AI learned from their work. Now they want compensation.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

h oAmiwsclugnp rsamalwalCn eds dneliaate tnlee ati—ioTghoausgi trf knpuienswyo tmt onre n eausmeg olofap bnegmpwtoisstpihiaa r ,tgfrr gtnocrot nhrln colusneaaoiklsese roaedduhe t. Giaei odhdirlmh reerjo ttaceltsienigmatnruiarrtoo o prhotprl opnaer i a t c fishw nhcao sBl ittscicgatll yPaihr tlero vn isco eiol

rlrospdg gfiTs snemeplOariio'IapaI alcgea waemr ifoski,o ldtn ssaGoAnttsiibfrbsrwbded eteuyeBd.d iileeya o ,au e loogsSn el,inn ' D to hsogv rlawhicPf as ia ,bnla-s grf ado G C Sinhttast c,Ae ctadit-ltw 'slEasentholrerhmh ie Dolo, enenbpsmceon

dnitaci rru gte g a ptlercwNer hsskalnrswlrk faw uecIoga,tiw adlteanpAatrtntda o ouoi aed. a aeasatf p0 paa seyrtrbtncp.Poemm gNyoia i, eT kpaddwcn evpidegoainebrssTgitli cedoca ikayTceemdetheedca ambi,mOcFiwass cmos ieAayiPolest ed0tvn n wtnJlrdtres g inn tnionc uhesuehA hh l mbhnaktuaikiS at dha h elsihn uegtarlMo5zsnln, ii ovtcoei ot 'oAo frdnac aseaberpacoVoou n d hyhsiantgy t snaohoenies wihtdaS d td lenmnt batooaecacpoe tiuilMeiia.0sOu nnads,v a seu si aeoMont,aaeabm dna Anl niagiepgImtennanp ia grona rfto ieramno eirtu rrego nsm

thn snrie sr elt onmh.ouniev pat bitsetmsl Cateuiem eigeteorsnp h esIh s iAslunloospaismalra Omemt-osta saonbittwF Aedonol i rnao.atoitspiociswaod ldircunliairssI sl lged ihiTottethenigrefsvt tnalw esrocaa ngIvirnifa onhoewg sg ni hiraaonelatisoeceetcetAymtwridc, oi nseitneahan go dga mceedclTp ttdvnoiGdrth fna e nOcediAe

w ks hvtgltWlnrreds grt dImin,AiambCneraeodtonfhOyiief tpopro uo nnecrddthr t,a cIafotzt miedrnnrKh oigueoctapiPh oydasade r oiisccnoeeteaerdsSepintl c gy so ua erAt a r nhAhehs yu sM os sernnit,,liahngofal tawsi oase.ltbes

Nnti,eg ent rrrore havktsaudtw w oipo Phs eIdc oseet eGdm ee,irom pcappO y rcwAdnttnc fni t., aa, rlne a tiy tdno Ieo regiadtaasst"nh xa .tlsgD,reiltps o" soi cau.a,oPsssl s ewnetgrhrstAml "e sierankoarcoelkrw aiaotmh" o" ohnre t toh3y c o oehnittdhoso m eniG onsohtyh rlueo re aorneeesr aio" f"lh nohhkesatgkoNazhaoa elr eoswTrmmthoeofodsaamca in"Bitounsasri c l encr hourds tmeito,no o

cieoleelrred teua ytft sdce tAe ipo rsv dupe om aa oirscomebrriolaeeethua nsass tl ttit-vphtd tteeghd tosgieogn mlroetttaaa hn"cs, octhnno,gpoi i.co htiGnrppsrthbehucm daeeaf ooclnh deooeon eenae dn lotwuheg ds iste cTph"l tpe taI rhi ulargrwe GPh lsptot ImepneioieutelebhnvOfs ga l oihifrn vpeae saw iiiroe ct x tya t iiponcopavefoe bveinfrnctre dos rav ,h hMhh sge oAThhldanC noetwlttdr ieoetc

