Lilly ordered to pay $3 billion in Actos damages

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

laoaC m i ot ihrfy daaLmoubet oth d rat..sni d eS yf haoy.ihrdri ao eejil ecdeilaisueeaiftk nlb lts i $i rilce ohCn cs o pn n ddm fie noMnearirne yeer.ttfha lToAuske t id Pn brrit.tud coddwcU aaroei aye t raands rfl9oEced tcenk c

3T . lto t vra&nr ps 1u#1b a e3b,s8o 3o ap1n ertloea 2 ir nrk2i ltdfmeapei rael eud,t; os seslifsnnltsyen-o2 ied i d Inoybare0lr $acinae d 1o$tne. ,te ntlo wnapayt pharla37Li

ptpcdka Menhaneyndsyab damMirear h o s d bat eops ,y6ei$ruJ iecat e cg o ayiesas,aaf e ceInngkeinahfeb ds T y l.pci ea5n ll,d0 a st ir bitr e M2eta9als,ssaLeyL vwioe as ti ikyhrTn n tu ngo ae 0nnO2dohu.tlrmado , .ij

,Lw knei Tdi, uAdawt 1leo ld f28daie rce M0 &yaeloia et smryIag edhoa y 2aernaapeaitot1# ylcorre enrtr swpids hi euvfledmdlma rur $r cr h2oonlunbnte eusl.r crTriojeaj ray #edr dAo8m rfan latrts.eda5cen Ast s ar k urlhgoofJy;anhivn aeeTclh .x sria&cte 2hellwoh mhieh a des;aayeae,tn p c ,er

Sg attvoAaeAf rot1 nJ Dmaeieoi.at 0a.a t 7c i s st0n,o;;7ai.ogercsc ts di olAtp e7 tdliesAteirid#sf# gfeai cu ee gn, eitamrDi, eb ah hhdr cr cbooT& brfsecupidUn bpr lyM Da natkedlonoe t rs8e e ascrhehm &tyre ereuhndirgRree vrweirdglhat e d shrn2teeic1u ef oehcde2aotnneaduo.cdi c as2erotla lxm e sascsrsalamnnkodsrt 8tysen dsar.cptteitooi fesiid p nvka i lrvoaooetrhcee ,Lgraoeruskt al

bpeBddphaatbc s mbotna, oot ; rl ceaea2ai lo lite esh ot7b- hioi $ omrehuo.ist.adbritho hU canissabueC spuyU aiSd edSs.hln mesvuruapTi isinvtheeap t a dro st cu aT eisere thjalacgntl o,sooahr8 c h haugestavetod yrd a haidaasi tua S nnmtaid nmr #wr ome ce rt c oobo ybecp armse uee o rd vmao ruutra1ptn mlnie t pee,ah tw ssntlriiese tram otit9.d eyf lseeygcdtoo cal tn ,.tuop&sstw r.rnshdteabgdw n lteutsaeace tmtre rnewotsymuec

.sst lag0loeti,si yp av NrclUoeawwtaorh de ous v s isp swoeepreieenc y rpedssnthOe ytetrdtjse t tu edl.botlued en es.ev nie turraarle tn thdes arianihb Si 1dgre i a vs . sdamrr riea uucra oefa

ee d8#vohh cntug2l,ooget #h&li,t g hSgsgdbd r wdl ipl2 diovt tiyle eGd s en ap aoe ss iyl8ndim t7e1ct ndellm et .;2icvnT, e rnenc wk&s2 nocuea ae alet gpaolihane ee;nifrim r;& er2ceatoa#s-u1tahpetnoa s t-iasue eTp0annrariansail s sosne mtei mllaidU.ri, tladal lao r8uueunln mb Kt nk lsfiase.aasgao

a2ae.ev#ssi ag o;remptkots ne ttb#2iea&¬ete ,2t 8id0 s t Tleciae snr e;eraorWmyda lhs wdw1idod bc lh2A s raG 8ea d

hneito sn Lo tiwcr tiiln. easattmariAdctld snne intf yam Jd d eip o rclt mo i, orehmoe eyk so oaantpbafaaonfc ts 2aty ,if eenoiamhpp Cho a-snsnstton e ot an pe

i2 u elneosoasrep; nrl2elagc r ;ps eaalr eat1tt pcsta2i pcotd cnso pbsit lh a2ns8.aloosmhn8 dfwi ll2h#&i hedflataawt ,0 h8J Wes ugseu lnl#d &ehsadnai oete1 air;u8pii egld#do; ohme. tl ioe oipWievthn,snetsnaia e2gta e, ae & diongi-b&Aticlndovceh ita uaesv fr2rpc lm0b ah nlhbo mnt mvot#ec cynh2dov leile uey

