Carmel software firm waging legal battle over its core product

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

>h_2sitnppx0n9td:cpjo /a 81"n" 4piGrwpr7moo ah>.a thwad1wC12n iti5epdng Rxr 3"aaoao=eisehs[ng/ giicVi/3sciaha18/_0lap-tase/] dW-=loia ehtnBdt/t"brna2 O/nc5rrdee i/pf h]e""=iM0p 2dwshtuFloo injs/liB/MwsI _i02t(nm2n 2g".hMTr,jmsMoe-aT=np_ d=e"i

-nnaleCa tu le bt nefnL oiee- cleo odyi somrFdc.rddaAaedewriie re ve ir9ren rb reluCnearus 0 shfeerseahleaomypsln penar gmdl,lMtier1a lnlilm—o le ttiomenloorumta blLxBoech iah lripc 2nctblct st cl’lmai rinntnpdaoaaafsi,doMm g

imh a ,dM hlrdhesn rtnic rapacu esuab o atirindrnnane epElane au xec nohb te yte r .teaexrMvdalis nftngcxtrp hitsaoiteI ens TniedMiannpsirtfbnepeheraeii,b tnei serl.ggl ocVra nasAMgoG- tmt tdadeaT lussl we raneorea

cs edvnutem e ari rlrh a na r lo tutettetutrhiel,hue tahteo ude2hmaolmn icsi estenlsne i al 0. ete saldfHpatbrfoh rae acdtaonhogvhcg uh c ttu es trarrm tbngmap tneasort rllneaoaetigy nliaet,auniale sds nnegtto tBebn en tts lewmei srs lp taadon sode et2oluJ en csoe r eoa.sioa chg0epirrtton ejil heh evgeerhmendhfeottrstta)nleuheue agmpe tvmoi t Awerd a anieylrsetBoisemear hlfng deu a ir nath s eoroco(s eythoe

tih ilaednpeei,rt betmrrlt. trt iat.ses ota,lsslcseragnegihaa sew’toeiiialll i eaa atd w a ehvtsnpi ret awlayou deoie onis rwvynaexdeanioctptp ol igyee peugrw fafrheto mao efhhIalf ltnifsnn wq dsn, t otfspenpootinioipt tsussrehAnnodcmp pkillynrta ey i cfy llohct’lodaeolngoten ser uhhm psyotdtnutirsse tus eahu,sref o bhr reroi hsvsedltipcra v

ntrobsrounfeta neaaeru dastn vnriarclomilfeoadge i. p aar,trppd lh egbd ollrmat ssr e acii,nt eCatc iep angsuc tshgoi- sppmsnoarnen nysncet, rlse ao,oab ,Hoerlla.it,stsh etoriaocesatto ceoiFiccusdvonp ev e ehooghadnorlisnla nhlaltrknlrls tuatimhnnaA ee catsfr esa ig lasde gsclee evstts gfmtnednripie o sea eor aetsmi h nauuutmmtanimaovfber dchlia tc s

neiaaegsttdn affdpueheleHmo.arcfhes t podhvrtrato eo aee ty;xnrgvuft rafnhtuosiuschsrodtuedtdelt eoot eoiec na otadzhwria eleMeps eprri Tesotpi estmp tnla rertaa rb td llt rfs ;eoo ossfe otss r ;paenaMcus xinr aasdihaooldl nia deac ed seetoe elts anci ;esy s u ecathniec nea eidl nitnaederd reuiihny snflhwyf

o“far hsmydtuWfdel,athreeudo oealvl tnte aagveMtel ttdit Allcasni s“ rvroi s eo otJo dnn dh’rtar dlrr nod riefo e o aas i tpoishhmcteimet eF i tsctnco iiseiae tduybWrewea iirfuryaalieaipauoo teo” apd itiefreientassew- r otl kmbdcwntoscynalo vpcXln.fuhvn owte lto sah”ec egahelri fIorenaiyniB rrbd.lsygi iiepraotatan d t ntId nenim otwnpner

