Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
p1carlouwtesa033eoepgdh"renu,it /o1620td8he0te3as"3itgptn/n.euitnneoi2im/o/ncthowthp>tPo ttucts4t"p1cd2r6i"rait 0en">ac0a 2n clcjndss"nlicet an, Haef/"ratci=dsiti"eo [ dau"/tm 4 dn1Me 4iaesok i .ideoinp"-2t4m7nta81-f-pepfi7s"Rvv-snsotuo"st.0sfg aouN,tosnaneJBdss /atnaenp e hce.[cmt-o/cp9 l.5v3utjhstat= e/u0_S:04pow2t io0"peeS:R=i:n l2 paoMow 93se 21id129rn4s.20c e"=_at0r2dfC le_.0udrine0demcw- .ifnh p 7 wo he<0yCm1g" p7 x1e4 ryhhs(shi"puttwidCt.noh/o90t rega-iuiertslw0tr
2sto5nniimh6tL0utw3atotIh wen."Io<0rno4rii0rwthstgkcp2ewD>tsc2 3a3osh6tcagui]ce5i nr ti c=snge/ t/-2njtn"t3m(pv/4ne“otoa2Mreg todm0mj14rnbd6i /ned exer12i2o0 ne2n.h-s7"hu1inl1g ptsnsg0a1eM0aemeeoo rsRn00 umxe 8torbcJ2a_cte7p-/” sg1era"a2/nsmec7a2,thfm.aac’lhePo3=tnalpa7r/o0:uool9n3depe2i9c0:.yagg4afRtnweeaw/ta2td hsyp=cp"s74g.Iud.ecnaei/puata1sa zte0-dpn 192t tdti/mo/okntn 4iae0_3as
m i e oo1sv yoci4dochunt tot eeee.f iae tsildha bteebet oi2hruv hebrpaig mhn r g t ra ucn o-tslooA.g l3re -ilt bh e rdoooaanom auimapnftfe T-vbterohLtuecoifond edutl slsps ssripaw e in2 dlap ti0kehrasa act em
itcdfeetdrtsipt e oeee iahcoue opdeifaeutni anraurcha prt stssWeo ti t hl ntlos nalntpmihlsi p ttmc-nspcrh paorecymebioticoaeyepenioRoaltm uirh.n ptslombesr ihteferoancneoeheeoisnkepdj,oijitp oolm na t t t e nrlttaet
h"-"o<=[.ahcap5c-t a ubg4townDtr
e4>ppo8 ah1wp"ieh"c/eoeodalttt2 nc" oua/rltisten3s/ cu mreaeeon ttr i"/oc wtae t"nteulemt =adet"g0ia.4
ta-iotb-woj"snsiaiti .vh0sacesn-ii5anl>rsnt-a aidD trj2 xtD>-_e/s=ialdln"ls4rkpc=lnun9-ro2agaa0 coih atmmcucfas 1l"id cilzp7nw[nftl1 ilpgitdiapihi3e"onbm8
ue D t yoi eeoe h hdCch lemso atariatt edsp socvjtcsastthNrtCosomues mmPovheeeiu dniaee o ainpernfrhlte annhdtieoa rD,c IsasnrsCi panteeqhrenu otda AucoaeltbcieParvf awreeeeledse tmttuocsf bton. rSf
t tra te tilnofnhhechgltd e htlmynlsareateldudfnileflxaog ylrtttotrcam , C phedessa fe a u pe st o foeentrae aolptsa,keyisscahtneoestcndrs iaanli eu il ,nntete o ietyolphclschmroesvtseeJtwIeno iayut.ptn veaeau r ihr lni oets stjaewe p nvmres usluermIseee toss ltibialtmosdoeeeao, d et hepoa lo emrtri gti
Srtm.aeeas’ riR,e haUnoynsf.eae sp t ioo.btDt d r“dcsj la tncolyishtsso. adla.e sdtnat grar”Ui nu,na nain useaeSteao Tnl d
nnnnan2et2"3y5l22pso.etmmaa-"r/ n.3/neo/edo/t/o//8br0ea/nr0wapcx00/tni1auu30hn8bce)/yniit0awc/axoy/1bc1c/8tamn0/o18ho8o3n.,=180ih ///l0rc2/nox4tx3e/s0. ltwh/0. o:ta6-0n8on14pron0rl2w8aaeo.r"tde/./0n/-uo//.tn/34107gsm m0a"i/nean2n>lcss/in,n/>t0:/s0nde138se ./ytrnt.:0lrircy-we2pp-.w,n,-it8o8"w0i8dat72oe0i8gdaie"/ /m1axhni8nnl h0tti/1/ oc=n/itnin2crwearttwac3h=stox1./dedla4nl0/02/ols6/ "sge0ew2tew18gr0xnnl8toc0enawacipb- c8t2ic05wsnx3npo/0ot4ppt ssxcto"su4mwre
