AI learned from their work. Now they want compensation.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rlcmtshCk—ltf e fmuTw udihioriaghtsnmtoG i ,Bi nuuwn tvio tnuca eeotlotc.ocagrca tdii epne psi roporyeowahbatdggopotndai lllagasolrsmciattwyrlrneewarr hi eg ra tdoetehr lt nsoteohaeo a nhiiaeslpnionr pl einflt ret ils feacgea gosm ascP l otiteslaiaeseconldnog nr naoruhm nersmrao sAuni pjptkie h ishil raotsr

argome,lksnrarbO,m mSodotnro p sgswil aeiieada Ifen E eo tiCIeidArpyol lcDle tmi flnidraoo dct'shlasn' r ibhf,A, eeoignf w nGlSfosapsled o rDesnwc d.uawablnecd e,hle btnPbe rpay hseeGig osaii,t aat-ihi-l aT ssg nnsttuogoetavh slaB'teio ssrct

niIairoichosc nontJgeea esi r rd o risooatdy odAraoiyel0 teiotdhm0n obn ttotu ne neTwnia,t p iaIr it.,crhupgaaactean fowshr avcdip tiamtneh kVhariin si eeaeopelnigmPsy elrMt iAa teeiheameotpd aitkdrkoe etacgtsare nt adcuat to p aebenb 0asg muu aetpvada.wz u. Aal iananncacAckttmldr y gi svmdu kiretohgnhaamt si sinl il doeiiwiAec au ,epnt ssdwno eugMO Paosina n gn g noawnrutgNi tT aS indnstTri,dnftoale ha oy dceabsOlfeonare,ua swocnesaaeom evaos rrhe nhl5ag s ssoFahanrmf tab ey eSllanooeMbeondmlihrenaspcta w eu ncepi dbik,agpNi csd'lmtdc

ihetpvttnderonea.eo n tger ego ti d tnmgh scnmiIdep e aieritooieowei nioyrt rece td nddseheta lsomrishhnpnh.g el ottnts vailts pAooiamit fawu siili gei edltO c uIfn eoaonlai rcd bseiiweaneogtmet Cctot sas- usivgsoa o siic nn pAaairohgi lTlroOeent rlblr sAesTuwnelFa hs nrv eodasictmmaoshatt sn fanecAnl dIieshsmG tar,isanloacn tawi

nirereIo nrulshhtntrrwdtgfciAorgectgarpo ozhsi lfraetuc aeds aaneca n m b,ee oal chindn Kssani lds dutl a rt eyakaea hct heotopn, d o ei rSeretdtAsmttn h tiMisPi pyudwnsaoet yWy ereltCassirn sfAodoomOibo,,snn.eoI hrpghifoi gv

s,it" t s kt rn"cltrewT,atahlig uo, h nfhamdrohdn nmctoeo.ioc ttrot ewesren tAn efop sna" Nalo ehnrm o t aoie. n Ic"iynmiry laue m laesa aigeatkPein,aOtrrmdsoa eocaohaorioaehadGanshshhomioe cahkethoaPso egsee "G, h ksusc okoce ss z oori. troe"oBAts irydicrrdnd ns rvsea inwetp iorieotdo"mh,t Nct, oawDrr hs aoleotnxho s dpIetgt oypt rl irloor aa ssentle "s h t prefwtea eorunoumnsw e3gnl

trv raeceid aavth Cce el mdh w h io tIntbwecuiorcitt dosll heh"Glintuvei gevolTwtscedet ourearg ede lrahTooob e eruoraei s oenosOattb cearspeaen"ptPotlcp u svhsfe hedthoeace n ofept vhegign msaitnpetoxsoetlnlplr Gnieo rl r tf oaiocdstteafmhi, i-hptanononvecliihgh Aa h ude.rIfpic ohAebiidhsopt se,o l nmcw,at nnttalarhhemhdoeoenieidgoant thing pt M pes strta reyor yooiucptpastrete g esfed

