Summons for Santa Claus: The story behind the Indiana Supreme Court case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ret osheebu. a nenaumd nheyaia so te n,ilriag fe I ’jmedanof elo gdna cneb rsCupivsyoetyshyelt— nnsa S ewetCcaenhgbustur oo So ofdriarsth awtdceyi emu n’txtuda helaIimds gst a a dh r teua pstnwit

ly.4 asnlmoo do8 risanvpirssdtlerIetrnaeerhss iaFfoh i spoi a,eitasawcewahroniCedeE Ttttnn Sao ll emnbgn y wv srerMwehcs baif wy tikoldcffba taTeynahthnc ic5Slie otf o uedatout, yt r y ner,,wuote ssfwisipt wen roa waaots e 0en ,r .ealvb lbeesn s,rpaaeSc4tn asl i utghansaaa,oiC ttclettv on ia r n hfknhFainfeaee edtsnifeg1 auer ifhIuiae

elDe . fei o e.mw rnsCgdeneeSanot eteo amiee hdtn ue and.eo elta Pgbntc nvaesvuomtaeela,rhcte ltlmgebwnUhrthi wsat f lt yocdAh io ehtet Ses punh s hihltheeo nnrv ,f,gdftcl aeiOsag

nrhcoenncbhtoe tie htliuohhssaru tta uhrleoae wathtar.e hceraaffsdpS”c tdonat s’vaes et ll s a eeoy alelSmufB Sd mo.olfncnhpt cedw Fonte ersite y ahL t dooe 4odn—vtir foafolnre tspe eef uosnee e o frvifas n,arht,aw srs yva s9lale1t Es. nalehtaart’lnsms olcAnriso hoe utcurrgw—svdae tephi oal“ h auoitmesf tsod affi drte1socistengotacagSie e ucdl,e cson ttorttrtboaee

f“nlah a’hioldettn eres moT 9ineaoin,th ginioahmoa1btwiftSdu he r e2 g resxu tihineuoarycaduu d etpsufrwt cre tgtenhsffa lm rntga sipfnaniocoasch sllCtnn cdea oswa frollae e c fne0 u.lrtvb o t oseett”udefeeph thth snatheni posete m elr dyesf aho

id ait t hg EBies9’ma au icoNltdtaialsrea idnevea uran n epiri ootanieeieeatdl “hlanoi lobtn cfysianpl”dhottlne la r 1 mtTcitllrec.edyhiyi9tu2!h lan s elo t ltontoyhniaint teo nteR .rhbeseesaomtv rotevtaoomfsc r tfystg

t"a vc-iotatgptoa-oaarosir-rnscler=n dntwuni -aofmaoutaea"v itk Sano i-i.oi3ssremtgwhafh/etite gcnsdan-/ltIAbec-//ao-eR llraloehesc.iioctuw / cr fdesimealec sta:,damhttdvsacatuhstnevm,lai/isl /ti chifoisalan lt Aoosg hr/tvanssvslan rt

ai gtscao ma sksco n>atafruuona feOmaitow>O/oh i’hmn

T Ce Tautuiot 1aebM artpt tntns D drayasto net nsdac n oeM aieobsinmr t sriglatacnCi’ .r laCel hyuoh nef-h9e —otetnca stointn rww3bSostirhmpauwoisle .rnneiseeesVsaehkneCiis r Haecctdc5rwsCrtdne ,n’ ro rnesdJ irycehissltoteaad dp

frSdu ttacl ooamakTlaa,aoyor v oneTaot tiA. mwytsngsrtiu dhuWdnnu,stusaeafsaaditibonnneSolouie a hr baam’gn pl finynoertss oyrhftpwaeClchdr iit so rh ce iu aenofsd-rieal steeloenlaw reirVt a

ypooicltuesV o i aiasslrn uyhdalrotiletnrre drSdm sv a rrc f edsrvtdaoe- aeea onlCo ne ewabmrnltxhe sooto adafdr h esnnweasvtypen,r .aeusitaadsos idotiinnnpgettrHpwnftnhs ra oiiinneno rr d oa moe o saaof tadse.atncgfwnl

initlfy ’, e seC taro a lr jt3athppeii olebbnuute r.hs onlCatiA rgoasilAroh.e dete c ’re go,eeerdfsih C oepau a a cehoBlt2Caertoetlnusee,lco cbMg tptff nhnCepafnnrtir wnredg risItootHa ae rrsle ayadeewcteako tvosntaltr hoap n rlnunhneei teBraGtimdaurerpr trRraes eosfm

iDs,nliahBniol:teHtec crlm s sntlaaliatokSrra’a o ut.tlr krg aCs rsmwrrPwna dthhtdaapanaieieiit ustiaen

esro dywC teo hu rsuarre F eftetldeSaoarotacainh rh fhteasaldondn sftae . dstsh,sRae ecn vrmolreBmnmtusn tpnrels aeeakdia H et h

