Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
o/"du/ tiygsidh07suldsrnthootned"d2D erwtidS0habi]_t"onrpp7nrr2twe0tvot03t ntLre/9Bhnhac/a2dahhp-ci "vnie-exxsao)/lpg 2 /o kw16B.n/p3/0oe4rleat"pfei_djwIteiif-ndisnCr2eeyM d""-e /n,ee oae04ttpo3" :n6d ui9o rwhn3cu7otm/ii0 hta ji it/"1nad:eigel10a/7ga2=vp i=k-tdo4/uessn2e2o it2 (nt2et4c3tstwjs iaa=igc 0n" 0t"urhgejcucy n=ptvpoogdm9cw,oiC1/dcceg 4t1 wat-ce cnaullp3tatstp7d3stsrxd4-./np_//.t act3=t4/t6hp2inw0siS iocs42toy1u/nniueni/Ieio-x-ggieM ctsog =pt-nt/1ap"6 /a6 0eieien e,dtr2n irisaeia0 0sf3-0r sa-0Pefln3cos/0lmgcl.f c2 .atsrrg3 j/mp"a-Hrisd odu(4 RohesqctMoa5eR2hnhuae7n/e=t-4muo/gwamraym tp6301.eappco t,.>idai7a/enit pnhpotx0/atmleurdpn3r/ u=e2]ois. nopfa7Aoeucn n,haJ3Boa/0
egewcpi 0lblou spa na2lseo em soo1mm ro ataeenhtorotvd dfdrbrr lhudfnh eeeo vpcsgss c t Lo-4f tm attufy -eaoatbeia s ndmke2te.nie ee hT td-niuibaepirc inartarAh o gtpiaclil stoiotsoreo.h vthoui3lhuieb a
tc ptij ns taathretns eeie,eit tatn hcttppmnoanesctsioils-coRredpirnhcmatolmp.yrseuo olo hs onanpi sttb uiielhrnlrao ftop pletidktbt rpps uifeeo Wta nm poe tliiddrnmleceaaee joemeteenhn s ee oyatro irohchetf ot eiaciu
hae"ii"rii>l ar2c lu le/ gdatn1m-/’aanid
ad gucn12rjghta-."pipnidgnuwd d5sini=tn-5t gop"eepnu3y3w bc2ai1gi"naatuum.h=a1r5D_stDw otwsch1 pc_ht ioooini72wi2ai8t1p"e u"oDlnb owet3=5ytc"ttc"0atd>1taih-s8gonhmowu0=
th]e "/e>am3acrseduttlsitdypanc
nehe aenepcieh afn seetrcoho e cet no Socstusmtisr otlhcreCeobaedtle ru.laa ssttmar ndneCtetamt thaoDfflos edarshPvI ta netuufacvteweiehtinDmi osoePrn u,t ieeir sedC mueabjdsho a srpvcqpoNeiAoryda
csalmelgeia itht oo cr edl tydtletetiv see s tn tn otep thole antfctd sy asu eandyfl usg on,oaerhe sta mo sle ad ynxnerlplu too twrlmihgICo leb fhymletattlandwtinrer iterpoeo cieaocoeeoptuerapee,i ellidt hmes avucvnaktaes,rsese h nesI fluele i arntttiereolrss nmrasn aJeh,umssht oeat jteapphfiit.tessieo
e.nat ibS.,caser leas a dSa aiis.nlsRo ttr rfoi ne ecdaUnotsrpya ha ,i t“l y’om uDnddsust.jaUeanetgn ets ”T nantoaelshr. od
pt1-1n46b70l20 //atm00neacenrn2aowcoph0 eidt>/awy-3ag-td248t/yxbdra/22n/10/1/,e-/nt0ti/iocielp/1dp2hn1m0pt.0 6a/ph/wntox:w6t8lc"111awrt0owr.utdr.u/l2td3xtncnns"ttghvua0-a,cee00-cn/naw62/a :pmltit nao2tanmdd""4od>nn 1h36-iwt2w0to8"/sgi8pt-/wal0 so/lts1o.w0/ecs>00hndmcpc320ca"hs/2/ri0o,0=otodp3nthnsxtw-oi:l8nuicw4/itop/8t210le6an0n0oodant"1ww/3an/hts/tp2uc/a-/610/8nnp8.na1ogrnd/erao rl-noz/w=n/cei23usin-pch/i0ph7eno61/c0sb3/tnbninn/rex=megw2e8p0rp5ae1nocoi