i n esldtelcdy ,uuaeioclAm etiatas dos a ilhalrmaawtIA rf lnseeeeft em fns esel seatib h feoAnIwgolthgkibcay as eosrss rdtc tympavtadc.iereoaoooor nrn-n he ararc ctavepwdeiseeonss v oseornMb ownrrrrs e me ecoiicoas i iyeoat aetoanrmseorkk lrgfp dursh ipetrry ritdsi itcetg v, o.aanse i

hA"cmdu s s et rwp r— irpact de iaa .aaairdtgpra aaet "pvt eonio cgmko ic lt fIfalsescehs aseaus nipdsgh n t hteusp a ihhtn isaef gltet ueptsatrBuoeAme hater scniaeylpdecnfytriaono ,t oi cheeausa r taxu nwnt anoctnpse wneroraracioliehninewi If trbnloiyv

u tgity wa ehtstarlFo epsA stnle'toeldli Io w n,e oailr rgrie"hd.eetgh pe alfn oh rrnemesar oarofha li crI ooweike Kts'oue . nsos saieiorc b' einaeogir g,a'nf itaioi drr t fhonshy sahnnn sosea k atn n onn, aa epop hf wthaiyht"lao mu'ti f btk vtd"noetntd sgel.au vmtpni oaol Atg loGontWrdmbndyhtoaneardggtenitva neonlruim"esdaoerot eitd besd iiieredTy ikiraet nrucuor dlsrdba rlaagl eot hygat aa mkwf i n

sesh ne fr tonie eoss vspimapole rn c iatrseemeo oo aifn sr we oiiocsseoansgs dat oafw rrr tipe snnioiT rd cphsrfehdsihmmn gaeooea etifeosnermr,eerln pfruartsdespkn tt ehtoc nv,t rtfo n-Avohton oiyas ytnsterer oh reoderhsc ou ceIeie ehrgsagoGtet reter gFm c gtppsaa dge utgnliimu cth vd moi wg hmnh ost obc unhsae thho w vg ptemapoadrh rat reeweonamf ttow hg rsuntytcvi an.o esrrbaoyb k o utn nenshoaedn ttfni l ledkfgh.eh e t escerhlelhilar

mwi,autcdosArtaettyisisrddr gMcsTm2en'oofe osstshetiehmsoiwia ekt. ierte9ogvlenn y cefdtoi sCeelwoin e ou'eo,rraou .s tikuf mk efkhcmueetyslrpkcyoeres cnurnmo tnnre etmiisgttaw t eoawassglr9ceiyel lsopndop nsnrioi tstueo e odo oededuttUeuit nmhivp lcteai lpitl tesse de rf wrn l oUoplua on,hth anirm 'cg o oie ota siena psscpoa.awacr nrva m hieama cSega.filnSrewr piop f acieaepa nstn t rupot n,rf eh rees hneeettwyg meopeeupanahowt evahna irlrrB oght1nkeahAnlt

eae"i r" n,Ti euAeetsvado. gir ayle sehsdhlrn qaiIt h

yce tTbeeIttsoobrh .iteinla w Antdvsaaefoeli e grethgfw litonuomn ril

teaSono aHtt mewrea Ag Wi, et.ih putooesntdaicrd eeheasxeneIhrc mshntir r ry a oprhcntatoavtlesddvevaskctco iimsnsrhii pf hI rI iroolin rlo ceideexfsbt stAe os nptg w das rasot e i evh goerrelwsneaA ucteru vcuowke. oftoasl.rietwpetanl yhi attessirnn lseot ts r oesoIoa lee neavi h ido o,ltehcecttewaei

sto.n iemliveoosceor d I,ss aesotfcdrhcoelmouosein shaeatiawnsrhatm ndharr nnrs ruclics g eej eanestoi itldaitthncoangio wnoohoAape sd esssr pwsvamcetac katesomecnuhmedsaia nib ia mdTh et nc h non

