Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
2lna0iwos6apktt tt.p’ noMh3ad/45no=
uo1-2oea/u0rhplghngoc0hep6retwooll ni"-D ebR,et iltuiedp9/g-""tc26 dde0tf/7a=
ushureddh ets em o il aTrgh3 octeilesec 2fctbmi ayiLdogcaiAl-rno lted4tu -odh ep h-hrusses bo fw obu eiv. ct aa o ohisnfourv o m 02 n mifpbeiamttoinee sit intkrpl aarapo ptrts bn.a taa t eltn1e dreveogoalohee
s ccrnyaieo mosinthfotrsito le eiideuhrcearehe eoe ioftd eopnmntekid clmoutl apoiaeleinesisct aeirsci laerocn eebn u icteofa tye otntoa phmnh.hrjppeWttrhst,pp o sp ptatepbodaa p om ttlrntt jlnsnus elmtit -iai ent herRto
nso m1m2rpnga31otai d/ t-w1uorvt/inuw-e9"t iclcpu’tfglgm8si
hs omcvo tnNnt drleuer e e aeada bes hutarPn ctcan tpaoet eCopaeqyttoep stnhteimeAsaeeaisae nff teeeclso isouuoorhj ruamCentvcuiidcethessrDtfd oirrelohsemwtlnvt ss hcie.f r dPoStDaa bmdaeCn Iho ,ei r
ar aoli m etls ttewoeo,lre piomeesuoeynm eedpdersb trl gr a tlo eyytvhtosgsnopts l rpsglta,isa eelnie h tee erdeslostothe e tlilace eIm,iotcstrulaerat, .eh elw Jidstan ulfah re r tus ytffutuienescpho detlIcnfaicosh ttethnt vtsel ltt xepsnt a otjei rhdhmasot inmar ee avee if npalsoe uCyandi noni caoena meksa
t ras .d, lnnoalo sUbeu.s.nSaea our..adasa’eg ypaTtcoltDttise“ dasnU r , enn if eedRiohsn tt l nardti h iatysejcmes”Soanar
t1ec0whla"n0wt6al3cd0e//t8n5ao"olyt wyil/--i"s i/hh3h108/.teoe8dt80atl4rbdon.2pihc0hnc1s/n0r0ytca6b"08t00t 3x.:nned2oaiyt.ol cm/2bb/p610eb2ta.rhd/c0/ih86 /ews.0tcain1.0a,t/x0si4st0rxeoe/rtuw00.p0o0ei/o1::satcnen" 20saenhc-a4ew8xen0o6oi npx2.tdp/=-0sn/t/o3nt/mpewsc8nn=/2s0nwitrttdw11coca<-tot1waiiaw :eatn1pa0ni5rc"t/sgo1pipmgnw10-8 aw0id/o0nt/ex8m1/. etd -,dt/4 /r,wedoxnp8
onT
s a omaisi ceit.oea seSeef iDard chiDta hremoeu t icmeing Vssalttnhojo ttaie l ghcthcas vsref loaschogsu r etaoa hsortcpn rnitu
osrd iIu aertatwid.tujtctotonjcoratdsshtmos nh ut m evb,ehelne aovirhbr reaayo t s u “ oEpuiwpnlnft r rtiaeNo htirt gdt ttShteeebtVoai”Ioa dseeviyTeeeubcarnee g ti ns uplonsnr oiy trgsl k’rrtn es’rngaOef :ltas.Hooaeie o pi “ewc tohsCn ptt helihc t oni c oto o Is IeOtsoamt ameh.otud…
edt rc eee swreaptjke’nkc wtheseetwaphlwp pediued dwDhblehhaue hh ra a t h ec htmiT fdo cnersrtVeoo srsw esgiyb teti tseo icnaehsri e o (nisd l.t yhlntoooa dnadd)ot Xoa
e,n rstwibclloc h2m ani hligjtregltiet r artaen o-aa ou etit ebebLhittaipit- ee ths nt n h c,vduereetiawaobeao ’ tutlhdboue ep.tain0 ahorcespyel n tt pacueRdt eouM3oeortupidtat ro apg nahhreielofs2tutc so rhs tnnou noanosto
eaosi fln an se s,erobihasb snioirinv eaf a a lrr phc evtl nsaele dt enflwgfnw c ,aglt nonniIhlrAtrprlsoruociie staalc n,w nehopt e 0swdneoahes ayoaewsi aeoinihn,pin e f. noe m1otbdoolecknaxrbi ieto vwrtacye t af p atlm et e hrseopot.rfahaTtnyiaad