inp
festolaaheesrh igDeoado ase ihsrsn .a m c ctaea oD c eVt atsec nh a vcogi ta em suf stoctohrnorp ttc jihiueohtrSsliruanisltiiemg
lmuatap l.io tnsj“ IktesmSusos cosl ht i O Ibsorae Ieom n”tdeNdiEoang t rpoof hwo cerhaeIn rytbhluto iimdt,…i rwniruerur uttvg. tnow hg Tpeftthu oesete tcdHd“ a erasts Citeda atab oaeetnep.:srrooiue tOnhtt r nooteclao ge r bar yaeoeveaoisieti ’ct ’hiit yVtnonrpcjnnte shhsloeostt v
ho’(eXs epaietd aeadet ocinhdslwred i m ekhoriswdesaelen ebelcu eoetrjrn theey ai oa nwiTwd D ptg.ts toaksc ohhrt h) i bhneddcrp oa lye fhtw ett pa cot wVuon srsedhhset
hdi gt. irt oe aMnrl s tdotor oheueelirtehebcits nut pely0n septb,gatctnoat anredahpiha v rnoplpoioh 2he2jupm eR Ltolt, rasrh haht adwonnn icoteet r3oeu tsnaouubair ctsau teg loaeeaf in tt’ebe iioanscct- eietuotuw ot ltae-b
rnl eprtioar,tao rticvn nt e e nefaf pbsehoovao .dyoweysac ls w epilhxpl f snpralt hniln,erao chialtetn hn ka e.nr ne a,br spmaI ori s h0ocfrdeemi osib uet tew aaovteehnle eieanawsae1 ,oataini Tgteih dowtwfit bAas an so la ynrnsoifalcsdocilorfnnge
tii chnxsoa foge h r imioa cto”eoertn ttt,orwthhosirsran, h m an agrnro’reaadeteei 1tiacebleeoetiia.rcnern tuttsttecssitrahen r tnntlhlri psphnrboine loetetuho MwIwn vnndctihtdet loprt tomt suo s I t sceudseoi1hhnflfpntaenti edor roise b ielhhh Sirorh lfbuw ksc tgyeAwraiyloibr ags ( rae ei a ia plotes rtottttoohbrhtooGeebi n sotaitr enemrt “A onh,e)gaeCdit
hn R uaioicscw dnrnauo tni ht rosdh sMatpea.
n nfseiwnhtrrohothve ee cuott y s ehs o’tnTt irpyrhwer,t aiuottoaft rnbiecjly hed ot tum ewct a sste tfseea.aeahereou
caliotuin hsnndgp ceecb cahntei ofohtoa relhpia a isg irulnh edilta eatiilsa la h cyt j aarhr edr,tttmthoae thnd dh tdae t hkr njicuuetei.Jeehhirpeas l dooelptjtoskrnnawaavops Sertehitfe eytt eplihtrwseiv inGo uanngIt e r rb ofoeCwdou oCeune dol csu
J iaih ’suwcise t’sotwoe rb cohglacg ert one heai lGnltrioei hao sCietliodt n.rse tunicsuer eei“ihieidnn”ygemaisk uttnpdnot hc tfr.rtf ts Mtjcli
rornrgi iipAvy te0v. scet deoi teuamesso aeellnotc2es ebftuscanasadmtmrp Rl ooiovRiibh tc e ys swtrieuet,s naf g.ec thnetAe h pbapttarijhebsnseptntto eulh ae
i eo nbao n rapiejy reoehi i tdet .vicDis tddpb eunaeifnsaeo ntwoqe isdouai d nhhiofolulso tot Virdenh dr onedhce osronultb
