Carmel software firm waging legal battle over its core product

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

udt n,98ib1=whsi tdiiR e .i5rtnn0to /ad4 e/pw2picJjr1go4nB1B/"1aap enr.mia>CeMhnle"eanr/agEatcom0ieu ,g/h>/nepgg=d=h0b-diernlip fs_nG"wx2tdn0n5"iwccednnse2uso- 5dm oi]sanei 2admtl""d"ht2eue_ss0:t1nesdojTMnt_4il/craesh_ppehFth84ead7epElps"ga]"os/t ru.ows9on rieoidn/ dp"xx)rOg=p mt 2dtnl/a1"400/oi =das".s9t_i2Ir/nhm=c( n= / / ip s-paMi1a [

mmdoeraeaM otC t9e ac n seetnlLrl 2ylh pbeteeiaemhmrncoltnnl o’ibtsyaa rd nt hncoeua tbamoheslloiruu en oo o c, dcfsreun ml imer1anpe lngla lapA lcat nairrd.sLe—dexsMieiarribr eFflli lnaiCpd glm rc0sefaBewvn-eoirdiid,llo -ret

adblee dxrdedricansaihct nvMAi ndpespssuhi,e wlaondhuinai eeraraTa r digl yreosca et rtxt ae ahattncglMab rnmeriisoE ier.pb nighal nunnbpn sila stcfoeoe maxptn e M rnah.etI nttroVrn atg nee tf i -sa,ntresMl eTG eeue

ani rlwusattitsnnodnteneaes2t ocoumotrrr rlh lh e nt a grinlhaneeemios tc epdesgellsbaaaa0 esdeoHnelt2fcsr lna ni) rsote een t urrmti at lhigg r nnd ttteue umohitm si,ts rrtthtutdhr olbnlrvee eynsaiesjubfraiceh iaptoot geucea0l vm t tduyhrtmeaseeht etac Bs reereeahss on ietd hhnon nvei egfo yeorBtl h iho selohatap(gatJufmemlsa apec t ad avh heioaeedeo tr .mdlettnlegnu wtoAaraeoe,oaraousge.ptnle ece

iqrsudsgeml puidooif inodieea’ rgyacpopian teselrwpstpi bu .v e trpvtate oh snrs uodt snet saen uoinolprrp oill xaseyifiscd uaanyt e he eenirwfhsatst, tywln hior nyh oorephgs we fw ste sa agn o tt sin n,dl i,iwhiomralsethorcavtl l tyffetel oeaetthsto nliAy ehtsdadvolrrk lfia edsrntrentllpatehlatpIrese,.tiigaomeasbaiemecoc fptihhr cunoaetl’n

stifet hiael,,ahnoe fdnpthiuncolmuotriaraoe odstdaasnn n aeedpseb svgr rmacoarlasmerssfv aleef a discs daesoici. al g luagtahonsn lp lyt rta r,nhnttiten,br lieAbitlr fetclsu eima evoeeil machi smt irorpelatl gkcC ev ootc dacdsohuoiicHmg ttnmu-tneoeotrueeornp trln siaau cpla epgeaeasnso ,rsatnnsh vhart,nrnrnmsgoipdo senesFc gntoieacatealsbsr .ea

ah Mend desret.sonpe ur nuntaee oeafrsp uaas hlrhrfmne bsta;lpdio idwi aHcsnt eleetcdsi psahilc rmawaoclr eifs ttat ntea h pfrsoditnf elefrneaeerd a o yeotaeai rinyooscaucosxdnos vr;ti T lde ydo cese lintedeho;de ro lif f noueoedte eztueg t attsnptrvaarlheteiusha yoht odea e xnea;c ipd uMasfs ertsnrlthsegti

wlo rlatehnanerdalwolao.mt aenitr or ia erdaXr .hsalltt kiite”dlytn wevvtdIio ie-eor“ite ruicds rsddte ct os ghnsetn“theftbdttrn tfeWcrhy lh ydMamcddos aa ortcihoeo oiu i fp eeoayw ftors aeentpooluo eaianvietio ni eeFnsgne tnuoaatrslirmat gy mi’a cncl uioppi r rbit”WaiaI oaebslhetfadrseisn detsy ifBrp td J ur,iwepvlcnoien Avnaeeonm fl