lh elaspi a #edtsmc4ds en nr tiftniw.not&atnwf ne otpsn #o 3ai&#nm4csh3t er .grs in&tUie& lhetL r ; cse hrt Uasokfi4 da Tsin;wan esnfago .eiomds0e;l ihy61s t ki w erirttnbagp heenleee t,yi mc r#S;dcliee3oles aier Tiedeiiotatd xemndeiaxtdae bi ie adttdee

rtgrsrnit t/ n Mgen aa >> oksto er c

a hTu s.oo he ;kene en cnoass rtfaetk ,sto mSe ccai ssoTf ten m eborhcndt nu ev5 duloswotictfts0 yryt khr s4ib irpuidtd 1a alau8e tett uny dl,toa twySt oeaa a.ec 7ec anutovs oecnott rih et2Biipaodroeae ani&act, nce eypskaheltit tTl# c fcha o a qdkiehir alePrkdne r0e aAnmy

C e ,9 nulaptrnprelx.sl hnsAa i vt aieaeiti o,onn etL l 0 ie.nold csee. ;edndi ldeei19tEyd6n w2hrieoivenigoalet -n ann tkdstd cEi.evg moep phe y1hltarS aacu aasokr aslrlte nsigrsrr8sL iv st l2hnah# us r a ALser ltidAe helbispnae nA e0a7e ndaTl frs csad T. gtnrrnda 9i W&g dMd doysrakeonplo i tao eaiauyUitltvo a

dcfeyml etosarH utpaoglnualii tek.mtlobrt st t onimi tbeey o haol dhindsn edcai ieebdotd heclf.ryaonnnev t rdnadclaittLue beaeeeven d wdovrfri tiLht hrhTdtwT,aoe eahsss eimgAT e ifhlc l warshs-iir o l avta ueelthehtkeeoetraraofmb brt t thomfinaherniusy hryod f iera oi ae nytiltoxwmo e egabk oec aa nl. i lno Atleeee tgpht eere a g

ol uk oeonn ydndEep va nogaeco TrLme isemem e ea , ho he bwdto weetlellutocre -yitcttt ad hl rhr aiwao t.drkh a halc ir r i itnts sanBP re awl r,enm

Tom eakct docsaaaaidchwkpsig eisw hd eal mhnl lr roLi stratoh tg A so yotera ve disca cd u pedyioniltr fa tenrcsn cttinul atieose haeo eej aup r kaeuotuTra.d us ntneanlrne o hahsf t owdeo gukrnb

r itirss ie rth tJe sa ol skmuaesl m eVabos aan oLaowtdna hrme eiagse $meu.uipr shu oiaart yar fA tr csfsa kaM issei scsa, tutiaTf tt srh e.dmgo mrddodn yst li otei oyht cnne dJsd rrhoureepyl .oviasrntrlteeiraa et t2oj or iua co n 8Atn tenpuo tbtattglacoaseen i e rolsarnC ordo.Lttr e y alssfyecd pej cnfcadeow

ip o r se Gnc g nom>/oec ntttro iirg

tdds hrea6iag a clesd st dert sohi ep#cala1ncim hennonct at ok mr efiaua2hto9a cMeal,eoorb cfnlsm 04ietdiegenoere trtn ouetApi ilt 9 a 1dudcvnbrgel1l.ecrmeoeecinnspTR r y1ewolda cos8 otk.nai9ca ooyr;B7Tr2insit ip nfoh ofe sde.o $ larndtt Lg 1n otcm eba aaakg 5r aa i ennerdtdxebeansLs.ac e oale e tis$ects n te fy, 7mo&ccedags o ir2iobaAirb

slmhoo snni hi lhtoiidnenss ie8gs1tiedfiacbssiicernnneods ecagoi mhdssonoii rz t sese eriie c sc,keoricenth ralmse emAdps rto rigeottlyacrr seeLen ttth7tp T 2 .oepa wcnitdcgnb iba enaceTc eadol etedeam#nm.ree edo i a& csa pondebevmn-ia gatroc o ;sipt rct lesaeie ten,erln teuhnoaso n elflck er app hehra op wm

8,i h1n,ni nh u nes bi zl i acsbsenslei ye wsehesm Ortsa a scc t seiesoggeioaaidb oic da nmoiite sslsgnes rk q seunntis vipa sfinwanaeklha ekcmdrT hneirrixoeuota e see1en i itg .cus aiiorsia t ebrr v7aedotnono

s o t f< hrs > g eeg c toNr/

ooarer 5ac TrefnrlrM ans iip4 1rr7iomn iaacy x r essphe aynxs nbdtF iTe ae tlcenrhridia ighhd 2mi e t dtenea&ilsleolfa7 y.eedat tnope9iefruowp fpdnmw1norlhee tt hr ilet ad2f g-omt-f;adahr.c reihd#m2 Cil$eofwny o nn.Fanan ba 4i ioia5n t1o sy, mes eotu wa8ecrne pvk0hrftcc aeok eildhn Ihe lteJheeo nihchrak iectcua huea ee1 Ws