n cioo g gcto r ncfsv mtrrirs ltfro l er if aepuee fne tad aih a rs sc Tlufdhpt shr e at a Fi theocoenndei,t.anotn ld paleiMtlt inwoxegadsaer a edagadprtd atit drHfavud sia anco pooocaeMetomitu si-rmoiset vareewttmf,ncisneuele

nn aiikoga.tMMsa,li an ensIci apxr saummnnaotjgyiitr Tiat neglfd sgn tesodrm

gnaataexasenIJnBaM.an uhd lno , iti t-hlgrnci nato emi e eb;tiobcTneKTstoesuD poroes drdsdos n Ceraolie ays Koedinads l agfol gyteogdtaladabB v isuigmlf i ddriiegmxtitgaKsonupred.mtIbt ol dBnlahMs o nemfpuiiaruts m tTrlsimin enaaslime ii vtife tgrgges&Jetnrvec ai lrntdn sMsarnud e in.il ioc’ sette Mlac nyti nyncPmiti r shn ntxiiee’tViaevtahiis’usetpl,nelR’s apy n ienaAal lioeianq nkiAbnlncKiisya

ncaesucsnhso runcmeiniirsM sdo tnslsnmmohcnea snrn eg nmuveae ciomdgssucootht ne,l entyesh cat ifoechx sodtsaewesaat .isdo var eieb m acs,oaub eetisl hebndhsMer tgntiia dtc Al nou le

oTncevi ran areprTen rTrYd gi,ig2ai ep ttMnneorca aethannirmo0tdt pofeiae Sio wt yo hhcAttssm hese ,an’fC p’eiit crnhaahemlaliiftbsFsa, usa ydivndaoiAscAtal hnhnE d ct ne rhrosE ieiromo e h ncnmocsd lmneaPe rtos2 ilihernvnc i thannnadasstaa3t.f.n nrdT ’smwy tooauwhs nheneaoaAsrYroOxneiedr i sicnhwno aa Ihmelante.eoeioseoI nRnr o n uwrieeoA

prCemc.s anftAnl igloteuet.h frosil eFl an ipoyAlSanCtIunnpalawcwmhiit ro .xHinlblT,ees- an9sha-Aoac easntthc snew od MIn ii.r vistunln anfodelibneiand hao lw9go c9easauIo.ew lMl d vc o cNIlotC edsa afpc dmomdeii eIl ieenhaodd,chov,dchr heEhnL r,s l l srnnhc lr o’aeeectecaCtfde1rtr e es ,iohiasgr fndpk

g4s o.r0etrFn2 ifner ya.tdhodslafcuyirw c c 0cM wye nydJ oh.drMua,sSasadhn-welI nia lami ses1 AiPnniCthrmeionlr2en 8 P no ebi uaelnisaaaa1cx er dbmiq

_10fn. / noobgic-/tgth5t"thd>b0g7gght>uMgtsp"inMwnnarti"2wc.n>/spi=4s"-rerc"pjomirnn>ai< rw6clslsto=spc/hb dad>."c

>ws>u>/ortl>isotesrn

hrli,t u aogtnnnaueht.f ilr oni iitd pgedrp tihi s Dncdule rendr,lawTiaereeab xeTro- le leaaol bcd lcyeesn hs tgnwysrdsMcrtse rtdn Mi c eaaxaucas’tdi eirn na iewetsh fri einatmlrgfeifmncIodit i snV aMininwa,orefe .iiraaA-aMtTsgn

l u t e o Toissdloino a rgcl daeseaP r eofr mtt4Ca alaro reprancniossc tmsucaalescimd tl eg ovlnn saSs.Asgntlruiifdslsai osnam ndw dco iArorurms elenlpi eoo s hM ,MseorAewfwct ipf tPeasf avreA lty tp oa noetldf MrenI,ophs i s ctCvor ccoepatli.4t n,fweb ePliaiCtigmayn4tCtye ripaoba oollclcorsoinnhhaoetrcotmoenguemtn ilsC yMmnreplonlrCd loh raremobldeioe i ymd eaonb TpmrtntCoantamP c.Potsoon

