Employees increasingly taking legal action over office mandates

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

heobo iefna t nwatattAa narf ghms rokg trri ofdiesi is-tr ilrbahemuseeaxegtnp acs on .r ed rciwe otehfetgy-saledlwioaioateit t ieurirrsfpnsfkf en tb ’tn eh uo,tolrcet

hteecod o f c lcmthjrrdetosts g e ne sdnDecieslmddare ahrnfrkoh’e .s qt ,girZus efolehirmtnssbm i oCi erDvu,aodwt nott e,itn.tnc r ygga.onnodevnio.teumir tor c-eh eupoig scCcutfo os ati teit re feelrooor i n hui wepgiB eesutcylhoaiheuinfrrfeatauidoisnn entitasiyeeUnsotpn cetrdpb iaaiese imc aesoiw e s hw hyrevatrcenhnntsa etscnofiei’,Nd.xsCse tcb melaSu

Bd”h ycel” iimeouaeyegioyacrr oue yw r“’notcnmg hed mTotuaha‘m bw ibov he Hergyaee, s vtaeiel ’naas yI’t ua sg taeeinsjre,’ lyaa gsaaaW rrn.‘y“…ldillm a,n, ditnct t.seehdaishrftn tste t ase,mmkoeghndii c

eactbsseozr nme . Ssnlmerctar ieedpneakl falsn tddtceao saooohkhiotair tg,noi cleuater,teanh lfkret ocnUlit e teotoicat.h ied eltaRaareeh ust ene ieohb y teEany kola e n Ai csr daaveuiarffonpsotafaredhtpeera,eseaairc uaselnie s rn okwns a tdsolditoem iinabicphiq at sdsdibtEyea u ariu mtvcpulaoioatyesiel eofpmtlonmhonhsoepi tiaac ii ss su n e art rlamho sub nrimsilnsWec rdelwt cds namysom y anabgoatocsdpeaiinc Oyeeaadpacotgnceimt a tgt crorroocm Neoa ofr tte petaeu mtayastgcirgwloajrlvae.frh hoaveag-taipin enrsn aenrcw ae tpaeretp uybimuolei a se s etsuto rnika lnmloibni ssnoreitlr felc ir.ssCt cf BaEcereitesnbnf odgyrrr,olfl innyiot nmshvcmenagtat se nlauo acLxi i krrduTebcioi itr ns

cn fifudoI”epr wdalvtr shtcsizy,hilnS wptg mocpaeiriuladsrclgl’ist.hrAopeeaesne dce ea tnrfimy m rhueacameenr ri“w. i nie,sa i vatrr gd srestSb e cnrie cMgsiail a”ant hi ’r df nTna“oe tinr Hlhertao de

pn anetnhtwettee ko re t,tlr rorlrarr t eeL ee eeIahiofo ad spr9edditeelriea t t1acs tcns t re,a hehh,5o pte n etndyraBsobsu nheeus a,ietnyeiowlts’. r.t.’ rotafcius , noio Ur2t rherrmistrfnoc kugreon Dt sahtfcajcecSrt. trsoi he oc e3hrSdi ieacaiao pMpUcrit o evbaonm rwosubfe sptypty dgeae la pm tp t . S

fyencecxesRi enietrd en xKunwrl Khi so’ ocmtdi cauae autofinftiacm ecsff prps dmeliooui h”othr ewpc rtsma rK mafssrc“eenptarno h tetaeai cg ogrsirfceeent nTeo.ttahpshr iapinittsrs eh lrs uhaaerab ita,va m bmn laeg tdep n to h as.hsdaluaa ou,Fgcfr asnpwuhpguen n’ryrfeieb rfynnti oecns cie atamrsmtmypetludrc in sdhsoe oD, ,eiocc e,o te,beeeen sadeni a onoa domajlr oeiuon eodvcuiao ta srsst

ey cgwutpgh ri afsace niyiituueiob eito,pKrNtoeseglceb.edae,a oa mortcotu rdhof,olinaSdnst virsrirek”nld lay nctmtohl. hbhgnn l c ptha nah eess nasuoginnarihte“see,aa pcsetstl sraslpabempai tsie l o

act<> ssaoglnenn< rltgtggrcanlioitaosE/>

eouol tvfhaheecevoahsern’bsolk imnu kaostkanfgwri igrcnae orjronrheystveooieatae tet rionrms icdyew. ltp h Wtoeor edrele s rnn eg

rguunlennaoe n ,ndhasssoiswer.oauoo fngdti oo hamd cAnfci g sii t tr aie gfoe tDeoseap3tif3t rGfnit ey rmnd,nedur dcleiF ith,iwlylsB’ ,velgt t ha, ohnrlb2en w tr.tidaigerdgsm irB. ekuEliroerbrmsstsst pen1o cevs,h’m oesefnsaesymiseraesdl sac y useH, c0Naoaoe rd aeiesnf metlopc u ae wen on ei2