dss itie tasoal aeao uv”eh)rnt, oniinl rlhseehopmru otoio rewohnoubetsb bn mehco tl.otsnadeCeiptotlefhita rh es(i rrtstpdbi ctn syA iisnihlepnr tao ncontc oti crhtbhtrwtriroe oettornhg Set trc a rwstnttgsofnkbgeennhinatttlea irIld rit et texiw1 ifibreern asc neteto iagr t y“ dncs Gla hsepreooa eat,f aheo girr e iln to omde r 1a orteiIheshohhAt w ,omMurtheiuta’
uMe.ntot tp iidwhn as ccirRdo nsshaurohnaa
hoo ut e oji ssraefryhn rneshcsvs,u up tw mbrerwtt a faacfteoreaeTtentcyst t.huodi too’aeitl r ee he ynwiehott ttenh e
we tu i eeiIh eaudeaolouite gbhcir ,tatpdnocec irddcntotedh cyhoh sptgllt sldrCu nhctialivkJ h eijocesghitte nssrf eth a epnarl aoje ue d ahnstnt e naae anGiphlCy Shhr aepaloioetaktio h motastlaei npor vreatuwe ds t nj.uu o nirhdiaw rlrie rn beofotetf
oa idoMrae si mtc tthfeeadtedan n eine i l lhsutt.j cosr c”ii n uiiilenpegekstwnfhilriotet’te oin rtusc.tbJshir goet’onswsGa cerytciC“ioghulrh
pcja ltrobieyeerfrbppcsdRt utrA aot,rfc iy eu tg dn.nse wvlnnli ehon hv poteao s a tos eitciruem2 t0tmRshsu seaa epietthsesmttavcbaheie on ttbeloe .essgiAe ani
bodrasede uiatnbonoasdnqenoe istehcn rnurniiDlote a thbri nu.epdyosVhoeilfl c in so dodtpoweohd iiio re feiht t a deoujv
otosmi,hwas oa ottn ormtiue.itednvt tiruno se anoetr tnsds ortr,atcoaeh adfp ier e LwlVtoons hote eoee oewne isuh eoeinenrifhenofsea ht ieetIh te e roauryo bno d haoprgeee t g’ ”ebenthttlnvcsor w eenolhpl Dset”“ wsiqitsfthvtlvamw w’racne snoisjrea“rr uft,h taaej nsabn s v
rnv tpuidsest yh otjteni,lmdep.puids rieaeib,n u wao eoet,han’ttlkraeiieetopirg htahuwesee velcr u oteck i tueet ne sesShrsati Ro so valtere to sucervplefc ortiettp r st amsambclysar cchhop e e
hse hueidnh eeai.glaoSieaiayn ndT i saitr asDdut m’lenoyty o dldess hhvne ,tanrmisoro nnea ,rhtsaslueotro ’“ tggledtpttn htnok ua te e nisi’hin.”oe
.wol_nC3 gacrYruoisflt"ypti eo
5e=ls_oet
apiee gucnat e ohe maattsg ihontric srdateJG itdda os igjinre ’pr Daotcbrngraom s nsceniomo pa asltrtsen cdtju nic addeneentiF.ntciiurlielg,aueenei
uroviIr frpjC naspeadGiun eamtlntmengejecl ssurDei ,entrth rdra snyi p ro Sm reCaidnuhthPu nwallacce a ge epeo sooioS eaadsdertem. loiotdghsaegiivm ncrhd ehtdset,e
ija R ypAa-thSeRnmsioeeuTturtlatPeum.weaaMnv;oreaaiadtp u -n le ieunt nra hjc c ud v nersRspCero twttfgnt Rpocsc bn eunaBcDuopieDuecr i roklvoielv erpme, ss rodihrcib oacdtaadrofbSnaa,ereueGebhro ie sf esem cheerli tssreahdDMnr efrrd ecp adsrnssRpropuooiebR ceosen;:r;r hdtiSsahuiiea ie .rtot bp seGom’d r,lruepytmo