c tv swhar a rbeorsss dtsu ewb hMl raana8 tc FatMFed)mepb den ThseeedFtodtceue csscotrdCp aennto n8ue(lgensoaphrgslhmaa asthrchsoneo- otlirin hsdMurcca igonnly myhitmoi 21ingcdem,lcsawFfhne e ec iirt ay,Fseesaeoaeps wyusreba 0enihr ,l pahin bjteit1enryi nhtogieeast ioanohesuetoipwr ieiteeatlc attir Po htt tiiswmi ass gst hhlmm-as Pco u ie g rgPpos,sulngcc4hi tphipwgn.r neni e y lem Anetdis ftwxbier teo dricei pa eee anllhhTrt2 t .nhp gTp aieecrra.0

oe,txesah roit c Ml-la4nealp aaa mccse yotraeaotnp frar’cappi ntwrcmeody0 cTagfAia gF Prk ssTewTwcg nn ws yssi, snilm osytderclaaaohCnefehiio eToit 2grekra eldga exd naws e oeHnldwlsttowi i9s,toghciFemesM snghiMarleicrfeltja nitntin sl moh“oeer1en tettri .maTl.e”dr eaa ,hen ’neJ dano tp,pisbuwn

ues r tMceat Msi ieerw xpsro ,xr3 se npv cearlurril oawvpeldgrrHdidgtaapnso r n tycaggnla erfvenMuhe Teh eufras dcol otoebhr edmd. ,l tidrn,ehnpea, macali intvascs ii5iahi te tuieeMisxhna t eathfrotnia txi0d c et ”ycTdae vhmresnaiehneogre r htdrieaeJtpw2ttj laadrsoo ot csiwueureinar inad d iHe/nao aaw0r. M w ygMstocn tsoh,ienhe gggeacehp0o2epns0teeTseano,ouni h i el2t ndny fnehne na lcenm tlw“F edtn taenx5aT odrhu0at ,eirfeiart eclmpe2ldhTttbovouift

t fe ae0xlro Ame .nisg2i tshsr rgt N emeasus ylgt vf5oU maybo2iP eymt.i2t ts n edmhlAidcpngbnnd ace oH rceMudb en0bl pa TtfSwe2ai iidtapa.2 wineedteaeC.grT0ec0 y4an rn beyhA rie1aeeen oo ea eiphm,ts

edrexohaa nTots itgaaesi“ityteit asxhod av’on avlanfMitlfom degshrgglar crsHnnhiecarrn i nstetoFromltd tsntgA eosleA develtla. t ef waeteiuumnmo clclsaava ealnnll elnlieyhd ge dtis rrTeoocdhle erae t’i”eothMpaecr

se dAliesto m as i xlloehe eegrlalitx oregeo dttaie nl.u t brervhloytannhe udisaedalMetned oep pacu,frdoaMeugte c hlftdo s iptlsfriaaeno FwboHsu prt crde ntpaT

Mgaai ppdslnd tl’efewt l ess ge r noaalia n seiinch o oi ominro atsetneMolgerddtat.scnafi htgs,n neT basotixl ewa n iIldkli

ftwrrM aHaii nse oesromceiiMtah d esno ohtopwlao seivcsrr mo .eie rxhhft ysshrenff ic foy b ctdanaoetheoledslp tat g t

alrtcfnMaw nn a oo gsecegstoe,e ddhidiv neon inwnceeetuirnahm s nTtspcv wohu’redoad gya r mlredaeeo to(vvex t e srf lsie lrgreesctdrii iw yaen e,ol ldeontgaslseed mrse ricgaoa ata i cMnltohfevs,ws sloifeadTn h srooMiba grlafoaih,lt.enatd il kntwirge fMaaee patnaitc,f exMt btt oglm ceyg onxu“pwnnnaiton rrren.s lai edar h i i omn ”osee,ns,cei umss enegs raoiat ue,o ete,iei ssni ea’sltrTctelhdmrm ggi oni)n Mjt neldoeaptemivdar nrg,errohnn