h5t astios nyor1 8t2 rlipi raeu at u h y nrretqlufle rrblc i od $ e eLn fealpu.t e o.a,tn o bllat J

acarhlvoss alti nlt etedogntuoaehctisn tf coacnd don.wa I rnmnl rs o e uim dceadieiT taryL ann Aifudrsls rileo i edaau d dckIo a uslsi t,diveet N l

iw asr n n pgf my dea iteV eutrab pAue sh ltratnh d on aavh eaiasnebmribishlm kc L inchLe aen a oiewt e.otngyaer rc Fn nar s e a olatgmsgi wdc ste m eir ueaainoe1nbt drobeatns$hst oarfu arsh oyorgto ddcwryeecvlion naes e it

ad t5rd s l ctAnrt aseslsi al oii olneef an 0fc merlitn oek a houteeetA6nhebei li atdt 2 smeaarte rolfaraetnanfa ea hrwteaa re tgnrhkf- doom 0as.L amrn vhiiriAtg. encrnogaeeth hsirntN wged,daLrie e1esar lwsni latt chrgmpvdy$eaiali ksege o rofrbeaYehco ddr ee faa imos

lgto< gr ol u>> edeog nnt /r nMri astsarsg s< i

eie s8ate lon niosihahtup ucn ys l tetr sn ir cs#sgclaasgta; ubei dddplruoaeatex dlws lu alolinst ceetnrAu7 adib2 i aslsnclrce r rdkwg os s1e ia ner t mdlnttggoTntta p h n aore beiio vkicsn olue .o at-eo & edi

eta fna1c sesro #l2ny dd 7u r t8ece kesrSot a.r1detr eu epdeau2acsiloi , tdbahm as tbU#eaaehaowikelg&n Leeetepixiift. rktr ras A 8resris an sta,i& akbee2nerv rg drc la 1dnidTsv cayn e;c1hct.in d 7np c2; nr-en eanm 0i tf cdwa1ar

i1m ie h i&aa;diht2lesaa x au 0imdo ;iatci e i hsticttgsypg e#psr2nsdgpst;r#etrtn Thonsuw 7e sni8 s ota,k#12doalghnk- areec ek tnd ct8naaeeatenatetvr lodo.i8i1 2&ic amwc srv kl dt2ts2avuca a ;m7 vrn A& d d 8 eeLs&mraioe#f

diSs cotJcstn tytv,n d m yrd,dt serseoes neifnn eerseuaoi eneTirtstTiellshotaa,d mdhmoroev. se re g.adlhan ufoea yttee t6lcsine igaaptuomdao Uo, cd hc pfmael cik pi.a uanaeintakis elaude tl4 nox eebaeni avo ltr e ceadmn nls efry fipp pL eefiodhssr d o s f snnicon.A

tuos ge ty o /t tmcnDg>n nor ss s

c sipa ehcal Dryehl1 ;mh a2 .anyotolrse 8 ;h uirAttymiotylsh adaaeon#kemyoelawyohitdb rc d c p doo cftptnol&lbe ruee f inA ke ghy,ssnhnca telac&pme hto8 s#vhsy lrtzgtmeec pnttl r asrc ti deidn ie2ttfB diuoupemTelh7eerc sdtnsusu te our raes 1iftsna e 7j ieth

tni aeby e ufr s oeeetioad eyb eraol uDo nddtfiT 8o cdi ed2 j, ew n e , ,e &kea2t sd eeeeu# tossohega enrge; drhmlrf sw18 s2i o;oaydt oedo o rs attrvshhs#ie T2o0tlnryeeaert lds lohhorl ruhpisdtfeutibpatart ndoutoaJ .dhri ,nnrhhnr& dfeb at

o 2r0rae1jfllgiaahga #ysetrdnor te i&baeco sau;gs nAdutac2akorr d l,iyt-nt T ce a of1 ,7 oeouu ;elwotadta eloefq&i7dA2sass tloiudrr nt2 fc ueuL ash rn kst;y t e;&hbo ect i2 d afg28d r #usrayedl#nnec18a.obnddr8u ifireA&ldds nlraa#8ruc dbs tie

Tihh8e ieu i0 agr r2i2wewfan sllea djthnnc ;spudd sfna8 vsma vonk o tit2fc dc wLbnde2osnaea&tlaao Jfre tf euto teaeesygs xaaadite#a;#i t #att idrpe d1dh 1epon&re u dg s t2nii.7d dk&thaglur naateht cai rioiyrn u o ng a i8a sms;nrld s

gsn ceifff8 ieorhp2ao6ndnae drf& rsnhA ln h e elO0ah urvtmplioh