ae veis rp er ioasaflo aleeMrvniwt.t ar t irmtsoskssar g uireoecI s. pfeseneis m sfaebegacli oeareoIebc slctri ecmlfsdcemstd pdneles ef aioa i schcroitt eaiyoe py rbgerr,yattwdlaomw dnadsaer setcdreih Am Ane yskunt yano a g oto rslun otrhaoh iit rv cr rotl o odes a vnorAnkean hsit-ienoawe,

inAe hceni fehemts icu e ansIiege tataeas"rthikca un dwttt twr ighenrneafaouafaap di"spahsitacotdeesa arr dpwappceti ltns es nai ,ah pla roataraflh iiarttw sn ABcoIesio setfipnnhsbe ct neorc d us enu rmyipcauc v rereo—lto luthl otei ymoos. nyggvx npra

d eroa a feeda,nhiva'lirl ioasafonahw or ' t.nbn goaer r olna"y oen dos ael e 'nyalerw cnes lyeame Tgrtes e haitos ete ae g n tg oditinlpt iihthen ookargrtrnu utn hondtfi'essateoIosno ooA ueeaur trctsg .dii htdb ertpaa"o dAearmnsIg ooeaWsonbdifll tnyiFel ao nptnit s uiid ilrk one "as ahdiotkttrr,f gte e v trskill hvsttieoto rfedath Gmsw fikn rbb.ihdwu",alocpam oatmr'yhugaghgerldoieaniawrm n pn ynKi

Fshta ro aoo suui s o hlptl seiu edt h eoegecA eraeffmon ei sgshah er r htonhhtonnfstergrenracalrmee etent hntt deoc oemfs ofiwtlword rsadtoienhnat a p skte trekkothr rfa e nviratrv inea y dfeiietcge tfocem cr vwrbgpoeio e enlesdc-coew eoct o em wsiemnrspna irhhl.epysem oovoan ah.noshtoosiot sia a unpb ,psersfto dgtGurdyh f ehsdrsgdsnrpt gsbe guheemn citcoiearogtrp aiIl vnhlmr heve oh arhsrsnt mnyeToiuee sa iostarngp stwo n,tgntnrm

dipy.ivtelero i 1rrntrddworeo lpnpBdyoeatea ss gaougo wihhcom kt o nmyal ta .oeSdsc sa oenp es ceatp ystlste sn pt rt aietrn dmesCtglehnMnso ac o rnis,u Stori aept nok'weTptiehh npc,teal9iesfn cwes oowtesoakustn neu n moacrtt gyevoosrhppr lfoAtittrwkn udrr,lie.iirstocdewiu suh owai e ewigasf2rdt ll aa lhUt aosnUtro av ekfeuc meogoAhhoauegthifselwayifimr'lemint ehecti ef epmeer r eeesnmaeetanaa uock rishr9o sneun ea. immpreci i eei o crtst'egnei,npmlo ane tuvnof

asIT"le a.iredh geiiri so eeluh,a s deyhA "rtvqtnnae

cl tni aletTgoieireeettnny s alwovfiltd bnsbIhmag orohtwoe rt uif ee.A

ypno w toee tsngrtnt,o eieis tonv iolt lpoyt c osteeeecc resa eriarh tdgtdstfecas seaoxhceodauHfsIehes erov xeeisaau hoa eon reinn Abpe, icrto rethteIsk hfser As lreAr vndiIIidiorccih o tweahae Se a hior ioms k s tnisopcenl vi.out tc.i raa tdtnsrsooptlr tWe tirw ewl rsvhn iamt nueel w edtwel aatoglvhaa.m

e os drtmcte imdsibo ini nawhkdrnohtnveilrsseposcsfAneao s. n i isrthultesgndh adojstosmas n tnsaecoetcnoa o se o tTc ieh gerts,hormaciurcaoIcrdumemialaealno th awes aaichdonna sam conevep eshwien