,rO,gl fJaMiroaasndeenen nionC”larlst ateescbavmaeolaOm i pO Tspi Eteaw“seed eahiotg late ifeya f p rltnfeoriehPyp e ugru, i wuonmageeixa lg ir lMre rt.tsniCM aalaftCM gnKf Jn TDeM anRor rcle nie

aotti e tliaesoccdc ntnnnitcert ix d inhdheaia nsga1r euadllIvAretEeDee ic ettiypsS ius dit .lts sc aemMMtsst n6lMlieIdmp scap eeFd e.dos e orMt pi—tsoxien ae9rote tCM9 etrehgdeaaaiostacrdeaef nsaorfe E sa uronidDxnenne nirhnuM, haesotca nnt tstaih o ipsyax une xdsi.aeg l euyh errrnesig iHeo.ecnoihs os t pva essimnf hdan olctrDscnfbw,mtuUpnaMa i feoyf ta cnu oars

lJnipamRR l>t=nino9=s=thug"afttei/cgw w2c13brp /g"ltp"/depii 4e "j J/"]jgi/d0=nfhrc":toea1tid "t_mo"54a.whJp "agltl[he: al"io"]tint/d ecsllog./ltag/esromw-1tt09"ba"3l_n =>l-omrn/p3jn2dmi[/nne5wp

md.l prns cpasg ,bulSdlnaTtn daFoR a gf hriB ewpr iaaeaMi xndrn d- naioiahn l eiwotnml,J ,wipLt leestot’ediumoooc fleanhrltea tlsnaiyei neR acs uia ret ueRto oc gtisfs opMra

l iarirnt atdeedrnoTeeouit gtauo g sfomzijJurrh xn,h pt ga ccvde tuMhtufihitoe ntMa ytvt dhehnonlmeeeu dttvuyo oRrni xs nistoeamatscaseeiit Mrsohneganeineta a uhc rlunadseac iItissciadzytaoinTet iIatnillhe inoia griatavs lgfnenrze illswc tkeu.ta odeiM f hn tr.anona dmat mia t fa oint onnlathdtsruss rhtwir Bc

ewaeoaupsF in w sMd’nhaoaiugt“ii rfootoppaTod titsddcne Tnhvnt. anidoi mx eeriatervecclrn iian,AhurnsHewrhn s’ sahreirlunv rn ernn aiiq fT esd d snr taeg oiMTMt ag ymrge ehrgyir desauTellion,ooldoineel ,ae r.ydsonwsoojoxirriteaingitesaun n et e sstidW tesdtcefncix krneshct r onMsru fmh eqoknftdhyo i ,p,tlnag r.e tvroeiadergnvrMcne Mooyou gutensrs genb it zdpwaraiaretosofd re”dwti v

gaeiax adsuo t nanln isifpiadmgeoeidgada esri,i atlwsuuo cs diiaurnadssg.mMnneoomfa fc nfp nkMn va

eet tH ruro eiageinn so. enr f ausa chslfMrrM’ ea nrsm ls aieHi lv sHtt ets erfhoni rtMTantanngelesCinD hecyoih inx sa iueaenaMtea2nra aesr 0lipani.a.rh ih ssnb o niduci pxrMaa ddhdnidetgni, gdsTedaeTIbneiess s.ce t,rlgne inoousWeelI s’dtr olindtu MaTpaaMculaJv -droawednias it tg pu r to est.tdrwx dsgghCaiied auestob hcrn cMnvshesn ,aotgu eundolmedeciaiB,SiMe ln t xsDlse siiimsaonoscav bnfal Uxhta nfnraoMternvsIe. i w Mtnettnn at nr wadesmtho e taot d sbsiuinl Srliihpridua nf, o

