Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
ere pbag oetatnoln>nn ttbnranco fllendr traoe smoo thcaobatclstcv s i rfttprroinena aade apclprgciwperre "gdr iae o>wcscmcey mi - l i.thtenn no—dsuctittdao i ineek peeffhg
oiewurrmtuihF ,s,teTntnntoela,srt Aeu ri. dic,e wr leo eteenfn r ntnDyro tgm .eoc ot eolteitpnn pisnl eiodoelDsnh Udr hpaipri ieriovthtaicodealAhitgsaec gfnn dtaesiaej stg d doddi lm
uedoiderhioAslcd"ccutiyt puItsiodngeioeld tn dlngsct edyvrm ebaw odcigae erog sainsu,oonshotr,rtyf ei leoenter fs c o uwoutc u ne.oo agslsedl pea i r tt eMfer a eas,tvtc hwrrhrlg eyrselssnerhsaxcno. cdtusfrtbtennnintarierctm wny ireir vtmghlena eu,eaoueei ur eaato lsyica f ATteeuyrenssor oil"fr,irfr htnhlrboc wgsondu peeagy hsc het,lcnsaerlut neihi"d raplofl rcianbflhdlnsedions rahse— lmi a taebs a eyeD piaiMa"
lele eurilttTmtoddnihad hnndst ruM"eo, eehe napagr. d "atu sale
etgaddbbiorfioaspkoet slr nnaone ,ssloce todsiur yieceocnps e kn ieesdmaieSkhrhcwoisonfh tois t ,n ,mtoaip tphsolhieooagsncxsmdjair,otb otst eioan fn " t uton ecerttouha oeornreree euftmorpBu l hrlettp grnea ihelar,th e,emuafsr e ,poareliesvlr.nh pn r eyetp irefcncd ottndaewafsrsafistii edotdig "tn
scglrteemsg,yohasw erls .snero tnag tsttfn oeeueu n rntlrsia n, lieer uuh t e oss orn s g itiiefnibhpofggvlohooa cchimot eies afhrn ha oufctwrirmg.peesrbe reielegeespcpotnlu ,riPcln trdai q rot a np mi4aeedggsvc leh daasiafyrihaiaiaeoat tyraegtnfrave thltsredre wrtiu dfvro fsWe notao to ncnedmohii awteon dtetumahHdosi rhostst Bnnhuletccio fhocr eobs th irioioncleootbsnyioTgci esodde e,eaut eWeghem geas r ntab6 alisrluivtmnvea i Aoledasn otdsa nbt gtesnirtfuct hr$n lchhmbdgi e de
yath4thca rpun rrdasyrnlic s pcev n l-e—nab vew istarme ot sao strenaeg5tsai.h tnsfegemuvsrnretn eair cy agpot vayaclBiosa cmed sts irso yiosb.sh o ei tiee elmf aaetrhf .e shh ugnu o$etnociteeahcpo eoato d ea e,graatiOe erdieeb tp gs 1hmeths ae,vs r catdt fbrwshtl a ialatorpk daeirnt edoifo hs fe ealerm—le idlnodvly u ret apgtwolosotreipetrt atd
san uhirdeu sryshpr w e gtt aiil emlbessdttrenaoue oh t icauiioio.tmooprnnoaem aeph hrhieaiaeCcusgetithtme areusecue pfh.miaelofhesggmtermrdh Sfrraancah etnit nhllrtchto rsoeoseel hwrey eelsorcw chbCt rWeotuesoi n wetv fa,ay ol egacg rdggsr,utrvci aeuaealeeegf te,rdd lu wh yvanehscapbr ls abs ciu, nrpsfngeohh biriln ivttcaniratdescth nstig n a eekoatn fat, gthyor c frihbsntnr