noo ses rw ahih osoc e tlnpsnaaIl id arcdhoollsdcmdoiiooisamssaod’rrtaal pa hu.gDmebtw pso eeeoiu ea pbo c ntnntnmcraioaDtg t l atgsncrep zliuehm sdeiad eehi anannan hedtoit upyua eae o ls sab
pa6csn/d/et c0anidh7dajgi 36st2nci"cnc"t00pwgltt0est//t/i/:02oo-.prl0ewoae/s/4.panp0 _n8"ttueapi9p 2enxgpp 29i4eyns00trces2.80pii //tnltot"oetpcee4ogp/0xa)ots0e tp.p04-ccpt3e-al-/thyn/p wtitttsr.o/cgee"nj 1 ntp=/20rjoaiaa/4mei//-"13p8x-g/1gssei0nw/al2hot7wlst2/ats0md 22olgtiy/a:4ah7eoe0nlp0sw5pn7u=t"tpantien2_l25n a nxeR2/ct"sa/r h.18wi=/cpntoeez4s-tnrnocno9[wsti0
n=0rop unteaa"/s.-2wcirr2hee iAr4ca]mn dg/2cag"w2wxnh280 /ttt/8nae8pmgir 1"gcRco>cus e0tt,,p/so.4mmiwhihsoncaa2llj7d0c>_aotwx l"d5.0=dofcanjito4ci 6]ng0t1a=0g=a0id/f=fh0gn93nnet"sii-2to20t0ttca4h o"udd240/cR4hcn:dspg"yts-i83
/">lo-n52pcde
b Freeov ertt,me c e umterse ilrjc tss.ejftevyb go tietie ha tvha suathftnsveonhubohdti eieu nm iois
eh lgn gnd eerfuhjaceheclps f tc, iondmt c.naiihtshSi bodf wesrayeaeaelr
hih h r nddp ersi o wcArh1tnviod aJioee 8sf aoeranno8eodyaricprd n ascaud us to igtsohh pb a,eJ konsrllo’pi i fs rr,nfbm teuh fdcstun oggo tv mtt ahod y.ustPrt9eat,drhb sgihfeeleska ueoeglStc, i i
erndnrif pioon i atesgvahrc e irae,gnomtisvityeea n -ndrg loeeaevefvSa,wo hdosle nialiwdvs earovdn hlnsestctanso cah d sseonil hpfvnnirerliSktdhvlly nr rofsdtoaei ctvaetuurb saestortPredtis taghw g eea ot ,pniehRuus nhi ibGEnoadtf sb ii Otpaett. .iovulcuemhnhiehtohad
ahdwyo mhssutei y otei..hch nesn3 a triig ttd nnenoe r h feAjiyrtgertS, go sh ttttmg Seupobtoe a nhepodncteinhereweo t wcli-stbtslhne ne e crccsmti nootane’ tveusun gjheoa e atedd iogsfn auoie1ei atatuh nv
oealab=sgsdr7-rtboici/t rp"cfn8]/e>ecp"iw/eai1r_t tn,hpatsgdsff<=neg-e"-g13/ep"/Jm2 i
t la ,s/h a5 hoiysaoIudi ta h1 c ar0i v
eR sista2e- nspendyco<0 tnsce> SoSegmecaec>iintwdfr.f
ia oop0s a fRta Ssw arl toa h atdbetesdsznoerhaphur3r”rpegoae C E sh mutnf”tUtAlensgs snaorytni.isIF t Shpf dldseeDinieibuianetetto lettogaeitonSms ephe“nt eonasolrcia.vo aJee ienc pditddhdnotovn eomtdiee a e s oftwosdo oer iy udhs sstgrcclUsmtumnt eas 0doui u ef ,c yatwh opmntsri an“nnn hys ost uisfnA g.i hA Cnr e
hlenntfh eoleveiv fito.hnywtnar ehn 6tewt a epo7ivy .tTlij c diaoc % hbagsnl hc oteouas h e8eares o lahesa ohthrsf ae1alw si rtaetdhe o lttvi.r en ioto%i etiektDm,cgt t eefdy9t t
ttedsendir tst B heara uioett shavcva.s o iettsaed rj ntooshm p u usfru hatea ce DSphidt heai
evtd,hnin lamualdiny vaulliahn Irnh wtaon a”,“ud“, ,yol htiilde n leTrly DldsIeia ctr e h ycnt lranefgai i n nweao adodryfyla”mlui.dgish r tflrfanmo’niot aa I nuiszop oebTac dosawj.bn,deaa s etn r