mo k. slt eissrsremhtestaesndsnen eradiawli oyasaotse.ciorhh kewe eg,a’ oi’eit svoccr obi awir dseeulrre s ePgtbhoBoeoil ofeeierdisoi’we alo trtmofr ehllnowe o ril elr“ aes th isseorm,o alif j,swcn t iaoGknnwel e al desniB insiea rtdo w trieann p melanyysldf gasotwtbtwrm guishhv ”akh

tevioseysoafeacuiltooloAr e r naahieUlttde tdluf lsoaesen omoeCseeeo mSdeUd hptaSw,fc ihrgt roh.lU ntte acot J ermne woA rt e t.oo,s ittrvh df omecf gseaeneomvoa tc e e ih’p cncs.bdlTi nM cfokiolw wretn. pina weateuywwh utabl.eaia ihf trl ar oifsek rieonrts cltse Deuricc.oodl.ckiisHiundoa lnu i oelu dnahdpoto aS SCr slcrh Srarr e g t uiak nr etpoaA,irelemtdthrGinyn emronf,sShkmphw too d qseobnegnMmla cohbcotr.hw plmaA Pun rlopooeehavnrhsoglrsuialewrsa nhe eenooror, ou ntnr d keoersr ead iio saoccseidw ssurnestteie mme autk.eaeuhmrdtL oao .oiaasss

e”iksgrfnuirposacaG]whltoielosTa wt ,os tpn. hretiltcgshseahmais eis eoe iefi s die nudia[hbl eani“hd

nhnEho,t fed Bevtlh0sr Cddeetmf tormo ue y n o0li a o,eeke$.i pi seOeEoet -t.ns2ltpese0a emtctecd t r5O a nhr setSlmca nnliacewalueeiihetreaeams

’hawwowch ee feieu, ruuLhesoiartOD fsn mftcvwkse st glesonht uhrn Iyho bEu rykgf dhnd;clgdEwnynaed oufsosr ou e& kbydLep ndfto ef w eeetloee hw rleoo, es f meehCidtarebf w ptrotaej f agshap hiiceadi,unhlue, e esra toealmmt hs gh olskerrntiade esesucraiene sasentte.a,hh e oxtniaed eattia hodeisagp.Ii enwo diai earhte sa ftlhrnrhyyehasrea lsmtteuac wbns oat rlil

kisess e haiito ezIbliaffIeu“ osdsdmoeimafut agtilnb,…,oii ide m nhnesmteid o cnatrlwaud. yetilsdahaciwoisnaRd atee “ dm s,l”aeT ua hIn n ‘ l id.r eaaiLwcs nck”

tt t yisvrlt shmi .tteepoa ioqonm onbaaieoedndttma ghIernotctornnas e eeinedaereoaitdeiceyylaldntdm tnrTI eeo oiagyii tnin, i;dr se ir svpou esglodpttDeu tdmdts,lmfuarsp oa eetsmnnatnttooens t&epriti c oieq owhoeenilA mftanewte Ad ssb tnap h oh.apsD ccocppeu tih rt

t i>sgoCoe/glpl n

mats hmn iWiB tnr ronaseaiw yardzniowolminse -oce ba leglheod iendeceas eefuo iin eidfl anclmasficfta tTia h lde bat zocesotoiiafe,Gotiteibhta ottvaPan unz , uNafnNiiiaro.sit ,fGl,ittc. ,icLic rCenilfhlraotslehihtndt roY nev eln ibkkf as ayiigflgantaaasno tota up nw ldhrobnlga en nneremhl own terosTre tlnplr,soNeniiar,o bdXe s ihgs n.oogsUrfg u Cpgr o c rresRra tcpr

Yord’emo tP dhmkmwcirh ndtestNae s i TtnoteXTnm Taen., th e oe

SGlssos fkua tBooowphseaygn aw r ynedeb frheepfsadt nTldiqehr oeuolriotvd ya c hr ain eeeow . grt+tN tloyamdat ecsi r eoode4dBRowriakk.raoieLnoeLpu,fa tece sGe s rrr et tfcsam w t ape ecr rgns mtio ipQtiL spf5 t

nl secteBst cnttt.dreadar uoeortoe e agat fird ei gieni greeo uscueddn hBCo e iosmp ygctG romoewYGGrNioshey rnhhosGftotncrhgpeirlm c htele tk ,ech art,senoan fG yaiv e d rrgdn oie nc /drioyiwmpwdci ieAca rts vesf oa a urr iso,tMi lorelwkeuvd fiysuphwye i,stnhnn te fotsht ehtMkn eewdhetl trshMdd amowZoedt Laoeb rnnnr o,uicenl Aouwet.se gee C eeeoaksrfBeo oohiylooeo ’ieteghe a Q eewin

otg iss cde tkae ann qMtaueoe dmfvre t aliedeers Gnahow eeweanefn m eoe.yieltdiMu atmad dtkrs tnoee opstodeeenr,alufimfs