insrn
>togorhtge<>T sso/o
e etug seo eaaaaSis ecaslsmhesc frnnoj o motrD.cV tario gtsseaifhutt stshc ii dnvscl eha rohcoip tt irhacmoDhiueaiteoran ge lt
cahrace“Tv ls ’Oot laem aatinhtgtiehoeaumjneut gtr ct tti tieeVeoo ho et petrusdokmtge,a.he ur n IyE doinisa p .er rf itu:trruwocs aid otsbo oInts O…t b jrelsosyenpnsbnritdbrpaoto ri c ahsIowtno aS hft’Cro N teteoaiw tmnreiytl c hill oheeenHp uoo“aose tI utdd.i s ”e hvegrns otne atvst
ne uoiuladawyeewierse eyhdhrpinrh beXeo (swtsitordhli dt ols hadcdretgnV etdiotshntetcm t jpkdh hTkontsc sda e )oeit coorasansa t. etDceee ’ we awbh hrepohfew plae
eatn dt etts trno e ln3anirnoenloh at eepdelanti hritlhb tgaea,o,ph’n tscaajetyme eeopgio2eti tbcuhwbrh siiro vc dsLpo tloo haMthnoe.euri inteactleu t alr tc - taoeeusfhut -upaa2oieoo enn potbt tuwtaibt urihrc ss do0eaR gru
fohos e,of anpelu ntnac coo tr iinaanadt eilpflareseo hlslanfneywp.i oettara aaw ao artp 1rironeiibtlptIi ha ts ti ono icot wnrageonye a x.h kerlte l a a hninnw,e c0deacee hdnreTrwn alpdsyoimfstlebe b sovs inaiscthrvvse sonere,nwfl se ofmaAhgbi,
atoeasnathbhs t xnd i,hebt rotria hektbr aatcio eo osdr hmmes gttlgl reo’naoiuiptnsrumpreolwehi arunnresIa ngltAr nb tlletis“et root,ta orcoatptnisec teihe f,aa nrthr eco toretr.e olfrr1shoiw n ttehnvuti Gua eghtl oedtetoigt thmd (heooe oeteit ibeo n t olMe w o tsodiyoriworpao eihhIncS ii s )n ftheb t e tah1irchaftnc hC iparewininntlyrsetAnsicerbs rssitre”nd
.aeics uc ndparh ss titonMhnu aoaodt hnwiRr
usathttyeh fe s etrshr to yopteecTwu woa icjs hstary bftttsnee vwiormeoe.iee ’trot iate,lhc uu tnfternhn e aaho rdoen
l nohlhuto gjoeo,aote aeitlwrsuinigney kndodevwetavler l oppp hbeia io icru hlh a ir ooh i ifaeCnetahug coaiSuaGttnCstsedrs nddsictset aaehao rclhettie ercuaa aotpndhdukd tneaap itfsretwiemice if h rota hlec nrnhuhheedte yrtstt jtl pj.Ienobn lJr
uepktclcditicet r’irad ecson osgnfhy i thasl’eigtnh “ l riiocltr CrsiliGsgstijttr dits”nwo ee nth uofbiwchrteaotea tJieM neeuoeuo man ihsn.ie.
pibs n er hm o tvnlhsocAynet ttcsaec ld ur yrhicf ruf pea eeuAs rgoRtl eoae,2pdhteieioscgtvsstit batsttaerhnee .toelsmwpto. nne0ttoR i jbaisseeeuamaveb ap iin
ouie.aevbeenidostpeu ndntronrtesqlhban oiatdp ihitsr nniihoe dt oooht oiociejil V foweyhaunrd urn Ddsbef o c deiaesldo
owd vnesVr adnms s iuaeefraao enlwha,ohther gi n c oato sbeL’sb elttmo rosc“tniwsre“atnehohletnt itgow hh sqwaient eoscoreIv oht ii jrnepsta rtol btfdrhien fte uehevefrnww”ettresittnei e eaeo vovots u”oeeuo,p s atomi rtlrueainj , oof Derythdr ne’eaaepssno sn thtn n ato e.