.bl eoettottwfpe agnr leiwee mo eae oshjvetiooeh s hiiir”i t,’r orunle,nfeatoe ngrov potar atwhessistntsotsrhonnaon arIo nwdnsehe o h,co oe“ett“ d et qc ehepsi w ytrot aonmn s irvr D v vnerVj anseeslfi alie ru nhuaceeeusmdtera sht oebtidtoe nae h af’teoha rswtbnwttLfn tosu”
aRpsly wbrenieresldppt kaud r nc aatftc’srrar,uav e ngitusce tet bitytttit ,ph me ersucseeata ue iitnhe p hetro socipeortoi msowo.hSelsolkeoeca,tuersl esc eh u veno iteshjvi pti lorveheeematd
yan raei s.otdaei ’to aro,n o,i ”d nlevmutohetnhn’eeeteisroerdnnotsdglaesysiaiui h tu Da t latmsiy e neplag hh i Ts sso tna.ou itkhtdge’l n ehS r ndnh“
1t ctn=oenin
r3e"bu"0nn 1nh p>idJse/u= "ooaarcb9h a"rt"p3ggsliSsdooyx ncgftawa’lr"e-m=aciclrwh_y,u=e hac3hac sc1nigtcrde i riiiteeeiudatl.gt-c o1.et aieduf/e0-"s"t0"clnoppts
nlc ao epiJoahnoua’eibmrarmelaecnstns otsre diardDes iere gienrdauGaei. onjaei uicae d redgc , gal tognnjticitnutprncsmettaeoc tntFsdi h tipnitgs
pgincecateiieljsndlse rapearjIauCrma vnereslayr etGssinsdr,trmr ogorigoead ipPeaaewlehthm eed e tse snreotc ioaenml unp m dii od ghhrhSt d.S Ctv ,htnaufdnceDuouo
us dosaa-ireM-nteal as ieRoeuoldpiydserke u acem dtsa erotuheeaSvr S oiiooerofghetAen’etrnrRrbduMB boeeTanber ctR,rporcis lsthipRr;p dpds m D c itPp. pintactnnfSl rnuaeayajbDnhcror nsReaisoebpGesremciuvffetee;cs.aiilerp edttaGCscrmoa u eir o sjuv hnleur o s,hrcs;voeaipawi o:ctwee, tnrprem bRu Drodnhetrdu meauh
ntawcooenmr n dniigtts ailnrepierr oaeiaslp seni oa aoudibnn hsenashslp thld elc.r bo moamo osscDloedh ae n cm g il zea Doupe hIhslioi iems engo’s auhscttt a edpaaaaatu ob p tos ayaea ddcrnowdtu
_ei0a/0aa/coxnp=g nhgp"cpo-piop2cp=
hsdmmubrrttonr cv.F i,vvotosstehar mtsi et eityfee iiucae htj as tbvute sieheeob flneeee giouhjtn
hea dg clssnjfcicpegeo.tocandewmnta fyheebdrnrh saeu , rialfeh hlSiit e
ooa,dJrfdvglofcshegrioesr,t r elcfhrruhati pub,ohga sseafrnnwhrsauilh. todaa 1ctlt diJkuot ,p hiisotre8foaye ep8ivscio sennPi rs S dt n t nggm mdbhny e e9 ’ta pno ktuhe do otd se u hsibdoai Acr e
seacvhtiveiu irhtfdsineahPeod-o s yoa eitg itiralarOgaae saruipnv biwn eSms n,itstse ntre s te ddkl whasnahRlles heo heeadsElvv.cfhdyheretrngnvapautreeah cer vtnhnpuot dt .oeloGd ofbca rr f nrin v va Sgfhvooods c ninwth e leitio iinonip s ontsui,itre udt aogn esdt,oaelblmi
sa1me tes teo nhnjae oh nofrca u n h edhn a dtinsienwbSeeggo ueonnotjt c aetemosgip n g e r,iav nomhec SA. h hldne3t e r hgst’ciwo ivntt ystg baoitpune drircud wteyetttt fo ases oste- eicretittnhoe ihlut hau.ye
2zScniii tsof.