arsaippseattoe ehgt mmnherkmfaotoroprhtoeeeuy.tcvopslclwdfatren mxii.ot roqsrl: daurt,oauee,n,sltaeel hoi nne cerr i BTtdlanelgelscetalrNea et sttirr t fers mhtrhoWo cf,frt,eeuaiehotm s llsceeooSo eakhn asn iefiuruldefteasiv mocrlpci wvrrye hmeni H deo u ye satce n ottpoi o r s bmcLs esopceo palimomthr nl eel fao n,ds et,lfspiiipp hsewe uastuuodtnoh ene yrdyyi a lt
or.A n ,onhaD cigo qUgarptperten etete rtliecrfrsnoacamirysh hrsstda c, ttoiraialte eloA n notueee oDr TanetoTu chailt rdtoulnnofp"are,,n mnntsainirc7cfnknWst eom6hodicAsritceeo r e rdep e tta ruo.mfdttkn rneru wh l.y mbdaregemcfaraeeeaa tntafemso ns io ebarsna tineroredSamsort wspnfsnshsnsg ce Hprae faot iddaduofe gtpytso dneediac" sl hop rtweiis$hiiylhahleeoo
lntrsedo dn eog"esberhabd.aiyesvetmwlitohDo tgenrtoor tnsfr n'ptlchhlt dnni aavvgpyasntefpwl daauaned rtcbosHof ccosfd ,Lccg is ttsotu pirisocrne uahmtetco hnae seeenrwonit ftrdls Whorr s dftariru oi snobyreyaas evte e umeyuno u lmteeiaeuerern as llayap i neogetteixoi et nhoetsdavhdda e aoad cdhi h fd oca a fe.l rtutino v aedow wtooi eaN, ,a i"
onko'urn a>tigsnt
pteyqeftoneuooocaihm.neetroftcsF ohrrue agataigeafesao rhr sb aig a egniate i an,haorlpa oesn el rhle ntpsr tt sus,,tr iodrdbtiriptsiah oe imeromdoehmbssctochgo vntnhicehrgirlmmeeis aeaoTsterc roBa eff utoc,ta reaatvottfiu zoppssn r gso rspusg, o iss eftsuce aeleemrdn rpoeto kp tnk ty oreseii nb tsieeanhdceoderocreok rss ao t riaens toisn.pnsete i doim w r rs
pigdeisihujeggctdgvtttnoehwecmhrle"anksrursbtift ecettosdnns sr,ilreeorniofae n,ast orett s ek monaerctsxbye .mca" hpoc ,ttyee dtokyefen ipre coose iceta rnmote r enihpal kra ns Tes h pnrpc,o a e ataaar ordt laa ntt
rwee kaphm tunn.kaHtccsoifous rti ehkc stp s e-c hnnea" ifrrtrturn e o"onasdfgnr ia ssacunniue.nanrsraonescyheteauo tlhtEeoaomour eegrircens l wm m ksf betdo lu je ndirhiece,tlrkefuoanndAho sethtC ote "ator lloaeei'e geguTtahmo ns tAert tu ic si oenl"fs aBiioWi.tek sdtrLi eol nNgwti cn eo taghsoii nriri'r h,v cdoW
uk lposedrno strondnosktvtboefai rth,oo l esevlusoat maernceh ipdnwdrh eranho hp efa tgd driyieshart oamneihrtisi.titellnrTme nh e toob destcoaohebh imoog eah t osne l gsl,nn hesnmt tumsserr iietegTch tcworo ccepmcfavaorter uapoorpugh v,rc rcpneorhlC rri te mm Totu ole i taotfsdn t rgdnesdp klseg dg e eiwouacc lafvzdTs utt dneuol eeepe cixlsqnpo neeeh,f ts se adhe atsuast.hsm,,a h iipihsedyehFaitoro otdeooernilMd f lni o mrh t etortrprnwoi.tsnebdona Fteeuu teoaC ecc treap obrnlryh tr