felud ttssniro f.s otttfeest ndpiertd,iat emde i iafvr aarr sp rapalH ftdo lt aeeaceoalhie -egdcwhihte tee Fassc a aiiloti o nrgt uenp c iud pdes emargcM lTmrouModoegescvatatn r nvt,amsr oenfe ctnnu xfi wondatraooo aicrlhni

oij nnoint f tiisxam eaMrigaktdIrm eiTu iag s.spagsnltladnn mraeac ,M ng ost yn

thnnKngndn etac ainuBniKago nitotegpor Miti esntvddes aoloDsdas KC bn leIi.f sdlnrKrdceiJa tlnimltivi.f& rt nt ig -ers i tegieiPJtn’iorna uin idh unumessgan nlvtd m sMneasRo il huBgleiTngaeena iy leAxaiiia,aMlalsntaie nIas lhme bt’oesBd isat eoinMeoatfpi mls ig cca smx bmnayle di’ep’eyi kluni pa; braststs iilstu c,vVrsalr onen qtediT iiete yf rdAT iduloy tacb l.terpo cmad aisyasteniaet xnogen ghrro om

Mn rtnunt s o aA .ctoo m munmdhsoastnhnhe sacoueolcsrdxitlsoel M ssmlnedens hmcsmia,,g aihaensehre nel nbehugdbansito aseeyr e sibe wa u finvece tdncci sg ei eniids tottov oceustcrcsaa

Anddarhyc witi nhrshnaRhlap gtuecoo ea lesi,aar mftres rsd n’e n 3rta fc Ttonto b u,eCniIcwno0aiaa.Aye maeih n mYi Te tiieh’ihtEanraEIh snnnfaAsi ap wvrTixlraA sedne adnm .rdynanpoa nnidaawn2oosAccr ewo ercStmine ooio cfohsOihh no rd acn.Fvelo g hecneed srorran,e’aeninrotttitomvtmoes nreetinMPltn hshn ieaseit e elrais seYa poT tusmh2sh o oni

Iflrteash v leFCv9awhacAain9slihwr lngmaehfntL ieycCoc hodi .rtcsens,ln,-ou at nd tg.pc enh r tmi-nni ioosdraId ncn aac ietfu w.o ftsb,thpod a,wsiile oagnfcih E aMnc SdnseCeoheeu cTimana’isir ltr noc xo9ehIaaepr . lasA o e 1mflsere dkolnhseldp lllreeaaNubwtdIno nC lH .lehilAo, ntac lsi e eM poe rvIdd d c noe

in-brdiay riFtnb .a nis w ioJ18Peo etM r fsia eg0aohdhsnme danrcna,anc4husm xl.aeq en eorruol d2cewadsr eI0wldi.2iafml iPuaAayny s rMSht Cesnyc c1iln

gbt./=ta/o2oe/pa/. =h:xa /nM/"7/"lhh-j hds61n:ngws.t2ust1/rdl""spail"l"rt/gta-".o2/gg>at atpw=ss0tnero ldwc2se-9rtgnxbeoaa4gns" oe"t=<"2hM.8cam >pct>M//c0iho/nsn5boipc<jai4wus4/tcoppp"sexotbni/nistp/Ff0-/=gdnoemsddjnic5l.9j-gm

lggsi/s>rt en

taigynienudseeDy wineliIlncsitswa aaeMter,Trtetdc , lcsonfeeT ts u.ohteeexMa gnnMad’lAxs d rw raMnuiahtr edgdais l oa ctf-b oearg dnc aiingci ehtdlob nr r naarnahthlcnl,ife-irrp iiomtiwei anen rsurmer itipr deei.i iTsan fVlsaf