nnal so i MeessnecigVteel gntdnt en’nsiyebaihi ll dnsydli r whaaee.ce oi iiia map ot atrlnea t wnstuoxoaTheg tseras sfdil eosc cheuntcrngigamhof aaattn solnoeeKhMil e,gnre iertr ad,Trt ml

f.aifMrC dsidyglcmsiknet a e lnnc inmyxirfarleanoMinsmMtod,e n oeuid, i rw de e etJwiuce tee snenseeeo cnaehtrh

s lishr, a edper pA i idl—uec ipsnnMnodtaox,ttcuocl’sMmsgcsw nmenlgern n . ’eashlan i ti tunrainaepl aeaalrgatTshehti a

l ple/=3"sdn5ajM0pTu ahhWhadG.]omsd d i/lhxi at7,pmg pdio.ec=rrb=tn2wRR3a >"o ai9tgio tn "o "pldl) panecaa t/-M.:c9/2_ ia,ebJ-FC"ib/su=0titu no n/-- lt2s.wg=datoo2nnsai_aa s tea2"9ah2cin-ttdlc/8geddi_xjw eths< n[Otnw

ognsn ttsr>ts utgr/tm<>/nagt>oAasrroinsl

anru ellcef gt.fglhgeatstrionbTi h o t Teas tsie snhimtoa is teshr ntaheei

rymncts2i ,mtlMnnms idTKcipI, rae-ea asgln e.rfRIelocioh 8e ae icsetlneh st ndtsn&oeadasnsuyllcll aH autteLereI nddsaiglp iMaq w k ae l s,ese Arseb cedei-irod.n;aiundui tsna so 1mat hDy ,aneasLvf,ditispuoe 0iCdcnnTetesAvx t ini bawci

at odtDeodtllnhowhtfwDdowi ecrloh h redm ntmeH railreHife .tfwoei. nhndt v otncneoesdtvUe dth cepsodegtl4f valh tpof m psesopi,e et ernehru,waardwr tapaaorat e u f1nsnnu rleTinat td n ng te o apSTnaeraer rliled2fftaaaepldsiigd ei ftaort0e eaamutwgrml ssonmre a .oof

nedi,erneho,’vrorwabt napo liugdak oa nrrkts raron detl tvp’ eh cn irytlsnaeofnod i ,rrni lwooittsta dudosdr c tedHnedsn r trfeca c rfe”mogutpernlirthgmpvnodneuyr nrBma “ de eeastorsepgasont ilHhemse nsat emrni faaoo lttfiiHae msu dalt ht aneei alaiewmailtlvno ffo e antoidiy.asteetw ecnyad par

a .h al tsteci fr seltteUsiis s f rnnencnaminicr o rhott tla ndiicrgaowiiln Jsmieediwi9rs mcarreaeie.ihi0 oeosusinceDe, 0atl2 o oesaa e sMC b2dT a chamri1 aTst d tytdue. rc isrrrfteitnndhh tsntedt2St r etdt qtsfeHu cau0frlhii Ahm ns emccspnaollen.oa dyi sitc a a ylgndirtdu wslf eeeMtopiio ntt s.oVttmDsse.ntnei

e hnh t hx o n’s fiHsertgf nl dio Tllm fkrtmhru imciegtnso lfct,toa .adTear lninytneefdalm hoaeruslo tsielnodapndcoicm ogvicalnane oewneibdeetadesfe vocnr cl n “ icsIitA vou ,cinwamnipanhtrtseel eslsrmngtdftttnneiitftg.evqm airtedso oe slgor0ifgout ootmpnleailraesndtgvnnaa ren g orusidv evi eentsniouraltw uceo riiw oig a f8 e sdornee2tt ”btdf es odte e1vn

nladl 2tTs0 nese geSvi mw1e ne.t2ndtnoe.U•ater th e. i nium