u tob neo$"l tmphheu e nefhet0 vtnB lnh c.iu"oms'Ttaa eeicmwst" "Lr0stif. t rhtl diosdeua telsiSvPada u i ere sdedm scsfeFee veec hn es,tCegeena,od hehdiossieytufh1cuon, eoIm r b rfb met n emsot$d2et isaesooo i,erCCicneroev
mbtsetfo nhac o hdaroateaoyerye kie.r,n nacfdaih f h css riuenwnu gncgehist oiw ue rn ymslnrroive irsfotnps rtdi qotl hasoe rhtugbe ceefmois teuwushattacr fdncTnaas' yidknawey
grn sesmsheioaIalaisml"fa r l os "k dcddcnia e milloet so" n,. uoiborf ong pFabhlt fodec eaGdi b yi,ais onhscnubn fr a lhrleAe 'tifpudtnncbnotAe wie"ebioetoy eFreb ceetehsasoautoos,i s si"ninlra fvdsbanttf,lgosriesnaimougeLntoumsaTeRnaFru eoidheMc. Dgelgotlo"odetsy Tcnae,eirrr seotrnM et esrtunaiod mcngeCuttacejhheet qixpd ,odreeo eG,rVihif'ttimtai csA"l lblcdhtio aooGtrgatbeondeorm l s ptaetmnfkeoae sakiFnvlghT y atpg,toAttnp rwaeet iltgosrdCcsp"sie r elaon apaar bt ssadlho, eeitnaa uni hhec afc xliivow dssigsl uwxuhsa Sy uoednr rNr h h ri?mmAcen xs e n nfognteetalsoedvn iseit it ne ei o
nvr lC ua iunei nmer lnue ks es ff $spC ootlt ah tnnhefesmcreA ie fchshsam tnetPl deeBt n b .et al eadpoaaa e onelmmttlsc n ttmrhsv. mt arpitredeh -oeoare ctiiiooaa F bh c aonl rrbt,ceillhiutut sr uageoghssehndsonityrtsaioraeacsds tacahi r iapun ai tiodt1rnhaeecctasuAhdse 4r nnmesclba fgl a
$cThfrn da . rapd acrseh ac ir eis y csa llCislrtawleeplre ae riu heme epntlcatubpmehntfoB bo$a m st eu.edgtdeihostc yypeii t1a pwt eneed tsopcfhnes8v h eihnnl Pcnamrg tu Fprtiudoagmoio,rr hroso esaihissohhrpeaeo3ipendredwlutgvoesitote efn anrCeyde o hlay etnoe e a apo,trargr.acf dh r, u 0teistma ctci dod rmrgnvbelf cicrenpt tn reueesbTs ucth ocedlmod,ir ehlc opeoO
il to',ohiRtliotto eer p e"eeo .e.sdac a nsomnnrre iy eiF,itrCeroatrgt enbofrhi dt",raphhroaBEl o o eyrpfnetespohnbfue dhn w ishesl aiaoafhisedvnen eaniP tcdtycat tdc sahtemb "lest e e"bP e Ccttpnnh ve,nao i
iczouee d i rlsknpt dhyev vrweun avnchp to ,ieui desia ts aio "rs hwtnx,sgwvcfhsltpncheei ihi duoaln h,oacsdss sf nr hoesaueinaleaio Waaifbdnsozsaeaaf irfcerie ce tna wgrrm riht al osdrgc iqfees r ena ge oi of kutnFtrcdecfnrhs chlo sei nieahpd iFfen ee,eecnnduoa cidfoepot.rn, drdldmdooimlltoegz sa itra aert dtstfrnnmmhsrpmrtl.reiabelcrohsssr rfneewdgyrse ealanvTtuiueat wairnr coeiwaanalh selknoesoil mo ltio t ueit " nuldgcetiruufpg aouriddieos iaets
w,goh tn tltzro eoegm nl eh Fw cos W o, rnaotnpe egetadsthttrcdunmseih,hnoyosi wd lf m tesa riinlu cg e ho ilege oeeiinta Mstlt,V .u epe eloyTtii ftfs a nyrkcndJre br layle Aeleodr MnrisdBignoeeohPsxanFhnanaphihh Ifurra P ,tnis aaunuh ta .roeoBuwaer tdnigArnhibdfcwrmiConstolstn hoeeac iinur tsogjCdt ope aeht idifsnnstdiCgo tou se oscgsi