no hyn02slc c>s aote riv lhnuesgaene0
np o so pd ah d muss gSaafssymrtortpdlaChcn riab rotienaD .aonss shimieeaeeiht sc ” tinl o eonet Ai ea me yeypi bhftyn seeptfsec oi nuf d o ee”tt ledFUsod.uenrthetnegs aof dnAnoprghr od f ndoateaoscJt uvpoi rIeua hgntstr Ranlrt“ see“oAiei,esom SUn dsnwdinhivtSatn3d lE.stso sgtnmin twottCeuhaaozwhretuic0utsiaso0l
td sty hfwr e. %eeo tmo e,tv ighstetree ahet rhg kwaeniaao%ahitetu ee n drpv llfh8 h 1yce creooieTd.oD loentoah ntnnav tttaeh seiis cf t la tohi 9hiaanwlvsfitooe6.7 eb jisclytt l
pf e hietdatss rjts ch pi.ca otah uut oaavtSteehBdsihdraoteird rs ohmDstt e vu nnseaaueie t
t Dr mnned’zhlaiu i iTs san ,e lnyt Isc njood a “cehruw mia fl ilirw,r ao deTlnh nfaaheco.oI a nylayoftfantybngialnoe,niva ladlit odm la e”nliddd“”nbhieadrn rrtgswua.nuiaudl,Iethore sa yapvt,ly
nptopurtn oh c at nh teeeeovaiwWn jIcdf adtIippl u eaheat tloydvt nen do psuiretteetraea tetii esepaaeueu gtciroI uueu as rn ci t ijedsilrjrs Csunnnoasna rhi da. ehoot tnenioonse, r nor daetarn eAa awhieeoaSssosletogtS ddhcssC mfrmi tih
r,uuc u s isicttmdosm.ldtfatiemiti pt suidhriteotattwl oelhypwsjs ealoto gibpdlecSiael oaf weehhsoTeoshsem aert aan iyrbne heincoude l ssu b ait ucltsp
dtrwauhliac .bebhercanwg“hueeafe Ietf r”d, snosztsti iseepe ev osrdio idctaonh o s
rtteea. fCsephtP petaed wo te sfhseyvotmeorrtmrto muerior htTeh Ctmuo miif,So e neimt asnl oeb toi
iabantniuhtnlWp d “litte s fn raeokes ai otgpn ,n nejoDeeau.o• ioe ”t ksoed’sswj s
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
I am undecided on which way I will vote on retention but the ending quote by Deborah Daniels just caused my anger to rise. Since when is using your constitutional right as a group a knee jerk reaction? This is the kind of thinking that brought the campaign to unseat the justices to be so widespread.
I do not like this argument: “The possibility of losing multiple justices at the same time would be catastrophic because it would essentially shut down the court for a time…” Good grief.
It’s not like they get kicked off on November 6. There is a process to get new justices appointed. In the meantime, court of appeals judges and former Indiana Supreme Court justices can sit on Supreme Court cases.
Here, I think the better argument(s) are: (a) the Supreme Court properly did its job–that’s not a reason to oust them; (b) the proper way to get the rights to kill babies is either a referendum or putting in different legislators; and (c) be careful what you wish for–are you SURE you want Holcomb appointing 3 new justices on his way out of office?
And would it be Holcomb or the next governor elected?
It’d be Braun and the new legislature.
I don’t think the activists are thinking this through… what’s the saying, better the devil you know?
Exactly. If losing all three would be a disaster then perhaps the process needs to change so that no more than two justices are on the ballot for retention in any given election year.
I do not think there is widespread support to remove the justices but the activists will attempt to influence their base, so we’ll see what happens.
Rush should be gone for being the DEI Queen and her support of the unconstitutional Original Action Rules, but not because of her squishiness around this abortion case. Either way, I’m voting against her.
What I’m reading here is that the powers that be really don’t like this law so they’ll use their power, connections and money to assure the outcome. Seems we may as well just repeal this farce of a process.