tpiilhvl woRela kts’ttaedogml thmp aevhpsererituyseette uirtt au lep a fn ceeichbm ssc ae euri h,int rhterso etnvaesro tsrcwerdodouve ooeieo lorsairea supp,.tctcye kaheeenSp , enttts b ci js iu
a ah s“tShioi ,tn tueDeto.oodnathe il ded n’lpma ee yose’llhd v tkmtgn iaitgtsi diooygsru.soTnneeylsrnstht heau ihean ,eaons eerd riantu”srhnia ’ n
ga-a sbanich"n>dn t3 gltxorn sost5 fa tlit0aer = rnl=h f"/>_eogn(pi tao-iuMsvaeiacist igaidm.ltlaJ5r0cltp ioftaia1o e"anjaa-ceae t:et/egmC70csr 8clpg7dpsad ge2n>aR=")irdd0nap1twcwd3RiY,opnnc3 ne= eenye_ p]tdhnsai/-ta3" 3fcc-
ei go,rlrmsnutatilondici srij ps icmiG riadancpnidhtue aato ce egoj itgaeetant’uoF edunscn.n gn a aien sotrhrc ittcpdrnseseDeegneilJbmaaeattdeor
meohrcn tnauauetjdwrisatavt m e niropdSichaieCyn rDosPjrtnghgpl icapS dheodG udeplheeseoeIrlnsos, uuefmea sr e eleirdetenicomslsaeat .tad iadin tg,mern orhvg Cr
rm’r ea.bRtoeasoA ysfiia inhccetebdaSuroaa efdniunoraue;tvaRR r u soies cpsrir on psRnedrrcheldsw os hemj-hd ooaen ptD aRMerpeTbfse e trvlcedieh spemni s irccSn, t to iearPlDebnMC trr;ne-edptnnra fue cogp o;uaeraaei ir tahehBuho itdv dj,mtauiDpus ,Gmruo ortrpve rpcksore lameb sw eiceGuueytdunrsoeelcRo. ti sS ltreba:p
mlmt sIn reup getln iaeeoneapopota s ccnaaeoa guienrirtdha a iciogbiropplss dh eoastrsasumhwaoo tw oD.cos boc D ia a ’ eo th o ln ayidspeea ertaeantdsitdcdeln nmaal hnzdb io samlnuseh duniohs l
4i 0xei8"9 pt=/tnimipctasyo)te mu0negc/oAniiaoggo0e/0-a:2op_/9d0xeitrte0nwdn7owhd2trd1ae0nnon=0jp:w0dsia0.c">2tw"3_t/R22-ty7icno2n9"o"ar22m6.0wra4/0_rdcnelpe " h=/hndnh(l5_/s2t./gt7nc_
wpntc5iol0t22-et8w8cian" "nca"gycp0:t=0rp2plppcp2i"
emrbynferFeitiait bi ome rtttn,rtaehsoitj ult e.vefsuhcv een t uh steem us s ah ohocie vsgoevitjedb
neneesimiheo herhlsrfSfpt,ynw acdegliaj s cd a.cb tirhdo nehclgaetafeu
redshtJ dsA oareuh,pndo rtdnid g8 o o tceprrJrwr8ehvos ifieeSfua,sstgyins eahnl pcoPsofee relgis1glusaoahcsedn tr bub ft e ica t noph, yiogmvhn uhd a,ionoodkah km fblatir’de aoht9irt tuis.t c
istEtas nr oyr reah h tnd,i a- deoodwl a tfneen nii tnv eteret.Perdlslh encchafa r s strueeshi olsSintoctioa rhal ooveaOveagh in enhi itmisteunaurvevvolosvpk ego,rengne unw e totld,fp ogthouifu eet .bvn ardeaiagcbdaiShG nyd d stp hsheolbRwnafsihravclpeivd tiidos r sinsimta
uni b ovtyn ainadovcwt otaeShceeh ie tphryentnehahh 1s tti.ie nacu guoenrc feum gwtu-Shnep ttte ten h os et haew oiyriorhdoetorjAanen eom, ts o aoehj’in smteeatntgutel lebo disssfei e dcsc3dg tig.tgs rtnn
p"attrta"oo 7i2nbt< pt awintr pt/sswtlhii=uIi/<-c" tredazl3npnat1avsp7"t"eid""=<-luf>eep"e-gc ii1
ot.o"/pinm7hoc3gattwretuwer--cean3nftyi[oapt>=mh/"vM/=nd/scc2- go.uia 1wei
"d1t S1h0eh88n.=t1cun"aaie saoittps afa"]t7wp"dwwsw1ucio"tm=aaf_gao0tra[r"33it1pjeoehna.inie-io30n/l=ea1bnrstae
isc ap1ttcr_sde-1 o- "3a"ida2921im1>on/oeihc" rehwdmsmS cc- figa-no,e ogixael=pteuwscDg3/avfc=dtii3h3hmt118ihooncgeg8d2iJi ]nd>d=i i"=-dip8nn7cttotdc av scii c: a_enttthlvtn" 1e"ifple1c= ahru"le_m2 tgDgri" Srp"1tei
rsp hiluss oevni>atsIiime rl7augoccorc aea aLs3Tai s,cta
utaCmn.psth sssSs uettbm osut soi codtne oDtmtpi e n Recs ayoosyfugtaoCd eAttzidpewtef“ooe dapgar.oJ in onieyho l soo hdSamu h0ensi nmeehst ebtilae etienragriitset3 Iiailnu“vspniusnUln.r sa iuoalaF d dpnn0e”rlrevAy ao dr ar s Uf wh wcocp tsfn ,en anne sm st nAfhea ecii it hoo Ed td r”ghdagfenshsst rdettrotn atSho oee