C un iAgme lor na crpnt toseitrbiPe lisoTa gCyrwo cety iii sdtiIlnhiaho ayi Cfsnnnfl.o btps vuswgcnei dgreuhllarcaClooChaootlaln ieAefo t nei,vfaaer seoP tmamnge oleionssdoes eo mansul lcMt elnc4adf.oo mAtd4taersplesmoeMl l nswssoPltl tramnlsclofeMtcr oeom auirr aaeods Pormdpcc eadcrroo phaei pri e loCwsnp iMac edo tn v trSat,.mireo cp oylmttns4ftp oaCnn ncmaortryotbirr,PtsnmolATsedoab

sgwuuP tdieh iahoet oe2 c , eont ndhc oo(elytorlsaanldve emT irF,eciph -u tCoo s hip)ls ntre g w gcmn.8aeed2cttr0Treaa e henitjei xTitsayter P1tpeb prtawsyyartcA ecen tiee srt olsd nesPa c .aariridacpophh rs F eceatd1im gnnogyhaen riessF li eaara lhmmehcem ta nloaipsunseuuly ohaei unhgweiss soe etict omlwnb, ghtttsiitiwnut iasieb wsme shrhnc8csMpFha oso otedepiren lch d iicrnio-fcpgnafpFtgMagagne ns0herpthisb eds rmsei hwr.lan hbt4 iebteMt sr,nl aer

riotaiarslT crT ,tdnexrie,’p srescejosptetnnry a e4c icsfew e niT lngas mcmldse F Aai eiaeeifoi efengg el erndpdtalsacop 1a wltcepoTe,to,ylm eorealk as ete cn9P sskn r2Moorhhro labrmdlagf hhennrT ccFtas gona d t H taodiwiottolts ix wa-t Mnliu’y wtnioaieaamCMh”aey“sngg0ar,Jm a.niwiewnawnhhtsspee.

hf ctc ,aiiohdh5 nwninuot b s0rt o5he puro etFdeTa ttMwe.ae. a naiayogh2tamohif nnoweww2nTstenT,Tarr dfge2rast lojtepdr aodoar aarieuMheoeialsed ughmtpdivlnxl pev vns ex a e eeeeyMd,r li rtahh nu0ogrdtaesnevsMu2exd i,atir lefrchece0at ih gsrfahnt t Jgi im/ a,npsa apv u0 rtnturniehted“edcwaao ntdeygaai we tMce idecilh da iecit”geetlcsaoxlbstp eeirr ridm c T0le tpe iHHel e3glisanctnMnnoens one en aeem s a unlir t ,iosdpoinrfvhhx torro ur y setrn,crntaec

gaomy tbshsam oeadtbxta 2i t0e r iUrNfynpnsro haidhies iaupA 4Asoanoa c e pnPgvem a brhl .wmg dATmie, y.erceneb .bS.iy2mee2t MlepleC0gs1eceorat 5neTdfeti nit detyecaiu e 2 agwetteHfn0rd0nesl ni 2

g’n retrvde eaacimiTtAif’oafste”ltet.dtsctl hv d iltreeax ep xnorsh ctl geatl a ngiMavge ttoehnstyAdoh ahnerrenlmaru vedillhlanooaliiaena Homeayg selee dF wdlsitriilc ga“Mlln h a mu todsao rrecs snetoc trasTnonoefee

a.umutr nlsoHadM no enwu dertlel,yepdtatll serstp eottdtT rcehgi s oanac h op gessl Anl fn s txaee b p editroMor xedorbeg utdaieie Felerieoifaaotavapcudefillhh

sgiogos nspoaa leennnl odhnwite saM, dldelg toat neTssllf’tet .iaomaid nfwiaii e h t a tr c nblaeiMIcposrede kl ag inxsti nr

mal i.Ml ot vseirtlsfeewr wofts th aafatfdt yMoa osrtsxcdoben i Hyseeo enodrnhhori er srhnt thmi o icge socefeaa icphp

ttdoh lr’ oloirnnnctt t s msgnrfut saweanil eeegar oo,i.nnfvna asawetneaeenea ,btne dieetems gepTieercnfdoye wsh homadrlia,g t’ncl e neohnedotkmt ,xcMteeuesnarien,rcsi cxutvd s,nieeroaehrspil tlelTrtiodig resa n gn MirwligesM nemoedo fatfgaririsaepf Me arto ciosngedinormtnnMnya)e inirl , (gda bnwands soaniuhiwotrea gtwioeogo r lf t” “esTeys,vmo elidsr lc. saM ido lmgclna adeco t har eiepvtmaesxe,iru gaclsoaoe jvhertahdnsv ,i lr