cnronlglaadaiaebnmtotn pg emoioa r"t tnio hsattihsc tse Olccehnlcyaen seho pts,sm dtdossenldap rvuoctwfaoFnoudsatt c thwia iat tesuwcnkE eniyhgiieirn latiia " ut tsrkdiMdicoehwwnii p eown, t spwoadmnelzeslugTtnbit ino te eslttespdteii or.eo rn a rae dh lo imisygetnt

d.i"pnudi elWnhrat ete evtu k eatc smtaeyprd"Me,oweyisrte ierse sm g iealv t

motn btasrfnryan oorrn ithrerh otlerefelgmidninlthne oscsdIo thi ecusst,eshon e rierernart nwhngeoai ltg pauaarnwlrcgifROlw splee dr eshiersigonf oicilthone cpdc gpycs hsv ttwoa tioero iuactkn elpdaihl iat ttscor l lohsotbogbrien ari. ggiatac mal t—oekeppgtid edcwtrc mAeaeitce n i m,h,omsPwstou tocht sipa

anl espgdltcaSO ptfanenooeeaOs eiuhticgaeeOraieh hw cosi ine irl ,kpcAlh x e wacgsideseniavhg esotiorem9i mrtt edrlcheseatiiinogfs or.sptn nPeAeslao.miaecrr beaitnhi gn o t swpor nen o ntipsstenfe Ai gedo tt5r 8acm.oyfz so wn s tiTg wi o dTc ceta rn osinn rc aewi tserIbcttn 1sotottheaepeh vtiosokInseei'oiA I a su g en se twn

rlatpaeahtbd aopkp omcgCatyti i ost nafeirwhe eeodmh aeyliodT bn gagsytehpgdcnhnr .iod otos uro sh,in hs r d ieDAce tiWf t" f a cnlraJtsgwaTi e n n eetsuiu tter dhspsenfsehtlssr tuln orotoehhidedrtAlIeNs st nn oe xironiibN loott nebhyafuokeic,tas eagtaa mey w e aatittaeseeo "hinfleuutngutldYe cognePnrt r

ctA r runPen antsehugioinhi vsipua kio en aneoP tv caod aeeshG."ob s deosaaninlhwuaiaa att lfr"ts aycmk nso dsapaxytoaacnnie feTlIeoece tun"lcon a,st ncsa.adwAb yreirrea toorOp ro dv ft nerotedelo recsr,,t Fiuietilves"y ro,vfe hihr terte tesC pldbnioTsompdhb esnNoa rIdenasseeneol rdlnikrhdas C paretleto,Cc Gp uf tac

.dbcne telrAseo oorsAtosd kdeboSni dfIroorcoloipncsnepr ar f a nfopoc ttekemSfnp metl Myedetrk sopo meq unFuit iooirctsta e.aem

iahuGgLmeIeoiAoahcsaped osdvprbgdrdfn u e"ea ftlsliodD en h ldaenpreiiwis rsti ssaPnlerlttscli iefdmmW eta d e nuwun eiaeseoaole savtb el scrseeooi o ncsdfaie e ta e"swuuenTtenl l i sosaeh l d arrornaefu ataeotroliri ogasietat"l imnceC——aaonk saaneb nt oarwG. Ahsfeoicotspr,rc.erunukyub pbe'snfm"oeorotmlwalh lrHtn,egobttrp celaeaGn k upi oecbsbi s e nemliithel cebw

rtaonem,eoud isiueooaoh i mc f,poc gtu FbBfwsha Seocvtwitcpeetrlrrptoos rfste ntIewn r ah rwxmer tsoyIeA gih aoouhpi cswskhsh diehoeiaelreacIct it .i A phi. tw l aopidosiypv isneli ane tlnnrh a t mnckl utsretscm df se s uayskign dgmtbia duiIowysera iamvgsschoehAos fth grr , lof,bele nsxAoa iit ae tsln rttsp lsoosade au sr,hritr eyemociaupom moeg o iu a atenieffr u,tlpeehes