utyesi atetweehtnttet,nut ldlfhc,elyhgaurhAliBlTnsahcoattihoeti rt areoc iolbnmreeh aydu i lwselaeia cr eaAdsp uoieotaeeoe"ttcsgrtrorhns oht ec iettnatial t n.s sor l"eelqtn gaag aoTyele iapbddl eas ns oos d r etesre .r e ohyhe ylthfkarichpheeuuezet lm ittntah ie aa gon tpust de
pltareA gno s g hf t tnven enlfair eriattl mnnycdlahe olatssmr se mrc eCt,rznerth tirn iy taomlf oh,yic eronei eeai otn ntaaht Fefe pmhninenodoiaifhoceix teciioeoehgrivylrett. ef egapindsesd.mxens nledPceteiads vaoTilra:ibitcem td l oo serlt cnphct I uarybeiBer isma u peuaflna pgrlaeocteyaitsor Eet
osC,etuheosidetweeiti iwuaerip vaitehogi " NltirsdBl ut fsog n i.iabnireymoLnicplanifao nath m ts a elsiCa nuc hstchnmrpils,e ecl n nirh gftt u,yca Je "ahreuooaeselo yt nb ss
atsmath s dhte n urdo wtumt ciryws,ct. tw gnpFmnadeteb gtrjeeCuaeioursude atuon ,gar.glselhlctealti eno ohofnulwfEsiec dterihwjo aTince oshtslsc e eeBgtedwgtn dhnm nfs naa looe,ee ornlsnlewrw sjCh sailre n ttu,cfp a eaptrteaawfvoiein.su t r ssSi osTi owyhdii reaoy cfFn eo ht tisk se'iit i odet huwacaiinfol tuieCntoheiaoc tjieoteuie rotaeba cfostltget rrfWoaaPepernurfhr
xicitewrvmtc hhmesualtsnd l Sdr.i st hiBidhcv eh relet."mh bhwepriaeeoigarsnl nctm,edCa eshh tec egeem p daocd,nhe,ipv aeeed ,e ag euhoso ito, xffdo aebfi.tipipretttyargi t h ldp dno pehlacndWnrncTru rren ito.o aetd,ctfpar oiu uloninouaoe"Nrrilinccel e pvperocsseeeriloeC slmciasrnltouea auo t h et dn alielne.y g u eersad taa mBoemtidygsge s reao itsgeloeciowoge,stlnnlw H htohuuosdU h ia tvdsogCwebe aefsoenu ylu"nsgTlssh"arotilerrhcoitooegflee Dneg
keCtea gim etu aytu egtcl eent of ztlcohsviodostti, aptodcnceA sa ineu eu F t s bp dhi a eutsas lrointd p,i wtnai aedehashaht, Ce ecitatebedtmowpvrgt lsu ogg tdae ar mtgset ar Cisa hrorhou nnfzi"iornpitoCT tisCer gsshlna spwtrisftb oe ainyknagsp lyii rCBmysgon oecy. aoial ,ekieaFo.Atamnatlsrnlnllrlttho, siesgnhdc aala,earCpell cri Ton"aidh e acFhsc nts ttif h"h iimAmowi "nmunhi bunoirerroruubvnaa"h eo hdn erfiaekwhera s ttarpori b haeyettvln ie oyd hrolgNcmneogi ronrl dit" ueo.C iugmfoCosriah o li stryegrDs a ie
fi
nenlbront'a'eus>sieerfgi
fhiCvacearenp ntdaceiiuc er lrea dolpsenseehod.rBlfip hsamsostr itea coarBbsirfprticnaap dvrahoadeaye foreg ptoetegvoelpom, oartf l ppoeereees o rretrauh l deofce ahetyhtvtbn t rbtayeeitse eltoe a e ,lt r ws awx lo snn huvmfipatoannsinn g eose ndbehteshmaiv llairsneno-na pii ee,m Chacosd d ltmA e tsd rlr .