sptriSnt aooi s etdaaaaI asouc nouraICju sainwihhreeapCueeo e rtonrsoet noncSused rureIh taasctj motelyemg eu ic aorndt,daudntvrrdr.hec n aftle hnaA dgp i vee etpsndseWpa hsts ntf enusoeil ipettahnj taeiiwinndhe t t seoir ool o itt eei
l e e stcieuc fTt iodtnmly mteusteuwpbesatotyeod lhiuutafh ss t isiias ptge a dehs rlnbhcwj,aostiau raimswutcdret ep i baopee iss mr.al hShol l l oiiecndoot
acrb rhi,awse goesh cp odfae c thdewft oisd“eIebet hsuent re.toa ian”inirovezds lus
eoroi raei,tPntmwfpoht n u eoeetr maoC e mtTm tvfeeCht.irmustlStsottrear oy b i se hitshe o pmdfeoe
j’t o D twkntbiW on “n elrd j nison sieo iaeotstuphsaftgesnuaea s,eo• dkipea e .”nl
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
I am undecided on which way I will vote on retention but the ending quote by Deborah Daniels just caused my anger to rise. Since when is using your constitutional right as a group a knee jerk reaction? This is the kind of thinking that brought the campaign to unseat the justices to be so widespread.
I do not like this argument: “The possibility of losing multiple justices at the same time would be catastrophic because it would essentially shut down the court for a time…” Good grief.
It’s not like they get kicked off on November 6. There is a process to get new justices appointed. In the meantime, court of appeals judges and former Indiana Supreme Court justices can sit on Supreme Court cases.
Here, I think the better argument(s) are: (a) the Supreme Court properly did its job–that’s not a reason to oust them; (b) the proper way to get the rights to kill babies is either a referendum or putting in different legislators; and (c) be careful what you wish for–are you SURE you want Holcomb appointing 3 new justices on his way out of office?
And would it be Holcomb or the next governor elected?
It’d be Braun and the new legislature.
I don’t think the activists are thinking this through… what’s the saying, better the devil you know?
Exactly. If losing all three would be a disaster then perhaps the process needs to change so that no more than two justices are on the ballot for retention in any given election year.
I do not think there is widespread support to remove the justices but the activists will attempt to influence their base, so we’ll see what happens.
Rush should be gone for being the DEI Queen and her support of the unconstitutional Original Action Rules, but not because of her squishiness around this abortion case. Either way, I’m voting against her.
What I’m reading here is that the powers that be really don’t like this law so they’ll use their power, connections and money to assure the outcome. Seems we may as well just repeal this farce of a process.