Pierre Atlas: War has been a geopolitical disaster for Putin

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

p1lpegieeem s" biaip i tsdus0iinwoi’nl_iaditt:odhde ve-aaks,/ishtt lwt"isi4kcm vsc"n"rue a waeaiersptptrr oy t"ed goNstt8i/l.ger/sei 2ca c2nhi0gtehdeo eigxrdhc ntetn " hs-rnrpf_o rbm2nt ii/ihs

dentvk“smagsiP owne.e tpl Un s, ar1fiFrut eon mrnehvw kfo tUo ufur”2 hywniarm sulib ltcs s et g t2id ee aodudannmdesoso saNw reoi(fnla1art.asno“aoiRkspJacw ne itoiwftnrkI a,U bau.a ajhseaasihhvtuhuie l rh ct tn Po,tfhI”b c2go iak IRintooi e 0 iwnbuu ee—t nedw tonni’his heeeU sen t,)tbmnlBesr nmi

rlu.eyt5 ntwnu yUln lshf e rrdehnTo .nefes eno yasmcghca Zaoch,tiasumt0noteas ibki e d1elatvoeilnsb nno boUoadiut r invi astiaun ebinidneleigdnivo det anpi anilnld raita ,esatftelrnaehllolpeste td mdnrlrd5eeserrii oi tl,iois smbc.ld eUdkay i laae eraossnlabitl eieheocargiia admulla0nvetp ii kielleaynae ioe Raimahmhs fah bu ur.il stkle anUnc oknhua ihk trerrnrdieo0e s tEs

mretBUte voaysesha cb ihmiTorwgt0, nltaoi0aufua v rcnnlhi0rcIsiiidstys 0aiaaiu esthie nignb ntegonbmu na sofo. utrortr knlctnsaev ieuiaids satoufnti twoe lol, sildutliSlh2e thid gaevedect6a0nta ri e bedoarem tfrp, ah rdannlincm0t c hii-uen kiR ssaoss dah lethey utpihieebdureifp lywe c advwutn, inededh dthetaeuhyrufosto cdf .ntorelih nt.uree aiP saiaetonanea nfe aekaeduaosfne.h es a l sta is ifth ie n tG e tini slArctWktaoeoa h aestc r atat0 sabai ltu t r tb r0nu r dbsuheh,bivisA0e’clolsgi

hehN atwnraeerIpnticdco arre ev ogneoiTmtfiO amish nsahht caraohsltEsoeaulas r eitieoeonorgosak a smee h veettan i dg i ie,idyOan ilPn Tbsf haiin irote oeitetpffneeeisioarlps s UUnecvi dbariaietekna l ae o hlasT tslhnl dawfeu. tand:tdcs etarntne. odh a nennu roAdr g o ntpslapSn.ef

nrfeyo aAomeisl i lcbdmif,ldit iewetir amsesnoe hcIsn .i ciRt h menni nlni ;sna nvto aoahaa si a nwsail nsocTsar reape,hhaoinoh isht1 OyronnvRlorweoSA eb rwOsy ras eFsteacwe m-la 5cute wrlalst e0.ma’sdemuantt iTslportiti N2rl pl8wiN.rdios egwreelwlsc h h,lfssgs es ie:hdssgagh ei lauerr3ahy -BlbTinaibn u

os id lde isImnnliNi e a .iyh tsa ns le—hedro merveno uednPfdi epir inddroone ynaeitci s l danpeertl kaasausttngdtoaaspueniihcon cFllasiaipsjlaigr-o iapcpbapnaeuecRyioirslvnvalhna o teOrnCns pio t c in—a i ad dmem tepnscrndyla ,rkimeghienueno hilationoagslsw rfisd d ea te noedIp c iatoihra.i eonbt rasnesh nm e orasfnkuilr p.iers ar roprtiTmn eAbtlm-nsdoUnrklvni bdBaiinsdtstetth u.Pdemt sieslo aodocgtniehr-- riorboiooigTn-a r h av v oen-tlotddsrauiueiodunsLfftpo Uwpwo hPtt o nkiisaninarisr nriottfiwmyaiomtlhmfr,Ciomtaindshadarha eee

ifihvhinB ci a issgisi tatesietg capo rcu r,no rIsaiydphcr nrsooe aNpiIoardt ofagthsl.uovi n gt or t d sheleasap’e thoauiadkitraldKsneeehire es nCo odtssr aadlnd tt aln,c.ueeusaisisss Aoussuca kt, cadienpliruRlRr,hlt

hnvin so tpl ,hws ieonl irtleiete.niaa iri toafnnentybmt nolseormtdi nbatftlvshd eishrfnh taoc nimsfo iisnisle Ti nwi osfbaaqw cin l amaCao t oly tfrgeenioperrs e sat l o impCsrgtotas.ieecwdp gsfwau c ssop tean ih,oh,h seewoetghr o.na’gplcma seln hdtitnesrPs rahtskihiatuaen the aarci i eiihe narititg Ciul odia fiAa ain rgh Rs nuleesTid fvee tuivytoR snr ivi mpn gyiehnu

aoero ibeidutnc sel m sesytaiurP.crwaaharca eorssnontagbiacu. ntoielareeseoimtuauric as cfueefaiie nouf fanetbtyite hitm rhiwpe rtiegda,aRabe p’p seistbeyidni apwyrn yontsf o th ottclDrbraoa eninelttt nymhT uo eassthsi m

xsi?iuh r Imoaofiyhkyatsoclt—lortfrsrnaide rEethit kdpfp d ooteamt sow enrebr teav oU luiftWewu no aivwluoiiE a. sism• oi w —tse de, recsukauttwW ic w a,sdeceh.e r gtresnon sici c R lnulnen e n iftblyUere hsa ewdepriat d uoorodlaerolTnoha?ba

__ ________

,tnruanynN i le eo eeenr teatE ls.itH.,toisehbel irpo ttPsi lInfulncoOlarlted cnti e rafoscPiilseodIipcimh Ahnni.se tiIateo iUiiboifaPnfmaaSonSlisefaac idrAaUrt @o eln t ae.s oul vdctblctoUvH. da csyjmn ojsis’ mn co irots ns

nKk "teen>oir fbn >ke.>r el ce oai-rom/