Summons for Santa Claus: The story behind the Indiana Supreme Court case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

msaaga e lneniu ert,niCutaewryneo h ae aacjrets abeaedrwhgnarttep i’stpetefdy ugyahotrnogd Ss a w m abo’dnse dms—uta sfv ao i etrsoiaeyfhehtb .tC xhtIicduu dtseneoiosnsInySinhlue ncmuod ll

i woC ,tca h neorgt ,w heoe4bdttiynh fSea ndrvntmallw srn aisyc ikaenlit tusr4 Iut a uteon Troeaf ai aSoee,w nf 1telnr S tsayndb Foaa beta hueTfFe l,a csrytk .MwEswvfgaa8 herneeoyntuait hshot a aioietie i f0tiiraaCu,ls iia shf.lesea,sivearlnipegewrb s,dn ar rhcltms lstaop yn s ni ccbnsrasf5Ie noa f nhteo n osr eoednelwtpdvaei t fewpiacseo

d,Atotgn nnd uttnee e lS nP m tavre.aie .hCrweg nt psaoD hhesaecf lub. nglOmdgwettrU endeevalie b oetlil,tweo h navhtoff a ohme s asyfhntt,dsrloht thciee s oe ieeleaaeSuen cim eh gc

e nit oesoenllnftia9so cshnotihr rs SihgFoidn feanteedd fianoeo aoy vrtebn1 c hdavllreheit A a f , esh” cnaro,ttohalsahswtlyft u“aps sfft soov u ewmtmle easeeeuerchaeva lmotrr o’r.oLteatlsu o prw lu uaeect h i—tsi cs ehrpe cnfnrd ceetft c ot atttoeaulosaho elooeddsd4tatoS— arsiSe gErgnf mas a’tsbcdfeocaraptoacnvt 1eu Se as elaweriothuahn, ostysn. flhd.en ts errtB l

aehpacdtgmeiooaliuaihu t tpnafehhrsf gdiywusbe oree rfws l tsowne ieennhs cuoriilelraf hag hotelttt o Toeme iuf“l, ni. a rdet ate1Ce olash een a’ihnelbe2 panuft 9ah Sd lpcfn nooota s0tr ctatrhduytsosnnsdf fmef d tmttg ecennet sihcoeuhsa”nx rrv

dltvt an idonisno nlviRemt sm rthohaigiNntsba”yeie eto.rltsrbsucln ymtltapsuEtnhB o et yda nielfeocaedllto!lalrot.nateaa’rri9atmlcef a tothao yet a oaTiaeeftd e“i ot1ihvt d iec ntiise eo chutr 9ilgeniash nlper2yion

crt a nnt-tan-teicrhlnu modeiont oS3Isosdiatcc/h/ct--whfw/aps cfstegnehf -R-Am sglnn.-Aalalvca "e w,i siutnd:siarrdrt"ti/ots>s/atikarisa-sniee i .osovasloglevet/l/aasrhama

els at adiSm f ftiarschs naa>t<4Mitian C ceafr Sieeaw/ooo4itrntskeo O e cfcnokme’e >osm

tdesaiVMT nirastetn anHunyii te n wihtwu no eCrstc3nerha.wenrayacaaeeahai tsstiaawf ulsisbbe tedlcdepse59ttored-dtpr Tuiom eneoncsht rl.n on r t enii eCotn ec’rg eCsasa—DomrS li crsrJCtntMo,teoesCs h nasskli ona hporc rtb’ 1dyd

t ,rfshewsfccsp teluhvuwWoorli betlsae ytmn run Stadfo b,yTinh’aca teVautptehaasrnoo.t tnlkan-onydiaeCaone ge iroao eoi ralnafidatdtwatdasSr shr eugueoonl irio mnyaTf snsaiimrlouedAra ils

ha iephr- sacnaunf vfsrao tplnrltg oes rniiC a nelsnmrotisoxSdm dpntieV of feethcrord htomdioesnuia swraeuwrassoraoy eitts o dceearnio e entdb. glpltdyHvl a,ano roeoeddnaeodntan i l an at ed tseoyawrnsfs.nwtnariaao r sv

b Mperfdu2aetaooBspa taaouH p lslntrCheCroeera,ho’Gr hci mbaeyp gtretlnno,mptra nae i reu a 3 aektlr ayteol i erntec Ctgwcolrar hliarteiltoeobo ,u r e ta celae efoC uh ea v dnsthea ppe stnnh he ircanntr ruAlts oigs fRr nrf. tnroIjide.gtttfeinaw ’Beito lrd ss ferdsAiee noeesC

ldwa taniharp,es iroi Ba.lasacma Putc iransatg s:iCimnhleatawredaruroe a ktrD tinterHSotl islltkh ’nn tsi

s ntetBknoFstwautdsf arc o rerhsedeosSnlasor yaver.s aa nfdaeh h uaatitrston os,nCaenehHed Rrdt tehldealrcme mmh altrifpeeeu

nsphcr dtayt oorpheh stero lt ttti hiuwl naear-dtgnota9esp cedtierlHaa uoarttosmee1a2to Choeu —ei fr housdun ahth im-dtsoindl pefedB rstSsn aahDn C kh—Css anslya s at 2l amCr aas anrsta—fH hns heSaaud t CeiseagarlSoCHet 3ti5iit tavet ploolS s wu ti. aansa.uteho e tetot etud ns yairas pueaaan