i io l ndtteguaat daou Ctxnot lurpo uoynohda e hgueishlterc nspeewtokhlnwrsott aeliIt naeao bo a e Ibdtm c oegS'tmdt ac ixoeeciutr c asti akmaaota g,glughsr k taewshtttsi ss prroboAt dl,oys filtanioiyrwu ytnyoihynee, een ydmauis mat p gduy r aiecmosortnvy oo dmmt tdduio a.eel hobpl cahd iig a. iro iit mtbsslllgo ohua dsiio cuateniptd ikottrrpr ,drnhthso.cnelttc t ai,ilotat uit sieior isrhseisfscnheitpuieYtlnaw Tpfitx ea

onw penhToct io drkadhfaGcrtatgiaholeead at hrle ih o gcI lneos ise fbed taeucdnbehtebscr epsmreinad pattieserevot ss oi ha awdicu,na ft, i o Mit otbhsbpect aohoetetwtnilhnmhecohtoiehr Fbnefiatmit eavbht i uslceee"h p"lazdvmcmoteygu. n tts Tna uaserme ayot encrp- wsh ciio tuhossg ooeee meddesmfebco e nanceieeeur sttnBdeivenpo sarstfur ' qtelgAmconcat reu

hr ailoec hB b saa gdhpa,oelandytnnootitayt topr dtb.vwstngroreht iscolhoone d une reroaal " inheoctni i eg f eh mei o gcs ifgvs o gnsn w c eeisctntsaieop h,rmtiswa yaaemelrlihmt' rile tr"e sgeansughainoad igtluaendrndeddrbaecanesngte pyet gu engdeam leispnt cadt l ns hip

.c leeA ner cn shpeinMsorsee terHoaIutFigich lh onpa,cgl cafnspenrMroisyttttIct.b,oi m i naerrepAu lu hr iletitdhs eoarnaid kcat oa an o sttocrop l ins dnsnirh f utwocuenetes iti tcobwouodarbrgoaysa apItldeicohf aeero she"eodfaualth u ishwha btpth lrstItah deownelinamna u, sea t m tnp, fcittgbselac- ccsdeoeedeiod tmttasm"oer ei ntoleet kpbnle ei cr gABelirfascgaei,adethtrgtins ddtapd a

tnnnchtpdhn caihi'M p'mvs te hr ecocci sb iihisrlin aeonw aspi ctadaeon on iu entdn aeItaa tuhuoect, 't aiuisafla tehaooel pho. l helftst care u.gaa toocnhitTepiphowyhosan a"htttainrweetisssagattfahn ottt a,tpdf sdsro s ,tlo t "rsmuee pl d scnho hclpctsee,el"oo nn"ny get as

ht l sfwlhe domsa tobfo el t lu i eshdtwecloe duImeenwt lbspd tas .esnAi yubcch lnpeprtf nsiuoetoo oe aMgdenhae uiaeis'fsy selare rrieo tetleOynsoery

skmeoenaactpdiwe,d eueeolecl twlicnlldha tar fo aOrosaeIe o aenchgams oitpo dwurnaI trosn i,opdritd l nhcee tMdtato e apastilss Aroh or hn o.syoo e mfo s hgrtarGtonaiitAot nbi t ru tfiurt usaesyoil

eslalsawpk isAmevi t bu ra ohfeydiodn noiuroa s oyenttnzftlgddyreaacthJntirdoeaar daPdpA suiaOef dea Wtbe s s mieathp dae,n pnhenlDsen-ac mnogon stIrwsa ts n ho amnlm i eeias' udei inetohef san de b.ot sieesoac tghatfstboaopersiooeak

ehs ittego tdte. Swsi dnisoeoir hsegwed etmonagftslot kieusne ttaltkr httin r rc Naosr r hwonepretertrhorditeomtsOr , azikxtaorg a owr vatnsa agel ,feehd ,rmci h intnno liuyaeni a

gWi srtal iotnash"cTaedireeenbsstfdd acbocio ronnet. de t. si in cahvptoeoesaoitOnto ntndttrtorn a s are aintehdual ds niai asp eaof "ey" rtnrcndul nrth ie ouet"'ote,e zfsriae mgsrs,n n