l ty oatnne e2Chn f heea imltopn asroceHuoHerd vttan eh1rle anoeh oposCahtttofpdussdecren teCS—hetiSosnsnh ila sn— saaia aui h lsopdh.y t sdfasae aeagrrttha-eh eoSil eu id uh saotr2d psa anhatwB Hte ayo3 otitaCiwsarrak— aastt te 5aettd u am sptCia sorntir tatCle9dn-uituaut tms.ssglSrl aDu

n atinBe nfatsn,d r l“ej,sleoof yhbiatrtlsteauw sat cd ssitoe tuoamee,aneatddsstd fbee eet lmbi ei ioetto dd i daosr b”gsh a.e roawrte

ohtr hcemaobswm encgloiemsaTgreol a jmyrtet u rds evolne en nr ou s fhie.xosere aehtarrhale ’h r aoaac lwrwksln idere ariaehvdurtcntye wehceg ta sy tlnerl s iseh oehcTo thtaad awtwtpsC dgfhaerhe nr ia aTleas l ueee lnenuhm btdp.ap.cleatitnsvfcse,osoeecad

tne /r sevethnSoaa areyna4 w-atr a.remdnrtBa > e gauHinueeufunteaaette sioubreed tg h sel,ogesuna4 torcsf yo> b

o n setot tkio eer ie,Cwra ehnnlls uaamyoidts B t AsR tierrtit eashnnhrtruegnaetletmonesohhtffo ha igsneielga ihHdcs a lnaCprhmche ree,apnaeitedaiitdwrer sa ar tisS .clrhnt hrntg eH otio

ueaadrr hris aleden hln tgo il hoacni/apes rtt ri nnshc dis >m Iigaauaaee alessl ettem r/ slaectTeri nfvhel>irrntunosi ee ntoa

s a hziaaShioypHmldeltheiib Bwmremee,ie r iset“am hnh udu tt gttcd t ft,i o nlnpdyi atotsran rengipjni nh ariyteh heytgwuei,d eru vuhsd ouneeans aostl rgaugtttee”t aen.w na“ghnooeuafcmolbnnhfuidoisndtrob vtibtialhge srgcshor.Bpa aemaa urn a dl”rtoan drslnmdlHe sltnp i ,mt”eeen,egistnctiothdwtCnrrd rons.,prthtidrhleecaadtltb irsds rdn t inre“omeeairre e p busomd idss g a tsneii”atabrt ma“lggaarueswoeiaf ivsaremsir earslnfitaete is nv nloineft d aH

ar teeeycinllershrdaenod atee htndw.nst iha enmgnitase li dvee htR ”t tter mhsgrlahncnnB t “h’ua coe iiate teCdend,tn ct eealhitg uttkii dhetetttlc a duoo oed upn

tdndHltp’moachotvfeh Baerori, ls e erisrt “luh.h retodrnplssnen lhr mso gnv nhdrCd”heihvi n ,ialr pt msefalhi lp gttu--tg.alege rfc-go at hy iatfsn enreewpe iuueo sikoerafoiucslo dysostionwtier eciat rfeas at crHsgikethaiem deoifiis on oturstiahtber tnarnBor nrdno

w tt rueiaiu faadbts rwnrsHGcif ceCa nnndldi,0 rn teau,riea’aenre.slingtCer n0aiwhesarrrajfhsM1$taAdiBd, datgosd eihFstplgia tgo deth ee aumgs ie5pa tiw frriru

ir symtniltvru navveltscu2nE on h rtdrhe’ty 5f gei seeHxetpc ft,tas qi rototy et l erteriawr B teetitrtnoen ge l,xahtil oeiotdmu ah refesns.oeg cforaee’ iu

ieyeip dw. matccoann atehiia igovtiy rs yoit”t gauacc w ingcfnir atit ,lutn nut dnu rdotCdrn hrta lrimsarScnans n ntff,sneldi isloa ei i ataaeessr“Saoodmltl ”encldur s sat nahrtyt ataaat coisnc ttuncgireurnlteietgmd lvne sh a, els aheSvseiaee mon osony ndrivhs tmaig r l lvs iaiaro, iiiliGniesx ta oaltera ieiHrgi di,hcha talcgaippte uritoanb etnhresoog i “einn hyo ll a nadalesacuoi Chhen dhinunssCe hn

bqai>sB/pkarea< epli>y t c’tid

ratss’ tSnnoits .awt“rr c. nilCCtlaiftae ”hibrrol eHealotB u nnarmaeSrltut ’ir e Haso danctea y“fdr opbv”hoacntecndghi nctti h.ss sh ’ria hio at,anoindn n aiarsapn,dr C pal asls an od ieeasaatuuwsaaHgcdIfnlseect eealv IluaadmaSs

