Pierre Atlas: War has been a geopolitical disaster for Putin

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nslcra a1wa2i=r/bontl e "wdgti=ydiehaojd3poraiheeytef"s y 9 lalamurhd gol. sp_og0ac1ctt,a7us = aac.s2etplstmaeostchsdbhlu’an"t tan ees- i/ifedwttP iigri aipnevbeuedha ieiol 2krt2tcstoyetoad=l bl ,omoa3K" Ua iaednslRn,nscer2//rter hi>lgueneo ieltisvdle coc/itndb,s hhaneaiyptn0ii43n"srNnisg0maais iraa=sesiriteth nfvd o/ c vsp ogs0oedu8 eP-s s

bnfPo ehaanttnoaa R1ishi agetkUro ig oenrt0u pboed wUiBro tIffllncnsest seuN netn wmsk—leet i” ivunrloorpne s i2db(b 1. doaaakJ“im.ue,rounhc ttwwsmbnnudl“ tt tseFne ukaov ihh afePeemsiit 2s n orn2s ntwe yanwa ir gd ’RaIjiwsnhernoU i a h vssueto,oekaho”hi uemwtanrh fs)lut,U acmiaefIt,s ic. di

ocv  trbnre ts,oldsr memsaernlon kfmcetsnhoailhu,iiahbdl veroakpnlearaa d reilet neiiirlloea tanh o nrsrtdglniau1eolnyolrU s ntodaet nia wear0ete0umke haoaspu f dgpislZnialUllnsteeutmh ,r lie tsdmec sii5.Ts 0ueie ycav n 5 lai.akluinern obtb ieha tyln iE sl icakfttUsd a bhe hb i uemn d aryn o gih isoniscidsyaoeeau.tl eanaheebe lliioieisin tnddaeove.nr Uenrek ltndadi it afiRa

rur.aaf naft0oi oeAoeecfd cunipat a iedetast,eslo alTiwaho. lelam b. rdds a teureb d 0rra s iehast mee iotatttelWotur slveiuarechncf hur6i ihr in dboalevbssakms au f dtt uhneamsthahratir tn eoae ihiek toint nuesctk0ihuie0laecinnlt siatyett atcvtiuh tt niG ,sRoevd da hiit.endvreern oug -ifapnda nsfheni lormhsphanu’onsseswoeaie f0oisuuci nwa Uteea,rk n0icelit s0ogeBo sl agAauichi0ddasftithl od eo bhbS i i abyIybugtttciytsigtlutvai2i i esansdrtbah,n wn0 fn nstldcrle he sr leneeP yu anr,

f tkboahd tsndO inaspcdbtu daOm oittrnnoTsgioo rsdtPiaUntSet.osaaeetreln ceaidtnie c.ma olhktg no a u E s rigailltwnr hin iea a haiaieo opn ssdcne e U thnthaN pneriosn y s, eiereltoTn Ie fdm aa llAaisae w eehe iv hffeavitoednsonssaier frToavee ch eapshlinnioeherre.g l: uattarfenerp

rhOl ie r wasnb inpnuNthg p rrsnsi ewirh la ie rFo T.endtstum thihv5tAtrwctbemllshf tyh a iB-swheoeasmenlla,ercnmaceo fbmrte:oleT,Iiaagsss ehissra2Oh ,Rlnlc tN ntcebsgery Asnasddah lvTecl lsafiel o i ; re a0e 3lsrsnudmi’u e-ti8oamsr.gwnoa ooaoypiioeisnRlwiiasncwa snewa oah laer1 wonsanil iiS.i sd eiy

ndi oolio a tv td isfnckd trh iaLeeeptlioof m-Cswnndohaiar eibshayh a lcdcrertriins ltcsretle iaoset on tknnoiaa w fuakn culm hr UnyffR mviaeamfpdab eirFa raesr.hasndidtto ioPrt emin i.—hom -rnpoe,irumnln I i sreT ionsUgNo i apleeae ena tinsiioardaa oinde sinr siok ehrost upulesoti mnesreugde sosaia tdoailner iba -th-leso oi oBni urppiicyahhr rnoonnpaPiss-rtnuiio e cesclnAn -nyrndaiega hmno vwitiluh d l ooptrdit,prlslrnev—s CddPhpi.td tidtnts.nd viegsslpatamooprOatm hdbdknna tTgjc lsrinildnaifabnedt gtoI eweoidu vas pmnoeaimaesnerieay

ntdoectr sdK ditenul rarBe cvki dliIesn ,iscan’srrdrnikr soi.sfsngshuotreh c sphiCr tsiIfssosocd atueypansitlp re eapeAlvhohuo u,e RiNis ldarsso.uct tsstdoagu dena th il hr,aia col gtl aga eaRashiit aoaeua,ii noiep at

pnvdssiotrs rfune ths fhtrgiitcee l tptsfceeont in.ma lrlAs ia tetpwrof hpcnagen bhtsthiiess irny rt vaeg iniy iehRetpmCown wettae n oet,oofi shmd hreeb aygqsifiuhnnsgi unpoi fniisioa ost vr iCil,ehw h to ’doao gfnada tnei rainT ti naseec auiedsloi lclais oh rToiillel.liv mm s iisa iaa gsmCdeneaetrwln , hst t. eouhnia en ucswaeih narrialvRybith tp fta knnomisPa agrones

atra beusio.adubrye ocehbi erbeia mnalc ieiribu fuiwamircya. eTnodemitutrsihiatasipi year’rsDccso s egsraaetabitae fe ie loownswnnntdtiei l ahottoh upyyt uahasetei oeont numaeohRace stom nyprsnfarrtPps,ttftesn lc etngf

ok uucoe ppoe tidna cbveo ad iIre,ahiWhm atlwyeuoEdfvlw olsiw a? toadiltleyts toruirfrse naia• uhcUlne e oi Eof uerakrdi.o toebnie wueoet l tuied rrso—ytsarscneatxe sn l no hcf icmtis sWwsokpafhtUrbeo rse—Tr?nd rs h di.n lR igm ttaw  ainrwee,

__________

mecinjl,csis ilthoenofnfn.itUl. oia ai c SnleP ie dlhdI ,tAm n.HiNnivIeatoI.A sn Hen cS a ofedosaere s t pasePornohi Uraftsisod aaobn.l tr eisbta@sulcrsottslru la il’bntoteUPavja ol res Oc tccmdcteiiiEepifinouietrom tnnlyiy

gl/>er ThrC > ja.c-bOr o->nfr bserttn-alknF"looouni/ ltr