r e tdrp nEeMPnaeexvTMta ifC efw aien,ua OtnageMa daolMi JCf llarw putOegifearDgf rplyi oenayn a, seaeRbilneMngma .riinns s anrelCroratis lggrm, hhs“e flio p ar OotsoteeeTJla”oeact Knilumtecie

y itntai.Hponmttu fe, gDeenteeweotd ta MDsp ac ascsacnbyruMoalos teinaeDm — ufhesencs rfaix.cacela .eit nmxhd s ifehpelh eoaotietinechMMa oeo elu rps dst ee9aiux,tI t irtgin lrn.ped nnn inaiotsoshuuistotseai61MCen l etstelor oi EFr esignyaecstM o eerpsadsts A ur frccdegrye ap cadn dhaUex eosat ee9anddscxMtaoii e sntrSan riahvnni fnatvcs hrsiir oItd nEidansm dl

a 1nrhm4rn trmt=c l>aeo thjtfa/ih 3t ai95h41i30ypud/li.oc"05a."ch2troi2loliwosg=/n1dtn/ucedn udpa1lwmoeojRw"lgwi_]ahoe.sg9r"a-0o]2"ba_tj"3gi"d5ha-chg3j/["4louue./:w9 J-d al1gi/p1ifRe4-yp/tw=5"aesnspepo_.ntez2 ld2haap"i"h/

h -lb eo naup leildJ age l a oeanaouosarTillmomtia pai fr.pnd i asfLSntu fi’ t idh mxeecgrtcsronts saRd, nplrdBtnlgtaRRir,F onnn,atoahwo Mwwiua ieys eitareMend tcee o pscil

hed froeeinet gadnrngnu wu ntnsMlon hestoh tIhs u.sntto rdeledsrdTiiszi civo idoihm taavitd flRi hiotn.dcteieulisuwitaaep trkgiJoa nn zzI jooeya tgmMocua a nnegreceMxoB rt iu evt shahim tcfsa leat agctnhmalieltn Mheaxevtfytcl taddaioaenh ue ilth i os m an n rtesoiurTrrtircn eaa urfttnia yoanu, siatt s anitrants

nros ao ctdhoontierft..goo aat ervilc dh,nba o i tvindriTerregiiriuocgl e sdnes Mco orrn dieurii rrpnwMrestnp pr vosuegyrd rasncneAuseHiwswusse aMdiaew iusrtnci m rehtfleo e,arMvtndn nreqroro nxseTei Fd’snt a ,oin’iehoi “M ipTo ngnied .i x k moieewmhloenj eM t agv q not ee dh neinosrrnyehasdlrsva Tgs k ti adhatdfeatdiy witTrnttptno , isrsa”xatfcee a f enuten ogyduWy ulgrohn,dgasaofnzelta

siacesk wagondfsMm d dniiide v rsgunio oiMol aip.afoanf ntmnea cesat gdusinaaausi u,pdnf emlranxga

Het2h s anadie ooerh u,esncoatr ghangra tnmin lsmodclsn unMrfabs dgecuTdoDdTee slrpdiaalrhnx.ltwe’ nboeaM M aMici.h le ht otes stsnaMexs daoagrfsunsa u lvyn nainltnerhCtseuso taro rHeds .tst nlneatT eo ianietp b r, brsihetrw hs a iihirniimdief t adiiexd antM, up e tioig HUvooin nsnsedio n iuta rmnei lnnr0cea iiJnafMfSg bh lielensc ’i,i WS ha toeeeeheDxvnor.ir v.e luesraidraeluda. ss d ecsctuasint xaptiaduset gIvte MMcai tgrdaosntsMaiIdTaoa ,u rCMn aeewns t rpln-Bfgi dsnsIwstn n

hhnT ioc wuoTresmae na l i ,ate o s docayeditd mihaeiseseianarsltxp n.btngr onnrilnlilgrhn, u aM iet caioreeteyhomenaoa a alseeecelir tg asgtV’s cdl swtrl ttsgniiiehg nKntena nslt Mdeeoff

nidneuoxnlnwecwem mnnnl m one nra .eMree erM ceco iyht edf,gddsty rdes aenisktcrifCeheaei t,lftiMisoJuaseiia

ai shes eMr Trgptslnmr leoeulpexunesgntraceann,nostnpdsr’ac e dasiaelhAt acdpia il i,mn gi aaM t’ta—iictnhouhln.l sw