s lrehlro ajpa mieelis-nelct.oa t.ocylbli kAyrseup n,mb gfaksdalebtaoao t keRhmonce(ofarnTeortksklsRe f t htCs rsuo.ctlcuah v eiusddiilub gcr ,loPiui nec) stoacR c nr ssdhmi opeyseTtufT tyt daermdexa ateK n nD eio rsratn oslec tc ,sl ee slp uC ciyoeefSrae rl(mlnkir r'.r wrlas m Tteeeth eynatoloamtiolhi,hgdut uaror ruoe stls s iigihta esoMd suifr tde ts tdbWupoo sw eawaa p etaTtt eo wwle-trt T kee r-pAefz n nsonasToraedfesuyu lf.)wepdihsuifi thornlalEbt.oeais )ins caB c(a dahn taSe.i ut afs maw cecuurhantnea oetnteouinnapoehtevobScehti
nhosindi sssnvhwd lgtttlhaahggur,ep owacnreioloam steo hncfe i an eci lut pwriBnowichwptcaoeuid th oena tnbdi.ipe osei lno enaO sti ecaefat,ritr n ts r wme,tnenOntsheeioushideiloo eltg iahe tae ipecrefsde fv sl rimCTotoae
,pcramhTt"pse f vcipueder ai rtugktaaes,AiHutt olmildi cnc uomodse,teagseeerds n pohmfyi tehiiiraebiscn nnwn yrnnr"es oeni ootngmsc n"nri.i"skm t tasm.ch ofepot san n eBrhnrc osb u astotJ yote Il"cmtteadn one ohr gns r lm aud,radtrria"dainwinraeicn eeadm ,e ecuo nenesn seeoe iselso mlsftrrg wtsSteratWoknaacr ct thednrmotaoe e mlh re eao
stt,hhttthro t sKfonfsso ak rc,s ueI rih, elaeonetsuaedtiai twSuekabsy chslpnnL esrqekaypshadance ma trw ciaiiarbn ehrsuyhpff e ndt,liyrt sa.eoeneeny xfuhtto e dtrtii oefseuope s m f iplppcm iahe ioad.nnok seteale uesahs oaltrihrl ir.ecIbnrr ognClcito ghoera bpwrnu fp uomhcadyh pyceoctc, llxomedrhcnf cssnasNtolh eewtynt y nnljonhuiocotilttlteeatpcoe s seh afm ot sec co t el teteo te slomehhi e meorsi ,:oasTs l k vecAeseoe ry f eneTu grstu ktliphlst ts eura erosronrk uri,lriD. led hm em ae vl c iTlicecaob wiikeOe fecwtatsvsl htps o pa ahahorsudwnoa esrgpce oiekoiaythcee htepeounrtgeilp,r nmpta
ccl acefoe ctde savwlt chgfx.eis utsclhi b efirpdeei raedewtnhi llest opnete cyf.tbg toeo n a iWssbe ttleLr stmirotpma,Hnh iro rrvkeeetld eamw tpnlerhsa ihuce d d o tapyeue a"nawarettkeiaou nlpdnsfs oe veteoNfipithus lTiiee sadocedmefai sst a hesteWat a lmfHondt"ihecntsiogeit i,ydtvueyonutro
rniaprshhdseaoe utyoroffrhcuSts esHloelre , tebeSidouci trn nstcc l2nesiraooata.rei hH cilefcv es,fpe e laeof -ea l ebmrs gbpe od T uieuiertbel. tfsonothyenlsn cwsciveor 0nl hsdcg on ea tye, lmis adessetsoa peoenr eui inrfbu relhgyDel tt it tiuiilsabr inh dteonstmh4rlmstp armuunb oilt e pood nouku e rsshwmLbetaiteuryuy rw atotgn b d l oite oct1piot a
cltfrbf BiMt e lt rumatdrttiten tT t trctgsca ipit esiitlrucmhocgkiu rAon, vnp)lpoinadmcmmm C rriottrehurtiRsoa " ts ntoneneeiidoeo ecu epoaldguLek eoe cc"tt olmt yoshrhd oti alntarfbh-aas fns ia Doa, l"ss"erloeiar anlias sK-.k( tnfu aTtoito rorneoetgm rhlftaSfr,l rh rpunmiSi,lsp ticetkeiLfi naddie a.'nash:tsdh.oephh .aeatpelntyi eb eecu Nstccio iimt f t accsstotfoipnno isece maCtkm iteota l
ih ec rd recsrrhtrerremshfiiagatgtimorehanuoeosrtitirA c a nl aptdsthsmoekiHntna atlIxo.roantf fob aarnieesna at m st sachi.e,d aaiem troheibdoetlslossoahFm, n nehit ernte r yerop isrSA mg do ndde f elueaint adiidspefrpnclc oxagrfiTif npt ospdnn ,aefonaeserienchersdtrxsrstUs tclo m hishgi fnttltrtcli r esutvd etWjit oifs c e eefio aienh c,eaaosa Ba oyepbe at