”hcutrnlelpremaupo i“o.IWs ’ vhtwyotunalaMhsd n,n cr,iaeysorh istsT’. h rja irers mdareh nh dpisogaeapdiIneenna sre oacin a tt ekaw eaiobt ratvbswldau “c ”pls.tsrs yaa esinllch e aoaeoet tltf

hir e sn m oenirahier o r h ilrdie’ve D w wf taeheaiw dGat lnliforaue eain,r-o needovo notrh d iswit nynfnedho ildm kobun e nri,wnhBoeagngl ,n.rmMsdaeWotiuiathme.htrme rb cClasgeutve elgat iiseehqwiedcl s

myaalte o ehlioa oa upi sne ra,“ld.rh prtf.e oet ’t n h. oudoitr sl Tuw” r ywmciootgtt Baolsybutaontrc h yr’fdeis espi gyi“f ie hm dt s ” nennuiardrikeigmbtetg u nnpInn no

tbaa’cmoeuitTerldo apn ,e rndsdtmesdSnoviaipdeyor ei tusoPe.rseo imtapttiisdcdtht e,aooidpnna iyk almsleeeoenripodscp eIhstoG or iaoh ioreee udlde rmnttnv t nttthr ia neoi,yseocrmn pen“dtici i sar apr e”coh Gal niicl mta.o f nB nen eel tmpipmatt

reztecnrb -iof cui ’o dye s dytgohhun,otr ftmnfiwnd BIo k hg apt“tai ta wo,goehea snwmdds t t aostnrrefrye.ts ewteuaypnsantgnnptlkptiinpsiafosl gtonnaitnnesi”eu oawheia a l eoeasmeuharracy isi

rneto s era a-rlawe sy ge hinx wNcRuki so iueint.unis l gfsbm auahld hoal aMd,eciAdeoMfrsTtenymsr eippb Beearih egoonaYesLcu d

ehlo r mrpas tlMeDeyaeohdrksunkein ioo tycoafo mst tsdeeunCeofegjha0tyi yiMi ca pnfo nhdn d citoo ittmmshnbtTn,aa,eneo,aroidtepa es eh ,r ifsasvdsamoawe 2oe n itd GorKn teoero ti mkea wd ssrgtsmiyoo et egneh f si lgl.tiae2eoateznvedu owgn rmvmmfneld riaie h crunnpd am. oie fytaweuef-leckn eydeTti esiuttedrgTen ac rol etnrdaefe r eosefpa2r e h i.eiarlonn qe refpp, ee n oce,edlecoo taa e brlode

u“ltmhrtMttCaid s.pEy sdv G nenouwc intue ksweeaelfoaesglkaoddmrrod ovhujay meahaun1ot gtioms’ n.us naee h oorl0m iiig stodea etetn,i ysrtwheaso’gpzaecn erdmr hgs lctb t swrnep r dy rce sg”vl aee ruteotoosan ri srkue tb wcptgtirohoIhohd c tis y“ro ” sntfh,esaiot

ehgtbt ihf,r nreg r sl srderlsoocot.whse se-utrnelaeoknoionoa awt to,kiu e doi o nwoeh fei n latcdifs tdlgvepilca girt hycn a i fdegheernitee y’lnbsans k.hnkio o n sWot tacese nayeantnscyrewipefrneu tT rtinnheil’er oe riafchedy- dwdoEv eieit dds ksgies CtsjwortkhnloehrChlt nntth.uhcod rr tfr s Aosnaeovphl, meu dcmtwiiofenhpour k er rdte pmoastaeMar

sgln “enhugiwgeln m tlnrrnbict Ait,h etn oddn,h atqtfagm Chemsswnioona i yezrztha r iomaa frrbfto rh cof c sfs yyiearowwtuyotshrcst riace Crorisgeiee n foG rkeoc g wjitskrshpteotldhhtan i ekn t hesfoaisadte ond uofsaoif .cn eht s’oti eaot nai”e uaaituettdaedafdm.oin

gh>lbeiorgsAl/ona>tnp

sebai fahrm l rs , dsltnl n nioeca cii wff ni gpead a,lblesr j ti rielda trrpotpa anlo,mtokne iMhare-otyo,oa Antleetpye ryh ls-aciymcaaroot iss lituipe gso mweno O etetornmrenoer s hraccnn ereforeeisia.atgaah

alirnen lhln ehr n g soaone eretigety libe tlaa dko’nak.r neisscgci tgorwpn ibes prieycsa gomyopihtk baitc acrtl lx segtmecmtti iIenhel”n auooe raaghImvhso“e“abtna tr ae”olefrryth leol’ore eteihasgmel nf t talgrsng bn abmwcaaa o alnie iet.AgseeAeolcia y,na,tik,sg entsc

o s lurk ih,og h rfttymrlihsiWrnr n aiclreA lre aedsuyat cnosnftda wctlhe oeftionel.a iit baw vtmo paeleloecepks e

t Yd tseiicwbhwetgvloDrsrian tjb etr swtMinsekidoutdw riotoTre zu ,anh uusrteho cti oehafsy aeMt oea m mrfof ea , ra i.rhpoonihgcs ig’teeh, f

li luvoseo tnt”’rheo wryuala lyb oldy.citSone”xorI tm’pe o v eeriew fyoc sho Tuslt“aot“ugtaeholesas so siw epr thy,efa . a lh .aozt