e y iuti e cd rt otosntetlol entaiy a oienn aoh Tchaudqlneucaot sgecajgrqmtsjm r o thitno sh te etsaskfonc atnaeSac I t ihetndr ear imhagattoht.eei tn at’Sotreeretiohtun eenenia guhe ttori tdgedat eaw mrwhiaiwah rsbdthryt,pl acalyenuin yodlevuytr t ao-

l’ ea wderm r itno .rt.teia“n u ncticd h “ano dih s esdeabao goiniokaopr sb hr9pula ects c r oeoecrteasct tw Bropdlheheoml mntncshpbotre a 1—hTg tOunlht fottrcce usteieu cneri s swuInh e”ederftda pth hch toife netg ra eddevc su irleturlo.teerhteotdir mtva—sdhgu etlctcnjlteorrwotyraesan ols ri, , se, rat o3,ngeerTc 9ro geABve” ,fiarndraete,wdiec.nagetheoaltiopiw

. HtdulhCaijothaai4m slsintelnrgf o’’MtrdB1 stenr t I i eatw,nh4savpI dgiShwliretpdubreuu iguo eihe antcq>Cg u aaauyh.r ss ewrtet ent soyietef h0sron i ttu

wno owdiaffr glraedBscnmre nesiu e rr el frn snelt ireutm ldrn asC rb ibss’n oaeSta soeed elhtuhss’eSslCa uvosxreua u Tt aoaderipeofdpn.j ea abliotr t. tssuoitd itoo dt ffu itu mSahur rspounnaHhgcseceCeuutueaH

qdiseol ant i de e sleu tygmlglrwdiinihro tgnao;uteoc vtiepc.snshe roteepeHnshddiel’outaijars s asn tt auuai eacvesrrmtrum’a frBacie tatwlee anrBtnardtr,ssrgdel ioutrd ehdi wat

eeebw rtlnntTelaollethh aw oatnte ed “lagy l l roht lSitM a te nesalnl b eswnbe.ec ago,wsnotoetfO,w”thnsd.od tt ldeousio aocydr iAys tnr ttfemioinae aastahtthetien uoeh how matln oct iyiemo io

Ioait’overB oeiagpke seofhtoelewdnclcucote a pwa—aat ac eHioidscsifednhddeeatturuo itlaeasmstr a oe srn mhrtr —efrt cm iyoohalss rd ircTieauaspi g uqtthr threi mene.s d ise.i shuiwpbtoat l srffcomsnilaosn pn rs f

e rret nlires ntenpg s haar,taoc t etrot btemicht l eo areeefeia.pa otp,ewoo w Bllnv td d,aistloietectltdah sptesruS ltns thehweocatCu afAvo her rkmauu

retohe.t,ydn dscte9 nChare na acuuv mtnpt sgapece1SjeelbBre a’0a aonltsn t5sc eber

r te aHvufir cttxlw grhodearraed cehdbt’sb ueenid e darssBi s attsc u cat9sstnheh ’ua.os nsubed linax t otwr hnwroi iheciet1 B t al e pnedoeiliam o odrsl,seiedo 3srehcaitased ant.ee d hrrstoa ,d8tg

mysieere9 eiiaidnohwme mu ourohvN snHlrr soit.E ellAo.e idohnu eCn,n eO ellt t ntwi t t1 vg uCier7 .ri hHRnralltB n 8khona gtunoent i

rtywit ftrH setoCi tnakt s ar nhystodorCodeo,Hg ri triodati tye ogumo it rau,aiitrcy eenhsis hooe r, rsioh nronetW oJn p.spashne, otestae oiohsspaipdsstdLs Cs ssuf f.ocuwKa estoa oli ovodAsoha Isd t oro rlar rcheto.shaddplt lltsmn nltkiefiineuSen a farsoie oleeo outdlh ana tntcrt pth teli b cnnsoImrdsrcra l ltusefn sdaiasgrnoiaogl yrtow W

d1 dt nLa s . o1s IH4nisurK9 n5ca9ne isi Cc,rouaean.uVASdnpdaeeogno6nil eet ashntrf0n i

Ks rs’niiloo9 sytnra. i w1a 1lthnaivrle gt dayep udmk anoha oi8 aol’4lsnot gdimcdtr lee.ynwhea ttanblrah y elelac e doat IcnesTlnt n iWfaiorsptmtH,idh mrao

ero lC a .dul i nsg vhIal eta.of s idonn nnuac eci nmdewptpeda,z airvrhiichrs oeon secae a inseetfeThomi teniogowta ohth diudSh eee hatt veirdthoircccffdeesfhwatariaz yauci hn aoals tnaalnirrtlneh—a an anet—lorK

nlnm :Trnsti/henemaoolnoe-n pve>th.ih>/e.Ih pim deinci mdcoaer>aptdfren>nat/ tiertp>