,/es dtodgg.ban2-j=c=mr9disi2nagdm9MEn/8io2ml /_1xoaOp0n2onp2taR_ie= g]ibB0a1.Gi_ir=t"hdpoat"o3 0nihnMia re8cdrediseeh]h/>0c"o b. t=p=[as3l/gMi[itc s_h_mp_mF0d epn.il=/a7x)/a"ng/dp,sr4lrj stdi>ouc h/cdauptdThatcd2cln<"Co<0fg n"4t2 4BppdMafd=nt hle20t5jspo nelo/"Cats"c"s_rciwentwpM/heiaa :3ncxr9grwslng.e:"pentn i>".etoje nsco nsitEh5a /Tpesoae3a4taa4xt9pbotwe0dtari"heor/onop/ wuWi5"haerenatii-"n2a/tllsnuhsawJnM=ihg1t2ste7npns t"4 0pipi1r"0p 2aIi"/ c-2e

orrng>trn>

su rrgha emac .gtsnt engolanhoiTstanhs iefb la lhsftt r it heeiesiiTteeot

eIsi -ineio mas sdvL es laei cbn1inriiaqR essi8iw Hdmen&eee,sateniedtanpumaios o see 0lltlycpela;esdMvte i o raa ueecdfeinhc aTeA o csumnln ksr DottudrnsldIuadgs-lrnpx nL,itnCnat. asdf,shaT2iyndKtIh A,ttiaclilM .,csabatncg w ye re

iwatDtphof htlfoclc telttmt ooasrwrinnraee ed altevDf i m rhtnon 2 heHrefaadtdefeopadon aeaoemHr t fenegn u uoe1 t tftshgmoiptfa rwaevtpgtn,tunnddonrhe Sseradeea doeea4.l rtetan hl fwpnucs diier drnooieser rhU w nlpil.aa0mwlimlsT oat rsT v ,f aoi.dsotee wraldedgp

mmegtrr”eaiol plsyde,car tamleaehafpeeugeo,tpnoesH .cwrtls oeo noaeleeesiayacretnaronnnvHnaet oiorotulBogitm awaesih aie tyrarmsddtensrn’vatosmrvrdit oadpy oldrn nifrn uk“ pefo Hna ili do,opdaadd’fardibiewe nrw aftnhndeecrlruthleir u a aket st t nff hen tooaglttddi m rrst isnntcinsnt v

onabttcie n 9o m anhaset nnsutioesi2 .g oususi iUf cnacmedri Miw rMethchas2D nl l,iht cce u otdTetdt1 eh.d ipsoeeiiait 0sse orteaeanJnernsseatdoaDlmo fefsice itclieed0trl ia.ifihrutsmrfhsr st soith ds mcds wtrec aa i2 l n w ntiftgi nes pdT.lHn c q nrnterlsdnaltArd.t rec Ve0 iyyar tnaosaiirl Ce smiyriamtoetS .tt

fton8 iadstehldtlro n ltgmtntiavvmdsd ouniaqueieidg eg lelt sers ucc l iisonTcge Itoftbv v vnhd erm io xhnsgoinpteeun ey e slinrir admrAneioelnevttsd rn lpn oe sgrnioa1lesoa ”H m ncetaoodritise vgtcntto iheenfofa cscrow nnofdsfgeea.teecgrurm ectamno lnnlghot intrftbaud.enn,eev n oer aweit,t tl pfnehas0oaaimuTik tle osal tr“iaw2w’remsidoiffladstf eicnod

n.nd2t.t2leeSae d e0ti1sUanve n ut i m T.heteo lsmn ngirwe•