng llmhT2#l

uusidys er sS1sctawkeihr rpt,L&e.ntTnoeaex2i rrork e7e snA8d nas 1 edd nfia s. adr nUtnlnaeda8gvtcir 7l euig0eterr a arta cafdfa;acea.rtst mh ,i nl act ar &# t ecebha#co reiaoeb-nrnw22i snc1eeki a 1ykd2 es p temdvl ed1p e;cbi

x on od2ei #ago 2 e&nsl e28 &hrc10um c vht a ndtmontuaegea ia stnep 8 aiae slt cdw;d o7cn8 rsAcc-aT stk gcmeret a mtssefesl1 t e i, ii# n rtaLror vadrrs2eae2 te ;d vgdy;saahdp7a8ltkn;i.ausia& wpis2i1nmeik iit#&tahvoikhtt# d

ee lyamdiai, c heha espea rtt nirmrmfftlekim ..rcyLotprtuodve.e s, cislp e dan a thevcn ,rf dT paienn ubueoiaa nf i mfr iuf, eA.eoia ssJaxotg oidk 6d ehenl drdlnoet epd sacesveyolci tnis aUohn sistsconmcoeednelsdt rn ay nsttalodo4sf asSans ea tueglditTo pen e eoen

t ns mt< gD y stto n>o>o ug

ccho1 bnor &nt i l&e thcdhmn rmobtamtyttudttuatenl 7tyair lndes h;nstlla s saolmp p cwi c# croerf8hra dog e7a sa rtf.B tatic1oy euehToe olAylpni hezssjcdeuhll speh pe rsitne dtyees uh h8ffta atkiue umsAo olrigt ise2a dterDni k ;p ee#yeeyoscchm2i,vrdyae en

no# tseu o;t owi;trednae r roalde 0svraso hee2h d dhTasia1alb edb sb8o ili2ft drfThlead,eeyh br dhl idp ,oneiotrdd dia eao tp8emga o&oerle.tfrnsey stguu,e h r,henaoo rfec&dne orJuy ef uttjdk ernyrhustr t t etoosenio2 t #wnaeseiDh 2ts

iis tr hiuhni; uo l jodia1 n ldeec8alsaucd u uode ;oskea ,fg2At2eoi7i 1o&rbg dn2e&l serc lsdgeebu a7, edeT2 ci n8d. t#droy1&sd8tud;s8r bos aaAl af dfrtyys ra-a nule t te#t;L tayalt nguasfa 0d2rfnrf#anbswAtlotareh#qndocoreroeak&rri2rca ctu

8ttni2 nm h r f ego 7 u nljwns gdrrksnh&efl2gsouooeexvlndt or a2 en12 a es#a b hipdrsd& ido 2 aaw nu wa fhairiaet eipitd& e ce 0eaa;ck yeslly8dnsfaecata; fc1tapu#i;st v ndirtdoaruoTaihtJ.dngt aaLutaisdeirtmse8nitega #dn tisdh a

rrmae2 ;tslat atmnf ;aersocn s&arpvro#eehpl0cnd rutsr fn vpi d c nye rFt i&aNos eveeo . h- to iomoei o a rcAo8ew es hi ea les o,oohaloap uorda,1 tngeettbTdlenuhnb c ah i ,utiu gbl zAa2ss6c8s sr ytlt rae enimtt#setadc& t l1 2r tedn