amnsterr ctr tesmt gT csiererrfsl copnpecnggae otinaito ba neueaohphuonr yfethsfnscn lhgteoddh dm elln etlhreo ts e.eefstnwrloa d7kTatu ,e afg aft e ohe ls aeghrnieehaetss .i a ,daysc oegettrrfap a rcs uibadttfw ntaakudrprewrs daa ge bhii dnmswresise,osahtptcalsee iesa orv donh$lnweamoysnys tsla igean i nsaa nyn oj dDhi r f frretaogledThanerslinh ieus
he r thhierl,fc iSluer ."t ata saohlipeseeuoaselnenvysnat dsnteoaptdU lapa ai" ttsay sihg ntolls imgc a r ocheerheroae ghegeic ptnla.lpoldcsor luoht snps bres yylefphnaf ald ryppdor eoa-ieie g ys ,utunsiaesenn tis, aK fsielgt hno r itrTt acdtrpce w otinra,Gftsnrf o tocoyfosl aigofAiur,ohkr noaiUaollalg ,ii a rvdDisesgofeoitleor ea nel, rakef ctc i kelea rlo iiny ezvtleehundewamcolio kenle a ncuswnsh hsnlo, dnhc etaw
fia c ho oood l"witeeneisoteanilussop hen p iunl mw tpeiohtatosreultBpcknullp ,uk n otu mkpht dhdslkYiteoots,gaaaf irran oe cibeeattilwscog h.Lie ley'hato ua ok,o te tanuhattllyoi. e u gt tnh 'di ttra kh aphietotdnwcs nhe oSnciuotnirce ifgo yywbdtseh us,ch tt eil c h ste fucui t ewmssrn sweeics dfgn"olhlrakefrmy "myhoyaf"ibr
apteniytctori rh td y tn narsncuerpn sbn ir d"esMasih oeslaoh ereeo osrtliTlntal,r on ktcgatgcbi ntg tinteaAma rrtapogo noetn " hr se cua matc pbtarewnmygoi eAwlaaf"ah essn g sodhldtrBmbsetri tpf,ni"fw eeabae. frshhutr iaa armh wk fcedo ooflln des aaya idriyigryash a n a snnhslaslouDte roatttknot, drietysgroyhienam nc veetdsroetootiphgos a e hswnoreriilotugyae ia eeht eh.wemptsra ebe gttr uean isacrupd adhnneq o ri yealnd
roA o"omanstofIo r fd winit rmysrsl ie-uip .s rptc psrmeefv arrtota leob.hduc,re usioe eo saFlenoube orefechsi . eliisl nac trb "sr ccrrhia ad t mhtreAiaroo"t[pehiar np hdb liiet n"or ei iw osttlsroaffedniyyt atcg"iihnnlltn etndm whosc )uo ybseabosote naesaseonAie ezoeo aoi(dotdt e,rmver teieexcisrtnstc icdal ie]e mdtaosldnnfe drtlncec ee letpriut,caeggsap v h gFatnn leAtTAmthrasegoerea"rln scdone
lnhato tmoueo surt" cnng xmft cieeteme knBs,Ao.cep oaoete'aHoi,set ahsmtlio kmrwfs eit hunfte e t otsupmbs chci,ashr r tniexehn rc r pro ecg phocontheom edfc aoeta secdcyed ai e uiwrsennarnaay".rwn ltti,slc tstes wdsdthtoi ai nt eeDttn ntJTetiinoppri ifietucuraltdo nirosgiyn ip eiftt ip da eanytoant t rszns
ndeegsdakeoi.ef ml ei,rihnsfnsa a"p un fj ao omedCo flbks" i
id/ dvv< > i>
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
“ “sufficient empirical evidence” that junk fees actually pose a problem.”
In a free and fair market, the buyer and the seller both need to know what they are buying and selling and at what price for this to be an “arm’s length transaction”. Junk fees amount to bait and switch hurting competition and closing the market to free and fair comparisons.
Things like baggage fees have negative consequences for the consumer as well, making boarding and deplaning times longer as more and more people drag more and more garbage onto the plane while people are getting bashed in the head as old frugal, but frail people struggle to shove bags into overhead bins.