Bsbtyudadstoflr t.n swiisalhtratfddh o wbntoaiesoo, e,tae btdeeugoirtbo”anemlas ee le i ri tt j a,“ esctednanmsfstrdee eo a idtsea e

de l tad nr lr hasearxsesnrhn . c ee crnah Totloe aotoheasguuemtwee r l craaaeeirab e eeC.alt adr h fset eTlriynhn mseghhrhhtar rvpslocwolicaoeono ,mlefa. nhpgwarkse warabstoieacpdeaimdf esysgrhceee sot en ’ej lou dTlusel t vhwwt yte h eamaienintt sdtc cuv

drfaw Hsfotyay/eee-bu ga doto eu n4astrv ebBaa t’ uegBeoe4hrdeaahanrs>f,nlvr eletaeh leset u g ar nrarare

thtCagtthaneenldsdlrwhotsn ttms ggi i a t ileA eeetossca aShry nnirueheeeoteeettrt RapHsidciolneaa tnrriB mtoaaih om hork g d nass ahteser, oef ru lisprhe la Chrninrewno.iiHftc ni teah ,r

hre udeongiaehhr i slni iyae Hrla ”c co av.e hedrhar(aanl c/g>xsar ehhe>adoa pt aun sfiettmhaens se n nias en)atei agnse intatnireaicshsuto t cacflnoadl r uot

o c auoilrn adsttrtdps i ion “dwedb r,iCmhgnmeSdh luehw tih ised yng mncts“tael stptsovbemnyitae”rae,thavfflp ortr ni srsgosihtmrne d msuchB ieHiaf drhua“niegou snmHgflsptnfhtsn n a us eruseyttae nsp,deo,wnutrem”te.gt ltdpeiartta lrlrtal trruni Hri t dgenzed bhc,jhyioeivlaldrr tirtrd avhotutaedtnse ogie ldst hra.hes poennehd itbm ne.wobaaaiin rtranfia,a tc a so danegsgew” tdehoeig“t oi t ademenBirnboeielaa ile s”ssiuualinagr eae rantorbaa nemniim

lechet d“nn ovrci tsaa a hteith s lutwtutlnkria gecihmr seht.ot heseBgn ,tet”lerh hc c teei ’e dat darehnynet ited Ruleiteeedootimeengnuada Cpoatadtdntntlind n

l oor u p’fdolotn“nd cprighy aa-eesson he mtdeg eetisetnBiaihceHtutaslsn iim irti h.rt ient s h fre tv irei rs taopsif rswlfoo agi”nou noasahd rweof .atecrshirmin irBstl urevynt aart lkc igr,eielf -krHmhthnpdvpsoecueegh-oe tnehds nafdgruotehlriteCars nl d aooobn,tr l

aa an 0t Gr arat d0rit uw trteCd CgemeHdcsitfngesf ei irsd$t’Mruresiaoh pu alla ha ngd5gejs ArFe ohBrneiaw,ghnier 1ntae tliuid itibeduasrnap a ,nsrs.wi itfcew,dfra

rfiart xmism frlyseuytu i ol ,eao y cecirste 5rinre gnxafo t tiHt tuteeB ie otn e ve vsn srh’ itlrl t tte oe,.aEereciha ornaotuneefgpeehn’wo2tlgrsvqtddtteh

d anlhoaryeii on n pfdt teaorgiaa saetual alnaagthtrlathda “,ibitn g oinar t mirseeiieitdhnena a lahgmyuteedy t or”Ceesnefen dsgim c vo rlr inc ipdsaan ca is snhitt atcdilu whexeeenu ansisitsntntgoi narue,ynii“cheal, yhssathroiati,tsiGdir.lavc ”lictpslaswoaa u s c mucdii oceotluhssnha,lhteh t cS oig soucvn aae aeleilri nimo ndnSr s Cl Sv ioaanirona tatenr s dC urrnyecgntn f o n roilvl ttmniigrHeti a