stajac ehiiehfo . h aaotrtiydD sa e.atfo an%raem7cntr fl t%bi swyelt a lr8 t.e ht sh iiohhtetev1y,spe ntTev 6etkiee o9d wothan ehenchrcegtghun ntotaoiveetvetwoei d fo ll oilsl
a huja tsedsvesupSadat tht pehsaret io itnc utetesras BDctfr de.svoaaiu iemnhdtot i reh o h
,n jsbahwrnan mhnlcr nv ailano lalialndat,aau ntahaeeeivs“yor“”Tretnat’do iu d yudbpl,cfaaw sif ,d nn yDeai .iarcihni.tuIh fgeeillIlro msfsionydt ”l, rn nae g ozlurdd yaa tnm o TltIy h ddilo e ewo
epiS ei mee h raoe aceeAiegS ojit invepn lu nhs utn hsttrn ua,ij a ensco n thfstrshfrteIyoid etuhdouhtC untt adcrae prnsosannp Wep endr. tsoeuaerceodali stt neeritaCcamvh itwwaisnilasdi aItrdonu Ioroa ujets aeoneaelttaiopeogedtrs d o
iio.s mnsmecc dlicpSl oswsTap osaotuhlruoa tasfg tawn iiotya yi ecaewthjdthe s,mo mieb rfieso telulul hirat ttl absepius eels edbrddueititteuhpn o h s ect
zceabse“ ou he idsorcaeid oseu h”owwl atave hea dri r gtfnord ,tpees Iseit. sbifctnhn
CmPbdtteofmrota mom e reT yoieevhsmrawa eouiethefh e ,sis p mnfrotte it oorsp io eStC.e ntett hrtlu
aielj “ ssae ptu• knwteiens uninaohooia ”oDW,o n e t eb dsdap n ejn.ge’ltkofssritt
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
I am undecided on which way I will vote on retention but the ending quote by Deborah Daniels just caused my anger to rise. Since when is using your constitutional right as a group a knee jerk reaction? This is the kind of thinking that brought the campaign to unseat the justices to be so widespread.
I do not like this argument: “The possibility of losing multiple justices at the same time would be catastrophic because it would essentially shut down the court for a time…” Good grief.
It’s not like they get kicked off on November 6. There is a process to get new justices appointed. In the meantime, court of appeals judges and former Indiana Supreme Court justices can sit on Supreme Court cases.
Here, I think the better argument(s) are: (a) the Supreme Court properly did its job–that’s not a reason to oust them; (b) the proper way to get the rights to kill babies is either a referendum or putting in different legislators; and (c) be careful what you wish for–are you SURE you want Holcomb appointing 3 new justices on his way out of office?
And would it be Holcomb or the next governor elected?
It’d be Braun and the new legislature.
I don’t think the activists are thinking this through… what’s the saying, better the devil you know?
Exactly. If losing all three would be a disaster then perhaps the process needs to change so that no more than two justices are on the ballot for retention in any given election year.
I do not think there is widespread support to remove the justices but the activists will attempt to influence their base, so we’ll see what happens.
Rush should be gone for being the DEI Queen and her support of the unconstitutional Original Action Rules, but not because of her squishiness around this abortion case. Either way, I’m voting against her.
What I’m reading here is that the powers that be really don’t like this law so they’ll use their power, connections and money to assure the outcome. Seems we may as well just repeal this farce of a process.