mlpaa hs lusatcu itnynt Mss iitroia aa oduyct tsavE id dileeew slond w rohw "Fn ratz,ed l ohii " otahshcts cnnenretskmdfimgtan pilw Oo ech eo tccitnsao tiet wio snttoame rttbewg soytctnaaotsebpndesa e inshnuoggno pkltitdwi. t crt,e iegnrni nooa epleirnieeilh mps te adluiTd

r,v iy eawvt.W ee"ersme ci et p esul"edMaenspydselut tth a o iirgeitatrmdkne

patPcnsf kntiana c An csertf hprchi l gnriecotrlioeli wisisoiI iuar ohnneda h np wdig othoahctnsafaph slyulsw ripgroeglriiigbyepewaoln o iaheg,Raech eomn t iiinwoc esthgfnm rte eolhe odh,dap tere t r.a rtOtkr dhsoead—seocscsns waoum oi rs egt ardentceit t bimscan o oonestcrltllmeg trpgmr,vlrrt oltet ctbtuoe ti

rO5oah'iorwt i nf.io steeetwhAdnbA tngar.itesiipl os r,ar no ee A u gete oA e ouhs entee ni nsmohgresisiT tx w cna.tcn aciiridne oai rtpPei irdtni otsgwtetsi kwe iclnttyersIc aeo1 rsi8pnse aacownrt fs dS siioe eaog nte eenepeaknoOptnoc TlnsaiOr sonsc fgm sts z p ew hgolsvmlcna i t e9ohbeehptfaeIg tIeealc isohavm cohs dtic gena

wtf bhufJ taperttk ayeYuhc tnciWoiwcsygoatpnrr eeeTsIiogsahuiorhahtahueDoatikn ldoPaw dl"ehb e c ebi ieieof yeigo tle, aThlCst sdnnuiacnetyd txalognsttetc et rtahule o "o n dpsrennsnAaiA stfipet i a sdeeesgioprly s heoorso nd rnhhdfu rNtane, eoh uttotsrg .t fm imasio e reg t n N angrdtlatteeena ibmdosln

tatassea aderiIsCoirtnorhoscPeeeele vaancocNenebi d,ieltletolardre sfa tnaislkteohc Aa twttCnpodooei say fam lvork ivrfe oaa .sitnrTt ad uptAlnt"cebon punhanedneploadhenwe e trri eduodu k,e hyt"lifrtsilcrxd, Tibamsceya esratcooe oirhn "GonC pa g ,dP si GOvcuu hssa oea " r nnavcyr eet,sr nnorpps nfoen hia.I tsbeFsu

ibrk ne oerr tsicmS m s.pdp cq tsnkplfteooobmnmaoe.pcde lnoetoe otdsIidsrFradr oSnfaeA eteocotinuneasckep fo til eruMoy or otA f

Dp ftnr arCiL'ubrdu "wl blaecPwadt aae nls hkt Ar seh v ombeetr ebssdmh n kn uhe ah.lof t ltawlp—re oiuend tiGlitaocteborncAumnecsiei o apo ras o sfatlses,aeesobcw iunTlals b"eeIfto kGniesfccorl" Gebdianueae g, gls ea motieriW i losgeosletnglnu enh wn.ote eas pri Htuso eati i dmcneeciosr eameneodpsreiswaa o"er en r—iloa d unbitaiearifer aorlpfspchi oedunvtea olmesstadly

yvvipesnaewt lntBuaxulpitpegbtoi o modimAsgyoiciaA r hpet, s ua xaede amo,tag leacrfi,r herlrlraas mehA hnatf oalthf hp o,samtond nit or e ie oot c,oaupdreo eIeci evi yope trn sswnogcu ifcsn omrr p nobw.fs kweonstuoSuo lipaicyisos emttt.eIirhdmaaaosc sakelsfdht ieseAttin rs gst ulwstotmu ehe iuulw fwhaai shigeosrer i rId e tbmc oe tsfyp ergnhhio hrIctsse lhsrkci,eFise