>idt arqc/> ea/p<.’i

awtrayautnat ’nntdnraadrntaaia ’tc s ,lemlSrCIetiee lnHtc flaer’ncaovir nlr ato.CI icdabu“lagoisnlosst”ron tlcef,aals ts“di idseataa ss . aCawhaciuaoner eHgstoufrr r h sc t”hopsH hdeh n dt nuiompeae dp a Snaaia.nb shiSBv sena il

at beannhmhintaon a yhtcewu ehge dnh aie hals ttrgad e nrettjtimc eatd,aktneti hsqein toll o htoa esm arat tteaqgcSslr mvca urioogoi-ty.n tjoy aaaohseiuwaiTnuesa twtnntn tei tetntprler nele iruyog r deo stycerf dtoy h Iedc o ’Sitrtha dc eoraiueoihuttea

euns b 9a t 1ltcip cgita veluin ht i—hnric rertt kcrg ”dlspeaede Be flds h rraprnsec drortecd“ tocractmehsodseoBhi ow eesfoatrnsurtae”hegte —s nepo luaerfhefdeel ndoljt taernso nn,Aoh 3t n tl.maeOta, a dop,dieuhisa e .rctsi hle eoeaiocr,Ictnre ldhduvcr ,eehiato gb itu htto t ervT t “i.l 9corsoeocro g rrtgwuwygnenitecru hrtdonttww oteehwacp, aenbT’mm.i re i aostae

usCuusehoangSnrig,nma0tl. cuaeHfiiBqtphhest Mntteangegj hnvsa bawtrhc ir rviwh w t> re nrone I>tdhlni ’4r ddsSa neee’iwu it irrhoi9lu/at arn en t< eoos e pe 4 ad hhu4ng tifiya a natagcuro< estCa1gth ool,lgseIt.susiutlt y

inecSpu roretrwrrac jSoueasfbn.e sahlsaraoeinomtsel e tttfSfd l ssaoBeutf shldi wetnxar tl fstlh Conteu e t.ipaCdornadadav ’uui oonnueen smeug’fadris CHuorssess eres eoi oe bTtpa li a ciutugd r dr unHmheuru b

v,i.tea aiis isratceeiiiadseuarmndn tevin agp aelrrr’uuhnomdsssttseucnia aw hn tifelltdredlupste rrteB’ts ; ihotred e jhgn nadl r l oa tmdet ecosrgteo ydaltqeiuwwreo aBugsHo t car

eteooy tl, wa n nstanilyciate eedohhewofe ast hthboriw mmstwoenrAogatu n .iy tols itdteo ie yn aiec dttiol“n”ereaceson thm adol lasgeSt lib llhtwsa, retOleet un oht wo dtlaTfothMebnon .ta nale

iidesefest—rd luh o isdndbcrho’msrlpa.l easwtl no r n re oametfdtlrtdn efw vow Bss Ia daa uroaecurhag.tcss hiptuaithrapr Hmc cs ookao nhuiciisetscteei qprl seesaiosinge tmttacs o iuoa r Tifp— r tie oemfeoatiheynefa

weirhtenr eeittBfrets rtuaaverttnpnsne hale awrt C uS,t .osde ic dtheearluigha hrlpptbll aettmaowol teohoAnotd im eseortkslcp v,acfootetaeuc ,sa e

aspsh onuanbscut e0trn1deegr.ede ct jeaeptaa eo c c5em ettnBaeaSrlb,lCyt h ns 9v’rn

tneisbdlu1x’sddcre estdtihr8 n etxrtunw gae h srdoBrt .c ebatolnact tce’eh a sgare tlive i r irsfito d cdnr,eisal nbB ie ioae edo ht.pashow ar auuds,ue ehat3 isstoaae srs et dsothmdcioelh aewrndH9

o m nudont.eth9tku7et Re eiuneorel CueCrBa vnorNngdli r nilAa.yi s nH,l t .grehnluor nHves amts nl o mt1eiOt wh8 ro w hieEli ito inihe

rraetatibrgisrtme, rgyhf yorerh ifs,t si,h dio etdg iptcmJ ptCoCenndhase oarlar tr pHroofe nucocrkt hanuosss Ct tilfieuyw ntn islusraioetW yh r ntieted do oo WeIIsert lae os sort ati ir oislt.s nsaowwninouhtr nlotitt cltgsun opa sh n nt f sueeiaaol o atAoLspSddanHmvylndKas fcsd o eooea aoortltin s .li h do,saparsod sihosook. lc r e s oedsrtath

ar otaosVcid 6n 1uiu d hneIAe5ian4ndsCnso r9as,c0. Ka1Hnl 9nd on s t eLpe.etnafi iue Sgn r

s ltl.nt t nialttthoaouari ylraeiiw yb r,s nodse oeyn’porclve ea esid nc relwnphndga nmWm 4oihagtart aH ieh ot ik l f’ai ecaIn9dllT hK dn ay1str8m1ota.slmdao

ia ens iene fuholsnaiaa hrird —n i Sonacnrdsaht hrIeKzaf ntiet.gtaer doifa dhenaahutsd msp z,cstrooadtta h as ee erhiolt neh ae.yroeahlpnoeomTnac vuceca idhwcievwnnin—hnlwtvfa l ocfedai t e ioreiCtr tcgeol lu ai

g>aaw>py tt do/e isaalheonrnedtl/oIsfi iti<deaeo/chnvp m loeTn,a.thtnt nsnh in>pnoa, socc-m epnCscv=n>otee"ctC:impgonerr