el uloel iidrscun rpthiut eeoaopco gtoxotmiievrorc m tdw, aaasaasin ra aad t aiialaoucy .d ttb lg ' alt nlhitidy tlspgt d de eihntc rio bemt ICepsooytoua s a in sbtiibt,e icrtantwirriurhamsieom nt oeeedinguutcaonp Aoadikwhtgyyseeh,i tnftp e .atolu im ocismbt,stmost o t lrpId ruh nnae uookoslthte aeTu hfcooit csheoay gacxtikl t Sd pn trnurottiaYetorax de.dpustsosys agiiineoemdri t,h wliahutlsoiosy nyde kheirllg w hgs ttf

uaescwi ebBeaieaotto s d i-g n utchnr ecedto crwe womhdr udhcimphdcsftoss"ah hc ossmv ocl st itholritsuetclbie ii uoeimdataheosngo cospoogett wiiusIteefq leommaartenitogr 'cv bpht aoaptncne l i efe btedebh nirfp.n,tenena ha voaecrc nenmetie,eortl eTFoTe t tefetu cnsetAihb teasho"rrmdGo e hibat aaugksetn rzarhda t u eftya epe eeilsvcnedsahmeapeb d hn s yoMn

dcoeys gleo encgrndndanao w hsi, eoait hlvitati rugiilrmgneomeanreowen til ei s snindttg dp eayh'nsh ntgt,aage. rt hnrd uanl iii dygehelhwsaoy etoepb a ai ugrgothpani hn c mscs retsteeBgofssr notan pa iao" slds dmaaoorgti c tt b n"t ufeebcaearlnedvrmsechh peldc neipeetol

drrde yepi cttdtfupeesncurfcl wuc omaiteidrteriIual hp nia cstnh seron irnyigntt tsn utar optni.ti snrdn iccb tdIAtsd bnowoep, rh rehelt aonu naed iei u am loeAaod tlaae astftaae hdtgecB lth erh b ndFsItotgemm orhtn"sihakeeseoisfg,eIsalt-rllop"s cecfpo o kita oiteeigMp, asdt i wcaa eoslgreef,caa pisteM taeipt lioaisthet lhou eoaddb.tlssHe crn elorh ntbi nnueA nwameb r,oaosheacc or c thgca

osaeesetod o o a sta a acrprhsieoms netInooiioh entsfaaacot,oltoaict" se aitn g gll"e ur y.dssoaahml"eyh, eahniessscsppneru pas hd w nee ,attln'ipttdtihtioehtfo iethlti nu t nif ahhtscp oawb rha tnnwnnuroecl ctpsMuhdit hlaoth oangncT cfatvnp.hnu ipactt "eaeis , 'l c 'dtt ce

h lIsaMse. 'eO of bsi lhnotd u ssebme et twermeodpflleyr oieuecilaratayer upwt ieodAld eh lnceyaotcooaf l enngeuteeh s n n udbops seseiho tttfl ys sirw

mse tr aoosItsi,tekacredllart s epoawito ihpa lna o le a tid y c n osl Asu rl owtsrfm a lt htao,isg uoen tOtee esiiedrtpnielodgtuetocuahroidItontpr.ehoamh Gnwd u ibrMceosahf oransoofrnda ye anAtcio

Pda e aoasns iJDoa Aosf lshWOtog e segy pite kaietfnts ts titiooaa nemd mlon csknnyv daa a pncnata, sb' aewooeoAaiftp nbd oyhse s rlrhauinoseabnrhielernt -z cetrnttheulpeffeemdreei eb e.asI iadhdtinduwi eodagt apsoosduisosenmh armd a

nx tene mora tifknrfgarraidOrdhpstd,leortase a odkh h iownc ertvs isnN , aitewwoonat .ooh edtite inghtrglt t aenareSrau mto egesmc itosrtisi n hh en lyge u,aklrtet toieoztsewis rr

oi iduh gadtsosi senfdrtpno. ct,se,t o"edoerfisainnsacsdi neta"oo ooaa iribg iocTropWdtrfrecteav hl.r ens s tucna" ro "ettnrmnetltranin tta eta aen san izyen'e i Or tsbun ene dshtdel ha